Connect with us
Advertisement
Advertisement

Health

‘A pointless talking shop’: Conservatives quit Senedd Covid committee

Published

on

THE CONSERVATIVES quit a Senedd committee charged with addressing gaps in the UK Covid-19 inquiry after Labour blocked calls for witnesses to swear an oath.

Senedd Members voted 24-23 against a cross-party motion, which was tabled by the Tories with the backing of Plaid Cymru and the Liberal Democrats.

The motion proposed amending rules to give the Senedd’s Covid committee a discretionary power to require witnesses to take an oath or make an affirmation

Set up by the Welsh Government, which rejected calls for a Wales-specific public inquiry, the committee published a report this week on gaps in the UK-wide inquiry for further scrutiny.

A Labour majority on the business committee, which organises proceedings in the Senedd, previously blocked calls for powers to require witnesses to tell the truth.

Tom Giffard, who was thought to be at loggerheads with Labour co-chair Joyce Watson on the issue, quit as co-chair immediately after the debate on March 26.

Mr Giffard said: “Without the safeguard of requiring witnesses to speak under oath, this committee has become a pointless talking shop. I refuse to be part of a process that fails to give the public the answers they deserve.”

He told the Senedd: “Covid bereaved families feared that this committee would become a whitewash of politicians marking their own homework.

“I initially resisted that suggestion, defending the committee as best I could. I’m afraid I can no longer do that. I do not have the confidence that this committee will be able to get the answers that the families who have lost loved ones deserve.”

He added: “I will not allow my name and reputation to be tarnished by the perception that this is a committee more interested in protecting the reputation of the government than getting to the bottom of the truth…. I’m unwilling to associate myself with a committee seemingly designed to protect those it is supposed to hold to account.”

Speaking following the debate, Anna-Louise Marsh-Rees, lead for the Covid-19 Bereaved Families for Justice Cymru campaign group, said: “Wales has just hit its lowest point in democracy and governance.

“Our Labour Welsh Government isn’t even pretending to be transparent and accountable any more – they have just shouted it out in Cardiff Bay.  We’re not sure where this leaves us, devolution or Wales. A very sad day.”

Describing the outcome of the vote as a farce, she said: “This isn’t just another Senedd committee, it is one that has been set up because thousands of lives were lost due to Welsh Government decisions, established so that this never happens again.

“Yet today, Welsh Labour used their whip to block this basic requirement. The message is clear: they do not want their actions during the pandemic scrutinised at any level.”

The campaigner stressed: “We don’t want hollow condolences. The voices of our lost loved ones must be heard and their deaths must be properly examined. Enough is enough. Justice for Wales. Accountability for Wales. The fight is not over.”

Conservative MS James Evans
Conservative MS James Evans

Leading the debate, James Evans said the Conservatives entered the Covid committee process in good faith, committed to working constructively cross-party.

But he told the Senedd: “We believe it is only right that the Senedd’s standing orders be amended to provide the committee with the vital discretionary powers….

“This is not a dramatic proposal, nor is it without precedent, the Scottish statutory inquiry already has the power to compel evidence under oath.

“It is a basic mechanism that helps reinforce public trust in the process and it ensures the seriousness of the testimony, particularly when addressing issues of such weight.”

The Tory rejected concerns requiring evidence under oath could deter witnesses, saying the power was only intended to be used for public officials, ministers and ex-ministers.

“Without it, we risk undermining the credibility of the committee’s findings and confidence of those people seeking the truth,” he said.

Mr Evans accused Labour of political interference and failing to equip the committee with the necessary tools, asking: “Why deny the committee the tools? What is there to hide?”

He promised the Conservatives would establish a “truly independent” Wales-specific public inquiry if the party was to form the next Welsh Government following the May 2026 election.

Similarly, backing a Wales-specific inquiry, Plaid Cymru’s Mabon ap Gwynfor said Senedd Members have a moral duty to learn the lessons from the pandemic to save lives in future.

Plaid Cymru MS Mabon ap Gwynfor
Plaid Cymru MS Mabon ap Gwynfor

Mr ap Gwynfor told the Senedd: “Without accurate, factual evidence –  it’s impossible to learn the right lessons and, more importantly, there is a risk of learning the wrong lessons.”

He insisted: “Witnesses must swear an oath … to ensure we stick to our moral agreement with the people of Wales: to find the truth … the whole truth and nothing but the truth.”

He suggested the members of the Covid committee voted four-two in favour of requiring oaths before the request was blocked by the business committee.

Sam Rowlands, a former Tory member of the Covid committee, said: “It’s clear that Labour politicians … are stopping the proper work of scrutiny that the people of Wales expect.”

Mr Rowlands emphasised that Wales had the highest Covid-19 death rate in the UK, so families deserve a full and thorough investigation into decisions taken in Cardiff Bay.

