News
HEART UNIT NEXT TO GO: Alarm as Withybush Hospital faces more cuts
NEWS that the Cardiology service at Withybush General Hospital is to shut has come “like a bolt from the blue” according to local health campaigners.
Widespread fears that the removal of essential services in paediatrics and special baby care were the thin end of the wedge and represented “salami-slicing tactics” by the Health Board appear to have been borne out by the announcement of plans to substantially cut the provision of cardiac care in Haverfordwest.
A week after well over 500 local people protested outside the Senedd in Cardiff Bay, the Health Board chose to release a report dated January 27, 2014 into the future of cardiac care in West Wales.
Relying on what is described as “anecdotal” evidence, the Board commissioned the report in September last year to review cardiac care, around the same time its plans for neonatal care were referred to an a separate expert panel.
THE HEALTH BOARD did not publicise the referral of cardiac services and it was not mentioned by Mark Drakeford, Welsh Health Minister, who rejected the idea that services would be “salami sliced” away from the Haverfordwest hospital.
It is understood that the report proposes further downgrades to outlying general hospitals and the centralisation of cardiac care on West Wales General, Carmarthen.
The press release carried on the Local Health Board’s website says that the report was commissioned “following concerns raised” but fails to say by whom. The Pembrokeshire Herald understands that concerns were raised within the Local Health Board itself by two cardiologists and not by an outside agency.
Local Health Board Medical Director Dr Sue Fish said: “Our patients deserve the best possible care and we would like to reassure patients we take the issues raised in the report very seriously.
“The review did not look at any specific issues relating to individual patients and has not identified any parts of the service that are currently unsafe.
“However, it did make a number of recommendations advising us on how they believe we should configure cardiology services to improve the care of patients across the university health board.
“We will have to consider the recommendations very seriously before reaching a decision on how we implement them.”
Surprisingly, the members of the panel writing the report not only failed to visit West Wales General Hospital, they also failed to visit Bronglais and Withybush Hospitals or to speak to the families of patients who had received treatment at those hospitals.
The conclusion that the panel has drawn is:
“The reality for Withybush and Bronglais is that the current situation is not tenable. Patients served by these hospitals do not appear to receive optimum care.”
Sue Fish responded to the report saying:
“It’s important to stress that no decisions have been made as the project board will need to consider the recommendations with our expert clinicians before firm decisions on the best way forward are made.”
The Health Board will provide its official response to the report at the public board meeting in May. The announcement comes a week to the day after the protest by outraged Pembrokeshire residents at the gradual and ongoing movement of essential health care services away from our County’s only general hospital.
As the Health Board had the report on January 27, it is not clear why its publication was delayed until March 12.
Spokesperson for SWAT Chris Overton said:
“The cardiology move is not a surprise. Very soon all inpatient services will be centralised at Glangwili. There is no room there and nothing is ready!
“The Chairman and Chief Executive are jumping ship. The Welsh Government seem willing to sacrifice a few lives just to save money. None of this was in the Health Board’s consultation, which was a farce. Hopefully we can really expose this now in court! “The next marches and demonstrations need to be much bigger. Are you with us?”
The next protest march to Withybush is scheduled for Saturday, April 12 and a fundraising craft fair will take place on Sunday, April 6 at the Picton Centre, Haverfordwest.
Spokesperson for SWAT Chris Overton said:
“The cardiology move is not a surprise. Very soon all inpatient services will be centralised at Glangwili. There is no room there and nothing is ready!
“The Chairman and Chief Executive are jumping ship. The Welsh Government seem willing to sacrifice a few lives just to save money. None of this was in the Health Board’s consultation, which was a farce. Hopefully we can really expose this now in court!
“The next marches and demonstrations need to be much bigger. Are you with us?”
The next protest march to Withybush is scheduled for Saturday, April 12 and a fundraising craft fair will take place on Sunday, April 6 at the Picton Centre, Haverfordwest.
Health
Ward closures at Prince Philip Hospital, Llanelli as norovirus cases rise
FOUR wards at Prince Philip Hospital in Llanelli have been temporarily closed and visiting restrictions introduced after cases of norovirus were confirmed on the site and in the wider community.
Hywel Dda University Health Board said the measures came into force on Tuesday (Jan 13) and apply to the whole hospital, even though four wards are currently affected.
