Politics
Senedd rejects motion on puberty blockers
THE SENEDD rejected calls to revoke regulations restricting the prescription of puberty blockers for under-18s with gender incongruence or dysphoria.
Adam Price recognised differing views regarding puberty-suppressing hormones, known as puberty blockers, as he called for the Welsh Government regulations to be annulled.
The former Plaid Cymru leader explained the regulations effectively make participation in a clinical trial the only way to access treatment for transgender children and young people.
He told the Senedd: “As no such trial is yet available, these regulations currently deny access to puberty blockers entirely for this group of patients.”
Mr Price warned making treatment conditional on participation in trials is unfair because it places undue pressure on the child to agree.
He said: “We believe that these significant changes … should be subject to consultation, with the children and young people affected by them, because that is what the law says.”
The former MP pointed out that the Welsh Government is bound to have “due regard” to the UN convention on children’s rights, with Article 12 guaranteeing the right to be heard.
Mr Price added: “Article 3 of the UN convention requires that the best interests of the child are the primary consideration in all actions affecting children.”
He said no consultation nor children’s rights impact assessment was conducted.
He warned transgender children are being treated differently with their access to puberty blockers restricted, arguing this is contrary to the Equality Act 2010.
Mr Price drew a parallel with a High Court ruling in March that a Welsh Government decision to stop free school meals in holidays was unlawful.
He said: “These regulations show the exact same failings: a lack of consultation, a failure to conduct impact assessments and insufficient regard for children’s rights and equality….
“The Senedd has the opportunity tonight to send a clear message to the government: the first imperative in making any law – and especially a law that affects the young – is to listen, which it has signally failed to do in this case.”
Conservative Sam Rowlands raised the Cass review which found “no good evidence of the long-term outcomes of interventions to manage gender-related distress”.
The shadow health secretary warned not enough is known about the long-term impacts of puberty blockers for children and young people with gender incongruence or dysphoria.
Julie James, who is counsel general, the Welsh Government’s chief legal adviser, said the proportionate regulations were in response to the Cass review of gender identity services.
She told the Senedd: “The Welsh Government continues to be driven by the evidence to best support the needs of young people who are questioning their gender.”
Ms James said the law prevents GPs from prescribing puberty blockers to under-18s, with exceptions for trials and prescriptions from before the legislation came into force on July 18.
The former solicitor raised case law showing the state does not breach the European Convention on Human Rights by refusing to authorise a particular treatment.
She argued ministers had no duty to consult and due regard was given to children’s rights under the UN convention, which was incorporated in Welsh law in 2011.
Caerphilly MS Hefin David raised the experience of a constituent accessing services in Bristol which they found “severely wanting”.
The Labour backbencher said he would vote with the Welsh Government for technical reasons but added: “I think we need more passion from the government on these issues and I’m deeply disappointed by the counsel general’s contribution.”
Mr Price told the Senedd the NHS has no plans to establish a youth gender identity service despite a commitment in the Welsh Government’s LGBTQ+ action plan.
He said: “I really think the government needs to look at this with some urgency even if they win the vote tonight – they need to look at the broader policy.”
Senedd members voted 36-12 against annulling the regulations on December 10.
News
Petition demanding resignation of Neyland councillor sparks public outcry
A PETITION demanding the immediate resignation of Neyland Town Councillor Mike Harry has taken centre stage ahead of an extraordinary council meeting scheduled for Thursday, January 16. The petition, started by Nicholas Wilson, accuses Cllr Harry of breaching the council’s code of conduct by making derogatory remarks about constituents in an email circulated to all town councillors.
In the email, Cllr Harry referred to some constituents as “degenerates” and “cronies from the Foresters bar,” remarks that have been labelled offensive and unbecoming of a public representative. The petition has gathered momentum in Neyland, with supporters calling for accountability and demanding higher standards from their councillors. “This kind of language and attitude has no place in our town council,” one petitioner commented.
First meeting since october 2024
The extraordinary meeting marks the first official gathering of Neyland Town Council since October 2024, after months of internal conflict and public disputes among councillors. It will take place at 6:00pm in the Viewing Gallery of Neyland Community Hub, a change from the usual venue due to a Labour Party quiz occupying the main meeting rooms. However, the relocation means there will be no audio-visual support for the meeting.
The agenda for the meeting is notably sparse, with a single item for discussion: council finance, specifically the budget and precept for 2025/26. Despite the narrow focus of the agenda, the meeting is expected to be overshadowed by the ongoing controversy surrounding Cllr Harry and the fallout from his remarks.
Escalating internal tensions
The controversy stems from an email in which Cllr Harry expressed frustration over disputes with colleagues and constituents. In the email, he dismissed critics as an “irrelevant minority” and accused them of spreading “garbage.” He also took aim at a former councillor, claiming they had resigned over a prejudicial interest relating to the construction of the Neyland Community Hub.
These comments have ignited outrage among residents, some of whom are now questioning the culture within the council. The petition has called for Cllr Harry’s removal, arguing that his remarks damage public trust in the council’s ability to serve the community.
