Connect with us
Advertisement
Advertisement

Politics

Welsh Government urged to act on ‘fleecehold scandal’

Published

on

SENEDD Members called for meaningful reform of the “wild west” of estate management charges in memory of Labour politician Hefin David, who championed the cause.

Carolyn Thomas led a debate in the Senedd on a petition calling for the Welsh Government to commit to adopting the maintenance of new housing estates by councils.

The petitions committee chair paid tribute to her Labour colleague Hefin David, who was instrumental in highlighting the issue in the Welsh Parliament for nearly a decade.

Dr David, who died suddenly last month, pressed the Welsh and UK Governments to protect leaseholders against “huge annual fees” charged by estate management companies.

In June, he warned people living on the Cwm Calon estate in Ystrad Mynach had just had their third increase in as many years.

Senedd Members from across the political divide paid tribute to Dr David for his tireless campaigning on the issue during a debate on September 17.

Caerphilly's Labour MS Hefin David
Hefin David speaking in the Senedd

Ms Thomas recalled the committee’s visit to the estate, organised by the late Caerphilly Senedd Member to highlight home owners’ understandable frustrations.

She said: “It is fitting that work continues to pursue the regulatory changes that Hefin called for with such passion and energy on behalf of his constituents.”

The north Walian told the Senedd that Dr David was practical in his approach but typically candid about the problems of a poorly regulated sector, describing it as the “wild west”.

Ms Thomas highlighted the plight of residents who submitted the petition after being hit with bills for maintenance of a park bordering The Mill estate in Canton, Cardiff.

Labour MS Carolyn Thomas
Labour MS Carolyn Thomas

Conservative Joel James fully supported the recommendations of the committee’s report.

The former councillor told the chamber or Siambr: “It seems that these companies have the right to charge almost any amount for the work that they do.”

Mr James warned home owners often find themselves paying “way over the odds”, with little recourse to challenge costs under lengthy contracts.

Rhys ab Owen, who sits as an independent, said: “This morning, whilst I was taking my daughter to school, I walked past The Mill. But, before I walked past The Mill, I walked past Lansdowne Gardens, another fairly new development.

Independent MS Rhys ab Owen
Independent MS Rhys ab Owen

“One – Lansdowne Gardens – has been adopted; the other, The Mill, has not. Residents have no idea why this is the case: why down the road somebody has to pay for their road and for the pavement but somewhere else they don’t.”

Mr ab Owen told Senedd Members he received an email only last week from a constituent trapped in such a development who was feeling suicidal.

Plaid Cymru’s Siân Gwenllian similarly expressed concerns about management companies “lining their own pockets”, pointing to the example of the Gwêl y Llan estate in Caernarfon.

She said: “Residents in Caernarfon and across Wales deserve fairness rather than a lack of communication and increasing fees for services that they don’t receive.”

“This is a devolved matter,” Ms Gwenllian stressed. “And it’s our duty to act but once again it seems that the Welsh Government is going to wait and see what comes from Westminster.”

Plaid Cymru MS Sian Gwenllian
Plaid Cymru MS Siân Gwenllian

Labour backbencher Alun Davies broadly agreed: “It is simply not fair on people to be placed in this situation then for ministers and for governments to stand back and simply say, ‘It’s too difficult for us to solve, so we won’t even try.’”

Raising the example of the Cae Ffwrnais estate in Ebbw Vale, the former minister called for a law to protect people and hold big businesses to account.

Similarly, his colleague Mike Hedges argued Wales desperately needs housing legislation.

Jayne Bryant, Wales’ housing secretary, accepted four of the committee’s recommendations but rejected calls for financial support to retrospectively adopt privately managed estates.

She said her officials are working closely with counterparts in Westminster on implementing the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act, which was passed by the Conservatives in 2024.

Ms Bryant told the Senedd the Labour UK Government has committed to further action.  

A housing estate bill – introduced by Alistair Strathern, a backbench Labour MP – is currently in the early stages of making its way through the House of Commons.

