Health
Despite protests, Hywel Dda forms appraisal group to discuss new ‘super hospital’ site
DESPITE the recent protests over the downgrading of Withybush General Hospital, Hywel Dda University Health Board is pushing ahead with its plans for a new ‘super hospital’, slated to be located somewhere in Carmarthenshire.
The board is inviting those members of the public who have expressed a wish to be part of future engagement, to submit expressions of interest to be part of the process to help assess and evaluate the shortlisted sites.
This technical evaluation process will result in a recommendation for the best location for the new urgent and planned care hospital.
Those against the idea say that Withybush Hospital in Haverfordwest is already ideally located to serve a busy county with a mix of tourism, industry and agriculture. Carmarthenshire is too far some say, and could result of the loss of the golden hour needed to save lives in serious medical emergencies.
The health board says that it has recently submitted a Programme Business Case to the Welsh Government to secure a scale of investment never before seen in west Wales. One of the proposals within the business case is for a new urgent and planned care hospital, somewhere between Narberth in Pembrokeshire and St Clears in Carmarthenshire.
The board says to help select a site and as part of its commitment to engage with communities, it is contacting individuals, groups, and organisations from across the three counties requesting expressions of interest to join a group to assess and evaluate the shortlisted sites and to identify the best location for the hospital.
This exercise, The Herald has been told, includes writing to more than 200 people who participated in an engagement exercise last year, who had requested to be kept informed about future engagement activities.
Numbers will be limited but the health board is seeking a diverse and representative group. Those who become part of the process will be expected to attend a small number of half day workshops. While dates are yet to be confirmed we would expect participation to include a discussion on the process for the appraisal, understanding of criteria used for evaluating the shortlist of sites and to agree the relative weighting of those criteria. Finally scoring the shortlisted sites to arrive at a recommendation for the health board.
The process is being managed with support and advice from The Consultation Institute, a not-for-profit, independent body, which provides guidance on best practice for engaging with communities.
Lee Davies, Executive Director of Strategic Development and Operational Planning at Hywel Dda UHB, said: “Public representation on this appraisal group is of paramount importance, and we want it to be as representative as possible of the communities we serve. The group will also include health and care professionals, clinicians and public sector partners.
“We fully understand the strength of feeling that exists within our communities, which is why I would encourage those contacted to submit their expressions of interest to take part in this panel, and have their voices heard.
“The new urgent and planned care hospital is one element of our ambitious plan to improve health outcomes and well-being of our population. It forms part of our long-term strategy to deliver A Healthier Mid and West Wales, which followed extensive engagement and consultation in 2018.
“Our target is to shift from an illness service with a focus on hospital buildings and intervention, to a service that works across boundaries to prevent ill health or deterioration of health, providing help earlier, and wherever possible closer to home.”
While many details about future services across Hywel Dda are currently being developed and planned, the health board has published a list of Frequently Asked Questions to ensure the public are provided with the most up-to-date information.
Charity
Charity campaign showcases powerful bereavement support for local families
HYWEL DDA Health Charities, the official charity of Hywel Dda University Health Board, is calling on local communities to help them provide comfort and support to families who have lost a child.
The charity is running a campaign this spring to highlight its Wish Fund which provides support to families during times of bereavement.
The Wish Fund supports Hywel Dda’s Paediatric Palliative Care team to provide personalised support to families of children and young people receiving palliative care, and helps them create treasured memories when their child sadly passes away. From hand moulds and fingerprint jewellery to memory boxes and specialist sibling support, the fund ensures bereaved families are not alone during the most devastating moments of their lives.
Frankie’s parents Phil and Veronica shared how the Wish Fund helped them during their darkest days:
“We had the absolute pleasure of looking after the most beautiful, awesome, wonderful, loving and brave little lad who was very poorly in the last years of his life.

“We met his Paediatric Palliative Care team two years before his passing and boy what an awesome team they are.
“We will never be able to thank the Wish Fund enough. Thanks to the Wish Fund, we had the most amazing mementos, a Christmas bauble, a necklace with Frankie’s fingerprint on it and a mould of his hand. Those simple objects are our most treasured possessions along with a lock of his beautiful hair.”
