News

Sea levels threaten Pembrokeshire coast

Published

10 years ago

November 28, 2014

ON TUESDAY (Oct 28), BBC Cymru-Wales’ Week In Week Out programme covered the threat posed to the Welsh coastline by rising sea levels and the lack of budget available to continue to defend under-threat communities. A BBC spokesperson said “Each of the 48 areas along the coast in Wales have different timescales that estimate when properties are at risk of being lost to the sea. And while the plans are based on scientifi c estimates of future events the impact on home owners is likely to be immediate.” Next week, PCCC is to look at its own strategy on the future of those coastal communities under threat in Pembrokeshire. Bridgend council accepted the shoreline plan almost two years ago.

It told Week In-Week Out it did follow communication guidelines to let people know, and will work with the residents on fl ood defences and coastal change. But a number of Newton residents whose homes are at risk said they knew nothing of the plan or the threat to their homes until Week In Week Out contacted them. However, it appears that communication is a common problem for local authorities. Emyr Williams, a coastal engineer from Pembrokeshire County Council, stated that when a public meeting was called to discuss the council’s managed withdrawal from see wall maintenance along The Strand, no Saundersfoot residents turned up.

The programme made particularly grim viewing for residents and businesses on The Strand in Saundersfoot, as the council’s coastal engineer revealed that the Council anticipated the loss of The Strand to the waves. The Pembrokeshire Herald has taken the opportunity to look at the West Wales Shoreline Management Plan (SMP), to which the council is a key contributor, and has uncovered a worrying picture around the Pembrokeshire coast. The report states: “With increased sea level many of the transport issues will increase, most particularly at Newgale, but also at Little Haven, Broad Haven and Solva.

As sea level rises there would be substantially greater pressure for the coast to roll back with disruption to natural defences at Newgale and the potential for increased loss of beaches where man made defences are in place. Increased risk of fl ooding would also occur to many of the other smaller communities.” The original Shoreline Management Plan suggested that further consideration be given to defence of the coastal road at Settlands, between Little Haven and Broad Haven. The southern part of Pembrokeshire and the Haven Waterway is similarly threatened.

Natural Resources Wales note that Dale, Amroth and Tenby are at signifi cant risk of sea fl ooding and that steps are being taken now to reduce the risk to properties. It seems inevitable, however, that regardless of the short term measures taken to alleviate the effects of fl ooding, the long-term prognosis for Pembrokeshire’s coastal communities is uncertain. In Amroth, in particular, the threat is stark with the policy being to hold the line for as long as possible through maintaining the existing defences to ensure that the risk of erosion is managed, but not to improve the standard of fl ood protection.

Once the defences fail, the shoreline will be allowed to naturally evolve and retreat through no active intervention, with broadly the same policy adopted for the entire coastal area from Amroth all the way round to Saundersfoot, affecting the settlements at Wiseman’s Bridge and Coppett Hall. The plans are due to wind out over periods of time ranging from 0-20 years to – most commonly- 20-50 years. However, that does not mean that defences will be maintained for the whole of that period but that by the end of those periods realignment will have taken place, including but not limited to the redirection of transport links and what is described as ‘relocation’.

Coastal engineer Greg Guthrie said: “There are places where we are saying that continuing to defend is basically daft, that we are actually building up, stacking up problems for the future. We have an opportunity – highlighted by the Shoreline Management Plans – to highlight those areas and say now, while we still have time, we can plan how we get out of the dead-end that we are driving ourselves into.” The new Minister for Natural Resources, Carl Sargeant, claims the Welsh Government has spent £300m on fl ood defences since 2011, but it will be diffi cult to justify defending some areas in future. When asked if people affected would be compensated he said each case would have to be examined individually.

Crime

Serving police office found not guilty of serious sexual assault

Published

10 hours ago

November 28, 2024

Tom Sinclair

A DYFED-POWYS POLICE officer has today been found not guilty of sexual assault by penetration following a trial at Swansea Crown Court.

DC Sam Garside, based in the Ceredigion division, has been suspended from duties since July 2023 when it was reported that he had committed an offence while off duty in December 2021.

He denied the offence, and a trial has been held this week. A jury has today returned a not guilty verdict.

DCC Ifan Charles said: “This was a serious allegation made against an individual whose job was to safeguard the people of Dyfed-Powys, and as such swift action was taken when the report was made.

“DC Garside was immediately suspended from duties while a full and thorough investigation was carried out, and today’s verdict brings the criminal justice process to a close.

“It should be noted that the force will now consider whether any formal action needs to be taken from a police officer misconduct perspective in accordance with the statutory framework.

“While the outcome of the criminal proceedings will clearly be of direct relevance to this assessment, it is important to point out this is an entirely separate consideration.

“DC Garside will remain suspended from duty whilst this assessment is undertaken and any potential return to work will be dependent on the outcome of that assessment”

Health

New hospital for west Wales faces delays due to funding issues

Published

12 hours ago

November 28, 2024

Tom Sinclair

A LONG-PLANNED new hospital for west Wales faces significant delays due to funding challenges, Hywel Dda University Health Board’s chief executive, Phil Kloer, has revealed. Originally slated for completion by 2029, the project may now take at least a decade—or longer—to materialise.

The proposed hospital, intended to serve as part of a wider transformation of healthcare in the region, had two potential locations identified after extensive public consultation: St Clears and Whitland in Carmarthenshire. However, the rising cost of construction, driven by inflation, has forced the health board to revisit its strategy.

