Politics
‘Long way to go’, admit bosses of crisis-hit WRU
WELSH Rugby Union chiefs admitted the governing body still has a long way to go after an independent review unveiled a “toxic” culture of bullying and misogyny.
The Senedd’s culture committee scrutinised representatives of the WRU, which has been rocked by allegations of sexism, racism and homophobia over the past year.
Labour’s Hannah Blythyn pressed the witnesses about the women’s team being given a three-hour ultimatum in contract talks, asking if this is how the WRU treats employees.
Richard Collier-Keywood, chair of the WRU since July 2023, told the committee he and Abi Tierney, the chief executive, have since apologised to the players for serious failings.
He said: “That was not something that should have happened … we absolutely should not have given the players a three-hour ultimatum to sign the contracts … it’s certainly not the practice which I want to see in the WRU.”
Plaid Cymru leader Rhun ap Iorwerth said: “You’ve made it clear that you believe you have taken significant steps in terms of changing attitudes towards cultural issues.
“Given that everybody’s eyes were on you … and in particular your attitude towards women within the organisation, do you feel you need to reassess how far forward you believe you have come as a union in light of the failings?”
Mr Collier-Keywood replied: “Yeah, I think we’ve definitely reflected on that and I don’t think we were fooling ourselves up to that point either … we recognise we have a long way to go.”
He explained that two board members led an in-depth review of the contract negotiation process, with their report expected to be published in full in the coming weeks.
Criticising “misreporting” of the review’s conclusions by the Daily Telegraph, he said: “There were many failures … but they were not to do with sex discrimination.”
Ms Tierney told the committee: “Everybody went in with the best intentions but … tensions and frustrations arose during the process.”
Mr Collier-Keywood explained the findings emerging from the review: “I don’t think that we as the WRU set out a clear process such that everybody brought in ….
“We were not clear of the roles of individuals in that process, both from a WRU perspective nor, in particular, the people who the players thought would be representing them.”
He added: “We had not fully appreciated the fact that we were dealing with a situation where we had players who were in a high-performance environment but they were also contracted to the WRU as employees.”
Mr Collier-Keywood pointed out that men are contracted to the regions, saying: “We weren’t treating the women as employees to the full extent of that term. That was confusing and difficult and we were not fulfilling our obligations towards the women.”
Delyth Jewell, who chairs the Senedd’s culture committee, questioned progress against recommendations made by Anne Rafferty’s 2023 independent review.
Ms Tierney accepted the WRU had not lived up to the standards expected as she stressed: “Transformational change is hard. I would say colleagues are really feeling that at the moment and it will take time for things to feel better, I think.”
Mr Collier-Keywood added: “Years of previous culture does take time to change and yes we’re impatient to do that but we’re also realistic in terms of not claiming false dawns.”
Asked about a £7.5m loss in latest accounts, Mr Collier-Keywood told Senedd members the WRU is on track to take £5m out of its cost base in the current year.
“We both now believe our finances are more sustainable,” he said, explaining that the WRU made a £24m profit but drew on reserves to allocate £31m to rugby.
Pressed about the impact on participation, Ms Tierney told the committee meeting on November 27 she is saddened that concerns around culture may deter women and girls
But she stressed: “I think it would be unfair for me to sit here and say we won’t ever have any more headlines again because I think culture is a journey.
“It’s how we respond to those headlines that is so important.”
Ms Blythyn, a former minister who was previously responsible for fair work in Wales, did not envy the chief executive’s task of having to turn the WRU around.
She said: “We’ve heard of the glass ceiling but there’s a glass cliff – a tendency for women to come in at a point where an organisation or institution is at the precipice.”
News
First Minister challenged over ‘£9bn cost’ of 20mph speed limit policy
A REFORM Wales MS launched a sharp attack on the Welsh Government’s default 20mph speed limit policy during an exchange with the First Minister in the Senedd on Tuesday.
South Wales East regional MS Laura Anne Jones criticised the policy, arguing that it has damaged the Welsh economy and ignored public opposition.
Speaking in the chamber, Ms Jones said improvements in vehicle safety had already contributed to a reduction in road casualties across the UK.
“Road casualties have gone down right across the United Kingdom because cars are getting safer. It is a known fact,” she told the Senedd.
She went on to question the economic impact of the Welsh Government’s 20mph policy, claiming official analysis suggests it could cost the Welsh economy around £9 billion.
“It needs to be asked: has this ill thought out policy already cost our country a lot of money? Yes. Will it cost an awful lot to reverse? Yes. But how much has it cost our Welsh economy? By the Government’s own calculations, this has cost £9 billion,” she said.
“So you cannot say it has been a good policy. It has been a disaster from start to finish.”
Ms Jones also referred to the record-breaking Senedd petition calling for the policy to be scrapped, which attracted around 500,000 signatures — the largest petition ever submitted to the Welsh Parliament.
She added that there is broad agreement that 20mph limits should apply in specific locations.
“No one across this Chamber disagrees that 20mph should be the case outside schools and hospitals and where it is appropriate. It is disingenuous to say anything else.
