News
BBC apologises for misleading article – after facts are corrected, the ‘scandal’ disappears
FOR six years a narrative has persisted online: “Herald newspaper editor owes £70,000”, “defies court orders”, “treats staff appallingly”. On 4 December 2025, the BBC’s Executive Complaints Unit finally ruled that the central allegation underpinning that narrative — that the editor personally owed £70,000 in unpaid debts — was inaccurate and breached the corporation’s standards of due accuracy.

The BBC has now apologised, amended the headline, and corrected the article.
And with that correction, the supposed “scandal” disappears.
What remains is not a tale of a serial debtor or a rogue employer but something far more mundane: a young entrepreneur who ran printing companies with his late father before 2011, closed or sold them in the ordinary way, and later launched a fast-growing but cash-tight local newspaper group in 2013 that hit a crunch point in 2019, paid everyone in the end, and was ultimately stabilised with outside investment.
When placed in proper chronological and factual context, there is simply no misconduct story left to tell.
The BBC article that refused to die
The original BBC Wales article (March 2019) appeared under the headline:
“Herald newspaper editor Tom Sinclair has £70,000 debts.”
It stated that Sinclair, who “runs The Herald in west Wales”, had “defied court orders to repay more than £70,000 to creditors”.
The phrasing implied:
- that the debt was personal,
- that the liabilities were recent,
- and that they were connected to the Herald newspapers.
None of this was true.
Fraser Steel, Head of the BBC’s Executive Complaints Unit, wrote on 4 December 2025:
“…the wording of the headline and the first line of the report… could allow a reader to form the impression that the debt was your personal liability… Accordingly, the article failed to meet the BBC’s standards of due accuracy in that respect.”
The BBC apologised and amended the headline to:
“Herald newspaper editor Tom Sinclair’s group has £70,000 debts.”
Even this corrected headline encourages a casual reader — or an AI system scraping for summary — to assume that the Herald group itself owed £70,000 in unsatisfied judgments in 2019.
It did not.
Where the £70,000 figure really came from — and why it had nothing to do with the Herald
The number traces back to a June 2017 blog post by freelance journalist Gareth Davies. Davies aggregated almost £120,000 of historic County Court Judgments from a variety of dissolved companies — nearly all of them pre-2013 printing or magazine ventures that were long closed before the Pembrokeshire Herald even existed.
Key points:
- The largest sums (£76,973 + £13,667) related to Megaprinter companies, wound down or sold years earlier, some jointly with the editor’s late father (same name).
- Pembrokeshire’s Best Ltd (£15,000+) never traded properly; its co-director dissolved it without opening a bank account.
- A scattering of very small CCJs related to companies that never commenced operations (“for all I know a parking ticket,” Sinclair wrote in 2017).
On 6 June 2017, Davies sent Sinclair a detailed list of the judgments. Sinclair replied the same day, explaining each company, stating clearly:
“I do not personally owe anyone any money,”
and noting that none of the listed CCJs related to the Herald newspapers.
Davies published his piece the following day, presenting the old dissolved-company CCJs as evidence of a pattern of evasion by the man now running a new newspaper group. Many industry observers noted the timing: the post appeared the very week the Ceredigion Herald was launching on the Cambrian News patch.
Two years later, in the middle of the Herald’s genuine 2019 cash-flow difficulties, BBC Wales revived the Davies narrative almost wholesale. No fresh verification appears to have been undertaken. The same £70,000+ figure resurfaced, this time expressed as if it were recent, active, and relevant to Herald operations.
Strip out the misattributed pre-2013 printing-company CCJs and what debt was outstanding in 2019?
A few thousand pounds in short-term wage arrears caused by a cash-flow crunch — all later paid in full.
That is all.
In journalistic terms: a non-story. Cash-flow wobbles happen to small newspapers every year; almost none of them make national headlines.
The real 2019 Herald crisis — and how it ended
Early 2019 was undeniably difficult:
- over-expansion without sufficient working capital;
- delayed wages (weeks, not months);
- one operating company wound up in February 2019;
- legitimate frustrations among staff and freelancers.
But by late 2019:
- a six-figure investment from Rigographic España stabilised the business;
- every staff member and freelancer was paid in full;
- The Pembrokeshire Herald returned to weekly print;
- sister titles moved to a digital-first model;
- by 2025 the Herald network reached 34 million Facebook views per quarter and over 4 million annual pageviews.
In other words: a messy but fairly typical small-business near-death experience, followed by recovery and growth.
