Health
New hospital for west Wales faces delays due to funding issues
A LONG-PLANNED new hospital for west Wales faces significant delays due to funding challenges, Hywel Dda University Health Board’s chief executive, Phil Kloer, has revealed. Originally slated for completion by 2029, the project may now take at least a decade—or longer—to materialise.
The proposed hospital, intended to serve as part of a wider transformation of healthcare in the region, had two potential locations identified after extensive public consultation: St Clears and Whitland in Carmarthenshire. However, the rising cost of construction, driven by inflation, has forced the health board to revisit its strategy.
Rising costs and strategic reassessment
A report presented by the health board highlights that the estimated costs of the original strategy—outlined in a request for £1.3 billion from the Welsh Government—have surged significantly. The strategy aimed to overhaul healthcare services by developing community hubs, refreshing Prince Philip Hospital in Llanelli and Hospital in Aberystwyth, repurposing Withybush General Hospital in Haverfordwest and Glangwili General Hospital in Carmarthen, and constructing the new hospital.
Acknowledging the impact of inflation and other factors, Mr. Kloer told a health board meeting: “It would be wrong to plough on with the same thinking.” He cited the effects of Covid-19, demographic shifts, and climate change as additional reasons to “refresh” the health board’s approach.
Phased implementation to manage costs
Executive Director of Strategy and Planning Lee Davies presented a paper indicating that while a phased implementation might increase the overall costs of the programme, it could make the project “more affordable for the Welsh Government” over time. The health board also acknowledged that reviewing the hospital’s location could be necessary, despite previous public consultations narrowing options to two shortlisted sites.
Financial struggles and politics compound challenges
The health board’s financial difficulties add another layer of complexity to the hospital’s future. At the same meeting, it was confirmed that the board is grappling with a £64 million deficit, despite delivering £32.4 million in savings.
The delay raises questions about the future configuration of health services in west Wales and underscores the financial and logistical hurdles facing ambitious infrastructure projects in the region.
The delays have reignited political tensions in June this year, with Welsh Health Minister Eluned Morgan (as she was then) laying blame on Conservative politicians for obstructing progress. During a Welsh Parliament session she accused the Conservatives of leading a campaign against a new hospital years ago, which she claimed delayed its construction.
Speaking in response to a question from Pembrokeshire’s Sam Kurtz MS about the ongoing delays, Baroness Morgan said: “If you [the Conservatives] hadn’t led a campaign against the West Wales hospital, it would’ve been up and running by now. The Conservatives must take their share of responsibility for the fact there is not already a West Wales hospital.”
Morgan’s remarks were met with sharp criticism from veteran campaigners and opposition politicians. Dr Chris Overton, a prominent campaigner for Withybush Hospital, called the comments “rubbish,” pointing out that the campaign to save services at Withybush Hospital drew support from across the political spectrum, including members of the Labour Party and non-affiliated community members.
“The reality,” Dr Overton said, “is that Labour has been in power in Wales for 25 years. They’ve had plenty of time to build this hospital. Instead, they’ve salami-sliced services at Withybush to the point where trust in their promises is completely eroded.”
At that time Plaid Cymru candidate Cris Tomos and Liberal Democrat candidate Alistair Cameron both called for greater clarity and transparency from the Welsh Government. Tomos emphasized the need for genuine consultation with communities, while Cameron pointed out that residents face uncertainty about accessing services during the decade-long delay.
Covid an issue
Executive Director of Strategy and Planning Lee Davies said: “The pandemic and subsequent programme delays have meant the timescale for delivery of the programme, in particular the new hospital network, is substantially longer than originally anticipated. It is now highly likely that the new hospital would not be operational for at least a decade.
“In accepting that a new hospital will not be operational in the near future, it follows that the key service changes unlocked through a new hospital will now need to be considered ahead of a new facility and within existing hospitals.”
“Work to support fragile services in the interim of a new hospital has already begun through a programme of work called the Clinical Services Plan.”
“Staff, including clinicians, working with stakeholders and patient representatives have reviewed issues and challenges faced, agreed minimum standards, and developed draft options for nine fragile services.
“The nine services are Critical Care, Emergency General Surgery, Stroke, Endoscopy, Radiology, Dermatology, Ophthalmology, Orthopaedics and Urology. They are services which need change and support to continue safely providing care in the medium term.”
Board agreed that the programme prepares for a public consultation to involve further staff and communities in this work. The scope and matters for a future consultation, including the options, will be prepared for the next Health Board meeting at the end of January 2025.
Lee Davies added: “In the absence of a new hospital in the south of our area to address challenges, we need to consider other options to bring together some of our services. We anticipate the emerging model, informed by work on the Clinical Services Plan, will seek to build on the strengths of each of the hospital sites in a way that builds complementary areas of expertise.”
