Connect with us
Advertisement
Advertisement

News

12 hour A&E service would be ‘end game’ for Withybush Hospital

Published

on

Protest: Cardiff earlier this year

Protest: Cardiff earlier this year

A LEAKED document has revealed 24 hour A&E services are to be cut at Withybush General Hospital and replaced with a 12-hour service, The Pembrokeshire Herald understands.

A report prepared by Dr Iain Roberston-Steele has been revealed on-line on the SWAT website. The letter states: “It is no longer possible to sustain a traditional 24/7 A&E service at Withybush General Hospital based on middle grade locums and locum consultants”.

Health Board chairman Bernardine Rees was asked by councillors at Full Council recently if the A&E would remain a 24 hour services seven days a week, but she did not confirm that it would.

The shocking document also reveals that since the downgrade in paediatric services overnight there has been increased burden on the out of hours service and that too is branded as “short staffed and at risk”.

The leaked letter says that staffing issues led to the latest crisis in the service, and that a solution needs to be found.Other services that Withybush should not provide services for patients where further or onward care is required will also include ENT, ophthalmology, urology, palliative care, oncology, paediatrics, gynaecology and other specialist services, according to the document.

“Limiting provision at WGH to those services at WGH which are fully staffed and skilled,” it adds.

SWAT chairman Dr Chris Overton told The Herald that the news was  the “end game” for Withybush Hospital. He added: “As predicted for many many years, there will be nothing much will be left at the hospital”

The hospital action group has previously raised concerns that the knock on effect of services removal will result in changes having to be made at Withybush A&E.

Stephen Crabb MP told The Herald: “This leaked document appears to confirm our worst fears about what Hywel Dda and Mark Drakeford have got planned for Withybush. A dark cloud is hanging over the future of our hospital.”

“The removal of a 24 hour A&E service from Withybush is just unacceptable. The Welsh Health Minister should stop hiding away in Cardiff and come down to Pembrokeshire to either denounce these reckless plans or explain why he thinks they make our community safer. People in Pembrokeshire deserve more than behind-the-scenes plotting.”

“Today the UK Government is giving Welsh Ministers an extra £70 million as a result of the increase in English NHS spending. I have asked that the Welsh Government confirm that it will use this money solely for Welsh health services. After all the recent cuts to services, Pembrokeshire should be first in the queue for this spending.”

Party of Wales Mid and West Assembly Member Simon Thomas said: “This is another broken promise on the Welsh NHS by Labour Ministers in Cardiff Bay. I will demand answers from the Welsh Government in the Senedd at the first opportunity to do so on this issue. The people of Pembrokeshire deserve better A&E services.”

“This development about emergency services at Withybush Hospital is very concerning indeed. Welsh Ministers rejected my concerns that losing 24/7 paediatrics would undermine the long term viability of A&E.

“I suspected this but I am amazed it has come so soon. The people of west Wales have been misled by Labour. A Plaid Cymru Welsh Government would recruit 1,000 extra doctors. We would train new doctors to keep services local.”

South Pembrokeshire MP Simon Hart said: “I have not seen first-hand the report that SWAT refers to but if it is accurate, then everything we feared is coming true.  This is death by a thousand cuts for Withybush.  Hywel Dda Health Board has struggled with these staffing issues for years and has yet to solve the problem.  If they are going to use “staff shortages” as an excuse to close any department where they can’t recruit then this will become self fulfilling. We already know that one reason for the GP shortages in the county is the uncertainty over the future of the hospital. Mark Drakeford and the Welsh Government in Cardiff needs to get a grip of this situation and bring this uncertainty to an end.”

Commenting on reports that 24 hour Accident and Emergency, and other specialist services are to be removed from Withybush Hospital, Welsh Liberal Democrat Leader Kirsty Williams AM said: “This news is obviously a huge blow to communities across Pembrokeshire, especially all the campaigners that have worked tirelessly to keep their local services open. A quick response is vital for people suffering from trauma and accidents, and cutting 24 hour A&E cover could well put lives at risk.