Plaid Cymru’s Heledd Fychan questioned why the Covid-19 Bereaved Families for Justice Cymru campaign group has had to fight so hard for answers.

Plaid Cymru MS Heledd Fychan
Plaid Cymru MS Heledd Fychan

The Conservatives’ Altaf Hussain, a former surgeon, described the Covid committee, of which he was a former member, as akin to using a sticking plaster to treat a bullet wound.

Jane Hutt, who used her weighted majority to block the request in the business committee, claimed the Welsh Government remains committed to learning lessons from the pandemic.

She reiterated that the judge-led UK inquiry is the “only way” to answer questions about the interconnected nature of the complex response to the pandemic.

Jane Hutt, secretary for social justice, trefnydd and chief whip
Jane Hutt, secretary for social justice, trefnydd and chief whip

Ms Hutt argued requiring witnesses to give evidence under formal oath or affirmation was “clearly unacceptable and inappropriate”.

Senedd Members will debate a motion on the Covid committee’s report on gaps in the UK inquiry on April 2 before beginning to take evidence following the Easter recess.

 

Health

Ambulance delays and blocked beds putting Welsh patients at risk, watchdog warns

Published

on

AMBULANCE handover delays, long waits in emergency departments and delays discharging patients from hospital are continuing to put people at risk across Wales, Audit Wales has warned.

The public spending watchdog said urgent and emergency care remains under “constant pressure” despite extra funding and new policies aimed at improving joined-up working between the NHS, ambulance service, councils and social care providers.

In an article published today, Monday (Jun 22), Audit Wales said its work since 2024 had examined how health boards and the Welsh Ambulance Services NHS Trust manage demand for urgent and emergency care, as well as how health boards and local authorities support timely discharge from hospital.

It found that pressures across the system are increasing patient safety risks and driving up costs.

Key problems identified include ambulance handover delays, lengthy waits in emergency departments, underused new services despite extra funding, and delayed hospital discharges which continue to result in hundreds of thousands of lost bed days each year.

Audit Wales also said workforce problems across health and social care remain a major factor in delayed discharges.

The watchdog warned that data is still not being shared effectively across the system, making it harder for public bodies to make informed decisions and manage pressure.

The findings will add to growing concern about the state of urgent and emergency care in Wales, with patients, families and frontline staff repeatedly warning that delays in A&E and problems arranging social care packages are leaving people waiting too long for treatment or stuck in hospital after they are medically fit to leave.

Audit Wales said staff and leaders across the system had made clear that “something must change”.

It has set out six questions for the Welsh Government, NHS Wales and local authorities to consider as they look at how urgent and emergency care can be improved.

The Auditor General for Wales is the independent statutory external auditor of the devolved Welsh public sector and is responsible for auditing most public money spent in Wales.

The Herald has asked the Welsh Government and Hywel Dda University Health Board for comment.

 

Continue Reading

Health

Wales most aware of alcohol addiction, but experts warn summer habits carry danger

Published

on

MORE people in Wales recognise alcohol as addictive than anywhere else in Britain, new research has found, but health experts are warning that awareness alone may not be enough to prevent harmful drinking habits.

The findings come ahead of the busy summer period, when pubs, beer gardens, festivals, barbecues and outdoor events often lead to increased alcohol consumption.

According to YouGov data, 86% of people in Wales describe alcohol as addictive — the highest figure recorded across Britain and above the national average of 78%.

Only 14% of Welsh respondents said alcohol was either “not very addictive” or “not addictive at all”.

By comparison, London recorded the lowest level of awareness, with 69% of respondents recognising alcohol as addictive.

Health professionals say the results show that while many people understand the risks, regular drinking can still become habitual, particularly during periods of increased socialising.

Official figures suggest adults consume an average of 10.7 litres of pure alcohol per person each year, equivalent to around 21 UK units per week. That is around nine pints of beer or seven large glasses of wine, and is significantly above the recommended maximum of 14 units a week.

Nearly one in five adults are also said to drink at hazardous levels or above, with men more than twice as likely as women to fall into that category.

Dr Karen Faulkner, Associate Medical Director at Panthera Clinic, said alcohol occupied a “unique place” in British culture because it was both legal and socially encouraged.

She said: “What’s particularly interesting is that most people understand alcohol can be addictive, yet many still underestimate how easily regular drinking can become habitual. Dependence often develops gradually and doesn’t always fit the stereotypes people associate with addiction.

“During the summer months, drinking can become even more normalised through holidays, beer gardens, barbecues, festivals and sporting events.

“The challenge isn’t necessarily a lack of awareness about alcohol’s risks. It’s recognising when a socially accepted habit has crossed the line into something that’s beginning to have a negative impact on your health, wellbeing or daily life.”