Health
Over one in four care seekers in Wales unsure who will pay for care as costs soar
A NEW report has uncovered significant uncertainty surrounding elderly care funding in Wales, with more than a quarter of care seekers unsure who will bear the costs. Data from carehome.co.uk, a leading reviews website, shows that 26% of Welsh care seekers who inquired between November 1, 2023, and October 31, 2024, did not know how their care would be funded—surpassing the UK national average of 21%.
Self-funding: A growing trend
Among those with a clear funding plan, 41% in Wales stated they would self-fund their care. This figure compares with 53% in England, 40% in Northern Ireland, and 37% in Scotland, highlighting regional differences in funding approaches.
Local authority funding and the rise of top-up fees
The research reveals that 13% of Welsh care seekers rely on local authority funding, aligning with the UK average. However, with local councils under financial strain and care home fees climbing, many families face additional “top-up” costs to bridge the gap between council contributions and actual fees.
In Wales, 13% of care seekers anticipate paying top-up fees, a growing challenge as families struggle to meet rising expenses.
NHS continuing healthcare: A complex system
Only 7% of care seekers in Wales expect to benefit from NHS continuing healthcare funding, slightly above the UK average of 5%. This funding, which is not means-tested, covers full care costs for adults with complex health needs. However, critics point to inconsistencies in assessments across regions.
James Urquhart-Burton, a partner at Ridley and Hall Solicitors, described the issue:
“Your chances of getting NHS continuing healthcare funding vary based on your location, which is a problem given that the criteria are standardized nationwide. The reliance on assessors’ judgments to determine need introduces subjectivity into the process.”
Rising costs and public confusion
Sue Learner, editor of carehome.co.uk, expressed concern over widespread confusion about care funding:
“Our data shows an acute lack of understanding among the public in Wales about how the social care system works and how to navigate it. It’s incredibly concerning that a significant proportion of care seekers still don’t know whether the council or they themselves will cover costs.”
Learner highlighted the financial strain on self-funding residents, with care home fees in Wales averaging £1,066 per week. Rising costs—driven by increases in National Insurance, the National Living Wage, energy bills, and food prices—add to the burden.
“Care homes are increasingly prioritizing self-funding residents due to financial pressures,” she added. “This trend may reduce the number of care homes accepting state-funded residents, leaving families to grapple with an already complex system.”
As care costs continue to rise, understanding funding options and planning ahead are becoming critical for families across Wales.
Pictured: Shani Lauren Escott at Pen Coed Care Home, Saundersfoot with resident May Spurr
Health
18,000 families ‘struggling in silence’ due to lack of dementia diagnosis
AROUND 18,000 people living with dementia in Wales do not have a diagnosis, leaving families struggling to cope without support and treatment, Senedd Members warned.
Mabon ap Gwynfor said Wales has the lowest rate of diagnosis in the UK at 56%, warning that dementia is one of the biggest causes of death in the country.
Plaid Cymru’s shadow health secretary paid tribute to Terry Griffiths, the former snooker world champion from Llanelli, who died on Monday following a long battle with dementia.
Mr ap Gwynfor raised an estimate from Alzheimer’s Society Cymru of a 37% increase in the number of people living with dementia by 2040 due to an ageing population.
He told the Senedd that dementia costs the Welsh economy £2.3bn a year, which is expected to double to £4.6bn by 2050 if services do not improve.
Leading a debate on a Plaid Cymru motion calling for diagnosis targets, Mr ap Gwynfor said: “Around 18,000 people are left to cope without the support and treatment they need.
“That’s 18,000 individuals and 18,000 families struggling in silence, without knowing what to do or where to turn. The situation is even worse in rural areas, such as Powys.”
Gareth Davies warned dementia is Britain’s biggest killer, yet spending on diagnosis makes up less than 1.4% of UK health care expenditure, “which seems a staggering oversight”.
He said families are shouldering 63% of dementia-related costs, according to Alzheimer’s Society, with the average bill standing at £29,000 a year rising to £80,000 or more.
His Conservative colleague Altaf Hussain, a former surgeon, focused on alcohol-related dementia and brain damage, warning it is difficult for GPs to identify.
Delyth Jewell said her grandma Doreen, who lived to be 100, had dementia.
She told the Senedd: “The cruellest thing about dementia is how bewildering it is for the person going through it. My parents would visit my grandma. They’d call her multiple times each day. But she’d forget that they’d been.
“She’d think that they’d forgotten her. I remember her calling my parents’ house one day, and I’d answered the phone, and she’d asked me, ‘Why is it that I can’t do all the things I used to do?’ and she wished that she could walk and walk.
“She’d get frustrated, she’d be lonely and she couldn’t understand why it was happening.”