“The fact that these services are seen as unsustainable at all shows that there is a major recruitment crisis in our NHS that the Welsh Labour Government seems determined to ignore. I have been repeatedly calling for a cross-party commission with doctor, nurse and patient representatives to sort out the major problems and plan for the future of our NHS. Today’s news shows that this commission can’t come soon enough.”

William Powell, the Welsh Liberal Democrat AM for Mid and West Wales, added: “Having supported local campaigners in their efforts to protect these services since 2006, this is obviously a huge disappointment. Removing specialist services and a full A&E from Withybush will leave it as nothing more than a glorified cottage hospital, with no equivalent services for miles around.

“With a health board intent on centralising services and a Welsh Labour Government content with them doing so, the people of Pembrokeshire deserve better.”

Spekaing for the Health Board, Medical Director Dr Sue Fish said: “I would like to reassure staff and members of the public that the Emergency and Urgent Care Centre at Withybush General Hospital remains open 24-hours a day and the University Health Board continues to be committed to the long term provision of this service. Senior clinicians continue to meet, and indeed clinicians and managers from across Hywel Dda are meeting today, to discuss how we continue to maintain safe, high quality services with ongoing and significant recruitment challenges. These challenges are faced by many NHS organisations across the UK and are a particular challenge at Withybush EUCC currently. The document referred to is the viewpoint of a single consultant at one point in time and represents no decision by the University Health Board. Changes to paediatric services at the hospital have not resulted in this position, which is a reflection of the ongoing recruitment challenges discussed.

Associate Medical Director for Quality and Safety Iain Robertson Steel added: “I would like to make it clear that this was a private and confidential paper that presents only one contribution from amongst a number being discussed and I am deeply distressed that this has been leaked without the full context.”

letterA letterB letterC letterD

 

 

3 Comments

3 Comments

  1. Steve

    December 1, 2014 at 4:13 pm

    thanks guys for protesting so much they are cutting down on so much including A+E department now us doormen have got to go to Carmarthen.

  2. Francesca Bosenius

    December 2, 2014 at 6:44 am

    After this news broke,it was reported on the late Welsh HTV news, that a plan was now in place to avoid all this happening.That’s clever of them.All into the space of a few hours when they have been struggling with this for months! Right then. Any chance that you can ask them what the plan is. and share it with the rest of us?

  3. Edward

    December 12, 2014 at 7:17 am

    Stabbed in the back by the Welsh Assembly again. No funding and another move towards closure. The Labour party must hate Pembrokeshire.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

News

Kurtz says he is “still fighting” as election approaches

Published

on

Local MS speaks about pressure of politics in major newspaper interview

SAMUEL KURTZ has said he remains determined to retain his Senedd seat despite growing political uncertainty, following a prominent double-page interview published ahead of the Welsh Parliament election in May.

The Carmarthen West and South Pembrokeshire MS spoke candidly about the pressures of public life, the challenges facing his party, and the personal toll of political scrutiny, while insisting he remains focused on local campaigning.

Mr Kurtz said: “We’re working hard for the win, but the world’s not going to end on May 8 if I don’t get re-elected.”

The comments reflect what political observers describe as a realistic assessment of the electoral environment facing the Conservatives across Wales ahead of polling day on Thursday, May 7.

Pressure of public life

In the Western Mail article, Mr Kurtz discussed the intensity of modern politics, including criticism on social media and the impact on family life. He suggested resilience was essential for anyone working in public office, describing politics as demanding but worthwhile.

The MS also highlighted his rural upbringing and agricultural background, emphasising his connection to farming communities and countryside issues — a key theme likely to feature heavily in his re-election campaign across rural parts of the constituency.

Local record under scrutiny

Mr Kurtz has represented Carmarthen West and South Pembrokeshire since being elected to the Senedd in 2021.

During that time he has spoken on issues including agriculture policy, rural economic development, and healthcare pressures, often criticising Welsh Government performance on NHS waiting times and public services.

However, with the election approaching, local voters are expected to judge candidates primarily on issues affecting daily life in Pembrokeshire, including GP access, hospital waiting lists, transport infrastructure, employment opportunities, and the cost of living.

