News
National Park planners approve injunction for persistent planning breaches in Pembrokeshire
NATIONAL PARK planners have given the go-ahead for an injunction on a Pembrokeshire site that continues to see planning breaches despite hefty court fines imposed.
The Pembrokeshire Coast National Park’s Development Management committee met on April 19 and backed a recommendation to approve an injunction in relation to land at Highlands View Fold, The Ridgeway, Manorbier Newton.
The land has been subject to a range of planning breaches, with the authority issuing two enforcement notices and two temporary stop notices in 2015 to Richard Scarfe in relation to land at Highlands View Fold.
Scarfe, a Pembroke Dock man, admitted developing the land and moving caravans onto it over a four-year period. He alleged that he had sold the property to his daughter, Brogan Scarfe, since the enforcement action was taken, but nevertheless accepted responsibility for the breaches. He also admitted ignoring warnings by Pembrokeshire Coast National Park Authority.
Local magistrates fined him £15,000 and told him to pay £2,170 in costs and a surcharge. Scarfe later lodged an appeal to a judge at Swansea crown court before dropping it and accepting the sentence.
However, the situation has not been remedied since then, according to a report for the April 19 meeting of park planners.
Despite pleading guilty to the offences, the breaches of planning control have not been remedied. Following a site visit by officers in February 2023, it became clear that the situation has exacerbated since the prosecution in March 2019.
Officers have sought legal advice, and it was identified that there are two options available. The first is to take direct action to remove unauthorised development and seek to recover the costs of doing so from the landowner. These costs would be significant, and the exercise would be resource-intensive.
Officers therefore recommended the alternative option of obtaining an injunction, which could result in committal proceedings for the parties involved if there is an ongoing failure to comply.
The report says that Mr Scarfe has transferred the land to his daughter Brogan but has acknowledged to the authority in writing that he is responsible for activities at the site.
The recommendation before the April 19 committee was to approve the county court injunction and to delegate to the Director for Placemaking, Decarbonisation, and Engagement the authorisation of the authority’s solicitor Mr Charles Felgate and Counsel Mr Matthew Graham Paul to enter the site.
This move could lead to committal proceedings if the parties involved fail to comply with the injunction, and it is hoped that this will put an end to the ongoing planning breaches at the site.
Crime
Banned for 40 months after driving with cocaine breakdown product in blood
A MILFORD HAVEN woman has been handed a lengthy driving ban after admitting driving with a controlled drug in her system more than ten times over the legal limit.
SENTENCED AT HAVERFORDWEST
Sally Allen, 43, of Wentworth Close, Hubberston, appeared before Haverfordwest Magistrates’ Court on Thursday (Dec 4) for sentencing, having pleaded guilty on November 25 to driving with a proportion of a specified controlled drug above the prescribed limit.
The court heard that Allen was stopped on August 25 on the Old Hakin Road at Tiers Cross while driving an Audi A3. Blood analysis showed 509µg/l of Benzoylecgonine, a breakdown product of cocaine. The legal limit is 50µg/l.
COMMUNITY ORDER AND REHABILITATION
Magistrates imposed a 40-month driving ban, backdated to her interim disqualification which began on November 25.
Allen was also handed a 12-month community order, requiring her to complete 10 days of rehabilitation activities as directed by the Probation Service.
She was fined £120, ordered to pay £85 prosecution costs and a £114 surcharge. Her financial penalties will be paid in £25 monthly instalments from January 1, 2026.
The bench—Mrs H Roberts, Mr M Shankland and Mrs J Morris—said her guilty plea had been taken into account when passing sentence.
Local Government
Sewage leak at Pembroke Commons prompts urgent clean-up works
Council pollution officers say they have no enforcement powers over Welsh Water infrastructure
SEWAGE contamination on the Commons in Pembroke has prompted an urgent response from pollution officers, after a leak was reported by a member of the public on Tuesday.
Pembrokeshire County Council’s Pollution Control Team confirmed they were alerted yesterday afternoon to sewage surrounding a manhole cover on the site. The Herald understands that officers immediately notified Welsh Water (DCWW) network technicians to investigate the incident “as a matter of urgency”.
County councillor Jonathan Grimes, who represents Pembroke St Mary South and Monkton, said the authority had been clear that it holds no enforcement powers over Welsh Water assets.
“Whilst we work constructively with Welsh Water, we have no authority to intervene on their apparatus or to carry out enforcement action against them for such pollution incidents,” the Pollution Control Team said in a statement shared with the councillor.
Urgent works underway
Council officers visited the site on Wednesday morning alongside contractors and Welsh Water technicians to assess clean-up options. According to the team, works will include cleaning the contaminated ground in and around the manhole cover and fencing off the affected area “until safe”.
Cllr Grimes said officers would return to the scene on Thursday to check on progress and ensure the area is properly secured.
Residents who notice any further issues have been urged to contact the Pollution Control Team directly.
Further updates are expected later this week.
Local Government
Pembrokeshire Council faces backlash over £3.5m housing ‘buying spree’
Critics say policy inflates numbers while new-build programme stalls
PEMBROKESHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL is under growing pressure over its multi-million-pound programme of buying back former council houses, with critics warning that the strategy gives the illusion of progress while long-promised new-builds remain stuck on the drawing board.
