Connect with us
Advertisement
Advertisement

News

No monopoly of wisdom or compassion, says MP

Published

on

no monopolyIT’S FUNNY how a spontaneous comment on Facebook can get picked up and played back, but that is what happened to a few words of mine about benefit reform and its impact on Pembrokeshire. And I am glad that it did.

In a thread of comments responding to the local charity PATCH I said that “no Government or Party has a monopoly of wisdom or compassion, and that none were evil either”. I thought no more about it but thanks to the Herald, I am now.

One of the things that I find frustrating about my job are the claims that there is only ever one cause of the nation’s concerns (them) and only one solution (us). If only it were so easy. The reform of the benefit system was largely seen as essential by all parties, but we differed on the detail. For me benefits are there for people in need; for that time when life goes wrong, when you lose your job or your health; for old age or some other unexpected hardship. They should not be a lifestyle choice, or a cosy alternative to work if work is available or possible.

And I think it is right that the way in which benefits are handed out are as fair to the people paying for them (you and me) as they are the recipient. If that means being reassessed from time to time then so be it. This is taxpayers money and billions of pounds of it.

Did you know that if over your lifetime you earn on average £32,000 or less per year you actually take more out of the state than you put in? I didn’t either, nor did I know that 30% of the UK’s income tax comes from just 1% of people paying it. What this means is that every working family is spending a huge proportion of their cash on benefits for other people – we are all happy to do that if we know those benefits are vital for that person’s quality of life.

By reforming the system like this we get other advantages too. Health and social problems, as well as crime can often be associated with a workless environment or extreme poverty. By changing the system to enable more people to get back to work and stay there we take huge pressure off our NHS, Police, and other services. And the numbers really are looking up. We have more jobs on offer in the region, lower unemployment and lower youth unemployment. New figures show that treatment for drug addiction is getting better. And as for housing I see nothing fair in keeping families in overcrowded conditions if their next door neighbour has two empty spare rooms. Surely we owe it those families to make better use of our housing stock?

Nevertheless I recognise one flaw in this otherwise positive picture. How can we apply these ‘one size fits all solutions’ to a nation which is clearly not one size? How can we make assessments as fair for someone with a mental condition as we do for someone with a limited physical one? Or encourage people to opt for a smaller house if no such houses are available?

This is where fairness comes in and where the nucleus of the problem lies. To be honest I think the Work Capability Assessment has fallen well short of expectations, especially for mental health sufferers. I have highlighted this point in Parliament – but I support the overall aims. The spare room subsidy is perfectly fair, but I regret that we did not have a longer transition period for Councils to work within. (It is of interest that in some councils the “discretionary housing fund” – used to help those facing a spare room subsidy cut – is denied to anybody with a Sky subscription or who smokes)

And it is a source of profound concern that anyone should genuinely face a choice of feeding their families or heating their house or flat. But I support the plans to move, by lots of carrot or a tiny bit of stick, people out of a benefit-dependent lifestyle.

Here in Westminster we mix with members of other Parties much more than the press would ever have you believe. I know and respect my opposition colleagues and in the main our differences are not as pronounced as all that. Strange though it may seem, we all strive to make our home areas that little bit better. The idea that there are any sections of society, young or old, rich or poor for whom we have
nothing but hatred or contempt is simply ridiculous.

This is why MP’s should be entirely non-judgmental when it comes to our constituents. You can love us or loathe us, you can vote for ‘us’ or ‘them’ or for no one at all, but in the end we are here to represent you and to use our judgment in doing so. We don’t always get it right, which is why I used those Facebook words in the first place.

 

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

News

Green candidate warns biodiversity loss poses security risk

Published

on

Party hopeful cites national security report on ecosystem collapse and food supply threats

A GREEN PARTY candidate standing in the upcoming Senedd elections has warned that biodiversity loss and environmental decline could pose serious risks to food supplies and national security.

Amy Nicholass, the Green Party’s Ceredigion Penfro lead candidate for the May election, has highlighted the findings of a report titled Global biodiversity loss, ecosystem collapse and national security, which examines how environmental breakdown could affect the stability of societies.

Nicholass, who holds a Master’s degree in Environmental Science, said the report shows the need for communities to become more resilient in the face of environmental shocks.

“We need to create resilient communities,” she said. “Such communities are being formed all over the UK at the moment.”

The report outlines how biodiversity decline and ecosystem damage could disrupt food production and increase pressures on national infrastructure.

Environmental campaigners have also launched a new initiative called SAFER – Strategic Adaptation for Emergency Resilience – which aims to help communities prepare for major shocks linked to climate change and ecological decline.

The campaign has been promoted by former Green MP Dr Caroline Lucas and environmental thinker Dr Rupert Read.

Nicholass said the involvement of national security experts highlights the seriousness of the issue.

“There are still people, and political leaders who deny that climate change is real,” she said. “Now is the time to come together to acknowledge the truth and find solutions that are good for nature and good for people, and which do not leave poorer members of our society behind.”

The report also highlights the challenges already facing farmers, with changing weather patterns and biodiversity loss affecting crop production.

Nicholass said farmers are on the front line of the crisis but must also be supported as part of the solution.

A spokesperson for the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs said: “Nature underpins our security, prosperity and resilience.”

Nicholass added that communities had shown during the Covid pandemic that rapid change is possible when people understand the scale of a challenge.

“In the Green Party we always look for hope,” she said. “The pandemic showed that people and communities can be resilient and rethink priorities in times of crisis.”

