News
Pembroke Dock grants scandal: A decade of deception unravelled
A SCANDAL that has plagued Pembroke Dock for over a decade, involving the misuse of European grants intended for the regeneration of commercial properties, has finally been laid bare, revealing a tale of fraud, complicity, and administrative incompetence that has cost taxpayers hundreds of thousands of pounds.
The controversy centers around property developer Cathal McCosker, who exploited the grant scheme to convert town centre properties into bedsits, a purpose for which the funds were not intended, The Pembrokeshire Herald can now report.
Despite the requirement for commercial redevelopment, McCosker’s projects had minimal commercial footprint, with the developer securing grants through deceitful means, including the collusion of an architect and a council officer who verified the ineligible works as complete.
This scheme not only allowed McCosker to benefit from substantial grant funding but also to collect rent through the taxpayer-subsidised Housing Benefit scheme, raising serious questions about the oversight and integrity of council staff involved.
The issue came to light following diligent investigation by Councillor Mike Stoddart, whose relentless pursuit of the truth, despite facing personal attacks and obstruction, has been vindicated by recent legal opinions presented to the Full Council. Stoddart’s investigation revealed glaring inconsistencies in grant application documents, dubious tender processes, and a lack of basic auditing that pointed to a systemic failure within the council’s administration of the grants scheme.
Over the years, the scandal has seen attempts at cover-ups, misleading reports to the Council, and even a botched police investigation, culminating in the conclusion that, despite overwhelming evidence of wrongdoing, the chances of successful prosecution have been severely diminished by time and the ‘convenient’ loss of crucial evidence.
The saga has prompted calls for accountability, particularly aimed at former Council leader Jamie Adams, under whose watch much of the scandal unfolded.
Despite the damage to his reputation and the clear evidence of mismanagement, Adams has refrained from issuing an apology, maintaining his innocence in the face of substantial evidence to the contrary.
As Pembroke Dock grapples with the fallout of this scandal, the lessons from this debacle remain clear: transparency, accountability, and rigorous oversight are non-negotiable pillars of public administration.
The failure to adhere to these principles has not only resulted in financial loss but has also eroded trust in local governance, a sentiment that will take much to rebuild.
Councillor Mike Stoddart’s vindication serves as a stark reminder of the value of those who, despite personal cost, stand unwavering in their quest for the truth.
READ MORE ABOUT THIS SCANDAL IN THIS WEEK’S PEMBROKESHIRE HERALD OUT TOMORROW (15.3.24)
News
Pembrokeshire loses out as Labour ‘rewards its heartlands’
THE HEADLINE figure is an average rise in Welsh local authority budgets by 4.3%. Every Welsh rural council got less than that.
From Monmouthshire in the east to Anglesey in the north to Pembrokeshire in the west, the funding bonanza trumpeted by the Welsh Government as part of the best financial settlement since devolution turned into a damp, wet fart. No rural authority got the average settlement; only Carmarthenshire came close with a 4.1 increase. Meanwhile, Labour councils in the Valleys and metropolitan areas all experienced above-average rises in Welsh Government funding.
Local MS Sam Kurtz said, “It’s clear that the Welsh Labour Government is looking after their heartlands first and foremost as we run up to the Senedd election and is ignoring the needs of others.
“Delivering services in rural areas costs more; it’s the rural premium, but for the Welsh Labour Government to ignore this shows them at their worst.
“Carmarthenshire and Pembrokeshire county councils are asked to do more and more. It’s only right that they are supported correctly to deliver those services. Sadly, this provisional settlement falls well short of what is required.”
WG “TAKING PEMBROKESHIRE PUBLIC FOR FOOLS”
Pembrokeshire Conservative county councillor Aled Thomas said: “Labour is taking the Pembrokeshire public for fools, claiming that today’s announcement is good for Pembrokeshire when the reality is that our rural communities are being left behind once again.
“Labour is giving with one hand and taking away with the other, with a significant proportion of this additional money already spent on increased national insurance contributions.