When the timeline is restored, nothing about this amounts to a scandal.
Why the corrected article still distorts the record in 2025
Even after the amendment and apology, the BBC article remains online and highly ranked. Most readers — and most AI summarisation tools — skim only the headline.
They see:
“…group has £70,000 debts”
and conclude that the Herald newspapers owed £70,000 in 2019.
They did not.
That is why Sinclair has asked the BBC for one final, modest addition: an editorial note clarifying that the historic CCJs referenced were unrelated to the Herald group, pre-dated it by years, and concerned companies that had ceased trading long before.
Once that simple clarification is added, the entire “debt scandal” narrative collapses.
There is nothing left except a local editor who made business mistakes, learned from them, paid everyone, and kept a community newspaper alive during an era when hundreds of titles have closed.
The wider lesson
This saga is a case study in how a misleading impression published by a trusted outlet can outlive the facts for years — amplified by search engines and by AI systems that prioritise authority over nuance.
It also demonstrates why accuracy standards matter: once the companies are correctly identified, the timeline is respected, and personal/corporate liability is properly distinguished, the lurid “£70,000 scandal” dissolves into something entirely ordinary.
The BBC has now acknowledged its error and apologised. With the full 2017 email exchange and the ECU decision published today on Herald.Wales, the record is finally straight.
- There never was a £70,000 personal debt.
- There never was a £70,000 Herald debt.
- There never was a scandal.
Just a local newspaper that refused to die — and an editor who refused to let the record stay wrong.
Community
Eisteddfod-themed lanterns light up Cardigan in spectacular celebration
THOUSANDS turned out for Small World Theatre’s Cardigan Giant Lantern Parade on 5 December, a flagship event of this year’s Festival of Light. This year’s theme, inspired by the upcoming Eisteddfod y Garreg Las, brought colour, creativity and community spirit to the streets of Cardigan.
The Parade was made possible thanks to the UK Shared Prosperity Fund, administered and supported by the Cynnal y Cardi team at Ceredigion County Council, with further support from National Lottery Awards for All and Cardigan Town Council.
Cardigan’s Mayor, Cllr Olwen Davies, joined the celebrations as Samba Doc, Jake Caswell and a spectacular array of giant lanterns led hundreds of participants through the town. The procession wound its way to the quayside, delighting thousands of spectators who lined the route.
Among the standout creations were large lanterns made by pupils from Ysgol Uwchradd Aberteifi, Clwb Gwawr and Cardigan Rowing Club. Welsh lady hats and top-hat lanterns, crafted by local primary school pupils, added extra charm to the festive spectacle.

Now in its seventh year, the Lantern Parade has become a cornerstone of Cardigan’s winter calendar, drawing significant footfall and boosting the local economy. Alongside the Parade, Small World Theatre has developed a Festival of Light Trail — an immersive after-dark experience running from 4:30pm to 9pm, with buildings and shop windows illuminated across the town.
Mayor of Cardigan, Cllr Olwen Davies, said: “We’re so lucky to have this annual celebration that unites the town and is a Christmas treat for all. Congratulations to Small World Theatre’s team and volunteers for creating another wonderful evening.”
A spokesperson for Small World Theatre added: “Thanks to everyone who helped — Ceredigion County Council, Cardigan Town Council, the marshals from Cardigan Show and Barley Saturday Committees, Cardigan Castle, and our brilliant team and volunteers. And special thanks to Samba Doc and Jake for the joyful rhythms. Together we created a very special event for all.”
There is still time to support Small World Theatre’s fundraising appeal. Every contribution helps ensure this magical community event continues for years to come.
News
Rising AI demand fuels fears of higher laptop and console prices
Experts warn memory costs could increase, but analysts say wider market forces also at play
A SURGE in global demand for advanced computer memory — driven in part by rapid AI expansion — is raising concerns that laptops, consoles and smartphones could become more expensive in the months ahead.
Industry observers say one factor is a series of major supply agreements involving OpenAI’s “Stargate” project and South Korean manufacturers Samsung Electronics and SK Hynix, which produce much of the world’s high-performance memory. Reports suggest the deal covers hundreds of thousands of chips per month, though the exact proportion of global output remains disputed.
Some experts argue the increased competition for components is already pushing up prices. Others caution that the situation is more complex, with global supply chains, cyclical semiconductor markets and post-pandemic production shifts also contributing to cost pressures.
