Connect with us
Advertisement
Advertisement

Politics

Westminster power grab ‘an affront to devolution’

Published

on

SENEDD Members criticised a “power grab” from Westminster, describing plans for UK ministers to make laws in areas already devolved to Wales as an “affront”.

The legislation committee raised concerns about the UK Government’s data use and access bill which would give UK ministers regulation-making powers in devolved areas.

Labour’s Alun Davies said the bill, which aims to make better use of data, would repeal regulations in Wales and impose English ones uniformly across both.

The former minister warned: “If UK ministers believe that they should have the right to take decisions and exercise regulation-making powers without the consent of Welsh ministers – that’s a very, very significant affront to the settlement.”

He explained the bill provides powers for UK ministers to act “only in consultation” with the Welsh Government, adding: “Consultation, as we know, means nothing in reality.”

Mr Davies said: “A bill like this tells you all you need to know about the inadequacies of the settlement but I’m genuinely bewildered by the Welsh Government’s approach.”

Labour MS Alun Davies
Labour MS Alun Davies

During a committee meeting on February 3, he suggested the Welsh Government was “piggybacking” on a UK bill and losing its powers as a consequence.

“That seems to me a real dereliction of responsibility,” he said.

Mr Davies asked: “Why on earth … what was the policy objective … that you’re just going to accept the imposition of this in some ways from the UK Government?”

Rebecca Evans, the Welsh Government’s economy secretary, responded: “These are the key issues we’re in discussion with the UK Government on now.”

Calling for the Welsh Government to legislate in its own right, Mr Davies said: “It just seems to me that we are creating another muddle on the border, another muddle of powers.”

Ms Evans, who came into post in September, replied: “I don’t sense that this is an area where something’s being done to us, it’s an area where we’re collaborating.”

Rebecca Evans, cabinet secretary for economy, energy and planning
Rebecca Evans, cabinet secretary for economy, energy and planning

Pointing to the Welsh Government’s “consent not consultation” principles on UK legislation in devolved areas, she told the committee most of the bill’s provisions are non-devolved.

Mr Davies, a backbencher since being sacked by Mark Drakeford in 2018, said: “We’ve got a new UK Government that made all sorts of assurances prior to the general election about extending the powers of the Senedd … devolving different matters … treating Wales fairly.

“We haven’t seen many of those delivered so far.”

The Plaid Cymru-turned-Labour politician contrasted this with powers being “taken away” from Wales to be exercised by the UK Government.

Warning Welsh ministers could be overruled on devolved matters under the bill, he said: “This scenario is not something I’m at all comfortable with. I wasn’t comfortable when the Conservatives were suggesting it, I’m not comfortable when Labour is suggesting it.”

Former Plaid Cymru leader Adam Price echoed his concerns, asking: “Are we on a slippery slope here, where England and Wales is once again coming through as a concept constitutionally to areas that we thought we had devolved long ago?”

Plaid Cymru MS Adam Price
Plaid Cymru MS Adam Price

He pressed the minister on whether she is in favour of the Senedd consenting to the bill, with Ms Evans saying she could not give a recommendation until talks with UK ministers end.

Seeming to prefer to seek compromise rather than set redlines, she described the issues as nuanced with a difference in view between the Welsh and UK Governments.

Labour’s Mike Hedges, who chairs the committee, asked why all the constitutional concerns have not been addressed since the change in UK Government more than six months ago.

Ms Evans said some of the concerns with the predecessor data protection and digital information bill have been addressed by the new UK Government.

But she told the committee: “It does remain the case that there are still some ongoing issues that we are in discussion with the UK Government on.”

Ms Evans added: “It’s not the subject matter that we have concerns about, it’s more about those ongoing discussions on constitutional points.”

Senedd Members will vote on the bill under the legislative consent motion, or LCM, process.

While the Sewel convention states the UK Parliament would “not normally” legislate on devolved matters without such consent, it is not legally binding.

 

News

Burnham sets out vision for Britain as he pitches for No 10

Published

on

Former Greater Manchester mayor promises radical devolution agenda after sweeping Makerfield victory

ANDY BURNHAM has used his first major policy speech since returning to Westminster to set out a blueprint for government, promising the biggest transfer of power away from Whitehall in modern times and unveiling plans for a new “No 10 North” in Manchester.

Speaking at the People’s History Museum on Monday, Burnham presented himself as the politician capable of breaking what he described as Britain’s cycle of economic stagnation, political division and over-centralised government.

The speech is widely being seen as his opening pitch to the country ahead of his expected move into Downing Street next month.

