Connect with us
Advertisement
Advertisement

Crime

How the Post Office Horizon scandal profoundly impacted lives across Wales

Published

on

IT’S a story etched by systemic shortcomings and individual resilience. And thanks to the recent ITV drama “Mr Bates vs the Post Office” its one which we all now know. The Post Office Horizon scandal has profoundly impacted lives across Wales and beyond, entangling figures like Tim Brentnall from Pembrokeshire and Lorraine Williams from Llanddaniel, Anglesey. Their experiences, are similar despite taking place on opposite ends of Wales. They are unified by a shared ordeal of injustice and a relentless pursuit for redemption – Tom Sinclair reports.

Tim Brentnall, a young entrepreneur from Roch, Pembrokeshire, saw his aspirations crumble when an audit in 2009 revealed a £22,000 shortfall at his post office branch. This led to a chain of events that upended his life. Despite no evidence of wrongdoing, the pressure to resolve the discrepancy saw Tim’s family take out a loan to cover the supposed shortfall, only for him to be prosecuted and advised to plead guilty. This resulted in an 18-month suspended sentence and 200 hours of community service. The guilt plea, made under distressing circumstances, cast a long shadow over Tim’s life, leading to social ostracization and personal turmoil.

In a parallel ordeal, Lorraine Williams from Llanddaniel, Anglesey, faced a similar plight. A cornerstone of her community, Lorraine’s world was turned upside down when she was wrongly accused of stealing over £14,600. Coerced into pleading guilty to false accounting to avoid more severe charges, she too received an 18-month suspended sentence and 200 hours of community service. Her conviction shattered her standing in the community she had served so selflessly.

Central to both Tim’s and Lorraine’s stories is the figure of Stephen Bradshaw, the Post Office investigator whose methods in pursuing these cases have been heavily scrutinized. Bradshaw, known for his pugnacious determination, played a pivotal role in the investigation, often refusing to consider the possibility of innocence or the potential flaws in the Horizon system. His appearance during the Post Office scandal inquiry and his portrayal in the TV drama have highlighted his aggressive approach and unwavering stance in these investigations.

In addition to his inability to comprehend the complexities of the Horizon system, he was evasive about his bonus arrangements. This evasiveness further underlines the corrupt practices that have marred the integrity of the Post Office’s management.

Bradshaw’s actions, particularly his single-minded pursuit of convictions and repayment of alleged debts, have drawn comparisons to those of a ‘mafia gangster’, a term used by some to describe his behavior. Despite these accusations, Bradshaw maintained that his investigations were conducted professionally and that he was simply following orders to defend the Horizon system. His lack of technical expertise, as he admitted to not being “technically minded,” raised questions about his ability to fairly assess the situations he was investigating.

Stephen Bradshaw is facing strong criticism for not noticing problems with Horizon

The experiences of Tim and Lorraine, along with those of hundreds of other sub-postmasters, culminated in the quashing of their convictions in April 2021, marking a significant step in rectifying this miscarriage of justice. Their stories, part of a wider narrative involving 736 wrongfully prosecuted individuals, underscore the most extensive legal misstep in UK history.

As the independent inquiry into the scandal continues, the focus on Tim’s and Lorraine’s experiences, and the role of figures like Stephen Bradshaw, brings to light the intricate interplay of personal suffering, technological failures, and institutional accountability. This scandal serves as a stark reminder of the necessity for transparency and responsibility in corporate and government systems, and the dire consequences when these are neglected.

Prosecutor Gary Thomas said that he got a bonus for every postmaster he convicted

In the aftermath of these events, the resilience of Tim Brentnall, Lorraine Williams, and others like them stands as a testament to the human spirit’s capacity to endure and seek justice in the face of overwhelming odds. Their stories, extending beyond Pembrokeshire and Anglesey, highlight the urgent need for vigilance and reform in institutions that are entrusted with public service. As they reclaim their dignity and continue to advocate for accountability, their experiences serve as a poignant reminder of the enduring impact of systemic failings and the importance of upholding justice for all.

Continue Reading

Crime

Four young Pembrokeshire men arrested on suspicion of rape

Published

on

DETECTIVES looking into a serious allegation of rape and sexual assault that took place in Saundersfoot on Saturday (May 11) have made arrests, The Herald can confirm.

Four males, aged 22, 21, 20 and 19 were arrested on suspicion of rape. They have now been released pending further enquiries.

A police spokesperson told The Pembrokeshire Herald on Thursday (May 16): “Dyfed Powys is investigating an allegation of rape and sexual assault that took place in Saundersfoot on May 11. The victim is being supported by specialist officers.

“Four men, aged 22, 21, 20 and 19 have been arrested on suspicion of rape. All four have been released on conditional bail pending further police enquiries.

Continue Reading

Crime

Father must stay out of trouble be jailed, says judge

Published

on

A FATHER who attacked his then-girlfriend in a violent outburst has been sentenced to a suspended prison term, with the warning that any further trouble will result in jail time.

Christopher Bendall, 33, of Great Eastern Terrace, Neyland, must remain law-abiding for the next 18 months or serve a 12-month prison sentence for two counts of assault occasioning actual bodily harm.

The incident occurred in the early hours of 6 August 2022, when Bendall returned home after a night out. His then-girlfriend, who had also been out separately, entered his unlocked home at approximately 4.20am. Upon waking Bendall, she questioned him about messages from another woman found on his phone. The confrontation escalated from a verbal dispute to a physical altercation.

