Politics
‘Piggybacking’ on UK laws ‘undermines Senedd scrutiny’
SENEDD Members have warned a continued reliance on UK laws in devolved areas is eroding the Welsh Parliament’s crucial role in scrutinising legislation.
Labour’s Mike Hedges reiterated concerns about the Welsh Government regularly relying on UK bills to make laws in devolved areas rather than introducing bills in the Senedd.
Mr Hedges, who chairs the cross-party legislation committee, made the comments as Senedd Members signalled consent for the UK mental health bill on October 7.
The Senedd is asked to consent to UK laws, though it is not binding, rather than being able to scrutinise and amend a bill line-by-line as it would with Welsh legislation.
Mr Hedges told the debating chamber: “The committee believes that a democratic deficit is emerging as a result of the government’s approach in this area….
“We consider that the use of this bill to make provisions in the area of mental health – which is a devolved policy area – contributes to that unwelcome deficit.”
He added: “The approach taken by the Welsh Government has the effect of sidelining the Senedd as a legislature and preventing elected members… from having an opportunity to scrutinise the detail of the legislation.”
Questioning why Welsh and UK ministers could not legislate in parallel, Mr Hedges said: “The committee considers that the best way to achieve outcomes that are in the best interests of Wales is to legislate by means of a Welsh Government bill in the Senedd.
“It is unclear to the committee how the approach taken by the Welsh Government of piggybacking on legislation designed for England respects devolution to Wales.”
While concerns were raised about Westminster legislating on Wales’ behalf, the Senedd ultimately supported consent – concluding the bill’s content was too important to reject.
James Evans, the Conservatives’ shadow health secretary, said: “This legislation is needed and it’s going to make a real difference to many people right the way across the country.”

And his Plaid Cymru counterpart Mabon ap Gwynfor similarly recognised an urgent need to grasp a “long-overdue” opportunity to strengthen mental health law.
The Welsh Government defended its approach, recommending consent to the bill on the basis that Westminster would provide an estimated £425m to cover the costs.
Sarah Murphy described the bill as a once-in-a-generation chance to bring the Mental Health Act 1983 into the 21st century, with a focus on inequalities and autonomy.

Pointing to constitutional safeguards, Wales’ mental health minister said: “The provisions in this bill, and indeed in the 1983 Act, relate to both reserved and devolved areas.
“The interface… for example between the criminal justice system and health services means the UK bill is the appropriate mechanism to deliver these policy changes.”
She apologised for a lack of time for scrutiny due to key documents being published at short notice, explaining the timing was out of Welsh ministers’ hands.
Ms Murphy, who briefly chaired the legislation committee, recognised concerns about relying on UK bills but emphasised her belief that providing consent was in Wales’ best interests.
News
Labour hits out at Greens and Reform in escalating housing and tax row
Party accuses rivals of “all words, no actions” as battle over renters and council tax intensifies ahead of Senedd election
A POLITICAL row has broken out ahead of the next Welsh Parliament election after Welsh Labour launched a twin attack on the Greens and Reform UK over housing policy and council tax.
The party issued a strongly worded response following comments by Green Party deputy leader Zack Polanski (pictured) during a recent interview on BBC Politics Wales discussing renters’ rights and housing shortages.
Welsh Labour accused the Greens of saying they support tenants while opposing legislation aimed at increasing house building.
A Welsh Labour spokesperson said: “The Greens say they want to back renters. Then why did they block the bill in parliament that will deliver more houses?
“All words, no actions – that’s what you get from the Greens.”
Labour pointed to the vote by Green MPs against the UK government’s Planning and Infrastructure Bill, which ministers argue would help speed up the delivery of new housing.
The spokesperson added: “At a time when families across Wales are struggling to find somewhere affordable to live, blocking legislation designed to build more homes simply doesn’t make sense.”
The criticism also referenced proposals by a Green-controlled council in Bristol to consider selling council houses in order to fund housing services.
The exchange highlights growing political competition between Labour and the Green Party of England and Wales as housing increasingly dominates the political agenda.
Across Wales, shortages of affordable homes, rising rents and pressure from second homes have pushed housing towards the top of voters’ concerns.
Welsh Labour also used the opportunity to criticise the growing influence of Reform UK, which has been campaigning heavily on council tax and cost-of-living issues.
Responding to comments from James Evans discussing Reform’s stance on council tax, the spokesperson said the party had failed to deliver tax cuts where it holds power.
“Reform has no leg to stand on when it comes to talking about council tax rates,” the spokesperson said.
“They promised tax cuts in the English councils they run and haven’t delivered – in fact just over the border in Worcester council tax has gone up by nine per cent.”
Political observers say the exchange reflects a wider shift taking place in Welsh politics as the next Senedd election approaches.
With the expansion of the Welsh Parliament and the introduction of a new proportional voting system, smaller parties are expected to find it easier to gain representation.