The Wish Fund relies on charitable donations, and every contribution can have a lasting impact:
- £15 provides a teddy for a bereaved sibling
- £30 funds a sibling support session
- £50 creates a hand mould keepsake
- £70 provides a Memory Box
- £85 funds bespoke hand‑printed jewellery
These meaningful items offer comfort to parents, carers and siblings who are navigating unimaginable loss.
Rebecca McDonald, Clinical Nurse Specialist – Paediatric Palliative Care, said: “I want to extend my heartfelt thanks to everyone who has donated and continues to donate to the Wish Fund.
“Thanks to your kindness and generosity, we have been able to provide meaningful memory-making items and bereavement materials. These resources make an immeasurable difference in helping us support our families through the most difficult time.
“Your compassion and support truly help us bring comfort, dignity, and lasting memories to the families we care for. Thank you for your support in helping us make a big difference to families we support across our health board.”
To find out more or to donate to the Wish Fund, please visit: https://hywelddahealthcharities.nhs.wales/campaigns/the-wish-fund/
Business
Narberth Kadinsky gallery to dental surgery refused
PLANS to convert a former art gallery to a dental surgery on the edge of a Pembrokeshire town have been refused.
In an application to Pembrokeshire County Council, Ahmed Abouserwel, through agent A.D Architectural Design Consultants LTD, sought permission for a change of use of the former Kadinsky gallery, Redstone Road, Narberth, to a dental surgery, along with associated works.
A supporting statement said: “The existing open plan gallery space will be transformed into the main dentist area, with a glazed internal lobby, leading directly into the open reception / waiting area. There will be five treatment rooms accessed directly off the reception, with a private archive room behind the reception desk.
“The rear lean-to projection will be extended to the north to accommodate a proposed decontamination room and to re-model the Staff area and W.C provision (number to remain as existing).”
It said the proposal would create 10 full and three part-time jobs.
An officer report recommending refusal said concerns were raised by the county Highways authority, who having assessed the application on safety, capacity and policy considerations, recommended the application be REFUSED on the grounds of insufficient evidence provided.
“The submitted design and access statement and block plan indicate on-site parking provision for 16 vehicles, located to the north and west of the building. The application form states that the site will employ 10 full-time staff and three part-time staff. However, the submission does not differentiate between practitioners and ancillary/support staff.”
It said, on planning guidance, health centres require three spaces per practitioner; and one space per three ancillary staff, adding: “As the applicant has not provided a breakdown of staff roles, the Highway Authority is unable to assess whether the proposed parking provision is adequate.”
It stressed: “Whist there is no in-principle objection to the redevelopment of this established site for a dental surgery, insufficient information has been provided to fully assess the proposal.”
It was refused on the grounds including it would lead “to the unjustified loss of an employment premises in a location which contributes to the local supply of employment land and buildings,” adding: “Insufficient evidence has been submitted to demonstrate that the building is no longer suitable or viable for continued employment use, nor that there is overriding community need to justify its loss.”
It was also refused on the grounds that “Insufficient information has been submitted to demonstrate that the development would operate without giving rise to unacceptable highway safety impacts or on street parking pressure”.
Health
Patients in Wales waiting years for autoimmune diagnosis
Study led by Swansea University says long delays, limited specialist access and referral barriers are leaving some patients worse off than those elsewhere in the UK
PEOPLE in Wales with autoimmune and rheumatological conditions are facing long waits for diagnosis, poor access to specialist care and repeated obstacles when trying to secure treatment outside their local area, according to new research.
The study, led by Swansea University, examined the experiences of patients with illnesses including lupus and other autoimmune disorders. It drew on interviews, survey findings and Freedom of Information responses from health boards across Wales.
Researchers found that specialist provision remains limited in some parts of the country. Some patients reported having no access to a lupus specialist in their area, while FOI responses indicated there is only one NHS neuro-ophthalmologist in Wales for patients with neurological or visual problems linked to autoimmune disease.
