Connect with us
Advertisement
Advertisement

News

Motive behind tragic suicide ‘remains unclear’, says Coroner

Published

on

Unit where Laura Hill had been treated

Unit where Laura Hill had been treated

THE REASON why 21-year-old Laura Hill took her own life ‘remains unclear’, the deputy coroner for Pembrokeshire has ruled. 

The body of Laura Hill, 21, from Neyland, was found by members of the public on 17 December, 2012.

At the inquest on Friday (Feb 20), Deputy Coroner Gareth Lewis said: “Miss Hill suspended herself from the branch of a tree in a wooden area near to Withybush Hospital, but the question of intent remains unclear”.

Tragic : Laura Hill

Tragic : Laura Hill

Earlier in 2012, Miss Hill, who was from Neyland, had suffered the loss of her baby son and she had struggled to come to terms with this.

She had been admitted to Withybush Hospital on December 11, after taking an overdose of prescription tablets and she was later transferred to Bro Cerwyn Hospital.

However, on the night of December 16, Laura absconded and she was found hanged the following morning by members of the public.

Among his findings, the deputy coroner highlighted evidence from a psychiatrist, Dr Shubulade Smith, who said that Miss Hill was suffering from Emotionally Unstable Personality Disorder (EUPD).

Reading out the facts of the case, Gareth Lewis said: “On December 11, 2012, Miss Hill was admitted to Withybush General Hospital after taking a large overdose of prescription tablets.

“Miss Hill remained as an inpatient at the Hospital until December 15, at which point she was transferred to Bro Cerwyn Hospital.

“On arrival at the hospital it was felt that she would benefit from admission in view of her depression, substance misuse, unresolved bereavement issues and her recent suicide attempt.

“Dr Athithan described her as having a varied suicide risk and placed her on level two 15 observations. She was described as bright, jovial and interacted well with others.

“At 19:15, Miss Hill asked to leave the ward in order to source some heroin. Staff on the ward tried to dissuade Miss Hill from leaving but she was adamant that she wanted to leave and she discharged herself against medical advice.

“In the early of hours of December 16, 2012, police had cause to carry out a welfare check in relation to Miss Hill. Officers were concerned that Miss Hill presented a danger to herself and detained her under section 136 of the Mental Health Act.

“Miss Hill was readmitted to the ward at 02.29hrs on December 16. On arrival she was assessed by Dr Athithan as being emotional, in a distressed state, sobbing and tearful. He suggested that if she tried to leave the ward they should use their holding powers under the Mental Health Act.

“At 14:45 on December 16, Miss Hill walked out of the ward and left the grounds of the hospital. Miss Hill was followed by two members of staff who persuaded her to return to the ward.

“Shortly after taking her medication at 18:15, Miss Hill absconded from the ward again and could not be located. Police were alerted to this and an immediate search was undertaken.

“Miss Hill’s body was found by members of the public at approximately 07:55 on December 17, 2012. She was suspended from a branch of tree with a blue nylon rope around her neck. The cause of death from a post mortem examination was found to be hanging.

“My findings are as follows: The decision to allow Miss Hill to leave the ward on December 15 against medical advice was probably right even if undesirable in the circumstances.

“When Miss Hill was returned to the ward by police there was a significant breakdown in the exchange of information under the section 136 handing over process.

“There was a failure to report Miss Hill’s attempt to abscond at 14:45 on December 16 to Dr Athithan despite his recommendation that if Miss Hill tried to abscond, consideration needed to be given to the use of holding powers. There was a clear lack of appreciation amongst the staff on the ward as to the meaning of the word abscond and because Miss Hill came back to the ward this was not perceived to be an attempt to abscond.

“Miss Hill’s mental state should have been, but was not, reviewed when she returned to the ward after absconding.

“The staff failed to appreciate that level two 15 observations were clearly insufficient to prevent Miss Hill leaving the ward. Miss Hill was only seen to be leaving the ward by fellow patients.

“There needed to be a system to monitor access and egress from the ward. Dr Smith commented during his evidence: ‘You cannot just let people come and go as they please, there needs to be someone in control of the door’, if this was in place it would have been considerably more difficult  for Miss Hill to have absconded from the ward.

“Staffing levels at the ward were such that it would have been difficult to put Miss Hill on level 3 even if this had been considered appropriate.