Dr Faulkner said people wanting to cut back should consider planning alcohol-free days, alternating alcoholic drinks with water or soft drinks, setting limits before social events, and keeping track of their weekly intake.

She also urged people to watch for signs that alcohol may be becoming more important than intended, including finding it difficult to relax, socialise or enjoy an event without drinking.

Panthera Clinic has launched a free online Alcohol Health Calculator to help people assess how their drinking habits may be affecting their health and wellbeing.

Dr Faulkner added that low and no-alcohol alternatives had become more widely available, making it easier for people to reduce their intake while still taking part in social occasions.

 

Continue Reading

Health

Welsh Government refuses to halt Withybush and Bronglais service review

Published

on

Health Minister tells Paul Davies MS that decisions remain a matter for Hywel Dda University Health Board

THE WELSH GOVERNMENT has declined to intervene in controversial plans affecting services at Withybush and Bronglais hospitals, prompting fresh criticism from local Senedd Member Paul Davies.

In a letter dated June 19, Health and Care Cabinet Secretary Mabon ap Gwynfor said responsibility for planning and delivering NHS services rests with local health boards and confirmed that Hywel Dda University Health Board should continue its consultation process on proposed service changes.

The response follows concerns raised by Mr Davies on behalf of constituents in Pembrokeshire and Ceredigion over the future configuration of clinical services, including stroke care.

While acknowledging strong public concern about access to healthcare in rural communities, the Minister stopped short of offering any commitment to block or reverse the Health Board’s proposals.

Instead, he stressed that any changes must be supported by robust evidence, maintain patient safety and demonstrate improved outcomes.

The Minister wrote: “Responsibility for planning and delivering health services rests with local health boards, including decisions about how services are organised.”

He added that proposals must improve outcomes for patients, maintain safe and equitable access to care and be supported by thorough impact assessments.

Paul Davies MS described the response as disappointing.

Posting the letter on social media, he said: “This letter tells me that the Welsh Government is not going to stand in the way of the Health Board’s plans.”

He added that he would raise the issue in the Senedd chamber next week and continue pressing ministers to intervene.

The exchange comes as Hywel Dda University Health Board continues a public consultation on proposed changes to stroke services across west Wales.

The consultation, which opened on May 28, is due to run until July 26.

In his response, the Minister stated that anyone suffering a stroke should receive treatment “as quickly as possible in the most appropriate setting” and said the current model of stroke care in Wales must evolve if national standards are to be achieved.

The comments are likely to fuel concern among campaigners opposed to the proposed changes, who fear services could become increasingly centralised and further away from rural communities in Pembrokeshire and Ceredigion.

 

Continue Reading

Local Government5 hours ago

Tenby Spectacular row continues as organisers say key question remains unanswered

Round Table says legal clarity over pedestrian access is still holding up event plan TENBY ROUND TABLE has welcomed Pembrokeshire...

Community23 hours ago

Manorbier fire scandal: Council’s payout just £63,777 after school destroyed

PEMBROKESHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL has accepted an insurance settlement which leaves it with just £63,777.07 after the catastrophic fire which destroyed...

News1 day ago

Bus overturns in major incident near Kidwelly

All passengers rescued as emergency services remain at scene A BUS overturned on the A484 between Kidwelly and Ferryside on...

Community2 days ago

Tenby Summer Spectacular cancelled amid council row over harbour access

Organisers say popular charity events cannot safely go ahead without clear powers to control crowds TENBY ROUND TABLE has announced...

News2 days ago

Motorcyclist dies after four-vehicle crash on A40 in Carmarthenshire

A MOTORCYCLIST has died following a four-vehicle collision on the A40 between St Clears and Whitland. Dyfed-Powys Police said the...

News2 days ago

Rhun ap Iorwerth urges new deal for Wales after Starmer quits

First Minister says next Prime Minister must focus on greater powers, fair funding and respect for Wales’ democratic mandate FIRST...

News2 days ago

How Labour’s landslide victory unravelled in just two years

Prime Minister announces resignation after losing support within his own party as Andy Burnham emerges as overwhelming favourite to take...

News3 days ago

Long Course Weekend set to bring thousands to Pembrokeshire

Three days of swimming, cycling and running will once again transform Tenby into one of the UK’s biggest endurance sporting...

Community3 days ago

The gentle giant behind the tattoos

Pembrokeshire security worker Josh Davies praised for professionalism, kindness and proving first impressions can be wrong JOSH Davies is hard...

Charity4 days ago

Toy Story fans fill charity toy box at Haverfordwest cinema

Donations pour in for SNAP Specialist Play as families embrace Toy Story 5 launch A TOY STORY-themed charity appeal at...

Popular This Week