Public divisions and Ombudsman’s investigation
Cllr Harry has defended his actions, stating that he is awaiting a decision from the Ombudsman regarding ongoing disputes. He maintains that the allegations against him are unfounded and insists that his comments have been taken out of context.
While his supporters argue that the email reflects frustration amid a difficult period for the council, critics believe the remarks highlight deeper issues within Neyland Town Council. The council has been mired in internal disputes for months, resulting in delays and cancellations of meetings, further fuelling dissatisfaction among residents.
Neyland watches closely
With tensions running high, the upcoming meeting is expected to draw significant public interest. Whether the petition will prompt immediate action or further divide the council remains to be seen. For now, the focus of the meeting is set to be council finances, but the controversy surrounding Cllr Harry is unlikely to be ignored.
The Herald will provide updates on this developing story as the situation unfolds.
News
Ambitious Pembrokeshire wildlife centre plans approved
PLANS to modernise the Welsh Wildlife Centre near Cardigan with a new public entrance and a raft of other works which will make it more accessible to all have been approved Pembrokeshire County Council.
The Wildlife Trust of South & West Wales sought permission for a long list of changes at the Welsh Wildlife Centre, Cilgerran, including an extension to the visitor centre building and associated works, with a new public entrance, a new pathway connection, reconfiguration of the vehicle turning area and disabled parking bays, a replacement footbridge, and the introduction of ‘Brise Soleil’ to the south and west.
A supporting statement, by Childs Sulzmann Architects, said: “The visitor centre was built in the 1990s with an award-winning concept design. However, the usability of the building and some elements of its condition have deteriorated over the years, requiring modernisation.
“In particular, access to the visitor centre for people on the approach to the building is confusing and unclear, with external entrance doors provided at each side of the building. For instance, visitors can often be found in the offices on the lower ground floor level by mistake, whilst looking for the shop or café which are provided on the upper floors.”
The Welsh Wildlife Centre welcomes an average of 70,000 visitors per year, the statement saying: “This important local facility and visitor attraction will be enhanced and improved, by providing a clear and legible single entrance to the building, together with re-configured accessible parking bays and a platform lift for wheelchair users and ambulant disabled people to directly access the new public entrance.
“Further improvements to accessibility, which include the new external stairway to the open terrace and public entrance, the widened replacement footbridge and the connecting path to link the accessible parking area with the main footpath to the visitor centre, will contribute to the principles of promoting and providing access for all.”
Plans for a new play area at the Welsh Wildlife Centre near Cardigan were recently approved by Pembrokeshire County Council.
The latest proposals were conditionally approved by county planners.
Health
Sir Frank calls time as Chief Medical Officer for Wales after eight years
WALES’ leading doctor Sir Dr Frank Atherton has announced he will stand down after eight and half years as the Welsh Government’s Chief Medical Officer.
Sir Frank has provided independent advice to the Welsh Government on all major issues affecting the health sector in Wales.
During his tenure in Wales, after a previous post in Canada, Sir Frank played a leading role in Wales’ response to the Covid pandemic and has supported the NHS through flu outbreaks and annual winter pressures.
Speaking about Sir Frank’s decision to stand down, Health Secretary Jeremy Miles said: “Sir Frank has provided invaluable advice and guidance, which I am hugely grateful for.
“He played a leading role in our response to the pandemic, ensuring people throughout Wales received valuable information about the virus and about how to keep themselves and their loved ones safe. I wish him all the best for the future.”
Judith Paget, chief executive of NHS Wales, said: “Frank has shown how passionate he is about improving health outcomes for the Welsh population and has led the way on improving the quality of healthcare.
“It has been a privilege to work with him and to have the benefit of his experience and commitment to new approaches.
“He has played a crucial role in being the Welsh voice around the table with other UK Chief Medical Officers, government departments and organisations”
Sir Frank has been responsible for leading the medical profession in Wales and the development of health and care research.
Speaking ahead of leaving his post, Sir Frank said: “It has been a privilege to act as CMO and a highlight of my professional career to have served the people of Wales during this incredibly challenging time.
“I would like to thank all those other civil servants, who have worked tirelessly behind the scenes, who have assisted me for almost a decade in this role.”
Frank Atherton’s successor will be announced in due course.
-
Crime4 days ago
Milford Haven veterinary manager jailed for £50,000 work fraud
-
Crime5 days ago
Garage owner faces rape charge, case sent to Crown Court
-
News6 days ago
Six-month old baby girl confirmed dead after being hit by car in Pembrokeshire car park
-
News5 days ago
Man charged after tragic death of six-month-old baby in Tenby car park
-
Crime2 days ago
West Wales Farmer groomed teenage girl using cash and manipulation
-
Charity7 days ago
Tributes paid to former Tenby RNLI crew member Stuart Fecci
-
Top News6 days ago
Fresh snow and ice warning issued for Pembrokeshire
-
News6 days ago
Award-winning Welsh fashion designer stands down for health reasons