“There was a lack of joined up thinking between the members of the mental health teams working with Miss Hill. Dr Smith felt that the mental health teams never looked behind Miss Hill’s substance misuse. Dr Smith commented in his evidence that ‘undoubtedly, Miss Hill was suffering from Emotionally Unstable Personality Disorder’.

“One of the main features of EUPD is a tendency to act impulsively without consideration of the consequences. In her evidence she stated that it was very difficult to say whether she intended to kill herself.

At the end of the inquest Mr Lewis added that he would be exercising his powers under regulation 28 to send the report to prevent future deaths to the Hywel Dda Health Board and Welsh Government’s Improving Patient Safety team. He highlighted that his letter would surround training needs, lack of policy regarding access and egress and staffing ratios.

 

1 Comment

1 Comment

  1. Geraldine duff

    July 28, 2024 at 2:13 am

    Are you looking for a way to get rid of shameful bedwetting problem, or your children pee on bed uncontrollably, stop wasting more time and contact Dr. Lababa on [email protected] or WhatsApp +2349073527621

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Business

Young people in Wales face confidence, money and travel barriers a music career

Published

on

A NEW report says confidence, cost, transport and rural isolation are among the biggest barriers stopping young people in Wales from pursuing music.

The Atsain Consultation Report, published by Anthem, found that young people are benefiting from face-to-face music projects across Wales, but many still struggle to access opportunities because of where they live, what they can afford, and whether they have the confidence to take part.

Anthem, Wales’ youth music charity, said the findings show the importance of safe, supportive spaces where young people can create, perform, build confidence and make social connections.

The report, undertaken by Ella Beavington, identified a lack of spaces, finance, equipment and transport networks as major challenges, with confidence described as the biggest barrier preventing young people from taking up musical opportunities.

The charity said the issue is particularly acute in rural communities, where young people often have fewer chances to meet others with similar interests, access rehearsal space, borrow equipment, or take part in free music sessions.

Small World Theatre, based in Cardigan, said young people in the area face significant challenges linked to low income, limited employment and rural isolation.

The organisation said young people with an interest in music often have few opportunities to connect with others or make music for free, adding that these barriers can contribute to poor mental health and limit access to the music industry.

It said its workshops aim to provide a supportive, non-judgemental environment where young people can build confidence, gain practical skills and develop a sense of belonging.

Anthem was established in 2018 following a Welsh Government report looking at ways to support young people’s music making and learning in Wales. Since then, it has invested in youth music projects and built partnerships across Wales and the wider UK music sector.

Through its Atsain fund, which ran from 2022 to 2025, Anthem supported 56 local youth music projects. Feedback from the projects found they helped young people build connections, improve mental health and wellbeing, and create new opportunities.

However, the charity said support and investment must be sustainable if the youth music sector is to continue developing.

Rhian Hutchings, Chief Executive of Anthem, said: “We know that lots of young people want to make, learn, or play music but it’s not always easy. Things like cost, travel, confidence, or even what’s available in their area can make it harder for them to get started.

“Despite these challenges, the consultation has highlighted the transformative value of accessible music projects for young people in Wales.

“The participants that Ella consulted with described meaningful increases in confidence, wellbeing, social connection and physical musical development as a direct result of their participation in the Atsain-funded projects.”

She said Anthem’s new vision is “a Wales in which young people lead a vibrant and connected youth music ecosystem.”

She added: “As Wales’ leading youth music charity, we create work that builds skills, confidence and community with young people who are passionate about music.

“We can only do this in collaboration with the wider youth music community across Wales, and the Anthem ethos is all about partnership, connecting organisations, and putting young people’s voices at the centre.”

The report also found that community, encouragement and early exposure play a major role in whether young people become involved in music.

Participants described friends, family, teachers, mentors and youth organisations as key influences. Schools, youth clubs, community settings and early opportunities to perform or experiment were also identified as important entry points.

But young people also pointed to gaps in school provision, limited genre representation and the need for broader music education that reflects contemporary music and different ways of creating it.

According to the research, 44% of young people said their family had helped them access their music project, while 24% said social media played a key role in helping them find and connect with music opportunities.

Anthem said that while there are growing concerns about young people’s use of social media, online platforms are still one of the main ways youth organisations reach 14 to 16-year-olds who are not already connected to formal music education, youth services or arts networks.

Emyr Afan OBE, Chair of Anthem and founder of the original Pop Factory Music Complex in Porth, said young people need more real-world opportunities if society wants them to spend less time online.