 

Politics

Culture and sport ‘are not a nice to have – they are part of the solution’

Published

on

CULTURE and sport “are not a nice to have – they are part of the solution to creating a healthier, more prosperous society”, according to Wales’ new culture and sport minister.

Outlining her priorities in the Senedd on Tuesday June 16, Heledd Fychan highlighted the importance of the arts and sport in preventative health.

She also spoke of the importance of the Welsh language and Wales’ music industry, and called for the devolution of broadcasting,

“These priorities mark the beginning of a journey and the beginning of a new chapter for culture and sport here in Wales,” Ms Fychan told the Siambr.

She continued: “This government believes in the power of culture and sport to transform lives, to contribute to the vision of moving towards a preventative health agenda to put our health service on a more sustainable footing, and because we are determined to build a Wales where creativity thrives.”

Ms Fychan, of Pontypridd Cynon Merthyr, was quizzed on her government’s calls for the devolution of broadcasting.

In her statement, the minister pledged to create a “stronger media environment” which reflects a “confident and prosperous Wales”.

Laying out her priorities for broadcasting, she said: “Wales deserves a confident, diverse and sustainable media landscape rooted in public value and national ambition.

“To achieve this, Wales must have a voice in the decisions that affect us. That is why we are determined to continue to make the case for the devolution of powers over broadcasting.”

She revealed work is underway to set up a shadow broadcasting and communications authority – designed to build a “stronger and more accountable” media landscape in Wales.

She also highlighted her plans to support public-interest journalism and “safeguard the provision of high-quality news”.

Describing the development of a shadow broadcasting authority as “completely unnecessary”, Reform’s Louise Emery – who is shadow minister for culture – said: “This is more constitutional navel-gazing, more quangos, more slow state-building towards independence, and more cost.”

Reform MS Louise Emery
Reform MS Louise Emery

Ms Emery went on to criticise the government’s plans to support public-interest journalism and said: “On this side of the chamber, we feel we already have a state-funded news outlet with blatant political bias, and we don’t need any more.

“I would suggest that state-funded journalism in Wales will mean state-funded interference, and I would also suggest that ‘high-quality news’ is a highly subjective phrase. Who is going to decide what is high-quality journalism and therefore needs state help?”

She added: “How can we ensure there is no foreign interference when allocating Books Council of Wales funding to news outlets?”

Ms Emery’s comments were met with laughter in the Siambr from opposing politicians.

However, Ms Fychan made no reference to Ms Emery’s comments in her response.

Paul Davies, Welsh Conservative spokesperson for the Welsh language, culture and sport, echoed Ms Emery’s criticisms of the devolution of broadcasting powers.

Conservative MS Paul Davies
Conservative MS Paul Davies

Outlining his party’s opposition to broadcasting devolution, Mr Davies said: “Given the challenges that the cabinet minister has already highlighted in her statement today, surely this is not the best possible use of resources, especially given that these powers are not devolved.”

Mr Davies called for Ms Fychan to reveal how much was spent on the new authority, how it will be funded, and how it will operate.

Similarly as with Ms Emery, Ms Fychan did not reference Mr Davies’ broadcasting comments in her response.

Ms Fychan described use of the Welsh language, particularly social use, as an “integral” part of her priorities.

Discussing the upcoming Eisteddfod – which is celebrating it’s 850th anniversary – she said: “A contribution of £0.25 million from the government will support a programme of activities to inspire people to use the language and raise the international profile of the National Eisteddfod.

“Our financial support will also ensure that local low-income families have free access to the festival.

“It is vital that everybody has an opportunity to enjoy our culture, language and National Eisteddfod.”

Reform’s shadow minister noted that she was “really glad” to hear the Welsh language was being prioritised.

Responding briefly to the cabinet minister in Welsh, Ms Emery shared that she has been learning Welsh for two years and is hoping to practice her skills at the Eisteddfod this summer.

However, she questioned Plaid’s plans to get people speaking the language, adding that “coercion drives resentment, not fluency”.

She said: “If the Welsh Government is serious about one million Welsh speakers, it needs to invest in the conditions that make people choose the language, not mandate it on those who don’t speak it.