Political landscape changing

The upcoming election will take place under new Senedd arrangements, with boundary and voting system reforms expected to alter the political landscape across Wales.

The constituency has historically been competitive, with support shifting between Conservatives, Labour and Plaid Cymru in different elections. Analysts suggest the result in May could be influenced both by national political trends and local campaigning strength.

Campaign period begins

While Mr Kurtz has not yet formally launched his constituency campaign, activity from all parties is expected to increase significantly in the coming weeks.

The Herald will be speaking to voters and candidates across Pembrokeshire as part of its continuing coverage of the Senedd election campaign.

 

Continue Reading

News

Sea Empress: 30 years since the grounding that transformed safety in Milford Haven

Published

on

Human error, storm conditions and salvage decisions combined in one of Britain’s worst maritime disasters

THIRTY years ago this week, the oil tanker Sea Empress ran aground while entering Milford Haven, triggering a maritime emergency that would ultimately reshape safety procedures in one of the UK’s most important ports.

On the evening of February 15, 1996, the Liberian-registered tanker was inbound to the Texaco refinery carrying approximately 130,000 tonnes of North Sea crude oil when it struck rocks at the entrance to the Haven.

What followed was a complex and dangerous salvage operation carried out in severe weather, repeated groundings, and eventually the release of more than 70,000 tonnes of oil into the sea — making it one of the worst environmental disasters in British waters.

What actually went wrong

The Marine Accident Investigation Branch later concluded that the grounding was primarily caused by human and operational error rather than mechanical failure.

The tanker’s steering gear and propulsion systems were found to be functioning normally.

Investigators identified a sequence of navigational decisions and communication issues between the ship’s master and harbour pilot that led the vessel too close to the rocks while manoeuvring into the channel.

Strong tidal conditions and environmental factors then compounded the situation once the vessel was aground.

In simple terms, the ship was not where it should have been.

A salvage operation under pressure

Initial efforts focused on stabilising the vessel and preventing further oil loss, but worsening weather quickly made operations far more dangerous.

Tugs worked in gale-force winds attempting to pull the tanker clear.

During one critical phase, a tow line parted under extreme tension, allowing the ship to ground again and spill additional oil.

At the same time, fears grew that vapours from the cargo could ignite, prompting evacuations near St Ann’s Head.

Aircraft sprayed dispersants over the spreading slick while emergency services prepared for a potential explosion scenario.

The priority at that stage was to prevent the vessel breaking apart completely.

Eventually, after several days of effort, salvage crews succeeded in refloating the tanker and moving it to a safer position where the remaining cargo could be removed.

Who was blamed

Responsibility for the disaster became the subject of legal and regulatory scrutiny.

The official investigation placed primary fault on navigational decisions during the vessel’s approach rather than any equipment failure.

The ship’s master and pilot both faced criticism over judgement and coordination, though the complex operational environment was also acknowledged.

In subsequent legal proceedings, liability for the spill was largely addressed through civil compensation mechanisms involving the ship owners and insurers under international maritime conventions.

There was no single individual publicly identified as solely responsible for the scale of the environmental damage.

However, the incident exposed weaknesses in escort tug arrangements, navigation procedures and emergency response planning.

Impact on Milford Haven operations

One of the most significant long-term outcomes was the strengthening of escort tug requirements for large vessels entering the Haven.

Navigation procedures were reviewed and risk management protocols improved.

Emergency pollution response capability across the UK was also reassessed.

For the port itself, the disaster became a turning point.

Milford Haven continued operating as a major energy hub, but with tighter safety controls and increased scrutiny.

Environmental and community consequences

Oil contamination spread across miles of coastline, affecting wildlife habitats, fisheries and tourism.

Thousands of volunteers joined military personnel and contractors in an enormous cleanup effort that lasted months.

While environmental recovery has been substantial over the decades, the psychological impact on coastal communities and those directly involved in the response remains part of local memory.

Maritime lessons that endure

Today, the Sea Empress is widely viewed within the maritime industry as a case study in how small navigational errors can escalate into major incidents when combined with environmental pressures.

The disaster reinforced the importance of escort towing, pilotage coordination and emergency planning in high-risk ports.