Bendall threw a footstool and the victim’s mobile phone at her, both of which missed. He then pushed her to the floor, dragged her by her hair, slapped her face, and dragged her into the hallway. The victim managed to escape by grabbing Bendall by his testicles, causing him to release her grip. She fled the property, taking Bendall’s mobile phone with her.

Following the assault, Bendall called 999, accusing the woman of attacking him. Police initially arrested her but released her after noticing her injuries, which included carpet burns, bruises, and redness. Bendall was then arrested.

The court heard that this was not the first assault. In May, Bendall had thrown his mobile phone at the woman, breaking her finger.

Bendall initially denied the charges but later pleaded guilty to the two counts of assault occasioning actual bodily harm. Three other charges, including controlling or coercive behaviour, assault by beating, and strangulation, were dropped, and not guilty verdicts were formally entered for these counts.

In her victim impact statement, the woman revealed that she had been seeing a counsellor and was on anxiety medication following the assaults. She expressed that she still struggled to feel normal and feared going out alone.

Bendall’s defence highlighted that he was a father of three, a successful solar electrician, and previously of clean character. They noted that he was a good father, very involved with his children, and had well-paid employment. It was also stated that he had abstained from alcohol and had no further incidents since August 2022.

Judge Mr Recorder D Elias KC took into account Bendall’s plea, a pre-sentence report, and two character references. He acknowledged the psychological harm caused to the victim and described the injuries from the second assault as ‘nasty.’

Bendall was sentenced to 12 months in prison, suspended for 18 months. Additionally, he was ordered to attend a Building Better Relationships course, undertake ten days of rehabilitation activity, and complete 150 hours of unpaid work. He must also pay £1,500 in court costs and a £156 victim surcharge within six months.

Continue Reading

Crime

Man sentenced to 16 weeks for theft from Pembroke Dock Boots

Published

on

RAJ DOMNU, a 27-year-old resident of Scunthorpe, has been sentenced to 16 weeks in prison for his involvement in the theft of items valued at £1,819.53 from Boots the Chemist in Pembroke Dock. The sentence was handed down at Haverfordwest Magistrates’ Court on May 14

Domnu, residing at Frodingham Road, Scunthorpe, appeared in court via live link. The court heard that the theft, which occurred on 13th April 2024, involved a significant degree of planning and was carried out as part of a group. CCTV footage presented during the trial revealed Domnu’s leading role in the offence.

Initially convicted on April 22, Domnu’s case was reopened following an application under section 142 of the Magistrates’ Courts Act 1980. The original sentence imposed on May 13 was set aside, leading to the reimposition of the 16-week custodial sentence due to the serious nature of the offence.

In addition to the prison term, Domnu has been ordered to pay compensation to Boots the Chemist in the amount of £1,819.53. He is also required to pay a surcharge of £154 to fund victim services and £85 in costs to the Crown Prosecution Service. The total financial penalties amount to £2,058.53, which Mr. Domnu must pay by 1st July 2024.

Presiding over the case, Magistrates Mr. Roger James Mathias (Chairman), Mr. David Andrew Fawcett, and Mr. Max Shankland emphasised the severity of the crime, citing the premeditated targeting of high-value items and the organised nature of the theft. The court acknowledged Domnu’s guilty plea in determining the sentence.

Attending solicitor Mike Kelleher of Welch and Co represented Domnu during the proceedings. The court confirmed that the defendant is not currently in custody and no bail remand days were to be counted.

This case underscores the commitment of Dyfed Powys Police and the judiciary to address and penalise organised theft activities severely. The magistrates’ decision reflects the importance of deterring such crimes and ensuring justice for affected businesses.

Continue Reading

News1 day ago

Welsh Government ministers ‘economical with truth’ over Withyhedge

THE FIRST MINISTER couldn’t have been clearer. There was no room for misinterpreting his words. Andrew RT Davies, the leader...

Business1 day ago

Ascona Group announces rebranding of two west Wales sites

PEMBROKESHIRE-BASED Ascona Group has announced the rebranding of two of its Pembrokeshire service stations to the Valero brand. The rebranding...

News2 days ago

Puffin protection laws at centre of post Brexit row

The puffin, a beloved seabird and symbol of Pembrokeshire, is caught in a heated dispute over the UK’s post-Brexit fishing...

Crime2 days ago

Man sentenced to 16 weeks for theft from Pembroke Dock Boots

RAJ DOMNU, a 27-year-old resident of Scunthorpe, has been sentenced to 16 weeks in prison for his involvement in the...

Crime2 days ago

Milford woman ’caused significant life-changing injuries to motorcyclist’

A MILFORD HAVEN woman has appeared before magistrates charged with causing what the Crown has described as ‘significant, life changing...

Crime3 days ago

Pembrokeshire firefighter admits drink-driving

A COURT has told how a Pembrokeshire firefighter volunteer made ‘the biggest mistake of his life’ after driving at Canaston...

News3 days ago

As pressure builds, RML closes Withyhedge to fresh rubbish

THE WITHYHEDGE landfill site will be closed to all waste inputs, except engineering material, starting Wednesday, May 15. The company...

News3 days ago

Sian Batchelor: Police issue new appeal for information

Dyfed-Powys Police is continuing to investigate the circumstances surrounding the death of a woman. Sian Batchelor, aged 32, was found...

Charity5 days ago

Angle RNLI responds to four emergencies in two days

THE Angle RNLI lifeboat crew demonstrated remarkable dedication and skill in managing four separate emergency callouts over the span of...

News5 days ago

Cyclist dies during annual charity ride to Tenby

A TRAGIC incident occurred during the annual CARTEN100 charity bike ride when a 51-year-old cyclist died of a suspected cardiac...

Popular This Week