Connect with us
Advertisement
Advertisement

News

Audit Committee to see key correspondence

Published

on

Evil?: Cllr Mike Stoddart

Cllr Mike Stoddart

FOLLOWING a lengthy – and at times angry – debate, councillors voted to pass a motion from Cllr Mike Stoddart to allow the audit committee to have access to documents relating to the controversial Commercial Property Grants Scheme in Pembroke Dock. Cllr Stoddart’s original motion asked for all councillors to have access to correspondence between the authority and WEFO and Mr Cathal McCosker but he amended the motion so that Audit Committee members alone could have access. Many councillors in the chamber felt they should all have access to the information in order to make a proper decision. Cllr Stoddart said: “This is a matter of some importance because public money is at stake here.

“Mr McCosker has offered to pay back a rather large sum of money – £189,000 is the figure I’ve been given. “There is also a sum of money that this council has got to pay back in respect of administrative payments that WEFO have made to this council. “The audit committee have a duty to look into this to see just how much this is going to cost the council, that’s what the audit committee was set up for.

“I am not talking about the police disclosing information; this is about the council disclosing information that is already in its possession. I’m not asking for the police to disclose it. He added: “Suggesting otherwise is another red herring being dragged across the floor.” Cllr Bob Kilmister said: “This is very important information for the debate and we need to see it, but once again members are being asked to debate without seeing any of the information that is required.”

Cllr Jamie Adams said: “Any information will be made available to members on conclusion of the police investigation and we have a process in following that investigation and I believe it’s very important that we recognise effectively the polity that should remain around any evidence that should remain following legal proceedings from that situation. “Members will have full information but as a body of council we must recognise that there is a time limit on it in terms of when that information is appropriate. “It may be appropriate for the audit committee to consider that advice, but I would suggest that it’s not really the function of full council to undertake that, and I am confident in the ability and the desire that is held within audit committee to get to the bottom of these matters with the assistance of the police. “Now is not the time for us as members to discuss the matter.”

Cllr Jacob Williams said: “How times have changed! At our Christmas meeting in 2013, Cllr Stoddart put forward a very similar motion and Cllr Pugh gave a number of facts, and subsequently it was revealed he wasn’t telling the whole truth and he has since been sacked from the Cabinet. “At that stage everybody was in denial in the IPPG group and a vote was taken, but that vote was taken on duff information. “Everything Cllr Stoddart has said about the grant scheme has proved to be correct.

The police investigation is ongoing – I don’t know what stage it is at, but isn’t that a long way we’ve come? Information was denied and it’s still being denied now. “One thing remains constant, and that is the ethos of this county which is to keep elected members in the dark. “Cllr Pugh denied there was a problem but now there is going to be a loss to the authority and I think you should all know about that.” Cllr Paul Miller said: “Clearly we are responsible for the budget. There is a financial issue in terms of a loss or a reclaim and we need to understand that.

That is part of our core remit as members, and this information is key to understanding that. I don’t how we can be in a position when we are not given the information.” Cllr John Allen-Mirehouse said: “The committee was requested by the police not to divulge the information which the police are using during the investigation. The legality of this was confirmed to the committee by the acting head of paid service. Assurance was given that in due course, at the conclusion of the police investigation the documentation would be made available to all members of this council. It is no good listening to what people think, we need evidence.”

Retired senior police officer Cllr Tony Brinsden said: “I’m rather concerned that so many red herrings are being dropped across the floor in front of us. I’m surprised that our leader had to go to council to find out that simple fact.” Cllr Mike Evans said: “This is information that is with the council, this is what we are debating.” Indicating the advice given by officers, he continued: “We open up this advice here and the first line says: ‘In this case I have been asked to advise upon a request by councillors who have access to information obtained by the police. This is not the case.

“How much has this one question cost us? What is the point of asking a question about information in the possession of the police? We all know that we have no right to see their documents. Cllr Bob Summons, a former police constable for over thirty years, said: “An email came in yesterday from the sergeant who is running the investigation. It says: ‘As discussed the police investigation has commenced and as part of the investigation team it is important that we have all material in relation to this matter.”

He continued, quoting the email: “Until any trial it is good practice for all materials to be classed as confidential. I am aware that information is available within Pembrokeshire County Council, which councillors have asked to be disclosed to them. “I would recommend at this stage of the enquiry that this material is not disclosed upon this request.” Councillors were not deflected from their pursuit of the matter by the red herrings offered in response to Councillor Stoddart’s motion: it was passed by 28 votes to 24 with four councillors (Mike Evans, Brian Hall, Stan Hudson and Steve Joseph) abstaining.

