News
Jury retires tomorrow in harrowing Baby C rape trial
Final legal points to be addressed in the morning before deliberations begin
THE JURY in the harrowing three-week trial concerning seven-week-old Baby C, who was allegedly raped by his mother’s partner, is expected to retire on Tuesday to consider its verdict.
Jurors heard highly charged closing speeches on the final day of evidence from barristers representing Christopher Phillips, who is accused of raping the infant, and the counsel acting for the baby’s mother.
Prosecuting, Tom Crowther KC described Phillips as “a malignant narcissist” and argued that Baby C’s mother had been manipulated by her new partner after being “dumped” by the baby’s biological father just four days before the birth.
“What the mother saw was the development of a healthy relationship,” he said. “She didn’t see a risk from Christopher Phillips. She may simply have been keen to find someone kind, to replace the baby’s father who left her four days before the birth.”
Crowther outlined the catalogue of injuries sustained by Baby C before his emergency admission to West Wales General Hospital on January 24, 2021. They included a broken wrist, a broken ankle, a bleed on the brain, a swollen testicle and bruising to the chest. None of these injuries had been detected by GPs or hospital clinicians during repeated examinations.
“If the doctor didn’t see the broken bones, how could the mother?” Crowther asked the jury. “None of the doctors or medical consultants identified a brain injury, a wrist injury, an ankle injury or suspicious bruising — and these are highly trained safeguarding professionals. How could the mother see that which the doctors couldn’t?”
He said the mother admitted failing her son but insisted she had never claimed to have seen anything that raised a red flag. He added that parental failure, in various forms, was commonplace.
“Yes, she did fail, but parents fail in big and small ways in their children’s lives. When things happen to our children we wrack our brains, knowing we could have done things differently. Most of us move on. She must now look back to that last moment of love and peace with her baby, with a man who did everything to take it from her.”
Crowther also dismissed any suggestion that Phillips’ strong interest in anal sex should have alerted the mother to danger.
“Anal sex for Mr Phillips is an abiding passion, but it is also part of many people’s sexual repertoire,” he said. “The idea that the mother should have linked that to the baby’s bottom bleed makes no sense. She asked her family, she asked her doctors, and she even asked her new partner. Phillips suggested it may have been a haemorrhoid. This nineteen-year-old new mum didn’t know that babies don’t get haemorrhoids.”
For the defence, John Hipkin KC told the jury that despite the horrific nature of the case, “things aren’t as clear cut as they seem”.
“This has been a horrendous case and we acknowledge that Baby C has been catastrophically physically and sexually abused,” he said. “The issue is who did it. Christopher Phillips has denied it throughout, and the question is whether the prosecution has proved he was the perpetrator.
“Anyone hearing this case would feel emotion — revulsion springs to mind. And if it were a popularity contest, Christopher Phillips would be low on your list. But you don’t find him guilty because you don’t like him. You can only convict if you are sure.”
Hipkin urged the jury to view the evidence with “scepticism”.
“There is no evidence linking him physically to any of the injuries,” he said. “He was around Baby C and had access to him — and that is it. He only had access when the mother was in the same room or briefly in another room of the small flat. It is a huge leap for the prosecution to say Phillips was responsible.”
In his summing up, Judge Paul Thomas reminded the jury of the extent of Baby C’s injuries. The head injury was described as being “akin to falling off a building or being in a road accident”, well beyond rough handling. The anal injuries — including a gaping wound — were so severe the baby could only be settled with morphine. A specialist paediatric medic told the court she had administered morphine to such a young baby only “a handful of times” in 25 years. The baby had also suffered blunt force trauma to a testicle.
At around 3.50pm today (Monday), Judge Thomas told the court that the case will resume in the morning. He said two minor legal points remain, each expected to take no more than a minute. Once they are dealt with, the jury will retire to consider its verdict. “It will take as long as it takes,” the judge said.
Phillips, 34, of Kiln Park, Burton, is charged with causing serious physical and sexual harm to Baby C in January 2021. The baby’s mother faces separate charges of allowing serious physical harm and child cruelty for allegedly failing to protect her son.