“Welsh culture, the arts and sport should lift people up and bring communities together – that we agree on. But they can do that in whatever language they choose.”

In her statement, Ms Fychan said: “For too long, culture, the arts and sport have been pitted against the NHS rather than being recognised as completely connected to it.

“These sectors are not a ‘nice to have’; they are part of the solution to creating a healthier society. Our manifesto commits to making culture and sport accessible to all.

“That includes addressing inequalities in access, whether due to cost, geography, disability or other barriers.”

Reform’s shadow minister for health, prevention and sport, James Evans, noted that he “never thought [he’d] find the day” he would agree with the minister on so much.

Reform MS James Evans, shadow health and prevention minister
Reform MS James Evans, shadow health and prevention minister

Mr Evans described sport as a “key part” of the prevention agenda, before questioning the minister on how much of the NHS budget will be reallocated to sports.

He said: “We’ve heard a lot today about money being moved, but I think a lot of the sports organisations listening to today’s proceedings would like to know exactly what proportion that’s going to be.”

In response Ms Fychan said: “In terms of the exact figures and how we will do this, this is a completely new way of working for government, and what I can give you the assurance of is that there is an acknowledgement across government of the importance of this, that we are ensuring that those discussions are now taking place within those first 100 days and we will update the Senedd as we can.”

Labour MS Mike Hedges
Labour MS Mike Hedges

Labour’s Mike Hedges questioned the minister on music tourism and it’s importance to both Welsh culture and the economy.

Stating that music touring in Wales, “attracted 834,000 visitors, supported 3,650 jobs, and generated £384 million for the economy” in 2024, Mr Hedges pressed the minister to commit to supporting Welsh music.

He said the Welsh Government must “grow Welsh music through smart public investment, bring down barriers to exporting Welsh music, ensure music education is accessible to all, and support home-grown creativity and new music that drives Welsh tourism”.

In response, Ms Fychan referenced a report released last year which showed that traditional music in Wales was in danger of “disappearing entirely”.

Noting that fewer children are taking GCSEs in music, drama, and art and that universities are cutting courses in creative areas, Ms Fychan said often these areas are seen as “not worth investing in” – adding that, “of course”, they are.

Closing her response to the member she said: “Hopefully we will then see, […], that there will be a future for creative people here in Wales, and a future for these sectors that are seen as economically beneficial.”

 

Continue Reading

Politics

Minister wants Wales to have more say over justice, policing, and rail funding

Published

on

WALES needs more say over justice, policing, and rail investment, the new constitution minister has said.

Plaid Cymru’s Dafydd Trystan Davies faced questions from Senedd colleagues for the first time on Tuesday June 16.

The Caerdydd Fynnon Taf MS, who was appointed to the cabinet role last month, has responsibility for overseeing the government’s priorities, supporting oversight of the cabinet office, and constitutional affairs.

He is also responsible for the potential devolution of justice and policing.

Adrian Mason, Reform’s shadow constitution minister, challenged Dr Trystan Davies on Plaid’s plans.

Mr Mason said: “Plaid Cymru has long argued for more powers for Wales and greater responsibility here in Cardiff Bay. But Plaid cannot present itself as a new beginning after the Labour-Plaid era when, at key moments, it helped keep Labour in power.

“After 27 years of Labour-led devolution in health, education, transport and the economy, does the minister accept that Plaid shares some responsibility for that record?”

He added: “Why should Wales hand more powers to the same governing consensus that helped create the failures it now claims it can fix?”

Reform MS Adrian Mason
Reform MS Adrian Mason

Dr Trystan Davies emphasised that Plaid Cymru is a “new government”, set out on a “new course” which focuses on “the people’s priorities”.

He continued: “I think it is clear to everyone in this chamber that the legacy of 27 years of Labour government led to their election result. That is why so many of our fellow countrymen and women voted for a new leadership for Wales, and that is a Plaid Cymru leadership.”

The Reform shadow minister also questioned the minister on Plaid’s desire for independence.