Burnham enters the contest from a position of strength after winning the Makerfield by-election earlier this month with a landslide majority. The result marked his return to Parliament and cleared the way for his challenge to succeed Keir Starmer.

At the heart of the speech was a promise to deliver “good growth in every postcode”, with Burnham arguing that Britain can no longer rely on decisions being made almost exclusively in London.

He said the UK remained one of the most centralised countries in the developed world and claimed the current system was failing the north, the south, London and the wider regions alike.

“The whole country suffers when the regions and nations are not meeting their potential,” he said.

Burnham argued that economic growth should be driven from communities and regions rather than directed from Whitehall, promising what he called “the biggest rebalancing of power our country has seen”.

The headline announcement was the creation of a permanent northern operation for the Prime Minister’s Office.

Burnham said a new No 10 North would be based in Manchester, but insisted it would not simply move power from London to one city.

“The job of No 10 North will be to make power flow into the Midlands, into the South West, into the East of England and yes, into London,” he said.

Burnham used the speech to outline what he calls “Manchesterism” — an approach shaped by his years running Greater Manchester.

The model combines sound public finances, local leadership, infrastructure investment, housing, universities, business, public services and trade unions working together to drive growth.

He said his time in Greater Manchester had shown that a different style of politics was possible, based on “place first, not party first” and “problem solving, not point scoring”.

Burnham also attacked Westminster culture, saying Parliament had become increasingly fragmented and disconnected from the communities MPs represent.

He promised a more collaborative style of government and said MPs should be allowed to be “authentic representatives” rather than being controlled by fear of the whipping system.

He also said local government had been left “threadbare”, with councils struggling to meet basic responsibilities while national government had grown larger since the pandemic.

The speech was quickly attacked by Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch, who dismissed Burnham’s proposals as “more public control, more regulation, more taxes”. Reform UK figures also criticised him for not taking questions from journalists after the speech.

For Wales, the speech will be watched closely because of its focus on devolution, regional growth and shifting power away from Westminster.

His argument that decisions should be taken closer to communities is likely to resonate with ongoing debates about transport, healthcare, economic investment and local government powers in Wales.

With Labour’s leadership transition expected to conclude within weeks, Burnham’s Manchester speech offered the clearest indication yet of how he intends to govern: less power concentrated in Whitehall, more influence for regions and nations, and a long-term focus on rebuilding local economies and living standards.

 

Continue Reading

Local Government

Fresh call for devolution of Crown Estate assets in Wales backed by county councillors

Published

on

A FRESH call has been made for Crown Estate assets in Wales to be devolved to the country, a call backed by Pembrokeshire councillors last year, after it made £210m profit this financial year.

Today, June 26, the Crown Estate published its annual review, also releasing a Wales-specific review, showing that, in 2025-’26 its profits in Wales were £210m, up from £8.7m in 2020-’21.

Plaid Cymru Westminster Leader Liz Saville Roberts said that Plaid Cymru – which has long campaigned for the assets to be devolved – has a “mandate to keep fighting for fairness” with devolving the Crown Estate being a position held by every council in Wales.

The new Plaid Cymru Welsh Government is also pursuing control over natural resources, in line with Scotland, where the Crown Estate was devolved in 2017.

Ms Saville Roberts said that profits from Wales’ natural resources being sent to London is a “striking injustice” and that the next UK Government “must take steps to devolve the Crown Estate to Wales”.

Back in 2025, Pembrokeshire County Council joined other Welsh councils in supporting the Crown Estate assets in the county being devolved to its people.

The Crown Estate owns 65 per cent of Wales’ riverbeds and beaches.

Proceeds from the Crown Estate, which dates to the 17th century, are split by 25 per cent funding the Royal Family and 75 per cent to the UK Treasury.

Responsibility for the Crown Estate is already devolved to the Scottish Government, which has previously been reported as generating £103.6 million into the public coffers in Scotland in 2023.

A sticking point in Wales is that Westminster has to date been against any change.

A successful notice of motion before Pembrokeshire County Council, by Plaid Cymru councillor Michael Williams said: “We ask PCC to support the proposal for the Crown Estate assets to be devolved to the people of Wales, so that profits can be used to invest in the economy and communities of Wales.

“A poll in 2023 showed that 75 per cent of the population were in favour of taking control of the assets of the Crown estate rather than the profits going to the Treasury and the Crown.

“Local authorities are under huge financial pressure and placing the Crown Estate in the hands of Wales would be a significant step to address the lack of investment in our local government.

“We call upon the Welsh Government to ask Westminster to devolve the assets and revenue of the Crown Estates as a matter of urgency, as was done in Scotland in 2017.

“We demand that Wales is treated fairly and accepts management of the Crown Estate land for the benefit of the people of Wales.”

