Crime
Taylor wins appeal as Crown Court quashes ‘no insurance’ conviction
Judge rules expired licence does not invalidate insurance where driver is not disqualified
A HAKIN man has successfully overturned his conviction for driving without insurance in a case that could have wider implications for thousands of motorists.
Seventy-six-year-old Niall Taylor, of Haven Drive, won his appeal at Swansea Crown Court on Thursday (Mar 27), after the court ruled there was no case to answer on the insurance charge.
The court found that Taylor was insured in law at the time he was stopped, despite his driving licence having expired.
This is understood to be a landmark ruling on a point of law, directly addressing a long-standing assumption used in policing and prosecutions — that a driver whose licence has expired is automatically uninsured. The judgment provides rare clarification on how standard insurance wording should be interpreted in such cases, and may influence how similar prosecutions are handled in the future.
Key issue: licence expired but not disqualified
The case centred on an incident on January 18, 2023, when Taylor was stopped by police while driving a Vauxhall Zafira in Haverfordwest.
It was accepted that his driving licence had expired in November 2022 and had not yet been renewed, and Taylor did not challenge his conviction for driving otherwise than in accordance with a licence.
However, the appeal focused solely on whether he was also uninsured.
Certificate wording decisive
The court heard that Taylor held a valid insurance policy covering the date in question.
Crucially, the certificate of motor insurance stated that cover applied where the driver:
“holds a licence to drive the vehicle or has held and is not disqualified or prohibited by law from holding or obtaining such a licence.”
The court found that Taylor met this definition, as he had previously held a licence and was not disqualified or prohibited from obtaining one.
Judge relies on leading legal text
In a detailed ruling, the judge referred to Wilkinson’s Road Traffic Offences (32nd Edition), a leading legal authority, which states that policies using this wording commonly cover drivers even where a licence has expired.
The court also considered the case of Adams v Dunne (1978), which established that an insurance policy remains valid unless and until it is formally avoided.
The judge said that, in law, such policies remain effective even if they may later be considered “voidable” rather than void.
Prosecution evidence ‘insufficient’
The Crown had relied on evidence from an insurance company investigator, who said the policy might have been cancelled had the company known about the licence issue.
However, the court found this evidence did not establish that the policy was invalid at the time.
The judge noted that:
- the insurer had confirmed a policy existed,
- no full policy document had been produced, and
- the certificate itself clearly set out the relevant terms.
He concluded that the prosecution had failed to prove that no valid insurance was in force.
Conviction quashed
Allowing the submission of no case to answer, the court ruled:
“We are satisfied that Mr Taylor did indeed have a certificate of motor insurance… which covered him to drive on the 18th of January 2023.”
The judge added that the prosecution evidence, taken at its highest, was not sufficient to justify a conviction.
Taylor’s conviction for driving without insurance was therefore quashed.
Wider implications
The ruling raises important questions about how insurance policies operate where a driving licence has expired — an issue affecting many motorists, particularly those over 70 who must renew their licences regularly.
The court’s interpretation suggests that, where a policy uses standard wording covering drivers who have previously held a licence and are not disqualified, insurance may still be valid despite administrative lapses.
Taylor’s separate conviction for driving otherwise than in accordance with a licence remains in place and was not part of the appeal.
He was asked to write to the court if he wanted to claim travelling expenses to cover the cost of transport for numerous times he has been to court regarding this matter.
Crime
Teenager banned from roads after being caught six times over drug-drive limit
A DOCK teenager has lost his licence after driving his vehicle on the Cleddau Bridge when he was six times over the legal drug-drive limit.
Gethin Moseley, 19, was stopped by officers carrying out random traffic checks on the bridge on January 24. Smelling cannabis emanating from his Mazda, a roadside drugs swipe was carried out which proved positive Subsequent blood tests showed that Moseley had 14 mcg of Delta-9 tetrahydrocannabinol in his system, the legal limit being 2.
Moseley, of Milton Terrace, Pembroke Dock, pleaded guilty to drug-driving when he appeared before Haverfordwest magistrates this week. He was represented in court by solicitor Jess Hill who informed the Bench that the defendant only uses cannabis recreationally or socially. He has no previous convictions.
Moseley was fined £249 and ordered to pay a £100 court surcharge and £85 costs. He was disqualified from driving for 12 months.
Crime
Drunk motorist arrested at Pembrokeshire petrol station
A Johnston motorist has appeared before magistrates after being caught driving when he was almost twice the legal drink-drive limit.
Police received a call at around 11am on April 23 from a member of the public concerned that local resident Martin Phelps, 55, was driving after consuming alcohol.
“He was at the petrol station and the member of the public was concerned that he was drunk,” Crown Prosecutor Sian Vaughan told Haverfordwest magistrates this week.
“When they arrived, they could see he was unsteady on his feet and had trouble getting into his parked vehicle.”