 

1 Comment

1 Comment

  1. Tomos

    December 30, 2014 at 10:54 pm

    used to be an accountant and I’d have thought any decent company IF they’d been overpaid would have refunded the money without auditors, police etc getting involved – If I’ve overpaid british gas they’d let me know – why didn’t mccosker?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Education

Final closure decision set for Clydau and Manorbier schools after earlier vote

Published

on

Extraordinary council meeting will consider objections before final ruling

THE FUTURE of two Pembrokeshire schools will be decided in June, despite councillors already backing plans in principle to close them.

Pembrokeshire County Council has confirmed that an extraordinary Full Council meeting will take place on Monday (June 15) to consider objection reports relating to the proposed discontinuation of Ysgol Clydau and Manorbier Church in Wales VC School.

The meeting represents the final stage in the statutory process, where councillors will decide whether to proceed with closure after reviewing formal objections.

The Herald understands that the extraordinary session has been called because the timetable for the proposals does not align with regular council meeting dates.

Last chance to overturn decision

Although councillors have already voted in favour of closure in principle, the June meeting is not a formality.

Campaigners still have a narrow window to influence the outcome, with councillors able to change their position after considering objections and any new evidence.

In rare cases, proposals have been halted or reversed at this final stage — particularly where strong community opposition or concerns over the accuracy of data have been raised.

However, the earlier vote means the schools remain at significant risk, with the council having already indicated its preferred direction.

Political pressure building

The confirmation comes amid growing community concern and a mounting campaign to save Ysgol Clydau.

Campaign group Save Ysgol Clydau – Cadw Clydau yn Gadarn has described the situation as a “critical moment,” urging residents to challenge political parties ahead of the upcoming elections.

Supporters argue that the future of the school is closely tied to the survival of rural communities and the Welsh language.

The group has also thanked councillors — particularly members of the Independent group — for their support.

Decision looming

The June 15 meeting is expected to draw significant public attention, with strong attendance likely as councillors prepare to make a final, legally binding decision.

If approved, the proposal would result in the closure of both schools.

 

Continue Reading

News

Kurtz calls for urgent fuel duty freeze and support for off-grid homes

Published

on

SAMUEL KURTZ MS has called on the UK Government to take immediate action to ease mounting cost-of-living pressures, warning that families across west Wales are being “squeezed from all sides” by rising fuel and energy costs.

Writing to Chancellor Rachel Reeves, the Carmarthen West and South Pembrokeshire Senedd Member urged ministers to cancel planned fuel duty increases and introduce fairer, more effective support for rural households living off the gas grid.

Energy bills are forecast to rise to nearly £2,000 from July, while persistently high global oil prices continue to drive up costs at the pumps. Diesel prices have surged in recent months, with petrol also climbing—adding further strain to already stretched household budgets.

Kurtz warned that any increase in fuel duty later this year would hit rural communities hardest, where reliance on cars is unavoidable due to limited public transport.

In parts of west Wales, the challenges are even more acute. In Ceredigion, up to three quarters of households are not connected to the gas grid, while in Pembrokeshire around 40% rely on alternative fuels such as heating oil and LPG. Unlike mains gas users, these households are not protected by energy price caps and remain exposed to volatile global markets.

He also criticised existing support measures, describing them as “limited and reactive,” often only available once households reach crisis point. While recent funding announcements for off-grid households have been welcomed, concerns remain over delays and a lack of clarity around how the support will be delivered.

Kurtz pointed to the UK Government’s response during the 2022 energy crisis, which included the Energy Price Guarantee, £400 bill support, and a £200 Alternative Fuel Payment for off-grid homes.

He said: “Households across west Wales are under real pressure, and for many this is not about cutting back—it’s about keeping up.

“Rural families already face higher costs, whether that’s heating their homes or filling up the car. Increasing fuel duty now would only make that worse.

“Off-grid households are being overlooked. They don’t benefit from price caps and are exposed to volatile fuel costs.

“The UK Government acted decisively during the last energy crisis. The same level of urgency is needed again now.

“The Chancellor must act—cancel the planned fuel duty increases and reintroduce the £200 Alternative Fuel Payment to give households the support they need.”

He warned that without swift intervention, rural communities risk being left further behind as cost pressures continue to rise.

 

Continue Reading

News

Labour promises 48-hour GP access as manifesto faces questions over delivery

Published

on

WELSH Labour leader Eluned Morgan has pledged that patients with urgent health concerns will be seen within 48 hours, as the party launched its manifesto ahead of the 2026 Senedd election.

Speaking at an event in Swansea on Monday (Mar 30), Morgan said a re-elected Welsh Labour Government would guarantee access to a GP or other primary healthcare professional on the same day or the following day for pressing issues.

She said: “If you are worried about your child, if your elderly parent needs help, or if something does not feel right, you should be able to get help quickly – not weeks later.”

The pledge forms a central part of Labour’s health offer, alongside plans for same-day, open-access mental health services and a £4bn “Hospitals of the Future” investment programme.

