Politics
Wales ‘piggybacks’ on Westminster renters’ rights bill
SENEDD Members denounced the “ill-judged, regrettable and unacceptable” decision to “piggyback” on the UK renters’ rights bill but held their noses to vote for it nonetheless.
Mike Hedges, in his role as chair of the legislation committee, expressed concerns about the Senedd consenting to the UK Government making law in a devolved area.
He said the Welsh Government provided no clear rationale for “piggybacking” on a UK bill, adding that a bill tailored to Wales’ needs could have already become law by autumn 2024.
“This would have meant that the benefits of the legislation could have been felt sooner by citizens in Wales,” said the Labour Senedd Member.
“Moreover, the provisions could have been consulted on by Senedd committees and subject to more debate and scrutiny, with a view to producing better outcomes.”
The renters’ rights bill, described as the most significant change to the private rented sector in decades, amends two Senedd Acts – with little input from elected members in Cardiff Bay.
Mr Hedges warned: “The Senedd is in effect being provided with a fait accompli: vote in favour or risk losing important legislation on housing.
“This is even though the bill’s provisions for Wales have not been the subject of rigorous policy development, detailed scrutiny by members of the Senedd with knowledge of Welsh housing issues nor consultation with stakeholders.”
During a debate on a legislative consent motion on May 20, Mr Hedges criticised the lack of a formal Welsh Government consultation on a bill that creates new criminal offences.
He added: “In the committee’s view, the decision to pursue provisions for Wales in the UK Government’s bill on grounds of expediency was a miscalculation and ill-judged.”
The former Swansea Council chief pointed out that using a UK bill meant Welsh ministers could “avoid” the need to prepare relevant impact assessments.
Expressing the committee’s scepticism of claims the bill would have no financial implications, he said using UK bills has become a matter of convenience for the Welsh Government.
Mr Hedges concluded: “The approach…, which excludes the Senedd as a legislature and stakeholders in Wales, represents a regrettable and unwelcome approach to devolution.”
Wales’ housing minister Jayne Bryant responded: “Practically, we could not deliver within the timeframe of this bill without making sacrifices elsewhere.
“We could have looked to deliver a discrete bill but it would have been delivered further down the line and I’m not prepared to make tenants in Wales who are being discriminated against wait… and nor did I want to jeopardise other important legislation.”

Ms Bryant, who was appointed in July 2024, stressed the need to balance Senedd scrutiny against the need to deliver positive changes for Wales, “which I believe this bill offers”.
She pointed out that there was nothing to stop people or organisations in Wales responding to the UK Government’s consultation.
Her Labour colleague Alun Davies intervened: “This is essentially an argument to go back to the pre-2011, 1999 settlement, that there’s no need for Welsh consultation.”
The Blaenau Gwent Senedd Member said: “That is unacceptable, minister, I’m afraid. It’s absolutely unacceptable to speak to our parliament in that way.
“Members here have the absolute right to scrutinise legislation. It’s why we are elected here. It’s why the Welsh Government fought for and achieved a referendum on full primary powers and we should be afforded the opportunity to exercise those.”
But he said he would vote along party lines, prompting roars of laughter around the chamber.
Fellow Labour backbencher John Griffiths was disappointed a new right in the bill for tenants to request permission to keep pets would not extend to Wales.
Landlords in England would not be able to unreasonably withhold consent. “We would like to see Welsh tenants afforded the same rights,” said Mr Griffiths, the housing committee chair.
Laura Anne Jones, the Conservatives’ shadow housing secretary, opposed the bill due to concerns surrounding a potential ban on so-called no-fault evictions.

She said: “Scotland abolished no-fault evictions in 2017 and… there’s been increasing hostility… resulting in 22,000 rental properties being taken off the market last year.”
Senedd Members backed legislative consent for the bill, 37-14, with the Tories and Rhys ab Owen – who sits as an independent – voting against.
News
Police asked to investigate alleged ‘sabotage’ of Senedd candidate’s campaign
INDEPENDENT Senedd candidate Paul Haywood-Dowson has contacted Dyfed-Powys Police alleging that his election campaign was deliberately disrupted less than 24 hours before polling day.
In an email sent on Wednesday afternoon (May 6) to the force’s Electoral Fraud and Malpractice Single Point of Contact (SPOC), Mr Haywood-Dowson claimed a marketing contractor had taken possession of 4,000 election leaflets and then stopped responding to communications.
Mr Haywood-Dowson, who is standing in the Ceredigion Penfro constituency, alleged the actions amounted to “criminal sabotage of election material” under Section 115 of the Representation of the People Act 1983.
He wrote: “I am formally reporting a criminal interference in the election occurring right now.”
The candidate claimed a Liverpool-based contractor had collected the leaflets and accepted £252 in payment before allegedly failing to deliver or return them.
Mr Haywood-Dowson stated: “By taking physical possession of my flyers and refusing to deliver or return them 24 hours before the poll, he has used a ‘fraudulent device or contrivance’ to prevent the free exercise of the franchise by my potential voters.”
He further alleged: “This is not a delivery delay. It is Theft by Deception.”
The email requested a crime reference number and asked police to contact the contractor “immediately” to secure the return of the campaign material.
The Herald has contacted Dyfed-Powys Police and the contractor, who we are not naming at this stage, for comment.
