Connect with us
Advertisement
Advertisement

Politics

Wales’ top lawyer backs ban on ex-politicians judging old colleagues

Published

on

FORMER Senedd Members should be permanently banned from judging the conduct of old colleagues, Wales’ top lawyer has suggested – contradicting plans in a new recall bill.

The recall bill includes a two-year cooling-off period before former Senedd politicians can become “lay” members of a committee which recommends sanctions for misbehaviour.

But Julie James, who is counsel general, the Welsh Government’s chief legal adviser, argued the disqualification should be for life to overcome public cynicism.

She made the comments on Monday November 17 while giving evidence on plans to introduce a system of recall, which would allow voters to remove politicians between elections.

Under the bill, for the first time, lay members would be appointed to the Senedd’s standards of conduct committee but – unlike in other parliaments – this could include former members.

Douglas Bain, the standards commissioner who investigates complaints about Senedd Members, has warned two years is too short and called for a four-year ban.

But Ms James went further, telling the legislation committee former Senedd politicians should not be able to sit as lay members in judgement of their old colleagues at all.

She told Senedd Members: “For what it’s worth, as a personal thing, not speaking as the counsel general, I think it should be a permanent disqualification.

“I think you would be permanently thought of as being in whatever camp you’d been in when you were elected – and that’s just a personal view, it’s not a government view.

“But, I can see, if you’re trying to overcome cynicism and so on, the idea that that person is now non-aligned and independent is difficult.”

Asked about the rationale for including the proposed two-year cooling-off period in the bill, the former solicitor told Senedd Members: “I mean it’s a place to start if I’m honest.”

She said the two-year prohibition aligns with the qualification requirements for the standards commissioner as well as rules on ministers taking jobs after politics.

Adam Price, the former Plaid Cymru leader, warned: “The degree of perceived conflict of interest here is possibly even greater because you’re being appointed not just to any external organisation but to the sub-committee of an institution you were a member of.”

Plaid Cymru MS Adam Price
Plaid Cymru MS Adam Price

Ms James concluded: “If you’ve been an elected member of the Senedd, you shouldn’t be allowed to be a lay member of one of its committees because, frankly, I don’t think you’d ever be regarded as ‘lay’ by anyone.”

She stressed ministers are walking a fine constitutional line – seeking to establish a legal framework without dictating internal rules to the Senedd – and she suggested the Welsh Government was open to amendments.

She said: “We felt very strongly that we shouldn’t start from the point of view of the government telling the [Senedd] commission how to conduct its business.”

Labour MS Alun Davies
Labour MS Alun Davies

Alun Davies, a Labour member of the legislation committee, raised concerns about plans to create election-related offences, including around false or misleading statements of fact.

Mr Davies warned the can was being kicked down the road, saying: “We’re being asked here to put on the statute book a duty to create an offence which itself isn’t defined.

He added: “But that feels like an extraordinarily unsatisfactory way of making law… It does not feel like we’re creating a serious piece of law here.”

Ms James told her colleague: “It’s for the next government and the parliamentary authorities to define that offence, yes.”

Mr Davies said: “You’re going to wish your successors well with this, I trust,” drawing a laugh from the counsel general.

Senedd Members heard an existing criminal offence on false statements during elections would be widened beyond a narrow focus on the character or conduct of another candidate.

But Ms James highlighted the need to “insulate” a bill “right on the edge” of devolved powers, saying: “We need to make sure we don’t push it so far that the whole thing fails.”

She warned the final vote on the bill would fall on the last government sitting day of term, with royal assent before dissolution on April 8 but after the Senedd rises at Easter.

She said the tight timetable means the bill would instantly fail if the UK Government was to refer the question of whether it is within the Senedd’s powers to the Supreme Court.

The counsel general told the committee: “We’re very keen that that doesn’t happen so we are perhaps being hyper-cautious about it.”

 

News

Palestine pledge signed by 115 Senedd candidates

Published

on

MORE than 100 candidates standing in next week’s Senedd election have signed a pledge in support of Palestinian rights, including backing calls for boycott, divestment and sanctions against Israel.