Councillors have previously heard the Crown Estates derives nearly £60,000 from some 16 leases in Pembrokeshire.

The £59,005 quoted at the time includes £26,600 for foreshore lease agreements, £8,520 for the land around Haverfordwest’s Riverside Market, and £12,800 for a sailing centre and car park at Cosheston Pill near Pembroke Dock.

 

Continue Reading

Local Government

More than 2,300 housing units in more than 100 schemes in limbo

Published

on

MORE THAN 100 development schemes in Pembrokeshire, amounting to more than 2,300 homes, are in limbo due to the ongoing Nitrogen Neutrality guidelines from Natural Resources Wales, councillors heard.

At the June meeting of Pembrokeshire County Council’s services overview and scrutiny committee, members received an update on the ongoing issue of Nitrogen Neutrality which has led to delays in many housing schemes in the county since its introduction last June.

The area which development is required to demonstrate nitrogen neutrality is approximately 75 per cent of the county, including Haverfordwest, Narberth, Pembroke and Pembroke Dock.

The report, presented by Cabinet Member for Planning and Highways Cllr Jacob Williams, focussed on the implications of Natural Resources Wales’ (NRWs) Nutrient Neutrality requirements in respect of dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN) for development within the Milford Haven Inner waterbody catchment of the Pembrokeshire Marine Special Area of Conservation (SAC) and the measures being taken by the council at a local level to address this issue as well as the council’s contribution to regional and national initiatives.

The report said that, as of May, there were 21 planning applications which were in the system before the introduction of nitrogen neutrality requirements (June 2025) which are now caught and which remain undetermined, along with a further 66 undetermined since that date, and a further  15 applications which are caught by nitrates requirements, but which have not yet reached eight-week determination date.

It said the 102 developments caught by the nitrates issue amounted to some 35 per cent of the total undetermined applications; that figure even higher when determined (refused) schemes were taken into account.

Cllr Williams, who last year with the backing of full council, wrote a letter to the First Minister, conveying the authority’s “great concern over Natural Resources Wales’ recent river nitrates guidance in relation to development, and the serious effects this is having,” said that amounted to 2,376 of 6,741 potential housing units, adding that “Pembrokeshire County Council cannot approve development which is unable to demonstrate Nitrogen Neutrality”.

Last October, Cabinet endorsed an action plan to address the nitrates issue for affected development within its planning area, the early stages already delivered, with a final report due for Cabinet consideration this September in order to determine how mitigation opportunities identified might be taken forward.

Members backed a recommendation to note the action plan progress ahead of the report to Cabinet.

 

Continue Reading

Community1 day ago

Thousands line Cardigan streets for Lord Rhys homecoming parade

THOUSANDS of people lined the streets and quayside in Cardigan on Saturday as the town marked 850 years since Lord...

Crime2 days ago

Dyfed-Powys Police rated only ‘Adequate’ in organised crime inspection

A WATCHDOG has rated Dyfed-Powys Police only “Adequate” in its response to serious and organised crime, despite praise for the...

News2 days ago

Two taken to hospital after aircraft ditches in Cardigan Bay

Coastguard helicopter spotted two casualties after light aircraft came down off west Wales coast TWO people were taken to hospital...

Sport3 days ago

Long Course Weekend gets underway in Tenby as thousands head for county

Three days of swimming, cycling and running begin with The Wales Swim at North Beach THOUSANDS of athletes and supporters...

Climate3 days ago

Welsh waters, Westminster profits: Crown Estate row reignited in Wales

PLAID CYMRU has renewed calls for the Crown Estate to be devolved to Wales after figures showed income linked to...

News3 days ago

Reform MS: ‘I felt like shouting get out of the water’

Paul Marr says children playing in streams at Pembrokeshire beaches deserve better protection from pollution risks REFORM UK MS Paul...

Health4 days ago

Senedd backs call to rule out hospital downgrades after heated NHS debate

Reform UK amendment passes as West Wales hospital fears remain central political issue THE SENEDD has backed a call for...

News4 days ago

Coastguard callout payments axe sparks fears for coastal communities

VOLUNTEER coastguards across the UK are set to lose callout payments, prompting concern over the future resilience of emergency cover...

Farming4 days ago

Rural Wales ‘left out’ of net zero debate, warns carbon entrepreneur

A WELSH carbon entrepreneur has warned that rural Wales risks being left behind in the national conversation about net zero....

Local Government5 days ago

Tenby Spectacular row continues as organisers say key question remains unanswered

Round Table says legal clarity over pedestrian access is still holding up event plan TENBY ROUND TABLE has welcomed Pembrokeshire...

Popular This Week