News
Concern over learning centre closures

A CONTROVERSIAL decision recently made by Pembrokeshire County Council’s cabinet members to close down Community Learning Centres across the county has been called-in for further scrutiny by opposition councillors.
Four CLCs are set to close in two phases with Pembroke Dock and Fishguard centres closing down from August this year, and Tenby and Haverfordwest from August next year. They host a diverse array of day and evening courses in crafts, languages, art and basic skills, taught by a range of tutors. Following the centre closures the council plans to relocate these classes to other community buildings.
Disposals of the closed buildings are to return to the Cabinet under separate reports in the future, whilst Crymych’s learning centre will be retained by the authority as a Welsh language hub under an arrangement which Cabinet decided ‘will be kept under review’.
The report before cabinet members at their February 9 meeting stated that in January the Welsh Government announced funding cuts of £85,600 from April this year, and there was a likelihood of future cutbacks.
Cllr Jacob Williams has criticised the report, telling the Herald that, although the decision on the face of it was about saving money, he found it bizarre that ‘no other pound sign is contained within the cabinet report’.
When he became aware of the scale of cabinet’s decision to approve the closures, the complete lack of consultation, and what he calls the ‘wafer-thin report’ it was based on, East Williamston representative Cllr Williams set about the formal process of calling the application in for further scrutiny. He did so with the support from fellow County Councillor Jonathan Preston of Penally, Tessa Hodgson of Lamphey, Viv Stoddart of Milford Haven and Peter Stock of Haverfordwest.
Within the call-in requisition supported by his four colleagues, Cllr Williams states that the ‘consultation to date on all aspects of the closures has been inadequate’, and that ‘no financial assessment’ has been undertaken about the costs for room rentals for classes once the centres are closed.
One argument put forward within the call-in is that classes ‘are in jeopardy of being lost altogether if suitable rooms cannot be found’, and profits currently generated by classes ‘could be diminished’ by alternative room rental costs.
“I am not convinced that the decision to close centres has been made with a strong enough case or that all other options have been assessed, including the possibility of charge increases,” Cllr Williams writes.
As part of their decision on February 9, Cabinet members noted that the Tenby CLC was located in the same building as the youth club and library, and as a clause gave a reassurance that the youth provision in Tenby would be protected but with no guarantee that it would remain in the same building.
This reassurance offers little comfort for Cllr Williams because he says no other potential buildings have been identified by the council for the youth club or library to move into, and he believes if the learning centre closes it will lead to the youth centre closing, and fears that as a knock-on effect, eventually the library will face the axe for the same reason.
Cllr Williams told the Herald: “I won’t stand by and let the residents of the area take this on the chin without a fight, and I’m grateful to the councillors who signed my call-in without which it would not have been possible. In the south of the county Tenby Library serves a very wide community. No building has yet been identified to relocate it to, and with the removal of the learning centre which takes up the vast majority of the same building, and then very possibly the youth club moving out or closing its wing of the building, the clock is going to be ticking for the library in its current location at Greenhill Avenue which I’m sure the council is eyeing up for developers. I’m aware that there is outcry over the decision in Fishguard for similar reasons, which is another reason why I was so keen to call this decision in. The matter should have been considered as part of a wider review and strategy by the council with the whole of the county’s community services in mind, and not as some innocuous report slipped into a cabinet meeting agenda without any consultation, dressed-up as a necessary response to funding cuts from Cardiff Bay. Cardiff Bay’s cuts don’t help but it’s simply dishonest to blame this decision all on that – there’s just no strategy from County Hall other than to mothball the buildings without any consultation and that’s just not good enough.”
Cllr Jonathan Preston who put his signature to the call-in bid told the Herald: “The cabinet’s decision has been made with seemingly little basis on the facts. Community learning centres are a hub of activity and provide learning opportunities for all. It’s a fact that of the 22 councils in Wales, Pembrokeshire is the second largest provider of adult and community learning with enrolment of 6,000 each year. We should be proud of this but before long we could be near the bottom of the pile in Wales if the learning centre closures mean classes are unable to continue.”