Thirty years on, the Haven remains one of the UK’s busiest energy ports — operating under safety frameworks shaped directly by the events of February 1996.

 

Continue Reading

Community

Local faces appear on BBC Countryfile marking Sea Empress anniversary

Published

on

Programme revisits Milford Haven 30 years after oil spill disaster

TWO well-known Pembrokeshire figures appeared on BBC television on Sunday (Feb 15) as Countryfile marked the 30th anniversary of the Sea Empress oil spill.

Phil Thompson, former public relations manager at the Texaco refinery, and Martin Cavaney, a freelance photographer who regularly works with The Herald, were among those featured during the programme, which looked back at the disaster and its lasting impact on the county.

Presenters Datshiane Navanayagam and Hamza Yassin visited Milford Haven to explore how the area has recovered three decades after the tanker ran aground at the entrance to the waterway while carrying crude oil to the refinery.

The grounding of the Sea Empress on February 15, 1996 resulted in tens of thousands of tonnes of oil being spilled into the sea, contaminating large sections of the Pembrokeshire coastline and becoming one of Britain’s worst environmental disasters.

The programme also featured Mike Ryan, Harbourmaster at the Port of Milford Haven, who explained how the incident led to significant improvements in marine safety.

Ryan, who served for around 30 years in the Royal Navy before joining the port, said the disaster remains part of the waterway’s history and helped focus attention on the need for stronger procedures. This ultimately contributed to the development of modern safety systems, including the Port Marine Safety Code introduced in 2000.

Countryfile also examined the environmental recovery that has taken place since the spill, including work by scientists and conservationists to protect wildlife across Pembrokeshire’s coastline.

The Sea Empress disaster prompted one of the largest clean-up operations ever seen in Wales, involving salvage crews, emergency responders, volunteers and environmental organisations.

The anniversary remains a significant milestone for communities around Milford Haven, where memories of oil-covered beaches and wildlife continue to resonate 30 years on.

The programme is available to watch on BBC iPlayer.

 

Continue Reading

News2 hours ago

Sea Empress: 30 years since the grounding that transformed safety in Milford Haven

Human error, storm conditions and salvage decisions combined in one of Britain’s worst maritime disasters THIRTY years ago this week,...

Health23 hours ago

NHS pay row erupts as ministers confirm 3.3% rise

Unions warn award amounts to real-terms cut as inflation remains above headline figure NHS staff across Wales will receive a...

Crime2 days ago

Governors defend leadership at Milford Haven School after stabbing incident

GOVERNORS at Milford Haven Comprehensive School have issued a public statement responding to concerns about leadership and staffing following last...

Crime2 days ago

Four arrested in armed police operation across Pembroke Dock

Firearms, drugs and GBH suspects detained as pre-planned raids hit Bush Street and Gordon Street A MAJOR armed police operation...

News2 days ago

Climber dies and two injured in St Govan’s Head fall

Major air and sea rescue launched as coastguard, lifeboat and helicopters scramble to Pembrokeshire cliffs A PERSON has died and...

Education2 days ago

School in special measures after inspectors raise safeguarding and leadership concerns

Estyn orders urgent action plan and regular monitoring at Pembroke secondary A PEMBROKESHIRE secondary school has been placed into special...

Crime2 days ago

Armed police arrest man after major operation in Pembroke Dock

Firearms officers, dog units and roadblocks deployed on Gordon Street as Dyfed-Powys Police investigate ARMED officers sealed off part of...

Community3 days ago

Lifeboat to find new home at Pembroke Dock museum after historic handover ceremony

A HISTORIC lifeboat which saved forty lives around the British coastline is set to begin a new chapter in Pembroke...

Crime3 days ago

Pendine man jailed for abducting and drugging teenage girl

Offender had 1,101 unlawful images of children stored on his devices, including 122 Category A images – the most serious...

Crime5 days ago

Publican admits supplying cocaine and cannabis at Crown Court

Admits cocaine and cannabis supply but denies intent and cash allegations A MILFORD HAVEN pub landlord has admitted supplying cocaine...

Popular This Week