“Pembrokeshire’s Labour cabinet member for finance must now commit that this money will be spent on core services and not wasted on vanity projects as we have seen time and again in the county.”
Whether Josh Beynon, Pembrokeshire County Council’s Cabinet Member for Finance, rises to that challenge remains to be seen. Our request for a response to the Welsh Government’s funding settlement for Pembrokeshire was refused.
SETTLEMENT SHOWS WHERE LOYALTIES LIE
The Independent Group was not as shy.
“The Welsh Government settlement lays bare where their true loyalties lie and the battleground for Senedd 2026 where Labour will concentrate their resources on protecting their established strongholds at all costs. “They may deny it, but that’s the appearance with healthier WG settlements of above 5% for Cardiff, Newport and Merthyr compared to 3.6% for Pembrokeshire, Ceredigion and Anglesey and even less for Gwynedd at 3.2%. Inflation is currently at 2.3%, meaning the real increase for Pembrokeshire is around 1.3%, and higher inflation over the next few months will erode the value of this settlement further.
“Furthermore, all local authorities are currently having to accept the consequence of the Chancellor’s rise of National Insurance, with Mark Drakeford revealing that there will be no decision from the UK government on NI compensation for public sector employers until May 2025, meaning much of the additional AEF will have already been swallowed up, a decision that needs to be taken sooner rather than later many would suggest.”
CONSULTATION UNDERWAY
The Independent Group spokesperson continued: “Today launches six weeks of formal consultation on the settlement for 2024-25, ending on Friday, January 24, 2025.
“We hope that the current administration will use this process to articulate the concerns of many, that the settlement is not sufficient to cover the financial pressure faced by Pembrokeshire and argue for additional support, even if targeted towards areas of significant concern such as Social Care.
“The reality for us in Pembrokeshire is that providing the services our residents expect and rightly deserve has just become a lot more difficult with this settlement, which can only be described as disappointing.
“As a direct result of this AEF settlement, we will inevitably face a higher than wished-for Council Tax rise in April 2025, and much of the responsibility will sit with Cardiff.
“Pembrokeshire has the joint highest second home council tax in Wales, and we will almost certainly increase the level of tax on empty homes. Many of us in County Hall cannot be accused of shirking tough decisions that best serve our residents.
“We have significant Social Care pressures, which is a common theme across all Welsh local authorities. We have many schools falling into deficit, with Ysgol y Preseli, Milford Haven & Greenhill in dire need of a total overhaul to provide the facilities our young deserve. We hope that the Welsh Government will see fit to allocate Pembrokeshire a generous element of the £1.04bn for the capital grant they have provisionally allocated in this settlement for all of Wales. The continuation of the 40% business relief for tourism, hospitality and leisure businesses is welcomed for an industry that employs 23% of our working population.
COUNCIL TAX AFFORDABILITY CRUCIAL
“The Independent Group will focus on the need to protect essential services whilst addressing the ability of hard-pressed households to afford further Council Tax rises next April.
“In a week when the local authority, partner agencies, and many volunteers have stood up to Storm Darragh’s challenges, the least our residents deserved was more bad news with today’s Welsh Government settlement for Pembrokeshire.
“Storm Darragh’s impact highlighted the need for careful management of Council reserves. Using up reserves cannot continue year on year. Therefore, any proposal for their future use must be carefully considered before we can support it. Once used, these reserves are not available for future eventualities.
“Without additional support, this settlement will result in even higher Council tax bills in four months.”
The spokesperson concluded: “As the largest opposition group within County Hall, we will hold this administration to account in the forthcoming weeks and months prior to setting the Council Tax for 2025/26. We will be critical friends in this task and will not shirk from asking difficult questions.”
Crime
Dozens of alleged litter offenders to face court in Haverfordwest
HAVERFORDWEST MAGISTRATES’ COURT will hear a series of littering cases tomorrow, with individuals from across Pembrokeshire and beyond accused of offences under the Environmental Protection Act 1990. The cases primarily involve cigarette butts being dropped and left in public spaces, with locations spanning Pembroke Dock, Haverfordwest, Tenby, Milford Haven, and other towns.