Lamphey representative Cllr Tessa Hodgson who sits as an unaffiliated independent member told our reporter: “I’m grateful to Cllr Williams for taking the initiative and calling-in this important and sweeping decision made by cabinet. I was very happy to lend my support and sign the requisition forms and I welcome the opportunity for councillors to scrutinise this matter in detail as well as the ramifications of it, which cabinet members failed to do on February 9.”
Meanwhile Cllr Vivien Stoddart who represents Milford Haven Hubberston Ward as an unaffiliated independent member said: “I was pleased to support Cllr Jacob Williams in his bid to call-in Cabinet’s controversial decision for further scrutiny, which will see most of the county’s five adult learning centres close down. The report to February’s cabinet outlining the plans to reduce the council’s input to the centres was just three sides of A4; light on detail, facts, and figures. These cuts in services will impact on communities, and Tuesday’s scrutiny meeting will enable councillors to assess the potential effects on the people they represent.”
One of the claims made within the report approved by the cabinet which the councillors object to is that ‘there will be no impact from these changes on the range of courses or opportunities that Learning Pembrokeshire offers’.
Within the call-in request it is argued: “Given the uncertainty over the future locations of buildings and the facilities that may or not be available, I don’t believe this claim is sustainable and the viability of all current classes switching to alternative buildings appears not to have been assessed.”
Cllr Williams’ call-in request triggered a joint extraordinary meeting of both the county council’s Older Persons, Health and Well-Being Overview and Scrutiny Committee and its Children and Families Overview and Scrutiny Committee, to be held on Tuesday March 3, which was arranged by the newly promoted Head of Legal and Committee Services, Claire Incledon.
The joint committee consisting 26 councillors is unable to amend cabinet’s decision of February 9 or make a fresh one, but it can refer the decision back to cabinet with recommendations for changes, one of which has already been suggested by officers in response to the call-in.
Within the agenda for Tuesday’s joint overview and scrutiny meeting, Kate Evan-Hughes, the authority’s Director for Children and Schools, states that ‘there is some validity’ to Cllr Williams’ point concerning the failure to adequately assess the impact of Cabinet’s decision and the short time frame for closures.
Ms Evan-Hughes recommends that cabinet should be advised to revise its decision to delay the closures planned for 2015 so that no closures will take place until August 2016, which she states: ‘Will allow more time for community engagement in the process’ and for ‘the potential impact of building closures’ to be assessed alongside the planning stage for the 2016/17 academic year.
Cllrs Williams, Preston, Hodgson, Stoddart and Stock urge anybody who shares their concerns over the closures and the lack of evidence the decision was taken on, to come along to Tuesday’s scrutiny committee meeting which, like all council meetings, is open to the public.
It takes place at County Hall, Haverfordwest at 10am on Tuesday March 3.
Crime
Whitland father acquitted of child cruelty but faces family court proceedings

A 45-YEAR-OLD father from Whitland has been found not guilty of child cruelty following a decision by the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) to discontinue the case.
The man, who cannot be named to protect the identity of his children, had been charged with assaulting, ill-treating, neglecting, or abandoning a child in a way that could cause unnecessary suffering or injury. He had denied the allegations and was set to stand trial on June 16.
The case was reviewed at Swansea Crown Court on Wednesday (Mar 5), where prosecutor Dean Pulling confirmed that the CPS had decided not to proceed with a criminal trial. He explained that subjecting the children to the process was not deemed to be in the public interest.
“The matter will be addressed in the family court,” Mr Pulling stated, adding that the decision did not diminish the statements provided by the children.
With no evidence presented by the prosecution, Judge Catherine Richards formally recorded a not guilty verdict. She noted that the CPS had carefully considered its decision, clarifying that while the criminal case had concluded, it had no impact on the separate family court proceedings.