When spoken to by the officers, Phelps admitted drinking alcohol earlier that morning. Subsequent breathalyser tests carried out at the police station, showed that Phelps had 68 mcg of alcohol in his system, the legal limit being 35.
Phelps, of Langford Road, Johnston, pleaded guilty to drink-driving and was represented in court by solicitor Jess Hill.
“He’s had a troublesome relationship with alcohol which has increased over the years,” she told the court.
“He’s engaged with the Dyfed Drugs and Alcohol Advisory Service and Alcoholics Anonymous over the years, and this incident has been a wake up call for him.”
Phelps was disqualified from driving for 17 months and fined £120. He must also pay £85 court costs and a £48 surcharge. He was disqualified form driving for 17 months.
Crime
Violent man jailed after ‘Banksy’ claims and campaign of domestic abuse
A PEMBROKESHIRE woman told a court she wished her former partner had killed her after enduring a campaign of violence and coercive control by a man who claimed to be Banksy.
Patrick Smyth, 49, of Oaks Avenue, Romford, was sentenced at Swansea Crown Court on Wednesday to 22 months in custody after admitting coercive and controlling behaviour and two counts of assault occasioning actual bodily harm.
Swansea Crown Court heard that Smyth met the woman while on holiday in Tunisia in 2024 and later travelled from Essex to visit her in Haverfordwest.
Thomas Scapens KC, prosecuting, said Smyth quickly began mentally and physically abusing her. He checked her phone, isolated her from friends and family, and installed a phone tracking app which he controlled under the username “Powerful 666”.
He also claimed he was Banksy, the world-famous street artist, telling the victim he was powerful, wealthy and well connected.
“He copied Banksy’s signature and presented it to her, and she believed everything he told her,” Mr Scapens said.
The court heard that Smyth’s abuse escalated during a trip to Cardiff in July 2025, when the couple attended a concert. Smyth lost his temper and had to be removed by security.
Later, at the Coal Exchange hotel, he locked the victim in a room and placed a chair under the door handle to stop her leaving.
“He beat her continuously,” said Mr Scapens. “He put his hand around her throat to prevent her breathing.”
Hotel staff heard him calling her a “slag” and later saw reddening to her neck. They moved the woman to another room for her safety, but Smyth repeatedly tried to force his way inside, banging on the door and shouting.
Staff contacted the woman’s son, who worked in Cardiff. When he arrived, he became emotional after seeing her condition.
In September 2025, Smyth threw the woman into a wardrobe, fracturing two of her ribs. The following month, despite being on bail with a condition not to contact her, he turned up at her home.
“He pushed past her, tied her to a chair in the kitchen and turned off the lights,” said Mr Scapens.
The court heard Smyth refused to let her use the toilet and told her men were coming from London to put her in a pre-dug grave.
The final incident happened in October after the couple visited Morrisons in Haverfordwest. Smyth became aggressive in the store and threw shopping items at the victim. Concerned staff asked a security guard to shadow them.
During the taxi journey home, Smyth threatened to break the woman’s legs and punch her. When the taxi driver intervened, Smyth threatened to break his legs too.
Later that evening, a 999 call was made. No one spoke, but officers could hear a woman screaming and a man’s voice in the background.
When police arrived, they found the victim with cuts to her head. She was extremely upset and tried to hide her face in her roll-neck jumper.
When asked what had happened, she said: “I would in a heartbeat, but I can’t.” The court heard this was because Smyth was listening outside.
In a victim impact statement read to Judge Catherine Richards, the woman said her life had been “fundamentally scarred”.
“I hid my injuries away from other family members because I was scared,” she said.
“I’m scared to go out in case Patrick is there. I don’t treat life the same way anymore and I don’t leave the house by myself.
“It got to the point where I wish Patrick had killed me because I’d prefer to be dead. I’ll never be the same again.”
Smyth appeared by video link from prison, where he had been remanded since his arrest.
His barrister said he “wishes no bad will on the victim” and had reflected on his behaviour.
“He wishes to apologise,” she said. “He has no intention of making any further form of contact with her. Custody has acted as a wake-up call.”
Sentencing Smyth to 22 months in custody, Judge Richards said half would be served in prison and the remainder on licence.
-
Crime11 hours agoMan threatens to torch Silverdale Lodge through ‘demon drink’, court hears
-
Crime6 days agoRacial abuse suspect barricaded himself inside Johnston lodge
-
Local Government6 days agoTenant says botched wetroom repair left her fearing flooding
-
Crime6 days agoMilford Haven woman denies causing suffering to cat
-
Crime8 hours agoMan sentenced for stalking women and threatening to torch home
-
Crime4 days agoPolice standoff ends after four-hour incident in Pembroke Dock
-
Local Government2 days agoCouncil leadership hopeful responds after anti-Tory rally photos surface
-
Entertainment6 days agoLlys-y-frân Lake to launch Wales’s largest inflatable aqua park