The following individuals are set to appear:
- Nathan Abbott, 30, of Hakin, Milford Haven
- Alex Austin, 49, of Malvern, Worcestershire
- Tim Benfan, 36, of Rugby, Warwickshire
- Anthony Bevan, 39, of Pembroke
- Melissa Bevan, 43, of Pembroke
- Arron Bridges, 23, of Crundale, Haverfordwest
- Daniel Brooks, 38, of Tenby
- Dale Brown, 38, of Milford Haven
- Stephen Charkes, 62, of Llanelli
- John Cotton, 60, of Ledbury, Herefordshire
- Chaves De Oliveria, 24, of London
- James William Gwyn Dewhurst, 38, of Haverfordwest
- Kevin Filer, 66, of Milford Haven
- Barry Frost, 64, of Bradford, West Yorkshire
- Andrew Griffiths, 41, of Aberdare
- Robert Jeffrey Hamblin, 42, of Pembroke
- Victoria Hodgson, 34, of Pembroke
- Gerald Maddocks, 40, of Haverfordwest
- Deana Sophia Mead, 31, of Milford Haven
- Jacqueline Niblett, 63, of Hengoed
- Micheal Raymond, 55, of Cowbridge
- Shaun Tuxker, 38, of Haverfordwest
- Liam Unsworth, 27, of Narberth
- Shaun Manche, 41, of Milford Haven
- Chelsea McLaren, 29, of Narberth
- Marian Radoi, 40, of Haverfordwest
- Leah Reynolds, 31, of Haverfordwest
- James Stewart, 44, of Pembroke Dock
- Andrew Stokes, 53, of Stourport-on-Severn
- Nicola Wilkins, 48, of Swansea
- Rhys R Williams, 24, of Tonyrefail
- Ryan Williams, 45, of Swansea
- John Wright, 41, of Pembroke Dock
Each case involves allegations of littering, primarily cigarette butts, in public places such as streets, car parks, and parks across Pembrokeshire. Offenders face maximum penalties of up to £2,500 under Section 87 of the Environmental Protection Act 1990.
Authorities hope these proceedings will serve as a reminder to the public about the importance of maintaining clean and litter-free communities.
Pictured: Litter enforcement officer in Haverfordwest (Image: File)
News
A475 closed as fire crews respond to west Wales house blaze
EMERGENCY SERVICES are tackling a property fire in Ceredigion, prompting the closure of the A475 Drefach-Rhydowen road.
Dyfed-Powys Police have shut the road between the B4338 (Llanybydder turn-off) and the B4459 (Capel Dewi turn-off) to safeguard the public. Motorists are being urged to avoid the area and use alternative routes.
A police statement shared on Facebook said: “The road is currently closed due to an incident. Please avoid the area and find alternative routes for your journey.”
The Mid and West Wales Fire and Rescue Service and the Wales Ambulance Service are on the scene, responding to the incident. Authorities were alerted to the blaze shortly after 2:00pm.
AA Traffic reports indicate significant delays in both directions due to the closure. Drivers are advised to plan ahead and expect delays.
Further updates will follow as the situation develops.
(Image: File)
-
Sport2 days ago
Referee Marty Jones shares thoughts on the season
-
News4 days ago
Storm Darragh leaves its mark on West Wales as major incident declared
-
News2 days ago
Extensive historical child sexual abuse and institutional failings at Caldey Abbey
-
News6 days ago
RED WARNING: High winds expected in Pembrokeshire
-
Community5 days ago
Clean up starts after storm causes chaos across Pembrokeshire
-
Business3 days ago
£1 billion boost to Welsh Economy as ultrafast broadband reaches 1 million
-
Health6 days ago
18,000 families ‘struggling in silence’ due to lack of dementia diagnosis
-
News6 days ago
Neyland Town Council faces fresh turmoil as Mayor cancels meeting