News
Campaign against US military radar in Pembrokeshire gains political backing

CAMPAIGNERS from Pembrokeshire-based PARC Against DARC visited the Senedd on Wednesday (March 5) to present their opposition to the proposed Deep Space Advanced Radar Concept (DARC) at Brawdy. The group argues the AUKUS-backed military proposal, supported by US President Donald Trump, could escalate tensions in space with China.
Twelve Members of the Senedd (MSs) from various political parties have endorsed a Statement of Opinion recognising widespread opposition to the project. The statement highlights concerns over DARC’s visual impact, potential health risks, and regional security implications. A petition against the proposal has gathered nearly 17,000 signatures, with campaigners calling for a Welsh Government commission to assess the issue.

Political support growing
A spokesperson for PARC Against DARC said: “Today marks a significant shift in the political impact of our campaign. We now have cross-party backing, including from Welsh Labour MSs, strong support from Plaid Cymru, and support from the Welsh Liberal Democrats’ Senedd representative, Jane Dodds.
“For the many people opposing DARC in Pembrokeshire, this shows the Senedd at its best—reflecting the views of the people who elect it. We urge all MSs to heed our community’s concerns and support the Statement of Opinion.”
The spokesperson continued: “The proposal to construct a 27-dish radar array on the skyline of the St Davids peninsula—a natural treasure and a key attraction for Welsh tourism—has been ill-conceived from the outset. The Senedd Members we met today are standing on the right side of history by opposing it.”

Concerns over militarisation
Sioned Williams MS attended the event, stating: “Plaid Cymru has a proud tradition of promoting peace, and this US militaristic project has no place in Wales.”
The campaigners argue that the DARC radar would serve Trump’s agenda for US space dominance and support Elon Musk’s rapidly expanding SpaceX network. They said: “Local opposition to this project is strong, with Pembrokeshire having a long history of resisting such proposals.
“With ‘untrustable Trump’ in the White House and Keir Starmer acting as a subordinate UK partner, we cannot assume the US will remain a reliable ally by the time DARC is completed. If this goes ahead, we risk inviting the enemy inside the gate.”
The ‘Highlighting Militarism in Wales’ event featured speeches from local PARC campaigners Roy Jones and Jim Scott, along with presentations from Academi Heddwch, Cymdeithas y Cymod, Quakers Wales, the Cardiff UN Association, and Stop the War Cardiff.

Peace vigil held at Senedd
Following the presentations, a televised Vigil for Peace took place on the steps of the Senedd. Ali Lochhead from CND Cymru spoke about the group’s vision for a peaceful Wales. The event concluded with a performance by Côr Cochion Choir and the symbolic release of two peace doves.
Heledd Fychan MS, who sponsored the event, said: “On this UN International Day for Disarmament and Non-Proliferation Awareness, I am proud to support this event highlighting militarism in Wales.
“Plaid Cymru has a long-standing history of opposing militarism and advocating for peace. We remain committed to supporting Pembrokeshire residents in their fight against the DARC project. Today’s discussions were insightful and provided Senedd Members with a deeper understanding of the strength of opposition.”
Call to reduce military spending
Campaigners also criticised the global arms race, stating: “While Trump’s erratic realignment of global power is dangerous and unpredictable, we support his suggestion that all superpowers should reduce military spending.
“Scrapping unnecessary AUKUS infrastructure like DARC would be a meaningful step towards ending the cycle of militarisation. We, along with other campaigners in the Senedd today, believe public resources should be invested in developing future technologies and improving lives, rather than continuing outdated and unaffordable military standoffs.”
PARC Against DARC is urging Welsh residents to sign their petition and email Senedd Members to oppose the project. A template for lobbying is available on the campaign’s website: www.parcagainstdarc.com/lobbying.
News
Pembrokeshire Council Tax rise for residents at 9.35% agreed

PEMBROKEHIRE taxpayers are to see their bills increase by 9.35 percent after “political tribalism was set aside,” but an alternative lower proposal by the Conservative group was defeated.