The latest criticism comes from Milford Haven councillor Mike Stoddart, who has accused the authority of “standing still” by funnelling Housing Revenue Account (HRA) cash into purchasing properties that were once part of the council’s own stock.
Stoddart said the council’s approach “doesn’t increase the housing stock – it merely moves people from the private sector into the public sector”.
He added: “It would be much better if the money was spent on building anew.”
A temporary fix that became permanent
The buy-back scheme began in 2017 when the council adopted a new inflation-linked rent regime that delivered sizeable HRA surpluses. At the time, officers described buying ex-council homes on the open market as a “stop-gap” measure until the new-build programme ramped up.
But that programme has repeatedly faltered. Major schemes in Johnston and Tiers Cross have been hit by cost overruns of around 66%. In Milford Haven, new flats on Charles Street are costing close to £300,000 each for a one- or two-bed unit, before adding land costs, architects’ fees and planning expenses.

Stoddart said the pattern amounted to a “disaster”, arguing that buying existing homes had become the authority’s default option. “It gives the impression of making progress while actually standing still,” he said.
Brownfield sites left idle
In Stoddart’s own ward, three former school sites have stood empty since 2018. Their redevelopment is not expected to begin until 2027 or 2028. Meanwhile, the council’s purchasing programme has accelerated.
A Cabinet report for late 2025 shows more than £3.5 million spent on acquisitions in just the first half of the year.
The most striking deal was a bulk purchase of five homes in Harcourt Close, Hook, for £1.851 million — almost £400,000 each. Stoddart said the developer would think “all his birthdays have come at once”, with the council avoiding estate agents’ fees, reducing legal costs and allowing the seller to immediately stop paying interest to the bank.
Thirteen high-value purchases
All properties were bought for over £100,000 and moved into the council’s HRA stock:
| Address | Location | Price | Completion |
|---|---|---|---|
| 32 Southdown Close | Pembroke | £115,000 | 29/07/2025 |
| 8 Hyfrydle | Letterston | £115,000 | 01/08/2025 |
| 6 Precelly Place | Milford Haven | £120,000 | 22/09/2025 |
| 50 Heywood Court | Tenby | £125,000 | 02/10/2025 |
| 33 Croft Avenue | Hakin, Milford Haven | £130,000 | 20/10/2025 |
| 7 Hyfrydle | Letterston | £135,000 | 05/09/2025 |
| 18 St Clements Park | Freystrop | £140,000 | 14/07/2025 |
| 55 College Park | Neyland | £140,000 | 28/10/2025 |
| 26 Baring Gould Way | Haverfordwest | £146,000 | 15/08/2025 |
| 25 Station Road | Letterston | £170,000 | 10/10/2025 |
| 16 Woodlands Crescent | Milford Haven | £283,000 | 31/10/2025 |
| 26 & 27 Harcourt Close | Hook | £744,000 | 22/10/2025 |
| 23, 24 & 25 Harcourt Close | Hook | £1,107,000 | 30/07/2025 |
All purchases were made from HRA reserves with no borrowing, a point the council highlights as prudent financial management.
Fears over market distortion
Stoddart also warned that the authority’s deep pockets may be pricing out young families by outbidding first-time buyers for entry-level homes. “If classical economic theory is to be believed, it’s forcing up the price,” he said.
House prices in Pembrokeshire have risen around 15% in the past year, according to recent ONS data. Local estate agents, speaking anonymously, told this newspaper that council intervention “definitely nudges prices upward” in hotspots like Hook, Neyland and Milford Haven.
Council defends strategy
A council spokesperson said the approach was necessary to deliver homes “immediately” amid chronic shortages.
“Acquiring existing properties allows us to respond quickly to housing need,” they said. “New-builds remain a priority, but delays in planning, construction and funding mean we must use all available tools to meet demand. All purchases represent value for money and are compliant with our HRA strategy.”
Housing charity Shelter Cymru took a different view, arguing that “recycling stock is not a substitute for expansion”. The charity says Pembrokeshire needs around 500 new affordable homes a year to meet demand.
‘Residents deserve homes, not headaches’
Social housing waiting lists in Pembrokeshire now exceed 2,000 applicants. With another Cabinet briefing due later this month, Stoddart says he will push for a fundamental rethink.
“It’s time to stop standing still,” he told this newspaper. “Our residents deserve homes, not headaches.”
-
Crime2 days agoDefendant denies using Sudocrem-covered finger to assault two-month-old baby
-
Crime6 days agoMan denies causing baby’s injuries as police interviews read to jury
-
Crime1 day agoPembroke rape investigation dropped – one suspect now facing deportation
-
News1 day agoBaby C trial: Mother breaks down in tears in the witness box
-
Crime7 days agoMan denies injuring baby as jury hears police interview in ongoing abuse trial
-
Crime2 days agoLifeboat crew member forced to stand down after being assaulted at Milford pub
-
Crime2 days agoDefendant denies causing injuries to two-month-old baby
-
Crime2 days agoPembrokeshire haven master admits endangering life after speedboat collision