Visiting has been limited to essential visits only, with the health board asking members of the public not to attend the hospital “until further notice”. Essential visiting may be permitted in exceptional circumstances, and families are being advised to contact wards directly or the hospital switchboard for guidance.
Norovirus is a highly contagious virus that can cause vomiting and diarrhoea, and outbreaks often lead to ward closures to help prevent further spread.
Sharon Daniel, Hywel Dda’s Director of Nursing, Quality and Patient Experience said: “We have taken the decision to restrict all but essential visiting to Prince Philip Hospital in order to keep patients and staff safe and to halt the spread of norovirus, which is currently circulating in our local community.
“I know this will be difficult for those who have loved ones in hospital and we will re-open the wards as soon as it is safe to do so. Please keep an eye on our website or social media for further updates.”
The health board said other hospital sites across Hywel Dda are operating as normal, but urged people not to visit friends and relatives if they have symptoms of flu, sickness or diarrhoea, and to wear a face covering when attending clinical sites.
Ms Daniel added: “You should only come to our sites if you are feeling well. This helps us limit the spread of viruses and protect our most vulnerable patients. It also helps us to keep staff well, so that they can look after those in greatest need of our care.”
Hywel Dda also encouraged eligible people to take up flu vaccinations, and said information on flu jabs — including RSV and COVID-19 boosters where applicable — is available via the health board’s website or its vaccination helpline.
For further information, the public can call 0300 303 8322 (option one) or email [email protected].
Crime
Man jailed after samurai sword brandished in Pembroke Dock street brawl
15-month sentence after “ugly” disturbance left members of the public fearing for their safety
MICHEL VALMONT has been jailed for 15 months after brandishing a samurai sword during a violent disturbance in Pembroke Dock which left members of the public fearing for their safety.
Swansea Crown Court heard the incident unfolded on Pembroke Street on Saturday (June 15, 2024), prompting multiple calls to police from alarmed witnesses.
Prosecutor Craig Jones told the court officers were contacted as the street fight developed, with members of the public reporting several men involved in violence in the street.
The court heard that while two men were already engaged in a brawl, Valmont emerged from a nearby property dressed in black and carrying the sword. He was then seen chasing the men while wielding the weapon, heightening concern about what he intended to do.
Police arrived to find Stephen Charge and Trevor Herridge still fighting. They were separated and arrested at the scene.
A search of the area later uncovered a samurai sword and a black hooded top in a nearby garden. Valmont was subsequently identified and arrested.
Valmont, 48, of Water Street, Pembroke Dock, and Charge, 52, of Pembroke Street, Pembroke Dock, had both previously pleaded guilty to affray. Valmont also admitted possession of an offensive weapon.
The court heard Valmont has 74 previous convictions for 203 offences, including violence, weapons offences, dishonesty and public disorder. Charge’s record includes assault occasioning actual bodily harm, battery, criminal damage and dishonesty offences.
Defending Valmont, Jon Tarrant said his client had not been involved at the outset but made what he described as a “ridiculous and stupid” decision to intervene after realising a friend was caught up in the incident.
He told the court Valmont accepted a prison sentence was inevitable, adding that “walking around the centre of Pembroke Dock with a samurai sword is not going to result in any other outcome”.
The court was told Valmont had used heroin for around 30 years but was now testing clean.
Emily Bennett, representing Charge, said her client accepted his actions went beyond lawful self-defence and was extremely remorseful.
She told the court Charge began using drugs at 13 and later became addicted to heroin, but was now abstinent. He has four children, whom he sees regularly.
Passing sentence, Judge Paul Thomas KC described the incident as an “ugly brawl” and said the scenes were “more reminiscent of the Wild West of America in the 19th Century than West Wales in the 21st”.
While the cause of the disturbance was unclear, the judge said Valmont had escalated matters by introducing a “fearsome” weapon.
After receiving a one-quarter reduction for his guilty plea, Valmont was sentenced to 15 months in prison and will serve up to half the term in custody before being released on licence.
Charge received an eight-month prison sentence, suspended for two years, with a 20% reduction for his guilty plea. He was ordered to complete a rehabilitation requirement and fined £400 for breaching a suspended sentence.
The judge told him he had avoided immediate custody “by the skin of your teeth” and warned he was now “drinking in the last chance saloon”.