Today’s March 6 meeting of full council was to consider three potential increases in council tax, 9.85 percent previously recommended by Cabinet, a 9.35 percent rise proposed by the Independent group led by Cllr Huw Murphy, which was later supported by the ruling coalition, and a 7.5 percent rate proposed by the Conservative group.
The council was to decide the annual budget, which includes the council tax element, on February 20 but that meeting was deferred until March 6, in part awaiting the final Welsh government local government settlement, which saw the county gain a small amount of extra money, worth roughly an extra £500,000, reducing its funding gap to £26.9m.
At the March 6 meeting, Cabinet member for finance Cllr Joshua Beynon moved the Independent-proposed budget be adopted rather than the previous 9.85 percent council tax rise one, seconded by Independent group member Cllr Alan Dennison.
The 9.35 percent increase adds £141.25 to the average bill over last year’s rate.
The Conservatives’ alternate budget of 7.5 percent was proposed by group leader Cllr Di Clements, saying there was a need to make “tough choices” with “a limited pot,” adding last year’s council tax increase of 12.5 percent was “one of the highest in the UK,” with “a significant rise” again proposed this year.
The Conservative proposals included addressing deficits in council leisure services by partnering with a national leisure trust, along with increasing the education budget by £6.6 million in the next financial year.
Cllr Clements added: “The budget choices will get harder and harder, we believe we cannot keep doing the same thing, slicing services until there is nothing left, that is why we are looking at alternate ways of providing services.”
She was joined by group spokesman for finance Cllr Aled Thomas who said people were “sick and tired of the status quo,” adding: “Taxpayers shouldn’t be burdened with failures of this local authority, whether vanity projects or failures to make efficiency savings; it is the taxpayer that pays for this, we owe it to them to be responsible.”
Cllr Alec Cormack, the former Cabinet member for finance, said he sympathised and supported some elements of the Conservative proposals but felt some parts were “not fully developed,” with “a very serious risk that many of these measures would not really deliver savings in 2025-’26,” adding: “I do not feel this really leads us to a balanced budget”.
After lengthy debate, the Conservative proposal was defeated by 45 votes to 13.
Leader Cllr Jon Harvey quoted from his speech when he was elected leader, saying he was happy to work on cross-party consensus politics, adding: “Cllr Huw Murphy shared a budget proposal, which we’re grateful for, not too dissimilar to the one proposed by Cabinet, considered to be a proposal we could jointly put forward, a pragmatic approach rather than an adversarial approach.”
He told members the 9.35 percent increase would lead to a county council part of the overall tax bill for the average Band D property would now be £1,651.97 in Pembrokeshire against Ceredigion’s £1,886.57 for the forthcoming financial year.
The final bill is calculated by adding the police precept, set at £360.68 for a Band D property, and individual town and community council precepts.
He warned there were still elements in the budget that were “a risk,” with challenging efficiency savings needed.
The 9.35 percent rise was backed by 46 members, with 13 against.
Speaking after the meeting, Independent group Leader Cllr Murphy said their supported proposal was “about doing what’s right by our most vulnerable, not doing what’s necessarily popular”.
He reiterated his party being “critical friends to the Administration” who would not “oppose for the sake of opposition,” welcoming the Cabinet support his party’s proposal, where “political tribalism was set aside for the good of our residents,” welcoming it as “progressive and mature politics on a very difficult subject, namely council tax”.
“In life it’s about making the difficult decisions not about making popular decisions that we are measured against.
“No tax rise is welcomed but today was a balance of offering the lowest council tax that was realistically possible versus the services we provide, much of it statutory.”
Cllr Aled Thomas of the Conservative group reacted to the vote, saying: “It’s disappointing that the Independent Group and Cabinet came together today to vote for the continued tax and spend mindset, at the expense of Pembrokeshire residents.
“The Conservative group proposed an ambitious budget with innovative ideas signalling change, and it was great to hear members across the chamber agree that change can’t come quick enough.