The jury is expected to begin its deliberations on Tuesday.
international news
UK considers military options as pressure grows to secure Strait of Hormuz
Ministers confirm talks with allies after Donald Trump calls on Britain to help protect vital oil shipping route
THE UK GOVERNMENT is examining “all options” to help secure the Strait of Hormuz as tensions in the Middle East threaten one of the world’s most important oil routes.
Energy Secretary Ed Miliband said Britain is already in discussions with allies, including the United States, about how to restore safe navigation through the narrow shipping corridor, through which around one fifth of the world’s oil supply passes.
Speaking on BBC One’s Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg, Miliband said reopening the strait was a global priority but stressed the government favours de-escalation rather than military confrontation.
“It is very important that we get the Strait of Hormuz reopened,” he said. “We are in talks with allies about how to secure that key shipping route. Any options to help the Strait reopen are being looked at.”

The comments come after US President Donald Trump called on several major powers — including the UK, France, Japan, South Korea and China — to send warships to the region to ensure the vital oil corridor can no longer be threatened by Iran.
The escalating conflict between the US, Israel and Iran has already led to attacks on shipping in the Gulf, raising fears that Tehran could attempt to block or severely disrupt the strait.
Political divisions in Westminster
The prospect of British military involvement has exposed sharp political divisions in Westminster.
Shadow energy secretary Claire Coutinho said the UK should explore deploying ships or surveillance drones to the region if doing so would protect Britain’s national interests.
She argued that keeping international shipping lanes open and protecting military assets abroad was vital for global stability and the UK economy.
However, Liberal Democrat leader Ed Davey warned Britain should not automatically follow Washington into another conflict.
He said the quickest way to stabilise oil markets and secure the route was through diplomatic de-escalation rather than military intervention.
Davey also criticised President Trump’s approach to the crisis, warning the UK should not be “at the beck and call” of an American president.

Global oil supply at risk
The Strait of Hormuz is widely regarded as one of the most strategically important shipping routes in the world.
Bounded by Iran to the north and Oman and the United Arab Emirates to the south, the narrow channel connects the oil-rich Gulf region to the Arabian Sea and global markets.
Around 3,000 vessels pass through the strait every month, carrying an estimated 20 million barrels of oil per day.
Any prolonged disruption could send global oil prices soaring and drive up fuel and energy costs in countries including the UK.
Government sources have warned the economic impact of the Middle East conflict could be “huge”, with ministers already examining measures to shield households and businesses from potential spikes in energy prices.
The developments are being closely watched in Pembrokeshire, home to the South Hook and Dragon LNG terminals at Milford Haven. Tankers carrying Qatari liquefied natural gas frequently pass through the Strait of Hormuz before reaching the UK, meaning any disruption in the Gulf could have implications for energy supplies and prices in Wales.
For now, the government insists diplomacy remains the preferred path — but with tensions rising and pressure from Washington increasing, Britain may soon face difficult choices about how far it is willing to go to secure the world’s most critical oil chokepoint.
Local Government
Changes approved to final phase of Saundersfoot housing scheme
Affordable housing proportion rises as apartment plans replaced with family homes
AMENDMENTS to the final phase of a housing development in Saundersfoot have been approved, reducing the overall number of homes while increasing the proportion of affordable properties on the site.
Morgan Construction (Wales) Limited, through agent Evans Banks Planning Limited, sought permission to reconfigure the third phase of a residential development at Whitlow, Narberth Road, Saundersfoot.
The application was recommended for approval and came before members of Pembrokeshire Coast National Park’s Development Management Committee at its March meeting.
The original scheme, granted permission in 2023 and already partly built, allowed for a total of 54 homes. Under the revised proposals the number will be reduced to 47.
A planning officer’s report explained that the development is being built in phases. Phase one consists of 16 market homes, while phase two includes 19 affordable properties.
The application concerned the final stage of the project, known as phase three.