He said: “Plaid’s manifesto is clear: it wants independence. But in the latest polling… the people of Wales do not. So, is the government pursuing independence by instalments – more powers, more separation, more institutions – without first asking the Welsh people the direct question?”

Mr Mason called for the minister to commit to “no constitutional change by the backdoor, no move towards independence, and no further substantive devolution without clear public consent”.

Dr Trystan Davies reiterated the First Minister’s election-time commitment that there will be no independence referendum during this Senedd term.

He then addressed the question of greater powers for Wales and said: “Where there are opportunities to improve the lives of the people in Wales, then [the Welsh Government] will take them.”

He said: “We are on a constitutional journey in Wales. It is a journey that is best served by consensus and collaboration, and that is what we will seek to do.”

Sam Rowlands, of the Welsh Conservatives, echoed the Mr Mason’s questions on Plaid Cymru’s constitutional reform plans.

Conservative MS Sam Rowlands
Conservative MS Sam Rowlands

He called on the minister to reveal how much time and resources are likely to be spent on “constitutional and independence-pursuing work” and to clarify how this will affect the government’s ability to focus on core public services.

Dr Trystan Davies said his party’s focus on constitutional matters will be in line with the priorities set out in its election manifesto.

He said: “On the constitution, [we] will be focused on those very specific priorities that we set out in our manifesto that will improve people’s lives – on water, on policing, on justice, on the Crown Estate, to improve people’s lives in Wales.”

Plaid MS Peredur Owen Griffiths, of Casnewydd Islwyn, asked his party colleague to share what steps he is taking to establish a national commission on Wales’ constitutional future.

Plaid Cymru MS Peredur Owen Griffiths, of Casnewydd Islwyn
Plaid Cymru MS Peredur Owen Griffiths, of Casnewydd Islwyn

Dr Trystan Davies noted that, in line with Plaid’s 100-day plan, a new national commission overseeing progress on further devolution and engaging with the public in a “national conversation about Wales’ constitutional future” is being developed.

He committed to updating the Senedd as the work progresses.

The minister also faced questions on potential areas of further devolution to Wales.

Plaid Cymru’s Niamh Salkeld, of Blaenau Gwent Caerffili Rhymni, asked him for an update on the progress being made to devolve rail funding to Wales.

She provided the example of Abertillery, describing the town as a “prime example of a community that is being held back by the UK Government’s chronic underfunding of Wales’ rail network.”

Discussing the proposed Abertillery spur – a passenger railway branching off the Ebbw Vale line at Aberbeeg to reconnect Abertillery to the rail network – Ms Salkeld said the proposed rail line would improve access to jobs and education, increase footfall for local businesses, and support town centre regeneration.

Plaid Cymru MS Niamh Salkeld, of Blaenau Gwent Caerffili Rhymni
Plaid Cymru MS Niamh Salkeld, of Blaenau Gwent Caerffili Rhymni

Dr Trystan Davies responded: “The figures are stark. The UK Government has promised an investment of £445 million, which sounds like a large figure, but when you compare it to the £4.5 billion owed to Wales under HS2 money, it is merely a drop in the ocean.

“That £4.5 billion would allow us to invest in Abertillery, it would allow us to invest in rail and bus services across the country.

“It is our fair share, it is chwarae teg for Wales. That is why I am proud that my colleague, the deputy minister for transport [Mark Hooper], is pursuing this case energetically with the UK Government. It is only right, it is only fair.”

Ms Salkeld’s calls were supported by Labour’s Mike Hedges, who said he has “consistently argued for the devolution of rail funding.”

Mr Hedges, of Gwyr Abertawe, said: “Asymmetric devolution has not worked. It hasn’t worked in Britain, it hasn’t worked in Spain. It is important that rail funding is devolved. The main question is how should the funding be calculated.”

Labour MS Mike Hedges
Labour MS Mike Hedges

He pressed the minister to share which form of rail funding formula he would prefer: “relative population, relative population with the 20% addition that the Barnett formula provides, relative track length, or relative passenger numbers?”

Dr Trystan Davies noted that Wales would do “pretty well” out of relative track length due to the geography of the country.

