News
Caldicot family still have hopes to find missing son James Nutley, 19 years on
IT HAS BEEN almost 19 years since James Nutley vanished without a trace during a golfing trip in the picturesque town of Tenby, leaving his parents, Catherine and Jeffrey Nutley, in an agonizing state of uncertainty. However, a recent surge of interest in the case has rekindled hope that answers may finally be within reach for the grieving couple.
On the fateful day of October 24, 2004, James Nutley, a 25-year-old golf enthusiast, went missing under mysterious circumstances. The last known sighting of him was captured on CCTV near the Giltar Hotel in Tenby at 23:57. Despite extensive searches and investigations, what transpired after that moment remains a haunting enigma.
“It is hanging over you all the time,” expressed Jeffrey Nutley, his voice heavy with the weight of 19 years of unanswered questions. “We were thinking ‘he’ll turn up in a day or two’ – 20 years later we’re still thinking ‘where is he?’.”
Recalling the events leading up to her son’s disappearance, Catherine Nutley described the ordinary excitement that filled the air that day. James, described as a “golf-mad” young man, was eagerly preparing for his golfing trip, seemingly content with his life and relishing his “dream job” as a golf club demonstrator. Little did they know that their lives would be forever altered by an unexpected turn of events.
The moment Catherine received the news of James’ disappearance, everything changed. Her sister and a friend rushed to her workplace to deliver the heart-wrenching news. “My sister said ‘James has gone missing in Tenby’,” Catherine recounted, her voice trembling with emotion. From that instant, their lives were consumed by an overwhelming sense of dread and the relentless pursuit of answers.
As Catherine made her way to Tenby, Jeffrey stayed behind, clutching the landline phone in the desperate hope that James would reach out. By the time she arrived, the search for James was already underway, and the couple found themselves in a state of numbing shock. Sleep eluded them as the realization of their son’s inexplicable absence sank in.
The investigation into James Nutley’s disappearance eventually went cold, with few breakthroughs emerging over the years. The Nutley family endured the anguish of numerous false leads and even a false murder confession, which only deepened their pain and prolonged their torment. Richard Fairbrass, who confessed to the murder and disposal of James’ body, later admitted to fabricating the entire story. In 2006, he was convicted and sentenced to two years in prison for attempting to pervert the course of justice.
Reflecting on the false confession, Jeffrey lamented, “It set us back a bit, it didn’t do us any good at all.” Yet, in the face of such setbacks, the Nutleys have not relinquished their hope of one day being reunited with their son.
Recently, the Nutleys shared their story on the podcast “The Missing,” which focuses on long-term missing persons cases. The podcast’s coverage has generated renewed interest in James’ disappearance, sparking a glimmer of optimism for the grieving parents.
As to what could have befallen their beloved son that night, Catherine and Jeffrey remain haunted by unanswerable questions. Did James plan to meet someone and embark on a different life? Or did someone abduct him, shattering their lives forever? The possibilities, while filled with uncertainty, persist as they continue to hope for a reunion with their son.
In their enduring search for closure, the Nutleys have experienced moments of false hope. They have believed to have glimpsed James through windows or in restaurants, only to have those hopes dashed. Catherine shared that whenever she sees a man begging on the street, she takes a closer look, just in case it might be her long-lost son.
The passing years have not dampened the Nutleys’ determination. Despite the absence of tangible leads, they remain resolute in their belief that a reunion with their son is still possible. “Well, you can’t give up, can you, until someone tells us differently,” said Jeffrey.
The couple refuses to accept the idea of a memorial service, as it would imply finality without knowing James’ fate. Their grief is suspended in a state of limbo, aching for resolution. “You can’t grieve because there’s no one there,” Catherine poignantly expressed.
Learning to live with the pain of not knowing, the Nutleys have carried the weight of their son’s absence while endeavoring to continue their lives. Catherine confides that she says her prayers at night, fervently asking for divine protection over James, wherever he may be.
As the renewed interest in James Nutley’s disappearance shines a spotlight on this enduring mystery, it is the fervent wish of Catherine and Jeffrey Nutley that this attention will finally bring them the answers they have been longing for. Only time will tell if their unwavering hope will be rewarded with the long-awaited reunion they so desperately desire.
Crime
Four men fined over illegal cockle gathering on the Burry Inlet
More than £36,000 in penalties after protected estuary targeted
FOUR men from Llanelli have been fined more than £36,000 after illegally gathering cockles from the protected Burry Inlet.
Natural Resources Wales (NRW) launched an investigation following a report of unlawful cockle harvesting in the Llanelli area on Thursday (June 12, 2025).
Enforcement officers attended and found that Ethan Thomas, Brogan Phillips, Finley Harvey Jones, all from Llanelli, and Korey Kathrens, from Burry Port, had driven 4×4 vehicles more than one kilometre out into the estuary to collect cockles without permission.
The group was intercepted as they attempted to leave the scene. During the incident, two of the vehicles became stuck in the estuary and had to be towed to safety.
Officers seized a large quantity of cockles along with equipment used in the operation.
All four men denied the charges but were found guilty following a trial at Llanelli Magistrates’ Court on Monday (Mar 23, 2026).
Each defendant was fined £4,000, ordered to pay a victim surcharge of £1,600, and prosecution costs of £3,546—bringing the total penalty per person to £9,146. The court ordered payments at a rate of £200 per month.
Huwel Manley, Head of South West Wales Operations at NRW, said: “This case highlights the seriousness of illegal cockle gathering, which can damage fragile ecosystems and undermine licensed fisheries operating within the estuary.