Ms Jewell, who represents South Wales East, said diagnosis rates are stubbornly low at 60% in the Aneurin Bevan health board and “there’s still no dementia plan for Gwent”.
Heledd Fychan, a fellow Plaid Cymru Senedd Member, called for greater support for Welsh speakers living with dementia, warning their needs are too often disregarded.
Mike Hedges, who represents Swansea East, said: “Increasing diagnosis rates across Wales is vital to enable people … to take control of their condition and live independently for longer.
“This supports people to stay out of hospital and in their own homes, relieving pressure on our health and care system.”
Responding to the debate on December 4, Sarah Murphy told the Senedd an independent evaluation of the Welsh Government’s dementia action plan will be published in early 2025.
The mental health minister, whose responsibilities include dementia, said the final report will inform a refreshed plan that will include new targets for diagnosis.
She said: “Ensuring people’s lived experience is at the heart of the development of services is very important to me, and I am committed to the development of robust diagnosis data.”
While the Plaid Cymru motion was defeated, 27-25, a version amended by the Conservatives and the Welsh Government was agreed unanimously.
Health
Health concerns as banned American candy floods UK markets
PARENTS are being warned this festive season about the dangers of imported American sweets, snacks, and fizzy drinks, which are flooding UK high streets thanks to social media trends. The Chartered Trading Standards Institute (CTSI) has raised alarms over unauthorised additives in these products, many of which fail to meet UK safety standards.
A growing trend, a hidden danger
Social media platforms like TikTok have popularised American confectionery, with influencers showcasing brightly coloured snacks in viral “candy haul” videos. This has made imported sweets a sought-after stocking filler for children and teenagers, driving record sales in convenience stores and high-street retailers.
However, this sugary trend comes with a bitter side. Many of these products, designed for foreign markets, bypass UK safety and legal standards. They often lack proper allergen declarations and contain harmful, unauthorised additives.
Major safety failures highlighted
A pilot project led by Staffordshire County Council’s Trading Standards team, funded by the Food Standards Agency, uncovered alarming issues. Inspectors seized 3,378 items valued at £8,500 from local shops. Tests revealed the presence of dangerous additives, including:
- Yellow 6 (E110): Found in snacks, linked to hyperactivity in children.
- Carrageenan: Common in jelly cups, posing a choking hazard.
- EDTA: Prohibited in drinks, associated with developmental issues in animal studies.
Among the inspected stores, 89% failed to comply with UK regulations. Common violations included:
- Products with unauthorised additives.
- Missing English labels or allergen warnings.
- Expired items being sold.
In total, 3,700 non-compliant products valued at £10,300 were confiscated, including crisps with E110, sweets with mineral oil and bleached flour, and drinks containing EDTA.
A national problem
The issue extends beyond Staffordshire. Operation Tootsie, a broader Trading Standards initiative, revealed that 77% of tested products from national retailers failed compliance checks, rising to 91% among importers.
Dean Cooke, CTSI Lead Officer for Food, said: “Social media has amplified the demand for American sweets. While retailers enjoy seasonal sales, they must ensure products meet UK standards. Parents should check labels to protect children from harmful additives.”
He also reminded consumers to avoid products without a UK/GB address on the label, as these fail to meet import labelling laws.
Councillor Victoria Wilson, Cabinet Member for Trading Standards at Staffordshire County Council, highlighted the seriousness of the issue:
“Our Trading Standards team was alarmed to find thousands of unsafe products on sale, often aimed at children. Poor labelling and unauthorised ingredients pose significant public health risks.”
The Pembrokeshire Herald advises that local consumers scrutinise labels carefully. Products with American weight measurements, such as ounces, are likely imports. These must meet UK safety standards, including accurate allergen declarations.
Anyone concerned about food safety in Wales can contact the Citizens Advice Consumer Helpline at 0808 223 1133.
This Christmas, Trading Standards is ramping up operations to tackle the influx of unsafe goods. Parents are advised to stay vigilant and prioritise safety when filling stockings with festive treats.
-
Top News7 days ago
Top international artist brings solo exhibition to North Pembrokeshire gallery
-
Crime6 days ago
Former police officer appears in court over paddleboarding deaths
-
Health6 days ago
Lockdown lifted at Withybush Hospital following incident
-
Top News5 days ago
Torch artistic director Chelsey Gillard shares her love of the power of panto
-
News6 days ago
Andrew RT Davies resigns as Welsh Conservative leader after confidence vote
-
News2 days ago
Storm Darragh leaves its mark on West Wales as major incident declared
-
News3 days ago
RED WARNING: High winds expected in Pembrokeshire
-
Community2 days ago
Clean up starts after storm causes chaos across Pembrokeshire