He added: “We have historically received a disproportionately low share of rail enhancement funding from the UK Government.

“Transport for Wales set out a vision of £14 billion of rail spending. That is the kind of rail funding that Wales needs to improve our rail services and to ensure that we have a 21st century rail system.”

Policing

Catherine Cullen, Reform MS for Blaenau Gwent Caerffili Rhymni
Catherine Cullen, Reform MS for Blaenau Gwent Caerffili Rhymni

The cabinet minister also faced questions on the devolution of policing, led by Reform MS Catherine Cullen.

Ms Cullen, of Blaenau Gwent Caerffili Rhymni, told the Siambr her constituents don’t want to see money “wasted” on devolving more powers, they want “better jobs and higher salaries”.

Questioning the minister on the financial impacts of further devolution she said: “Why does this Plaid government think this should be a priority, when so many of the public services that people rely upon are already under considerable pressure?”

Dr Trystan Davies noted that devolving policing to Wales has been recommended by a series of independent commissions, including the Silk Commission in 2014.

He clarified that Plaid’s priorities remain as the NHS, schools, the economy, child poverty and childcare, but with regard to policing said: “There clearly are negotiations to be had around the transfer of functions and how effectively those resources are transferred from the UK level to the Welsh level.

“We will be robust and energetic in those discussions with our UK counterparts.”

Labour’s Mr Hedges once again weighed in on the debate, affirming his support for the devolution of policing.

He referred back to a debate he led in 2013 that received majority support in the Siambr calling for the its devolution.

He said: “Policing is devolved to Northern Ireland, Scotland, London, and other areas with elected mayors, but not to Wales.

“Different devolution settlements for Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland do not work, as I said earlier.

“Currently, Wales gets 20% extra for devolved services than England gets. Why would it be different for policing?”

Welsh Liberal Democrats leader, Jane Dodds, also voiced her support for the devolution of policing.

Jane Dodds, leader of the Welsh Liberal Democrats
Jane Dodds, leader of the Welsh Liberal Democrats

She said: “Unlike Reform UK, I do want to talk about something that affects the people of Wales directly and affects women.

“The devolution of justice and policing is not an abstract debate – it has real human consequences, and in the last Senedd, the equality and social justice committee concluded that the current devolution settlement is causing direct harm to women in Wales.”

Ms Dodds continued: “There is no women’s prison in Wales. Welsh women serving custodial sentences are held in England far from their families and far from their communities, and far from the support services that they need.”

She called on the minister to share his plans for securing these powers, along with a timetable for when it can be expected.

Dr Trystan Davies responded: “There are a number of issues there in terms of services for women that are currently not good enough under the current justice system.

“I do think that there is work to be done in terms of the justice system and devolution. There is work to be done in terms of policing that is related to devolution.

“In order to make progress on this, we must build an effective, productive relationship with the UK Government. A meeting has already been arranged with the minister for policing in the UK, the Deputy First Minister, and myself.”

 

Continue Reading

Politics

New Senedd committees confirmed – what are they and what are their responsibilities?

Published

on

THE NEW SENEDD committees have been decided, meaning detailed scrutiny of the Welsh Government’s decisions can begin.

The titles, remits, and which party will chair each of the new committees have now been approved by Senedd Members – but which members will be sitting on these committees is yet to be decided.

Existing to check and challenge the work of the Welsh Government, Senedd committees scrutinise laws both before and after they are passed, proposing changes when needed.

They are made up of Senedd Members from different party groups who work together to examine the areas of law that are devolved to the Welsh Government.

For the new Senedd term, the business committee has proposed the formation of 13 committees – one more than in the previous term.

So what are the committees for this Senedd term and what do they cover?

For this Senedd term there will be eight policy and legislation committees, with each having nine members from across the political groups.

The representation in the committees for each group depends on their level of representation in the Senedd.

In the nine-member committees, Plaid Cymru will have four members and Reform three, while Welsh Labour and the Conservatives will have one each.

The committees are: early years, children, young people and education; health and social care; climate change; environment, sustainability and rural affairs; equality, human rights, and social justice; economy, energy, and connectivity; culture, communications, Cymraeg and sport; local government, housing and planning; and constitution, justice and external affairs.

