News
Supreme Court sides with couple in ‘bedroom tax’ case

Paul Rutherford: With his grandson Warren (pic. BBC)
SUPREME COURT Judges today (Nov 9) dismissed an appeal by the DWP against Paul and Sue Rutherford following an earlier ruling which found that the ‘bedroom tax’ was unfair and discriminated against the disabled and their carers.
Back in January, judges ruled that the Government’s stance on relying on local authorities providing discretionary support was not a substitute for the full protection afforded to them if the government complied with the provisions of UK law.
The Secretary of the Department of Work and Pensions lost no time in appealing this judgement to the Supreme Court, a decision Llanelli MP Nia Griffith described as ‘disgraceful’.
The Supreme Court Judges found in favour of the Rutherfords, who care for their severely disabled grandson Warren in a specially adapted home that includes a room for professional carers to stay in overnight. Warren, suffers from Potokoi-Shaffer Syndrome, a very rare genetic disorder which means he is unable to walk or talk, and needs 24 hour care by at least two people at all times.
The Conservatives’ bedroom tax meant that a bedroom used by overnight carers who look after him was counted as an additional bedroom whose presence in the family home was surplus to the family’s requirements.
Supreme Court Judges also found in favour of Jacqueline Carmichael, a Spina Bifida sufferer who lives with her husband in a two bedroom flat, but rejected several other cases.
A spokesman for the DWP said: “It is welcome that the court found in our favour in five out of the seven cases.
“The court also agreed with our view that Discretionary Housing Payments are generally an appropriate and lawful way to provide assistance to those who need extra help.
“In the two specific cases where the Court did not find in our favour, we will take steps to ensure we comply with the judgement in due course.”
Crime
Man sentenced after false stabbing claim in abusive 999 call
Court hears intoxicated caller wasted police resources after contacting officers from Penally caravan site
A MAN has been sentenced after falsely claiming he had been stabbed and making abusive comments during a 999 call to police.
Christopher Lawrence, 43, contacted the emergency services from the Oasis campsite in Penally on June 2, saying he wanted to report a crime.
“He told police that he had been stabbed, stating: ‘You f****** don’t care,’” Crown prosecutor Sian Vaughan told Haverfordwest Magistrates’ Court this week.
Lawrence then ended the call, but the police control room contacted him again.
He told the call handler that a man he described as “half bald” and drunk had arrived at the campsite and was threatening him.
“I’ve told the f****** police that if he comes here, I’ll go mental,” Lawrence said.
He also claimed to have suffered a stab wound to his side but said he did not require an ambulance.
When officers arrived, they found Lawrence heavily intoxicated.
“He told the officers that he had not been stabbed and had not made the call, but clearly that was not the case,” Ms Vaughan said.
Lawrence, of no fixed abode, pleaded guilty to sending an offensive, indecent, obscene or menacing message to police.
His solicitor, Michael Kelleher, said the offence had been driven by Lawrence’s alcohol misuse.
“What runs throughout this case is his alcohol abuse, but he is now showing a willingness to address it,” Mr Kelleher told the court.
“This functioning alcoholic wants to get to the bottom of his problem and stop offending.
“Alcohol can heighten a person’s anxiety and their perception of what is happening. There was no issue concerning his safety on this occasion, but there had been in the past, and that was playing on his mind.
“But what he did was wrong. It was a waste of police resources, and he understands how other people could have been affected by his actions.”
Lawrence was sentenced to a 12-month community order, including a nine-month alcohol treatment programme and 15 rehabilitation activity requirement days.
He was also fined £100 and ordered to pay a £114 surcharge and £85 prosecution costs.
Crime
Saundersfoot man admits attempted sexual communication with a child
A 56-YEAR-OLD man has admitted attempting to engage in sexual communication with a child in Saundersfoot.
Appearing before Haverfordwest Magistrates Court this week was Philip Williams, of Valley View, Saundersfoot.
The court was told that between July 20 and July 28, 2024, Williams attempted to engage in sexual communication with a 13-year-old child who was called Sam.
During his communication with the child, Williams requested snapchat images of the child’s bottom as well as images of her wearing running leggings or tights. This, the court, was told, was for his sexual gratification.
But unknown to Williams, the ‘child’ was an undercover police officer.
Williams pleaded guilty to the charge of attempting to engage in sexual communication with a child.
His sentencing will take place on August 4 to enable an all options pre-sentence report to be prepared by the probation service.
Crime
Rear-seat passenger admits causing serious injury by dangerous driving
Court hears 21-year-old repeatedly grabbed steering wheel of moving Volkswagen Golf
A REAR-SEAT passenger has admitted causing serious injury by dangerous driving after repeatedly grabbing the steering wheel of a moving car.
Joseph Lawrence Jones, 21, was travelling in the back of a Volkswagen Golf being driven by Sioned Tesni Povey, 22, along the Spring Wells to Spittal road on September 30.
Haverfordwest Magistrates’ Court heard that Jones reached forward from the rear seat and pulled the steering wheel from the driver.
“He then repeated his actions, but Sioned Povey continued to drive and made no resistance to Mr Jones’ actions,” Crown prosecutor Sian Vaughan said.
“This was a deliberate decision to ignore the rules of the road.”
The court heard that Harlie-Louise Smith sustained serious injuries during the incident.
Jones, of Wesley Way, Spittal, pleaded guilty to causing serious injury by dangerous driving.
Povey, of Duncan Terrace, Maenclochog, denied the same charge, maintaining that her driving had not caused Ms Smith’s injuries.
Although magistrates accepted jurisdiction to deal with the case, Povey elected to be tried at the Crown Court.
She is due to appear at Swansea Crown Court on August 14, when Jones is also expected to be sentenced.
Magistrates imposed an interim driving disqualification on Jones.
Both defendants were released on unconditional bail.
-
Crime2 days agoLetterston footballer guilty of eye-gouging assault during match
-
Health6 days agoHospital ward closed after highly contagious scabies outbreak
-
Charity6 days agoLifesaving charity could get over £60,000 from Snowdon hike
-
News6 days agoMilford Haven Coastguard coordinates rescue of injured paddleboarder
-
Crime6 days agoAnn Widdecombe: Welsh politicians pay tribute as murder probe launched
-
Business6 days agoCall to expand nature retreat with more lodges, a sauna and padel courts
-
News6 days agoSolardo pulls out of Haverfordwest show as organisers offer full refunds
-
Education6 days agoSaundersfoot graduate secures teaching job before completing degree