Palestine Solidarity Campaign Cymru said 115 candidates had signed its “Senedd Palestine Pledge” so far.

The signatories include 46 Green candidates, 37 Plaid Cymru candidates, eight Liberal Democrats, six Labour candidates and five independents.

The pledge commits candidates, if elected, to “take all appropriate steps” to uphold the rights of the Palestinian people, oppose what PSC describes as Israel’s crimes of genocide and apartheid, and ensure the Welsh Government is not complicit, including through support for the Palestinian-led call for boycott, divestment and sanctions.

Prominent candidates listed by the campaign include Wales Green Party leader Anthony Slaughter, former Senedd Members Mike Hedges, Sioned Williams, Llyr Gruffydd, Sian Gwenllian and Heledd Fychan, former MP Beth Winter, and Rob Griffiths of the Communist Party of Britain.

PSC Cymru said the pledge was particularly relevant under the new closed proportional list system, where voters choose parties or independent candidates rather than individual party candidates.

According to the campaign, the pledge has been signed by two Labour, three Liberal Democrat, ten Plaid Cymru and 12 Green first-placed candidates.

The organisation said the issue had direct relevance to the Senedd because of concerns previously raised over Welsh Government funding linked to companies involved in the F-35 fighter jet supply chain.

Bethan Sayed, co-chair of Palestine Solidarity Campaign Cymru, said: “Reaching 100 pledges is a milestone. It is a clear message that Palestine is on the ballot in this Senedd election.

“Wales has always aspired to be a nation that stands on the right side of history, a globally responsible nation that holds human rights and international law at its heart. These 100-plus candidates are giving real meaning to that aspiration.

“Support for Palestinian rights stretches across every community and every constituency in Wales. Polls show public backing for this issue. Voters will be watching closely to see who has the conviction to stand with them.

“To those candidates who have not yet signed: the time to act is now. This is a test of moral leadership. We urge every remaining candidate to sign the pledge before polling day.”

 

Continue Reading

News

Welsh Conservatives pledge to raise school standards in Wales

Published

on

THE WELSH CONSERVATIVES have set out plans to raise standards in education, warning that too many children are being let down by underperformance, poor discipline and funding pressures.

The party says Wales continues to lag behind other parts of the UK in international education rankings, despite the Welsh Government receiving higher levels of funding per head than England.

Leader Darren Millar said a Welsh Conservative Government would increase funding for schools, restore discipline in classrooms and place a renewed focus on academic and vocational achievement.

He said: “After 27 years of Labour, propped up by Plaid Cymru, our education system is failing too many young people.

“Standards have slipped, discipline has broken down and outcomes are simply not good enough.

“The Welsh Conservatives have a clear plan to turn this around. We will restore discipline in our classrooms, back our teachers and bring back academic rigour.

“We will ensure that every child has the opportunity to succeed and reach their full potential.”

The party says its education plan would also strengthen routes into further and higher education, with a focus on helping young people build their futures in Wales.

Welsh Conservative education spokesperson Natasha Asghar said: “Every child in Wales deserves a world-class education, but after 27 years of Labour, propped up by Plaid Cymru, too many are being let down by a system that is underperforming and undervalued.

“We will raise standards, support our teachers and ensure schools are properly resourced, while strengthening opportunities in further and higher education so young people can thrive and build their futures here in Wales.”

 

Continue Reading

News

Next Welsh Government urged to put worker safety at heart of policy

Published

on

HEALTH and safety professionals are calling on the next Welsh Government to make worker safety, health and wellbeing a central priority after the 2026 Senedd election.

The Institution of Occupational Safety and Health (IOSH) has published its priorities for the next Senedd term, warning that preventable workplace harm continues to damage lives, communities and the Welsh economy.

IOSH says that while health and safety law is largely reserved to Westminster, decisions made in Wales still have a major impact on worker protection.

These include policies on public health, education and skills, rural affairs, construction, housing and public procurement.

Figures highlighted by IOSH show that Wales continues to experience high levels of work-related ill health, with tens of thousands of new cases each year.

The organisation also says workplace fatality rates in Wales remain consistently above the Great Britain average, standing at 0.69 per 100,000 workers in 2024-25 compared with 0.37 across Great Britain.