Rising costs and strategic reassessment

A report presented by the health board highlights that the estimated costs of the original strategy—outlined in a request for £1.3 billion from the Welsh Government—have surged significantly. The strategy aimed to overhaul healthcare services by developing community hubs, refreshing Prince Philip Hospital in Llanelli and Hospital in Aberystwyth, repurposing Withybush General Hospital in Haverfordwest and Glangwili General Hospital in Carmarthen, and constructing the new hospital.

***There have been protests over the years as Withybush was slowly downgraded, and people have been skeptical about the plans for a new hospital.***

***Where the Health Board says the new hospital is likely to be situated, and where existing hospitals are (Image: HDUHB)***

Acknowledging the impact of inflation and other factors, Mr. Kloer told a health board meeting: “It would be wrong to plough on with the same thinking.” He cited the effects of Covid-19, demographic shifts, and climate change as additional reasons to “refresh” the health board’s approach.

Phased implementation to manage costs

Executive Director of Strategy and Planning Lee Davies presented a paper indicating that while a phased implementation might increase the overall costs of the programme, it could make the project “more affordable for the Welsh Government” over time. The health board also acknowledged that reviewing the hospital’s location could be necessary, despite previous public consultations narrowing options to two shortlisted sites.

***There were protests in Cardiff ten years ago***, **in 2014** ***(Image: Herald)***

Financial struggles and politics compound challenges

The health board’s financial difficulties add another layer of complexity to the hospital’s future. At the same meeting, it was confirmed that the board is grappling with a £64 million deficit, despite delivering £32.4 million in savings.

The delay raises questions about the future configuration of health services in west Wales and underscores the financial and logistical hurdles facing ambitious infrastructure projects in the region.

The delays have reignited political tensions in June this year, with Welsh Health Minister Eluned Morgan (as she was then) laying blame on Conservative politicians for obstructing progress. During a Welsh Parliament session she accused the Conservatives of leading a campaign against a new hospital years ago, which she claimed delayed its construction.

Speaking in response to a question from Pembrokeshire’s Sam Kurtz MS about the ongoing delays, Baroness Morgan said: “If you [the Conservatives] hadn’t led a campaign against the West Wales hospital, it would’ve been up and running by now. The Conservatives must take their share of responsibility for the fact there is not already a West Wales hospital.”

Morgan’s remarks were met with sharp criticism from veteran campaigners and opposition politicians. Dr Chris Overton, a prominent campaigner for Withybush Hospital, called the comments “rubbish,” pointing out that the campaign to save services at Withybush Hospital drew support from across the political spectrum, including members of the Labour Party and non-affiliated community members.

“The reality,” Dr Overton said, “is that Labour has been in power in Wales for 25 years. They’ve had plenty of time to build this hospital. Instead, they’ve salami-sliced services at Withybush to the point where trust in their promises is completely eroded.”

At that time Plaid Cymru candidate Cris Tomos and Liberal Democrat candidate Alistair Cameron both called for greater clarity and transparency from the Welsh Government. Tomos emphasized the need for genuine consultation with communities, while Cameron pointed out that residents face uncertainty about accessing services during the decade-long delay.

Covid an issue

Executive Director of Strategy and Planning Lee Davies said: “The pandemic and subsequent programme delays have meant the timescale for delivery of the programme, in particular the new hospital network, is substantially longer than originally anticipated. It is now highly likely that the new hospital would not be operational for at least a decade.

“In accepting that a new hospital will not be operational in the near future, it follows that the key service changes unlocked through a new hospital will now need to be considered ahead of a new facility and within existing hospitals.”

“Work to support fragile services in the interim of a new hospital has already begun through a programme of work called the Clinical Services Plan.”

“Staff, including clinicians, working with stakeholders and patient representatives have reviewed issues and challenges faced, agreed minimum standards, and developed draft options for nine fragile services.

“The nine services are Critical Care, Emergency General Surgery, Stroke, Endoscopy, Radiology, Dermatology, Ophthalmology, Orthopaedics and Urology. They are services which need change and support to continue safely providing care in the medium term.”

Board agreed that the programme prepares for a public consultation to involve further staff and communities in this work. The scope and matters for a future consultation, including the options, will be prepared for the next Health Board meeting at the end of January 2025.

Lee Davies added: “In the absence of a new hospital in the south of our area to address challenges, we need to consider other options to bring together some of our services. We anticipate the emerging model, informed by work on the Clinical Services Plan, will seek to build on the strengths of each of the hospital sites in a way that builds complementary areas of expertise.”

News

Citizen sought for governance and Audit Committee role

Published

13 hours ago

November 28, 2024

Tom Sinclair

PEMBROKESHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL is inviting applications for a citizen to serve as a Lay Member on its Governance and Audit Committee. This vital role contributes to the oversight and accountability of the council’s operations.

Committee responsibilities include:

Reviewing and scrutinising the council’s financial affairs.
Assessing and improving risk management, internal control, performance assessment, and corporate governance.
Making reports and recommendations to the council or relevant committees on the effectiveness of these systems.
Additional statutory functions.

Candidate requirements
Applicants must demonstrate a strong understanding of the audit process and a commitment to values such as accountability, probity, openness, independence, fairness, and sound financial management within the public sector.

Ineligibility criteria:
Individuals cannot apply if they:

Are currently a member or officer of any local authority.
Have served as a member or officer of any local authority within the last 12 months.
Are a spouse or civil partner of a member or officer of any local authority.

Appointment process
The successful candidate will be selected by a panel comprising an Independent Chair, three council members, and one community council member. An allowance will be provided for attendance at committee meetings.

Application details
Applications from all sections of the community are welcome. The closing date is 10 January 2025.

For a full role description and an application pack, contact Lydia Cheshire on 01437 775356 or via email at [email protected].