That has encouraged parties such as the Greens and Reform to push harder into territory traditionally dominated by Labour.
For many voters, however, the debate ultimately centres on familiar concerns: the rising cost of living, the availability of housing, and the level of council tax bills.
With the election campaign beginning to take shape, those issues are likely to dominate the political battleground in Wales in the months ahead.
News
Rayner and Lammy visit Wales to discuss justice and community safety
THE UK DEPUTY Prime Minister Angela Rayner visited Cardiff on Friday (Mar 13) alongside Justice Secretary David Lammy as part of a visit focused on community safety, probation services and cooperation between the UK and Welsh governments.
During the visit, the Deputy Prime Minister travelled to the Dusty Forge community hub in Ely, where she met members of the public involved in local community projects.
The centre provides a base for a range of services aimed at strengthening community ties and helping people rebuild their lives. Rayner also met staff from the Probation Service who work from the hub, discussing their role in supporting offenders back into society and helping reduce reoffending.
While at the centre, the Deputy Prime Minister spoke with local campaigner Donna Hurley, often referred to locally as the “Queen of Ely”. Their conversation focused on the importance of community cohesion and the role community hubs can play in supporting people leaving prison to turn their backs on crime.
Following the visit to Ely, Rayner travelled to the Senedd in Cardiff Bay where she was given a tour of the Welsh Parliament building.
She later held talks with Huw Irranca-Davies MS, the Deputy First Minister of Wales.
The meeting centred on how the governments in London and Cardiff can work together more closely to improve public services and create a more effective and fair justice system.
Discussions also touched on cooperation around probation services and youth justice, areas where responsibilities between the UK and Welsh governments intersect.
The visit forms part of ongoing efforts to strengthen collaboration between the two governments on issues affecting communities across Wales.
Business
Legal action backed in case over development at Dinas Cross
LEGAL action against a landowner, who repeatedly failed to comply with an enforcement notice served back in 2023, has been backed by Pembrokeshire’s national park.
Members of Pembrokeshire Coast National Park’s March development management committee meeting were asked to back delegated authority for prosecution proceedings in the magistrates’ court for failure to comply with steps required to be taken by an enforcement notice on land to the south of Parc Yr Eglwys, Brynhenllan, Dinas Cross.
A report for the committee said that, in May 2023, the park received a complaint that a green field in the open countryside had been stripped of its vegetation and turned into a mobile home park by the new landowners.
Following a site inspection, a planning contravention notice was served in relation to the removal of hedgebanks/hedgerows, widening of the existing access, alterations to ground levels, construction of a track and the siting of a storage container.
After that, a 2024 retrospective planning application was received by the park seeking retention of the hardstanding area, siting of storage container and additional landscape works, which was refused that May.
“As no voluntary steps were taken to remedy the breach of planning control and no appeal made against the refusal of planning permission, the Authority considered it expedient to issue and serve an Enforcement Notice as the development and use of the land resulted in an unnecessary incursion into the rural countryside which causes a significant visual intrusion to the detriment of the special qualities of the National Park,” the report said.
An enforcement notice was service in January 2025, but, the following month, the landowner lodged an appeal with Planning & Environment Decisions Wales, which was dismissed that June; the enforcement notice taking effect.
A further application, seeking permission for a small-scale seasonal campsite on the land was received in June 2025, subsequently refused that October; officers confirming to the landowner the enforcement notice remained in effect, running through to January 3 of this year.
A site inspection undertaken by officers on January 6 confirmed the breach of planning control continued, the report added.
This was followed by a further planning application seeking to regularise the development on January 21.
That application was refused on March 9.
The report concluded: “The landowner has had multiple opportunities to regularise the development through both retrospective applications and an appeal against the enforcement notice. Those processes have not resulted in permission being granted nor compliance being achieved.
“The continued failure to comply with the enforcement notice undermines the integrity of the planning system and public confidence in its proper operation.
“It also results in an unnecessary incursion into the rural countryside which causes a significant visual intrusion to the detriment of the special qualities of the National Park.
“Officers therefore consider it expedient and in the public interest to pursue prosecution proceedings should the breach remain unresolved.”
Members backed the recommendation.
-
Health2 days agoWelsh Ambulance Service to host bi-monthly Board meeting
-
News1 day agoRayner and Lammy visit Wales to discuss justice and community safety
-
Local Government4 days agoRegister now to vote in May’s Senedd election
-
Crime6 days agoFormer Pembrokeshire Army officer stripped of MBE after fraud conviction
-
Community6 days agoTenby still waiting as Wales hits 50 rural mobile mast upgrades
-
Community6 days agoCarmarthenshire woman celebrates 100th birthday surrounded by family
-
Sport6 days agoSean Bowen set for historic Welsh clash at Cheltenham Gold Cup
-
Crime5 days agoE-bike rider who sped through pedestrian alley sentenced by court