He said: “As Chair of Anthem, I know how much concern there is among parents, schools, youth organisations and young people themselves about the impact of addictive platforms, harmful content and always-on digital pressure. Keeping young people safe has to come first.

“But this change also brings a practical challenge. Right now, social media is one of the key ways that organisations like Anthem reach 14-16 year olds, especially those who are not already connected to formal music education, youth services or arts networks.

“So alongside regulation, we need a clear plan for connection, participation and opportunity.

“If young people are being asked to spend less time on social media, they need more real-world spaces where they can create, perform, belong and be heard.

“Music, sport, culture and youth-led activity cannot be treated as a nice-to-have. They are part of the infrastructure of wellbeing, confidence and community.”

Other groups involved in the research also highlighted social isolation, anxiety, lack of equipment and limited access to affordable lessons as key barriers.

Porthi Dre in Caernarfon said many children in its community do not have musical instruments at home and are aware their families cannot prioritise music lessons.

Wales One World Choir, based in Cardiff, said music can be a lifeline for young asylum seekers and refugees restarting their lives in a new country, often in a new language.

Anthem said the report shows that young people across Wales are eager to make music, but need the right spaces, support and investment to make that possible.

The full Atsain Consultation Report is available on Anthem’s website.

 

Continue Reading

News

Older people urged to claim missing benefits as Welsh Govt promises fairer system

Published

on

Ministers say face-to-face advice is vital, but questions remain over why support is still so difficult to access

OLDER people across Wales are being urged to check whether they are missing out on financial support as the Welsh Government promises to make the benefits system simpler, fairer and easier to use.

Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Minister for Social Justice, Sioned Williams, said ministers want to improve how Welsh benefits are delivered and ensure people can still access face-to-face advice where they need it.

But the announcement comes against a familiar backdrop of rising household bills, low benefit take-up and continuing concerns that many older people are put off by a complicated system split between Welsh, UK and local authority responsibilities.

Ms Williams visited Age Connects Morgannwg’s Cynon Linc on Thursday (July 2), where she met staff and service users to hear how welfare advice is helping older people access support they may be entitled to.

The Welsh Government said the visit highlighted the importance of trusted, community-based advice, particularly for older people who may be less likely to use online services.

It comes as energy bills remain under pressure, with Ofgem confirming a 13 per cent rise in the energy price cap from July 1 for a typical household paying by direct debit.

Welsh Government campaigns have previously warned that large sums in benefits go unclaimed in Wales every year. Earlier this year, ministers said previous winter campaigns had returned more than £10.5m to people across Wales since 2020, including support through Welsh and UK benefits, pensions, care costs and council tax reductions.

Eligible claimants could receive around £1,800 through Pension Credit or save around £800 a year on council tax, according to Welsh Government figures.

Speaking during the visit, Daisy Cole, Chief Executive of Age Connects Morgannwg, said many older people find asking for help the hardest step.

She said: “We are delighted to welcome the Deputy First Minister to Cynon Linc and the opportunity to show why, for many older people, reaching out for support is the hardest step.

“Older people often tell us the greatest difference isn’t simply the financial support they receive, it’s the peace of mind that comes from knowing someone has listened, understands their situation and can help them navigate what can often feel like a complex system.

“No one should miss out on the support they are entitled to because they don’t know where to turn, find the system too difficult to navigate or feel unable to ask for help.

“Peace of mind begins with knowing you don’t have to face things alone. That’s why relationships matter. They give people the confidence to take that first step, knowing someone will listen, understand and walk alongside them.”

The Welsh Government says it wants to work towards a Welsh Welfare System that is simpler and easier to navigate.

Ministers say they will review existing benefits and support schemes to make sure they are having the maximum impact, while also looking at ways to improve take-up.

They also plan to continue pressing the UK Government for greater welfare powers for Wales.

Ms Williams said: “We are working towards a Welsh Welfare System that is simpler, fairer and easier to navigate, making it as straightforward as possible for people to access the financial support they are entitled to.

“That includes improving how Welsh benefits are delivered while ensuring face-to-face advice and help remains available for those who need it.

“Services like Age Connects Morgannwg play a vital role in helping people understand what support is available and giving them the confidence to claim what they’re entitled to, so fewer older people miss out on financial support that could make a real difference to their lives.

“We’re also clear that decisions about welfare are best made as close as possible to the people they affect.

