Connect with us
Advertisement
Advertisement

Crime

A watershed moment for the criminal justice system?

Published

on

THE FINDINGS of the Ministry of Justice’s Independent Sentencing Review Report could mark a turning point in the future of Britain’s criminal justice system, according to Nacro CEO Campbell Robb.

The report, published on Tuesday (Feb 18), argues that successive governments’ “tough on crime” stance has contributed to the ongoing prison overcrowding crisis, which has brought the system “to the brink of collapse.”

Prison overcrowding at crisis point

The UK’s prison population now exceeds 85,000, a figure the report describes as symptomatic of a justice system prioritising punishment over evidence-based intervention. According to Nacro, research shows that community-based sentencing and investment in support services are more effective at reducing reoffending, yet government policies have continued to rely on longer custodial sentences as a default response.

Robb said: “This is a pivotal moment for justice reform. If we’re truly committed to a fair and effective system, we must shift away from the illusion of quick fixes and tough sentences and focus on building a system that rehabilitates and reintegrates people.”

Decades of flawed policies

Chair of the Independent Sentencing Review, David Gauke, criticised the “haphazard policy making and underinvestment” that has plagued the justice system for decades.

“For too long politicians have operated in a vacuum, increasing sentencing for individual crimes without considering the knock-on impact on the wider system. It is time to accept this does not deliver justice for victims; it fails them,” he said.

Academics contributing to the report have identified the 1991 Criminal Justice Act as a key turning point in the shift towards “penal populism,” in which political pressure has led to increasingly severe sentencing policies. Measures such as mandatory minimum sentences, extended terms for specific offences, and recall policies have inflated the prison population, with little evidence that they contribute to crime reduction.

Is prison the right answer?

According to the review, those given custodial sentences have some of the highest reoffending rates, with overall reoffending for ex-prisoners standing at 37.2%. For offenders serving short sentences of under 12 months, this rises to 56.9%. By contrast, community sentences and rehabilitation orders have been shown to be more effective at reducing reoffending.

Gauke stressed the need for an “honest conversation” about sentencing, stating: “Punishment will always be a central aim of the criminal justice system, but it is not the only aim; and prison is not the only form of punishment.”

Alongside the trend of longer sentences, the growing use of recall has significantly increased the prison population. In 1993, fewer than 100 people were in prison due to recall; by the end of 2024, this number had risen to nearly 13,000.

The review notes that changes such as mandatory post-release supervision for short sentences, combined with a more risk-averse probation service, have fuelled this surge.

The Independent Sentencing Review will release its full proposals for reform in the spring, calling for a “system reset” that aligns with all five statutory aims of sentencing: punishment, crime reduction, reform and rehabilitation, public protection, and reparation.

 

Crime

Governors defend leadership at Milford Haven School after stabbing incident

Published

on

GOVERNORS at Milford Haven Comprehensive School have issued a public statement responding to concerns about leadership and staffing following last week’s serious on-site incident.

The Governing Body said staff have shown “remarkable professionalism, resilience and care for our pupils” during what it described as a very challenging period.

Governors added they have maintained a daily presence in school and praised the teamwork shown by staff across all departments.

They confirmed the headteacher remains absent due to injury, with the deputy head leading the school day-to-day.

The Senior Leadership Team was described as “proactive and effective”, ensuring the school continues to run smoothly and with clear direction.

Addressing one of the key local questions, governors said a new Business Manager had already been appointed.

They stated the new postholder was in place for a full week before the previous manager left, allowing for a proper handover.

Meanwhile Pembrokeshire County Council says additional welfare support is now in place, including the Education Psychology team on site, counselling provision and an increased presence from the School Police Liaison Officer.

The authority also confirmed the Director of Education remains in daily contact with school leaders.

The statement follows last week’s incident in which a 15-year-old pupil was charged with attempted murder, grievous bodily harm with intent and possession of a bladed article. The case has been sent to Swansea Crown Court.

Governors say a meeting for parents will be held after half term to discuss the school’s response to Estyn recommendations and plans moving forward.

They added they remain “fully committed to working with openness, respect and a shared determination to secure the very best outcomes for our pupils.”

 

Continue Reading

Crime

Four arrested in armed police operation across Pembroke Dock

Published

on

Firearms, drugs and GBH suspects detained as pre-planned raids hit Bush Street and Gordon Street

A MAJOR armed police operation across Pembroke Dock on Friday (Feb 13) has resulted in four arrests, police have confirmed.

Heavily equipped firearms officers, dog units and CID teams carried out a pre-planned operation across Bush Street and Gordon Street, sealing off several roads and entering multiple addresses.

The Herald reported live from the scene as officers moved between locations, first targeting a flat on Bush Street shortly after 11:30am before extending cordons into neighbouring streets and making further arrests near the Jobcentre on Gordon Street.

Residents described a large and highly visible response, with armed officers carrying carbines and ballistic shields and specialist teams guarding doorways while searches were conducted.

Police vehicles blocked both ends of the streets for several hours.

Arrests confirmed

In a statement, Dyfed-Powys Police said the coordinated action involved several departments and led to four people being detained.