Under the original consent, phase three would have delivered 19 one- and two-bedroom apartments located in the centre of the site. However, the revised plans replace those flats with a mix of houses.
The new layout will include two three-bedroom detached houses, three two-bedroom detached bungalows, four two-bedroom terraced townhouses and three three-bedroom terraced townhouses.
This change reduces the number of homes in phase three from 19 apartments to 12 houses.
Although the number of affordable homes across the development will remain unchanged, the reduction in market housing increases the proportion of affordable properties on the site from 35.1 per cent to 40.4 per cent.
The applicants told planners that demand for the previously approved apartments had been limited. They said there was already a considerable supply of such properties in the lower part of Saundersfoot, while demand locally appeared stronger for homes suited to young families and for older residents wishing to downsize into smaller bungalows.
The report added that without the changes the final phase of the development could remain unbuilt, leaving future residents living on a partially completed site.
Committee members agreed to grant delegated approval to planning officers, subject to the completion of legal agreements covering planning obligations.
These include provisions to secure the affordable housing in perpetuity, along with financial contributions towards library services, recreational open space and sustainable transport.
Local Government
Appeal after Tenby harbour RNLI building takeaway refused
AN APPEAL has been lodged against the refusal of plans for a takeaway food kiosk at a former lifeboat store in Tenby’s seaside harbour, despite planning officers recommending the scheme for approval.
Last March, members of the Pembrokeshire Coast National Park Authority development management committee rejected proposals to site a takeaway food kiosk at the former RNLI lifeboat store at Penniless Cove, Tenby Harbour.
The application, submitted by Ruby Goodrick, sought permission to convert the old store into a takeaway cold food outlet operating seven days a week from 10:00am to 10:00pm.
The scheme came before councillors rather than being determined under delegated powers after Tenby Town Council objected to the proposal.
Despite the objection, planning officers recommended the scheme for approval, even though it represented a departure from the adopted development plan.
An officer report said: “Whilst it is acknowledged that the proposed use would introduce a retail element to this area of the harbour, on balance officers consider that no significant harm would be caused to the character of Tenby Harbour as a result of this development.
“The use proposed occupies a relatively small floor area and would not be a destination in and of itself. Rather, it would rely on the existing footfall within the harbour.”
Speaking at the meeting in March (2025), Alistair McKay, representing Tenby Sailing Club, warned the proposal could create potential conflicts with other harbour users.
The applicant told councillors she was “more than happy” to adjust the proposed opening hours. Ms Goodrick said the business would build on the success of her mother’s former sandwich shop in the town, Truly Scrumptious.
The proposed outlet, called Truly@The Harbour, would “contribute positively to the local economy,” she said.
However, committee members raised concerns including congestion in the harbour area and the handling of waste.
Members eventually voted by 12 votes to three to refuse the application.
The applicant has now lodged an appeal with Planning and Environment Decisions Wales (PEDW).
In a statement supporting the appeal, Ms Goodrick said: “The proposal is modest in scale, does not harm the retail hierarchy, is in close proximity to the town centre, and has received no objections from the majority of the statutory consultees.”
The appeal statement adds that the refusal was based on the kiosk being outside the defined town centre boundary.
However, it argues that the building is located only around 25 metres outside the retail centre boundary and would otherwise represent a use considered acceptable within the town centre.
-
Health2 days agoWelsh Ambulance Service to host bi-monthly Board meeting
-
News1 day agoRayner and Lammy visit Wales to discuss justice and community safety
-
Local Government4 days agoRegister now to vote in May’s Senedd election
-
Crime6 days agoFormer Pembrokeshire Army officer stripped of MBE after fraud conviction
-
Crime5 days agoE-bike rider who sped through pedestrian alley sentenced by court
-
Community6 days agoTenby still waiting as Wales hits 50 rural mobile mast upgrades
-
Community6 days agoCarmarthenshire woman celebrates 100th birthday surrounded by family
-
Entertainment5 days agoHow the Cheltenham Festival Captivates Racing Fans Every Year