Memory prices rising — but reasons vary
Several tech companies have reported steeper wholesale costs. According to the open-source tech community around self-build manufacturer Framework, memory modules that were around £100 in late summer are now retailing for several hundred pounds. Framework temporarily delisted its standalone memory kits, citing concerns about scalpers reselling them at inflated prices.
Higher memory requirements in modern phones — with many Android models now starting at 8GB or more — mean manufacturers face difficult decisions about absorbing the cost or passing it on at the till.
Analysts note that memory prices were already forecast to rise after a prolonged slump, with chipmakers gradually winding down production in 2023–24 following weak global PC sales. That has tightened supply even before AI-related demand is factored in.
Small businesses and consumers feel exposed
Colette Mason, an author and AI consultant at Clever Clogs AI, warned that the people most affected will be those who rely on affordable tech.
She said: “We’ve been told AI will democratise everything. But if essential hardware jumps in price, the people hit hardest are students, small business owners and pensioners who simply need a working laptop. It doesn’t feel very democratic when core components suddenly cost several times more.”
Rohit Parmar-Mistry, founder of Burton-on-Trent data firm Pattrn Data, said rising memory costs risk becoming a “quiet tax” on UK businesses.
“A 300% increase in a single component doesn’t just affect gamers,” he said. “It affects every company that needs to refresh equipment. If hardware becomes a luxury item, then AI tools have to start delivering real value rather than hype.”
Other experts say consumers may have options
Not everyone believes the public will be forced into steep upgrades.
Mitali Deypurkaystha, an AI strategist, said many people can avoid paying inflated prices altogether.
“Most AI runs in the cloud,” she said. “You don’t need the newest memory to use ChatGPT. If consumers choose refurbished or older components instead of paying top-end prices, chipmakers will feel that pressure. We’re not entirely powerless.”
Chipmakers yet to respond directly
OpenAI referred Newspage to earlier comments by CEO Sam Altman, who said Korea had the talent and infrastructure to be a “global leader in AI” and praised collaboration with Samsung, SK Hynix and the Korean government.
Samsung and SK Hynix — the two dominant memory producers — have not commented publicly on the reported long-term allocation agreements. Industry analysts say it is common for manufacturers to prioritise high-value enterprise clients during supply squeezes, but warn that consumer-level disruption depends on how quickly production capacity ramps up in 2025–26.
A price rise — but how steep?
Despite strong warnings from consultants, economists say it is too early to know whether UK consumers will face increases as high as “£300 more”, because:
- Manufacturers may absorb part of the cost
- Retailers often buy components months in advance
- Prices could stabilise if chipmakers expand output
- The worst spikes tend to occur in niche or high-performance modules
However, all agree that AI’s appetite for hardware is now a major force shaping the global tech market, and that ordinary consumers are likely to feel at least some impact.
News
A487 at Newgale reopens as council clears storm debris
Flood warning lifted but coastal roads still affected after overnight waves
THE A487 at Newgale has reopened this morning after Pembrokeshire County Council crews worked at pace to clear heavy shingle and debris washed across the carriageway during last night’s storm.
Machinery was deployed early today to remove pebbles thrown up by large waves, allowing the main coast road to reopen. Teams have now moved on to Welsh Road, Newgale, where further deposits are being cleared.
The Flood Warning for Newgale is no longer in force, though the council warns that large waves are still hitting coastal areas and visitors should remain cautious.
Debris has also been reported at Nolton and Broad Haven, with crews expected to attend once operations in Newgale are completed.
Significant storm wash has been recorded elsewhere on the coastline, including at Wiseman’s Bridge, where large stones and sand have been strewn across the roadway. The scene was captured this morning by local photographer Malcolm Richards.
Commons Road in Pembroke is currently flooded but remains passable with care.

-
Crime4 days agoDefendant denies using Sudocrem-covered finger to assault two-month-old baby
-
Crime3 days agoPembroke rape investigation dropped – one suspect now facing deportation
-
News3 days agoBaby C trial: Mother breaks down in tears in the witness box
-
Crime1 day agoProsecution delivers powerful closing speech in Christopher Phillips trial
-
Crime4 days agoLifeboat crew member forced to stand down after being assaulted at Milford pub
-
Crime4 days agoDefendant denies causing injuries to two-month-old baby
-
Crime2 days agoMother admits “terrible idea” to let new partner change her baby’s nappies alone
-
Crime4 days agoPembrokeshire haven master admits endangering life after speedboat collision