Those arrested were:

• A 37-year-old man on suspicion of grievous bodily harm
• A 28-year-old man for failing to appear in court
• A 35-year-old man for failing to comply with a drug treatment and testing order, fraud, possession of a firearm, and being concerned in the supply of class A drugs
• A 32-year-old woman for possession of a bladed article, being concerned in the supply of class A drugs, and possession of a firearm

Detective Sergeant Jamie Hughes, of Pembrokeshire CID, told the Herald the police were active proactively to combat criminality in the area. He said: “We would like to thank the community for their support and patience whilst we undertook our operation in Pembroke today.

“I hope it serves as a reminder to those in Pembrokeshire that police will take action against those who intend to commit crime in our county and will deal with offenders robustly and efficiently.”

Streets locked down

The Herald witnessed officers entering properties, deploying dog units and escorting suspects away in handcuffs as enquiries continued.

Access between Bush Street, Gordon Street and surrounding roads was restricted while searches were completed.

Residents said the scale of the response was unlike anything normally seen in the area.

Anyone with concerns is asked to contact police via 101 or through the Dyfed-Powys Police website.

More updates as they come in.

 

Continue Reading

Crime

Killer jailed for life after ‘vicious and sustained’ attack on brother

Published

on

West Wales family tell court: “We have lost two sons”

A 34-YEAR-OLD man has been jailed for life for murdering his own brother following what a judge described as a “vicious, sustained and seriously out-of-proportion” attack.

Darren Steel, of Swansea, was sentenced today (Friday, Feb 13) at Swansea Crown Court before His Honour Huw Rees, who told him he may never be released from prison.

The court heard the fatal assault followed a dispute linked to drugs, with Steel unleashing a prolonged and repeated attack on his brother.

Passing sentence, Judge Rees said the violence went far beyond any reasonable response.

“This was not a short burst of violence,” he said.

“It was vicious, sustained and seriously out of proportion. The anger you displayed that day — uncontrolled anger — arose from your belief that someone had stolen your drugs.”

Lies to police

The judge said Steel attempted to evade responsibility immediately after the killing, giving officers a false name when arrested.

He later repeated a series of lies in custody, including making what the judge described as a “patently false” allegation involving his former partner.

“I’m sorry to tell you that your performance earlier was out of self-pity, not out of remorse,” Judge Rees told him.

“You have shown no genuine insight into what you have done.”

“Pure evil”

Family members delivered emotional victim impact statements describing the devastating consequences of the killing.

One relative told the court: “I have lost both of my sons, either in death or in prison.”

Susanne, the victim’s aunt, said the family had been living through “a constant nightmare”.

“Throughout both trials, Darren has not shown one glimpse of remorse for what he did to his brother,” she said. “He is vacant. He is pure evil.”

Zoe Steel, the victim’s daughter, said her father’s death had robbed her of future milestones.

“I didn’t just lose my father that day — I lost the man who was meant to walk me down the aisle,” she said.

“Darren has created a massive hole in this family that will never mend. Not once did he even say sorry.

“Dad, the day you died, a part of me died with you.”

Additional offences

The court also sentenced Steel for two further assaults connected to the same incident.

He received three years’ imprisonment for inflicting grievous bodily harm on Julian Samuel and 12 months for assaulting Dawn, his former partner. Those sentences will run concurrently.

Life sentence

For murder, Steel was handed the mandatory life sentence and must serve a minimum of 20 years before he can apply for parole.

Judge Rees warned that release is not guaranteed.

“You may never be released,” he said.

 

Continue Reading

News4 hours ago

Sea Empress: 30 years since the grounding that transformed safety in Milford Haven

Human error, storm conditions and salvage decisions combined in one of Britain’s worst maritime disasters THIRTY years ago this week,...

Health1 day ago

NHS pay row erupts as ministers confirm 3.3% rise

Unions warn award amounts to real-terms cut as inflation remains above headline figure NHS staff across Wales will receive a...

Crime2 days ago

Governors defend leadership at Milford Haven School after stabbing incident

GOVERNORS at Milford Haven Comprehensive School have issued a public statement responding to concerns about leadership and staffing following last...

Crime2 days ago

Four arrested in armed police operation across Pembroke Dock

Firearms, drugs and GBH suspects detained as pre-planned raids hit Bush Street and Gordon Street A MAJOR armed police operation...

News2 days ago

Climber dies and two injured in St Govan’s Head fall

Major air and sea rescue launched as coastguard, lifeboat and helicopters scramble to Pembrokeshire cliffs A PERSON has died and...

Education2 days ago

School in special measures after inspectors raise safeguarding and leadership concerns

Estyn orders urgent action plan and regular monitoring at Pembroke secondary A PEMBROKESHIRE secondary school has been placed into special...

Crime3 days ago

Armed police arrest man after major operation in Pembroke Dock

Firearms officers, dog units and roadblocks deployed on Gordon Street as Dyfed-Powys Police investigate ARMED officers sealed off part of...

Community3 days ago

Lifeboat to find new home at Pembroke Dock museum after historic handover ceremony

A HISTORIC lifeboat which saved forty lives around the British coastline is set to begin a new chapter in Pembroke...

Crime4 days ago

Pendine man jailed for abducting and drugging teenage girl

Offender had 1,101 unlawful images of children stored on his devices, including 122 Category A images – the most serious...

Crime5 days ago

Publican admits supplying cocaine and cannabis at Crown Court

Admits cocaine and cannabis supply but denies intent and cash allegations A MILFORD HAVEN pub landlord has admitted supplying cocaine...

Popular This Week