The report also highlighted a lack of diagnostic services. None of the Welsh health boards that responded said they currently provide nailfold capillaroscopy, a test used to help identify conditions such as scleroderma.
Diagnosis in rheumatology can also be difficult because many of the conditions involved are complex and may develop gradually over time. Illnesses such as ankylosing spondylitis can be mistaken in the early stages for more common causes of pain, while autoimmune disorders often present with symptoms that overlap with other conditions.
Patients may require a combination of investigations before a diagnosis can be confirmed, including HLA-B27 testing, routine blood work, MRI scans, X-rays and detailed clinical assessment. Doctors also rely heavily on patient interviews to build up a picture of pain, stiffness, mobility and the wider pattern of symptoms.
There have also been local pressures on services in west Wales. At Withybush Hospital, delays were caused after the departure of a specialist consultant, and it took some time for that post to be filled. That consultant has now been replaced. However, it is understood the workload remained heavy, with the specialist working through a backlog of cases.
In some cases, patients may also feel rheumatology is treated as a lower-profile service. At Withybush Hospital, for example, the department has been based in a portacabin in the hospital car park, which it shares with the lymphoedema service — a setting that can give the impression that two important but often overlooked specialties are being accommodated on the margins of the wider hospital system.
Rheumatology also places a significant burden on the NHS because of the cost of long-term treatment and follow-up care, although that is not the main focus of the study. Biological drugs used to treat conditions such as rheumatoid arthritis and ankylosing spondylitis can cost around £500 for a pack of four injections, according to local hospital sources. Patients on those medications often also require regular blood monitoring, consultant reviews, specialist nurse support and physiotherapy. The Herald understands that more than 1,000 patients in Pembrokeshire are currently being managed through this treatment pathway.
Researchers said patients were also being held back by the referral system. Under current NHS Wales rules, doctors must apply to their local health board for permission to send patients for treatment outside the area or across the border into England. The study said decision-making around those requests was often inconsistent and unfair.
One patient with systemic lupus erythematosus told researchers he waited two years for approval to be referred to England, despite believing the process should only have taken weeks.
The study found that patients in Wales often face longer journeys to diagnosis than elsewhere in the UK. In the sample reviewed by researchers, the average time from first symptoms to diagnosis was around 11 years, compared with around seven years across the UK.
Patients described the effect those delays had on their health. One woman in her 30s said requests to see a specialist in a neighbouring health board had been turned down, and that her lupus had worsened as a result. Another patient said access to care became more difficult after moving from England to Wales.
The research was led by Rupert Harwood of Swansea University Medical School, who himself lives with several autoimmune conditions.
His own experience reflects the wider concerns raised in the report. After developing visual symptoms in 2016, he was advised to see a neuro-ophthalmologist, but no such service was then available in Wales. A referral to England was not successfully made until 2025, and he is still waiting for an appointment.
Mr Harwood said the present system can leave patients at a disadvantage if they cannot afford to seek private treatment outside Wales.
The study concludes that while NHS Wales rheumatology teams provide high-quality care, patients in Wales face additional barriers compared with those in England.
Researchers are calling for a review of the out-of-area referral system, better access to specialist services and greater investment in diagnostic testing to reduce delays and improve outcomes.
-
Business7 days agoA proper Pembroke local: Inside the warm welcome of The Old Cross Saws Inn
-
Community7 days agoDoorstep warning issued after reports of suspicious callers in Pembrokeshire
-
Business5 days agoMilford Haven dry dock pitched as home for giant £480m superyacht yard
-
Crime7 days agoRomino’s licence revoked after illegal workers found and fire risks exposed
-
Politics6 days agoWelsh Lib Dems promise childcare boost, social care reform in manifesto launch
-
News6 days agoHaverfordwest County AFC escapes winding-up order but ordered to pay costs
-
News6 days agoLabour split over Brawdy defence project as Eluned Morgan calls for project halt
-
Community6 days agoFamily safe after major house fire in Letterston, community told