The constitution, justice, and external affairs committee splits the remit of the legislation, justice and constitution committee from the previous Senedd, adding external affairs and electoral matters to its brief.

There will also be committees for finance; legislation; public accounts and public administration; and petitions.

Each will have seven members as opposed to nine for the policy and legislation committees.

The party-group representation in each of the seven-member committees will be three Plaid Cymru members, two Reform, and one each for Labour and the Conservatives.

Senedd standing orders – the written rules that govern Senedd proceedings – also require the establishment of a standards of conduct committee.

This committee has responsibility over complaints and the conduct of members more generally. It is also cross-party, meaning members from each of the political groups may sit, and it will have five members in total.

As with the party makeup of the committees, chairs are also allocated to reflect the size of the political groups represented in the Senedd.

In line with the current makeup of the Senedd, Plaid Cymru will have six chairs, Reform five, and Welsh Labour and the Conservatives will have one each.

Plaid Cymru will chair the committees for early years, children, young people and education; equality, human rights, and social justice; economy, energy, and connectivity; culture, communications, Cymraeg and sport; constitution, justice and external affairs; and standards of conduct.

The committees for climate change; environment, sustainability and rural affairs; local government, housing and planning; public accounts and public administration; legislation; and petitions will be chaired by Reform.

Labour’s sole chair position will be on the committee for health and social care, while the Welsh Conservatives will chair the finance committee.

The Senedd approved the creation of these committees and the allocation of committee chairs to party groups in plenary on Tuesday June 16, with no objections.

There are also three more committees to be formed – the scrutiny of the First Minister committee, Llywydd’s committee, and chair’s forum – but these are governed by different rules and will be formed once the chairs of the other committees have been elected.

The first committee meetings will be held later in the Senedd term.

 

Continue Reading

Crime13 minutes ago

Prisons at breaking point: MPs warn Wales is paying the price of a failing system

Frozen healthcare budgets, overcrowded jails, homelessness on release and mounting pressure on staff are undermining rehabilitation across Wales, according to...

News14 hours ago

Brexit at 10: How Britain was sold a dream that cost us dearly

A decade after the referendum, the promised benefits remain hard to find while the economic costs are increasingly difficult to...

Crime16 hours ago

Worcestershire man jailed after violent attack on woman in Tenby

Defendant was already serving a suspended sentence when serious assault took place A WORCESTERSHIRE man has been jailed for more...

Climate17 hours ago

Offshore wind ‘could bring new generation of jobs to Milford Haven’

Pembrokeshire ports and Celtic Sea projects placed at centre of Wales’ green energy ambitions MILFORD HAVEN and Pembroke Dock could...

Community2 days ago

Police officer hailed hero after midnight sea rescue in Milford Haven

PC swam 100 metres offshore to save distressed woman heard calling for help in darkness A DYFED-POWYS POLICE officer has...

Local Government2 days ago

Security privately arranged by Mayor at Beating of the Bounds

HAVERFORDWEST TOWN COUNCIL has confirmed that security personnel seen at this year’s Beating of the Bounds were privately arranged and...

Business3 days ago

Celtic Freeport five-year plan puts Milford Haven at centre of green energy future

Strategy promises investment, skilled jobs and new supply chains, but major barriers remain over grid connections, planning and delivery THE...

Education3 days ago

Closure of Ysgol Clydau approved after emotional council debate

COUNCILLORS WARNED RURAL COMMUNITIES WILL REMEMBER DECISION PEMBROKESHIRE councillors have voted to close Ysgol Clydau following an emotional debate over...

Education3 days ago

Manorbier school closure process to continue after narrow council vote

Questions remain over insurance, rebuilding costs and possible legal action by Diocese PEMBROKESHIRE councillors have voted to press ahead with...

Community3 days ago

The father, son and daughter lifeguard trio saving lives in Pembrokeshire

A FATHER, son and daughter are preparing to help keep beachgoers safe on the Pembrokeshire coast this summer as part...

Popular This Week