News
Farage mocked over ‘London elections’ advert in Welsh newspaper
REFORM UK leader Nigel Farage has been criticised after a campaign advert urging people to vote in the “London elections” appeared in a Welsh newspaper read by voters in Powys.
Critics say advert shows Reform’s campaign is focused on London, not Wales
The two-page party political advert was published in the Powys County Times on Friday (May 1), just days before voters in Wales go to the polls in the Senedd election on Thursday (May 7).
The advert included a letter from Mr Farage in which he attacked London Mayor Sadiq Khan and claimed the capital had become “lawless” and “unrecognisable” under Labour.
But the message appeared to have been aimed at London voters, not those in Powys.
In the letter, Mr Farage wrote: “If you want to get rid of Keir Starmer and change the direction of this country, there is one way to do it: Vote Reform in the London elections on May 7th.”
He added: “London needs Reform. It is one of the world’s great capitals. Yet these days Sadiq Khan’s London often feels lawless and unrecognisable to Londoners who can no longer afford to live in their own city.”
The advert has since been seized on by rival parties, who say it raises questions about Reform UK’s focus on Wales during the Senedd campaign.
A Welsh Labour source said: “For Wales, see London. Reform UK’s focus isn’t on Wales, it’s on getting Farage into Number 10.
“They don’t even care enough to place the right advert in the right country. It’s all about promoting Farage as their front man and fooling voters into thinking they’ve got more than slogans.”
Voters in Wales will elect Members of the Senedd on Thursday, while a number of local council and mayoral elections are also taking place in England.
In London, all 32 boroughs are holding elections, with more than 1,800 councillors due to be elected.
The Welsh Liberal Democrats also criticised the advert.
Glyn Preston, the party’s lead candidate for Gwynedd Maldwyn, said: “Reform can’t even get the right election on their own leaflets. It says everything about how little they understand or care about Wales or Powys, and raises serious questions about their ability to run the country.
“While they’re busy talking about Sadiq Khan and London, the Liberal Democrats are focused on the issues that actually matter to people here in Powys — long NHS waiting times, rural communities, and securing a fair deal on investment from Cardiff Bay.
“Powys deserves representatives who are rooted in the communities they serve, who know and understand local challenges, not yes-men taking their lead from Nigel Farage in London in his latest quest for power.”
Reform UK has been running newspaper adverts across Wales in the run-up to the Senedd election.
The party has been polling strongly, with surveys suggesting it could make major gains under the new voting system.
Reform UK has not yet commented publicly on why a London-focused advert appeared in a Powys newspaper.
News
Plaid tells Carmarthenshire voters: ‘Only we can stop Reform’
PLAID CYMRU has urged voters in Sir Gaerfyrddin to back the party on Thursday, claiming it is the only party able to beat Reform UK in the new constituency.
The appeal comes after the latest ITV Cymru Wales, YouGov and Wales Governance Centre MRP poll suggested Plaid Cymru is on course to become the largest party in the Senedd, with Reform close behind. The poll put Plaid on 33% across Wales and Reform on 29%. (YouGov)
Sir Gaerfyrddin is one of the new Senedd constituencies being used for the first time in this election. It has been created from the Carmarthen and Llanelli Westminster seats and will elect six Members of the Senedd under the new closed-list system.
Plaid Cymru’s list in Sir Gaerfyrddin is led by Cefin Campbell, followed by Nerys Evans, Adam Price and Mari Arthur. (Who Can I Vote For?)
The party says the contest locally is now between Plaid Cymru and Reform UK, and has called on voters who want to stop Nigel Farage’s party from gaining ground in Carmarthenshire to “lend” Plaid their vote.
Nerys Evans said Plaid was offering “new leadership” and a “positive vision” for Wales, including childcare support, a National Development Agency to grow the economy, and a new numeracy and literacy scheme for children.
She said: “As the voters of Sir Gaerfyrddin head to the polls on Thursday, the choice could not be more stark.
“Only two parties can win here: Plaid Cymru, who offer new leadership, a positive vision, and which will be accountable only to the people of Wales; or Reform, which would divide our communities, threaten the future of our NHS, cut support for our culture and language and is controlled by Nigel Farage, billionaires, and ex-Tories in London.
“Support for Labour has disappeared in Carmarthenshire, with people unwilling to vote for a party that has let Wales down for over 27 years and in Westminster since Keir Starmer became Prime Minister.
“There is no evidence that the Greens or the Liberal Democrats will secure enough votes to come close to winning a seat.
“We ask anyone who wants to prevent a victory for Reform in Carmarthenshire to lend their vote to Plaid Cymru on Thursday.”
The Senedd election takes place on Thursday (May 7).
-
News24 hours agoBaby in critical condition after Fishguard emergency
-
Crime5 hours agoMilford motorist disqualified for drug-driving
-
Crime5 hours agoJob loss threat for convicted Pembrokeshire drug-driver
-
Community6 days agoDogs removed after welfare concerns at Milford Haven property
-
Business7 days agoHandcrafted garden furniture built to last across Pembrokeshire
-
Charity7 days agoRow erupts at Spitfire museum after Reform poster displayed at charity premises
-
Community7 days agoCancer patients targeted with parking fines outside Haverfordwest support centre
-
Crime21 hours agoFarming company fined £19,000 for damaging protected wildlife site