“That’s why we’ll continue to press the UK Government to devolve more welfare powers to Wales, so we can build a system that better reflects the needs and priorities of people here.

“If you think you, or someone you know, may be entitled to financial support, I encourage you to seek advice and find out what help is available.”

However, the challenge for ministers will be turning the promise of a simpler system into practical change for people who already struggle to know what help exists.

A Welsh Government accessibility audit published earlier this year found that only two of Wales’ 22 local authorities referred to the Welsh Benefits Charter on their websites, despite all councils having signed up to it.

The charter was designed to help create a more coherent Welsh benefits system, with an ambition that people should only have to tell their story once to access support.

For older people, the issue is not only whether support exists, but whether it can be found, understood and claimed without stress.

Many key benefits, including Pension Credit, State Pension, Attendance Allowance and Universal Credit, remain the responsibility of the UK Government. Other forms of help, including council tax reduction and some local support schemes, are handled in Wales or through councils.

That split can make the system harder to navigate, particularly for older people who are digitally excluded, isolated, or unsure whether asking for support will affect other payments.

The latest announcement is not the launch of a new benefit, but a renewed commitment to improve take-up and simplify access.

Across Wales, Advicelink Cymru’s Claim What’s Yours advisers can help people check whether they are eligible for extra income and guide them through the claims process.

For free and confidential advice, call 0800 702 2020.

 

Continue Reading

Crime

Haverfordwest woman denies drug-driving allegations in Fishguard

Published

on

A HAVERFORDWEST woman is to stand trial after denying two drug-driving allegations.

Sian Brazendale, 48, of Pedwar, Dingle Lane, Crundale, Haverfordwest, appeared before Llanelli Magistrates’ Court on Wednesday, July 1.

She is accused of driving a grey Peugeot on West Street, Fishguard, on October 31 last year when the proportion of benzoylecgonine in her blood was allegedly 800ug/L, exceeding the specified legal limit.

Brazendale is also accused of driving the same vehicle on the same road and date when the proportion of cocaine in her blood was allegedly 67ug/L, again exceeding the specified limit.

Both charges are brought under Section 5A of the Road Traffic Act 1988.

The court list records that Brazendale entered not guilty pleas to both charges on March 17.

The case has now been adjourned for trial at Llanelli Magistrates’ Court on September 17. The trial is expected to last three hours.

Brazendale was remanded on unconditional bail.

 

Continue Reading

Health21 hours ago

Wales begins early NHS winter planning after long waits and ambulance pressure

Ministers say health boards and councils must act now to ease pressure on hospitals, ambulances and social care before winter...

Crime2 days ago

Judge calls pensioner a ‘dirty old man’ as he avoids jail for exposing himself to women

Judge says 75-year-old Stewart Laugharne behaved ‘disgracefully’ as he avoids jail but is ordered to sign sex offenders register A...

Health2 days ago

Stroke services consultation reaches halfway point as public urged to have say

HYWEL DDA University Health Board is urging people to take part in its consultation on the future of stroke services,...

Business2 days ago

Welsh firms eye share of £5bn defence drone boom

WELSH defence and aerospace firms could be in line for a share of billions of pounds in new military spending...

Community4 days ago

Thousands line Cardigan streets for Lord Rhys homecoming parade

THOUSANDS of people lined the streets and quayside in Cardigan on Saturday as the town marked 850 years since Lord...

Crime5 days ago

Dyfed-Powys Police rated only ‘Adequate’ in organised crime inspection

A WATCHDOG has rated Dyfed-Powys Police only “Adequate” in its response to serious and organised crime, despite praise for the...

News5 days ago

Two taken to hospital after aircraft ditches in Cardigan Bay

Coastguard helicopter spotted two casualties after light aircraft came down off west Wales coast TWO people were taken to hospital...

Sport6 days ago

Long Course Weekend gets underway in Tenby as thousands head for county

Three days of swimming, cycling and running begin with The Wales Swim at North Beach THOUSANDS of athletes and supporters...

Climate6 days ago

Welsh waters, Westminster profits: Crown Estate row reignited in Wales

PLAID CYMRU has renewed calls for the Crown Estate to be devolved to Wales after figures showed income linked to...

News6 days ago

Reform MS: ‘I felt like shouting get out of the water’

Paul Marr says children playing in streams at Pembrokeshire beaches deserve better protection from pollution risks REFORM UK MS Paul...

Popular This Week