Ruth Wilkinson, Head of Policy and Public Affairs at IOSH, said: “Too many people in Wales are still being harmed by work — whether through fatal injuries, long-term ill health, or through the hidden impact of work-related stress and poor mental health.

“These harms are not inevitable. In many cases, they are entirely preventable.

“Health and safety isn’t a barrier to growth. It’s a foundation for good work, strong communities and a resilient Welsh economy.

“We want the next Welsh Government to use the powers it has — across skills, health, rural policy and public procurement — to put prevention and worker wellbeing at the heart of working life.

“If action is taken now, Wales has a real opportunity to lead the way in protecting workers while building a fairer and more sustainable future.”

IOSH members in Wales have identified five key priorities for the next Senedd term.

These are stronger asbestos management, improved safety in rural industries, investment in health and safety skills and training, better safety performance in construction, and action on workplace mental health.

The organisation is calling for a national asbestos register for public buildings, including schools, hospitals and other parts of the public estate.

It also wants health and safety embedded into rural policy, with targeted farm safety programmes and better mental health support for rural workers.

IOSH is urging the next Welsh Government to strengthen safety education and skills through the Curriculum for Wales, apprenticeships and lifelong learning.

It also wants public investment and procurement used to raise construction safety standards, with safe construction treated as a mark of quality.

On mental health, IOSH says Wales should use the Well-being of Future Generations framework to drive prevention, accountability and leadership in the workplace.

The organisation says small and medium-sized businesses also need practical support, including access to training, guidance and occupational health advice.

IOSH warned that without stronger preventative action, Wales will continue to see avoidable injuries, ill health and deaths, as well as lost skills, reduced productivity and extra pressure on public services.

Ruth Wilkinson added: “Safe, healthy work is not optional. It’s essential to Wales’s future prosperity — and IOSH and health and safety professionals stand ready to work with the next Welsh Government to make that vision a reality.”

 

Continue Reading

Community1 hour ago

Scooter rally brings colour and nostalgia to Tenby

TENBY is buzzing with the sights and sounds of classic scooters this Bank Holiday weekend as the Welsh National Scooter...

Entertainment1 hour ago

Haverfoodfest returns to Haverfordwest town centre today

HAVERFORDWEST town centre is expected to be busy today as Haverfoodfest 2026 returns for a full day of food, drink,...

Crime24 hours ago

70-year-old denies assault and restraining order breach

A PENSIONER from Pembroke Dock has denied breaching a restraining order and assaulting another man. Henry Howlett, 70, of Market...

News2 days ago

Conservatives target two seats in new Ceredigion Penfro constituency

Paul Davies and Sam Kurtz say health, farming and transport are key as they seek return to the Senedd CONSERVATIVE...

Community2 days ago

Milford Haven Beer Fest returns to waterfront this May

EVENT WILL FEATURE 34 DRINKS, LIVE MUSIC AND STREET FOOD MILFORD HAVEN is preparing to raise a glass as Beer...

Community3 days ago

Cancer patients targeted with parking fines outside Haverfordwest support centre

Adam’s Bucketful of Hope says vulnerable users, elderly volunteers and charity drivers have paid more than £1,000 after Ateb introduced...

Charity3 days ago

Row erupts at Spitfire museum after Reform poster displayed at charity premises

A HAVERFORDWEST museum has become caught up in a political row after Reform UK campaign material was photographed inside the...

Crime3 days ago

Pembrokeshire man charged with making hundreds of indecent images of children

A PEMBROKESHIRE man has appeared before magistrates charged with making hundreds of indecent images of children. David Lewis, 42, is...

Crime4 days ago

Man appears in court charged over death of Blood Bike Wales volunteer

FAMILY WATCHED FROM PUBLIC GALLERY AS CASE SENT TO CROWN COURT A PEMBROKESHIRE man has appeared before magistrates charged with...

Crime4 days ago

Police launch arson investigation after Haverfordwest fire

CCTV APPEAL ISSUED POLICE have launched an arson investigation after a derelict building was destroyed in a major overnight fire...

Popular This Week