“But this default 20mph policy needs to be reversed.”
Reform Wales has pledged to scrap the default 20mph speed limit if elected at the next Senedd election, scheduled for May 7.
News
Leaked memo row sparks fresh devolution debate in Wales
Liberal Democrats claim Welsh Labour failing to deliver after 26 years in power
A LEAKED memo reportedly sent by the Prime Minister to his Cabinet has triggered fresh political debate over the future of devolution in Wales.
The memo, attributed to UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer, is said to outline how the UK Government should interact with the devolved administrations across the United Kingdom, including Wales.
The details of the document have not been fully published, but critics claim it suggests that the UK Government could seek ways of working around devolved governments in certain circumstances.
The comments prompted a response from Jane Dodds, leader of the Welsh Liberal Democrats, who said the row highlights wider tensions within Labour over how devolution is managed.
Ms Dodds said: “After 26 years of Welsh Labour running Wales and a Labour government now in Westminster, the public is watching Labour argue with itself over devolution instead of getting on with the job.
“Trying to bypass the Senedd from Westminster is the wrong approach. But it’s also clear that Welsh Labour ministers in Cardiff Bay have too often failed to deliver the results people in Wales deserve.”
She added that the Welsh Liberal Democrats believe the problem lies not with the devolved institutions themselves but with how they have been run.
“The Welsh Liberal Democrats will save devolution from Welsh Labour’s record and restore people’s trust in the Welsh Parliament,” she said. “It isn’t the Senedd that’s broken, it’s Welsh Labour’s management of it.”
The Welsh Parliament, commonly known as the Senedd, has held devolved powers over areas such as health, education and transport since it was established following the 1997 referendum on Welsh devolution.
Welsh Labour has been the dominant governing party in Cardiff Bay since the Senedd was created, either governing alone or in cooperation with other parties.
The alleged memo has raised questions about how the UK Government intends to work with devolved administrations, particularly at a time when the same party holds power in both Westminster and Cardiff Bay.
The UK Government has not yet issued detailed comment on the contents of the leaked document.
News
Tories press First Minister over China-linked arrests and Welsh Govt security checks
Questions raised in Senedd over vetting procedures and overseas links
THE LEADER of the Welsh Conservatives used First Minister’s Questions in the Senedd on Tuesday (Mar 10) to demand answers from the First Minister following the arrest of three men on suspicion of assisting Chinese intelligence services.
Darren Millar MS said the case raises serious questions about potential national security risks and whether appropriate safeguards are in place within Welsh Government structures.
It has emerged that the three men arrested had previously held political roles connected to the Welsh Labour Party and/or the Welsh Government. All three are also reported to have had links to the energy company Bute Energy.
Mr Millar told the Senedd that the situation required urgent clarification from the First Minister, including when she first became aware of the arrests and whether any review of vetting procedures had been launched.
The issue follows an emergency question tabled by the Conservative leader last week, which he said had not been fully answered.
During Tuesday’s exchange, Mr Millar asked whether the Welsh Government had begun reviewing its security and vetting arrangements for staff working both within government and in its overseas offices.
The Welsh Government operates three overseas offices in China as part of its international trade and investment network.
Mr Millar argued that the existence of these offices meant the public needed reassurance that robust checks were in place.
He told the Senedd: “These arrests are extremely concerning and raise serious questions about whether Welsh Labour and the Welsh Government may be a weak link in our UK national security.
“Today I sought clarity on the extent of the Welsh Government’s exposure, what safeguards were in place, and what steps are now being taken both in Wales and in the Welsh Government’s overseas offices in China to protect our national interest.
“Public confidence depends on transparency and accountability, particularly when matters of foreign influence and national security are involved.”
Mr Millar also criticised what he described as the Welsh Government’s recent engagement with Vietnam, suggesting relationships with overseas governments should be reviewed.
He said: “The Welsh Labour Government has also been cosying up to the Communist regime in Vietnam in recent years.
“We know that social media accounts based in Vietnam are seeking to influence our democracy with fake news and AI generated posts.
“It’s high time that the Welsh Government’s relationships with both China and Vietnam were reviewed to ensure that they are not a back-door for malign influence.”
The Welsh Government has not yet issued a detailed response to the concerns raised during First Minister’s Questions.
-
Community5 days agoWhitland Post Office re-opens under new management
-
Health2 days agoWomen’s health services ‘expanding’ across mid and west Wales says Health Board
-
Crime5 days agoMan who threatened to kill police during Milford Haven standoff avoids jail
-
Crime6 days agoMan sentenced after punching convicted paedophile in Haverfordwest pub
-
Crime6 days agoA teenage driver sentenced after pedestrian seriously injured on zebra crossing
-
Crime6 days agoPolice investigating nightclub assault in Saundersfoot
-
News5 days agoReform energy policy raises questions for Milford Haven and Celtic Freeport ambitions
-
Education5 days agoHaverfordwest student turns fitness passion into exciting new career plan