 

Continue Reading

News

Greens oppose US space radar plan for St Davids Peninsula

Published

on

CANDIDATE CRITICISES DARC PROPOSAL

THE GREEN PARTY has voiced strong opposition to plans for a major US military radar installation on Pembrokeshire’s St Davids Peninsula, warning the development risks escalating global tensions and damaging the area’s environment and tourism industry.

The proposed project, known as the Deep Space Advanced Radar Capability (DARC), would involve the construction of 27 large radar dishes designed to track objects in space. The system would form part of a US-led network intended to monitor satellites and other activity in orbit.

Amy Nicholass, the Green Party’s number one candidate for the Ceredigion Penfro constituency in the upcoming Senedd elections, said the proposals represented a return to Cold War-style thinking.

She said: “The DARC proposals are a disgrace. They benefit no one except the US government. When the US tells Westminster to jump, the Westminster government simply asks how high.

“We should be putting all our efforts into creating lasting peace, not allowing anyone to recreate Cold War tactics where none of us feel safe. Peace is at the heart of Welsh culture.”

Campaigners have also raised concerns about the wider implications of militarising space. The radar system would be used to monitor satellites and other objects in orbit, including those belonging to potential adversaries.

Critics argue that the destruction of satellites could create large amounts of debris in space, which could threaten other satellites used for weather forecasting, telecommunications and navigation.

Local residents have also expressed concern about the potential impact on the landscape and tourism industry.

A community group known as PARC Against DARC has been campaigning against the proposals, warning the development could harm the reputation of the St Davids Peninsula, an area widely regarded as one of Wales’ most important natural and tourism assets.

The campaign group describes the peninsula as a “jewel-in-the-crown natural wonder” and a key attraction for visitors to Pembrokeshire.

Nicholass said developments of this scale must involve local communities in the decision-making process.

“It is vitally important that local people have a say on developments like this,” she said. “We need more local power when it comes to large planning decisions that could fundamentally change our landscape.”

She added that the current international climate made diplomacy more important than ever.

“We understand how precarious the world can feel for many people,” she said. “We are fortunate to live in a peaceful part of the world, but proposals like this risk bringing global conflict closer to home.

“We all share this one planet and need to be part of the conversation about how to stand up for each other in peaceful ways.”

 

Continue Reading

News

Complaint over Fishguard DVPO court report rejected by IPSO

Published

on

THE INDEPENDENT PRESS STANDARDS ORGANISATION has rejected a complaint made against The Pembrokeshire Herald over its reporting of a Domestic Violence Protection Order hearing.

The complaint related to an article headlined “Dorset man stopped at Fishguard ferry given domestic violence order,” which was published on February 2, 2026.

The complainant alleged the report breached Clause 1 (Accuracy) of the Editors’ Code of Practice, claiming the article gave readers the misleading impression that he had a proven history of domestic violence and criminal behaviour.

However, after reviewing the complaint, IPSO’s Complaints Team concluded that the article did not raise a possible breach of the Editors’ Code.

In its decision, the regulator noted that newspapers are responsible for accurately reporting what is said in court proceedings, rather than verifying the accuracy of statements made during those hearings.

IPSO said the complainant did not dispute that the allegations referenced in the article had been raised during the court hearing.

The regulator also noted that the report made clear the nature of a Domestic Violence Protection Order, explaining that it is a civil safeguarding measure and does not amount to a criminal conviction.

On that basis, IPSO concluded that the article was not misleading and that there were no grounds to investigate a breach of the Code.

The complainant has seven days to request that the decision be reviewed by IPSO’s Complaints Committee.

 

Continue Reading

News13 hours ago

Greens oppose US space radar plan for St Davids Peninsula

CANDIDATE CRITICISES DARC PROPOSAL THE GREEN PARTY has voiced strong opposition to plans for a major US military radar installation...

Crime18 hours ago

Chinese intelligence probe reaches Dyfed-Powys Police area

Counter-terror officers arrest man in Powys as part of national security investigation THREE men have been arrested in Wales and...

Crime19 hours ago

Man sentenced after punching convicted paedophile in Haverfordwest pub

A HAVERFORDWEST man has been sentenced after punching a convicted paedophile inside a town centre pub. Haverfordwest Magistrates’ Court heard...

Health1 day ago

Davies and Kurtz attack ‘fantasy hospital’ pledge for west Wales

Senedd Members demand immediate investment in Withybush and Bronglais as election campaign intensifies SENEDD Members Paul Davies and Samuel Kurtz have launched a fresh...

Health2 days ago

Hywel Dda warns of ‘significant pressure’ as A&E departments remain packed

Patients urged to use NHS 111 as Withybush, Glangwili and Bronglais face continued strain HYWEL DDA University Health Board has...

News3 days ago

War stops Qatar gas: Milford Haven LNG supplies disrupted

UK energy security concerns grow after shutdown at major export facilities ENERGY bills in the UK could rise sharply after...

Community3 days ago

Martyn Butler dies aged 71 months after Haverfordwest visit

Co-founder of Terrence Higgins Trust attended local plaque unveiling honouring friend Terry Higgins A LEADING figure in the UK’s response...

Crime3 days ago

Nine deny Class A drugs conspiracy as case set for Crown Court trial

Eight remanded in custody as four-week trial fixed for May 18 NINE people have denied conspiring to supply Class A...

Community3 days ago

No asylum seekers housed in west Wales hotels, latest Home Office figures show

WEST Wales currently has no asylum seekers being housed in hotels, according to the latest figures published by the Home...

Community6 days ago

St David’s Day parade brings colour and celebration to Haverfordwest

HAVERFORDWEST town centre was a hive of activity today (Friday, Feb 27) as hundreds of children from schools across Pembrokeshire...

Popular This Week