“Natural Resources Wales is committed to protecting our shellfisheries and wider fisheries from illegal activity.
“We welcome the court’s decision and hope it sends a clear message that fishery and shellfish-related crime will not be tolerated. We will continue to take appropriate enforcement action against those who break the law.”
Education
Ysgol Henry Tudor reassures parents over Sikh ceremonial kirpan
School says religious item worn by pupil is secured, symbolic and non-functional
YSGOL HENRY TUDOR has moved to reassure parents after confirming that a pupil is wearing a ceremonial kirpan as part of their Sikh faith.
The development comes after around a dozen parents with children at the school contacted The Herald expressing concern about the situation.
In a letter sent to parents on Wednesday (Mar 25), the school explained that a Sikh family had recently joined the school community, and that the pupil is an Amritdhari Sikh — meaning they are required to wear certain articles of faith.
One of these is the kirpan, a small ceremonial blade which holds deep religious significance within Sikhism.
The school stressed that in this case the kirpan is “small, sheathed and secured,” and cannot be unsheathed. It added that the item is worn purely as a symbol of faith and “not as a functional item.”
Parents raise concerns
Around a dozen parents have contacted The Herald expressing concern about the situation, with some questioning both safety and how the decision was communicated.
Posts on local social media groups also reflect unease among some parents. One parent wrote that they were “not at all comfortable” with their child returning to school until the issue was resolved, while others questioned whether enough notice had been given before the decision was implemented.
Another commenter raised concerns about safety, suggesting that allowing any form of blade on school premises could set a precedent.
However, some claims circulating online — including suggestions that similar cases have led to violent incidents without prosecution — have not been substantiated.
Reassurance over safety
The letter made clear that appropriate steps have been taken to ensure the situation is managed safely and in line with safeguarding responsibilities and UK law.
School leaders said they remain committed to respecting the religious beliefs of all pupils while maintaining a safe environment, adding that the matter will continue to be monitored “sensitively and appropriately.”
In some settings, schools may agree adjustments to how a kirpan is worn — such as ensuring it is very small, secured, or sealed — so that religious requirements are respected while maintaining safety.
Understanding the kirpan
The kirpan is one of the five articles of faith — known as the Five Ks — observed by initiated Sikhs. It symbolises a duty to stand up against injustice and to protect others.
Under UK law, Sikhs are permitted to carry a kirpan for religious reasons. In schools, these are typically very small, kept in a sheath, and often secured so they cannot be drawn.
Across the UK, many schools have policies in place to accommodate the wearing of the kirpan while ensuring appropriate safeguards are followed.
Promoting inclusion
The school’s letter reflects a wider approach across education settings in Wales and the UK, where inclusivity and respect for different faiths are balanced with clear safety measures.
Pembrokeshire County Council has since confirmed it was aware of the situation and had provided guidance to Ysgol Henry Tudor when the matter was raised. A spokesperson said the authority is satisfied that appropriate safeguarding measures are in place, and that the school is following its procedures as outlined to parents in its communication. The update comes amid some concern from parents, including comments shared with The Herald and on social media, although no incidents relating to the matter have been reported.
Crime
Teen jailed after starting fire while others slept
Fire set in shared home left sleeping residents at risk and caused £130,000 damage
A TEENAGER who started a fire in his bedroom while other residents slept has been jailed for four years.
Jack Gornall, aged 18, of no fixed abode, was sentenced at Swansea Crown Court after admitting a series of offences including arson, threats with a knife, assault, and sending malicious communications.
The court heard that in the early hours of Sunday (Nov 17), Gornall deliberately started a fire inside his room at a shared property on Mansel Street, Carmarthen.
He then barricaded the door before climbing out of a first-floor window, leaving others inside the building at risk.
One resident was asleep at the time and had to be rescued by police. Two officers were later treated for smoke inhalation after tackling the incident before firefighters brought the blaze under control.
The fire caused extensive damage to the property, estimated at around £130,000.
Prosecutor Dean Pulling told the court that Gornall had earlier gone out to buy cigarettes and a lighter, and had carried out internet searches relating to accelerants in the days leading up to the fire.
The court also heard details of other offences.
In October 2024, Gornall repeatedly contacted his sister after being blocked, including calling her child’s phone. When she answered, he became abusive and threatened to report her to social services.
On another occasion in January 2025, he approached a car in Llandysul and produced a kitchen knife, waving it at occupants through an open window. The driver sped away and alerted police.
He also admitted stealing alcohol from a supermarket in Carmarthen, during which he became aggressive and assaulted a member of staff.
Gornall pleaded guilty to all offences at an early stage.
Judge Catherine Richards sentenced him to four years’ detention in a Young Offender Institution.
-
Crime7 days agoBroad Haven man remanded in custody over sexual harm prevention order breach
-
Crime7 days agoPublican jailed for six years for supplying cocaine and cannabis
-
Business3 days agoTaxi fare shock in Milford Haven as drivers switch to meters
-
News7 days agoPembrokeshire’s Muslims gather to celebrate Eid al-Fitr as Ramadan ends
-
Crime7 days agoCarmarthen man denies coercive control allegations
-
Business4 days agoCould Primark be coming to Haverfordwest? Major retailer in talks for former Wilko site
-
Education7 days agoPrendergast School achieves gold award for Armed Forces support
-
Crime6 days agoMilford Haven drug dealing pub boss who boasted of ‘best coke around’ jailed