Pressure on delivery

However, the announcement has already prompted questions about how the target would be delivered, given ongoing pressures across NHS Wales.

Latest figures show around 757,000 patient pathways remain on waiting lists, with approximately 38,000 people waiting more than a year for treatment. Previous Welsh Government targets to reduce long waits have also been missed.

The 48-hour target itself is less ambitious than proposals in England, where a 24-hour access standard has been discussed. Morgan has said the Welsh target reflects what is “realistic” given current pressures.

Critics argue the pledge risks repeating a familiar pattern of commitments that prove difficult to deliver in practice.

‘Plans to have plans’

Beyond health, scrutiny of the manifesto has focused on what some commentators have described as a lack of urgency in key policy areas.

Several flagship commitments involve future strategies or reviews, including a promise to publish a new industrial strategy within the first year of the next Senedd term, and proposals to “explore” ways to reduce teacher workload.

Opponents have characterised this approach as “plans to have plans”, questioning whether it reflects the scale of challenges facing Wales in areas such as healthcare, housing and education.

The First Minister has defended the approach, arguing that detailed proposals are set out across the manifesto and that flexibility is needed to respond to changing economic conditions.

Health investment under scrutiny

Labour’s £4bn pledge for new hospitals and infrastructure has also come under examination.

The party says the funding will support major developments, including replacing University Hospital Wales and Wrexham Maelor Hospital, as well as improvements in West Wales.

However, questions remain about whether the funding would be sufficient to cover large-scale rebuilds while also addressing existing maintenance backlogs across the NHS estate.

Morgan said the figure was based on previous capital projects and insisted the funding plans were “realistic”.

Cost-of-living commitments

Alongside its health pledges, Welsh Labour has committed not to raise Welsh rates of income tax during the next Senedd term.

The manifesto also includes a £2 cap on single bus fares, continued discounted travel for young people, free travel for over-60s, and plans to create 20,000 new childcare places.

Labour says the package is designed to ease cost-of-living pressures while supporting economic growth.

A ‘new chapter’ or more of the same?

At the launch, Morgan described the manifesto as the start of a “new chapter” for Wales, signalling a shift from what Labour describes as a period of “protection” through austerity, Brexit and the pandemic, towards a focus on growth and opportunity.

But with Welsh Labour having been in power for more than two decades, opponents argue the party faces a challenge in convincing voters that change will come from the same administration.

While the manifesto contains a range of policy commitments across health, the economy and the environment, the central question is likely to remain whether voters believe the pledges can be delivered.

As the campaign for the May 2026 Senedd election gathers pace, that question is set to dominate the political debate in Wales.

 

Continue Reading

News17 hours ago

Plaid Cymru launches bid to lead next Welsh Government

Party positions itself as ‘government-in-waiting’ ahead of May election PLAID CYMRU has formally launched its campaign for the 2026 Senedd...

Crime18 hours ago

Police appeal after attempted child abduction in Haverfordwest

DYFED-POWYS POLICE has launched an appeal for witnesses following a reported attempted abduction of a 12-year-old girl in Haverfordwest. The...

Crime2 days ago

Gunshot fired by police during incident in Milford Haven

A POLICE officer discharged a firearm during an incident in Milford Haven on Saturday evening (March 28), prompting an investigation...

Community3 days ago

Three Amigos Easter Run roars through Pembrokeshire

MOTORCYCLE enthusiasts turned out in force today (Saturday, March 28) as the popular Three Amigos Easter Run returned to the...

Education4 days ago

Ysgol Henry Tudor reassures parents over Sikh ceremonial kirpan

School says religious item worn by pupil is secured, symbolic and non-functional YSGOL HENRY TUDOR has moved to reassure parents...

Crime5 days ago

Teen jailed after starting fire while others slept

Fire set in shared home left sleeping residents at risk and caused £130,000 damage A TEENAGER who started a fire...

Health5 days ago

GP crisis driving NHS pressure in Wales, Senedd report warns

Falling GP numbers and funding gaps blamed for worsening hospital delays THE NHS crisis highlighted earlier this week is being...

News6 days ago

Reform reveals west Wales candidates for Senedd battle

Monkton councillor tops Pembrokeshire list as party confirms Carmarthenshire names and includes Haverfordwest councillor in unwinnable Swansea spot REFORM UK...

Health6 days ago

Clash over Withybush Hospital services as Paul Davies challenges First Minister

A HEATED exchange in the Senedd has laid bare growing tensions over the future of hospital services in west Wales....

Crime7 days ago

Police stop car in Pennar as three arrested in drugs investigation

Suspected drug driver report leads to major police response and multiple arrests DRAMATIC scenes were reported in Pennar on Monday...

Popular This Week