“Despite today’s result, the Welsh Conservative group will continue to fight for the best value for money for the hardworking Pembrokeshire taxpayers.”
‘Your needs and priorities at the forefront’
After the meeting Cabinet Member for Corporate Finance and Efficiencies Cllr Joshua Beynon, said: “I want to reassure residents that this budget has been set with your needs and priorities at the forefront.
“Pembrokeshire, like all local authorities, faces significant challenges and increasing demands on key service areas. But we are determined to navigate them in a way that safeguards our communities and ensures we continue to deliver for Pembrokeshire.”
Leader of the Council, Cllr Jon Harvey said: “Setting a balanced budget is a legal requirement and is the responsibility of Council, not Cabinet. When I was elected to the role of Leader last May, I made reference to the fact that I wished to build as much consensus as possible within the Chamber.
“This budget highlights that by working together to identify common aims and objectives, we can achieve an agreed outcome.
“As we are all too aware, the pressures across Welsh local government services are immense.
“In light of the challenges we’ve faced in recent years and continue to face, this budget will help us to avoid devastating, deeply unpopular cuts to services. It’s the only way we can protect the vital services our community relies on, while laying the groundwork for a sustainable, thriving future for Pembrokeshire.
In approving this budget we have sought to find a delicate balance between safeguarding our future and recognising the very real cost-of-living pressures faced by families in Pembrokeshire every single day.
“I became a Councillor to improve peoples lives, to help those in need and to support those who are struggling.
“Those of us that represent wards with high levels of social deprivation will only know too well how much our residents rely upon the services provided by the Council. This budget will support those in our communities that need our services most, whether this is our school children, vulnerable children and our elderly residents.
“Finally, I would like to thank the Finance Team and the Cabinet Member for Finance for all the hard work they have put in over many months on the budget proposals, to ensure we are best positioned to face the challenges ahead.”
Cllr Huw Murphy added: “On becoming Independent Group leader with Cllr Anji Tinley elected Deputy we released a statement that as a Group of Independent Councillors we would be critical friends to the Administration, and neither would we “oppose for the sake of opposition” and this can be clearly evidenced over the last 10 months within Council.
“We also stated that the Independent Group would challenge decisions which might have a negative impact on residents and where possible present alternative options. The recent budget setting is a testament to the integrity of the Independent Group where on Feb 20th we prevented a possible Council Tax of 9.85% by adjourning a meeting of Council to await a final financial settlement from WG.
“The Independent Group then prepared & submitted an alternative budget offering a lower Council Tax of 9.35% along with fewer cuts in services, which passed today (at Full Council). The decision of Cabinet in supporting the alternative budget rather than opposing it is to be welcomed where the (vast) majority of Councillors accepted the need to discharge their statutory duties where political tribalism was set aside for the good of our residents is welcomed as progressive and mature politics on a very difficult subject, namely Council Tax.
“No Tax rise is welcomed but today was a balance of offering a lower Council Tax whilst recognising the need to find appropriate reductions in certain service areas.
“Moving forward there is much work to be done within Pembrokeshire and further afield in Cardiff & London to secure adequate funding to provide services Pembrokeshire residents deserve. As a Group of Independent Councillors, we will continue to work hard for all Pembrokeshire residents in raising their concerns and holding the Administration to account.”
-
Crime3 days ago
Father and daughter in court accused of causing suffering to dogs, pigs and sheep
-
Crime3 days ago
Drug-dealing teenager assaulted woman and offering her cash to drop charges
-
Crime3 days ago
Pembroke Dock man to appear in court over indecent child images
-
Crime3 days ago
Man charged and remanded following e-bike crash in Milford Haven
-
Crime2 days ago
Woman accused of £85,000 fraud while acting as power of attorney
-
Crime2 days ago
Milford Haven teenager accused of Valentine’s Day sex offences
-
Crime3 days ago
Milford Haven man fined for littering in Haverfordwest
-
Crime2 days ago
Notorious paedophile cult leader Colin Batley may be freed this week