The court heard Herridge, 47, who had been charged with affray in connection with the incident, has since died.
(Pic: CPS Cymru)
Local Government
Minutes under scrutiny as Neyland councillor faces standards tribunal hearing
NEYLAND TOWN COUNCIL RECORDS QUESTIONED AHEAD OF TWO-DAY CASE IN HAVERFORDWEST
QUESTIONS over the accuracy and fairness of Neyland Town Council’s official minutes have resurfaced ahead of a two-day standards tribunal hearing involving one of its members.
Councillor David Devauden is due to appear at a hearing at Haverfordwest County Court on Thursday (Jan 15) and Friday (Jan 16) from 10:00am, in connection with an alleged breach of the Code of Conduct under the Local Government Act 2000.
The renewed focus on council record-keeping comes after minutes from an earlier meeting recorded a statement that Cllr Devauden had been “found guilty by the Ombudsman” of breaching the Code of Conduct and bringing the town council into disrepute.
The wording appears in the minutes of a meeting held on Monday (Oct 6), during a discussion about civic arrangements for the Remembrance Service. In that section, the minutes record Cllr Mike Harry raising concerns about Cllr Devauden being offered a public role, referring to his behaviour in previous meetings and “the fact that Cllr Devauden had been found guilty by the Ombudsman of breaching the Code of Conduct and bringing NTC into disrepute.”
However, the standards tribunal hearing listed for this week has yet to take place. No independent finding from an Ombudsman has been produced to the public record to substantiate the claim as written in the minutes.
Cllr Devauden disputes the accuracy of the statement and says it has caused serious reputational damage. He has also claimed the language recorded in the minutes amounts to defamation, and says similar wording was later repeated in motions passed by the council.
Concerns about the accuracy of the written record have also been reflected in later council business. Minutes from the meeting held on Monday (Nov 3) show the town council postponed approval of the minutes of a previous meeting, after the Clerk asked for time to check the recording and make amendments where necessary.
The Nov 3 minutes note that the October minutes would be reviewed against the recording before being brought back for approval, underlining the importance of ensuring formal records accurately reflect what was said and decided.
Cllr Devauden has also raised concerns about the process leading to this week’s hearing, saying he has never been called before a Standards Committee and questioning whether due process has been followed.
In correspondence, he also highlighted the practical issue of documentation, claiming the maximum number of documents to be presented is 200, while he says he has more than 1,000 documents relevant to the matter, with further material continuing to be updated.
The two-day hearing is scheduled to take place at Haverfordwest County Court on Thursday (Jan 15) and Friday (Jan 16), beginning at 10:00am.
-
Crime2 days agoFather jailed for 35 years after baby hurled at television
-
Crime14 hours agoMan jailed after samurai sword brandished in Pembroke Dock street brawl
-
Crime5 days agoMan pleads guilty after £150k drugs haul found in Pembroke traffic stop
-
Education2 days agoPembrokeshire Learning Centre placed in special measures following Estyn inspection
-
Crime2 days agoMilford Haven man, 65, convicted of sexual assault on teenage girl
-
Crime6 days agoHaverfordwest woman fined after admitting assault offence
-
Crime6 days agoMan given suspended prison sentence for drugs, weapons and driving offences
-
Local Government6 days agoOwners of empty Pembrokeshire homes could be forced to sell them










Geoff Sizer
March 20, 2014 at 7:30 am
This is going to be death by a thousand cuts for Withybush Hospital – so sad and so serious for the residents of Pembrokeshire
Teifion
March 22, 2014 at 9:12 pm
If everyone could make an appointment for their heart attack or stroke we’ll be fine with that “golden hour” where treatment is a must 🙁
Elizabeth
February 15, 2015 at 12:57 pm
This is dreadful news once again the people in Pembrokeshire are being forgotten. Glangwilli is outdated and unable to cope now without all the extra patients when the closure happens and it will regardless to how many protests we have, No consideration has been thought of with regards to the families who are going to have to travel so far to visit loved ones, A disgrace .
stephen
February 15, 2015 at 10:47 pm
tell me who the hell is taking all the money + glangwilli have they doubled the size of it? they need to the way h west are closing the wards, perhaps someone wants to build a housing estate on the hospital site for immigrants, good money in that so i heard.