Crime
Hope for John Cooper as DNA clears man jailed in 1987
Breakthrough in UK’s longest miscarriage of justice highlights power of new forensic science
A MAN jailed for a brutal murder 38 years ago has today walked free from court after the Court of Appeal quashed his conviction—offering renewed hope to others claiming wrongful imprisonment, including Pembrokeshire’s most notorious inmate, John Cooper.

Peter Sullivan, now 68, was convicted in 1987 of the rape and murder of 21-year-old barmaid Diane Sindall, who was attacked while walking home from work in Birkenhead. Despite maintaining his innocence throughout, Sullivan spent nearly four decades behind bars—until new forensic testing revealed DNA from an unknown man on preserved crime scene samples.
The Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) referred the case back to the Court of Appeal last year, and today (May 13), judges ruled that the fresh evidence completely undermined the original conviction.
Sullivan’s case is now believed to be the longest-known miscarriage of justice involving a living prisoner in British legal history.
The ruling highlights the growing role that advances in DNA science are playing in overturning unsafe convictions. It also raises serious questions about other historic cases—including that of John Cooper, who is currently serving a whole-life sentence for the 1985 murders of Richard and Helen Thomas in Scoveston Park and the 1989 killings of Gwenda and Peter Dixon near Little Haven.
Cooper’s 2011 conviction relied heavily on DNA and forensic evidence—particularly fibres and trace DNA allegedly linking him to the crime scenes years after the murders occurred. Advances in forensic science were hailed at the time for cracking the cold cases, but serious questions have since been raised about the handling and interpretation of that evidence. Critics argue that crucial items were poorly stored, contaminated, or even cross-referenced between unrelated cases, with incomplete exhibit logs and inconsistencies in how samples were managed. There are also concerns that some forensic results were presented to the jury with greater certainty than the underlying science could justify, potentially prejudicing the verdict.
Cooper’s legal team submitted a detailed appeal dossier to the CCRC in 2023.
The case is now under formal review.
Concerns raised include missing or contaminated forensic samples, questionable police procedures, and the alleged mixing of evidence from unrelated cases.
One of the team supporting cooper in his fight to get his name cleared said: “If there was nothing in it, the case would have been rejected already.”
He added that the Peter Sullivan ruling shows how persistent investigation and modern science can uncover serious flaws in past prosecutions.
While Cooper remains behind bars, the momentum from today’s decision may shift public and legal focus back to the unresolved questions surrounding his case.
Crime
Man spared jail after admitting child abuse image offences
Police seized devices after intelligence linked Pembrokeshire address to illegal cloud storage accounts
A 23-YEAR-OLD Pembrokeshire man has avoided immediate custody after admitting making and possessing indecent images of children, including extreme bestiality material.
Ryan Beale, aged 23, appeared at Swansea Crown Court for sentencing this week.
At his first hearing, before magistrates on December 31, he entered guilty pleas and being granted conditional bail.
The court heard the case followed an intelligence-led police investigation linking Beale to a Dropbox account suspected of storing illegal material. Officers executed a warrant at his home on December 18.
During his arrest, Beale told officers: “I don’t use Dropbox,” claiming his email and Google accounts had been compromised.
However, police seized his mobile phone and computer equipment. A forensic examination found the email address connected to the Dropbox account stored on his device. Although the account had also been accessed from overseas locations, including Nigeria, investigators were satisfied it was controlled by Beale and linked to a larger cloud storage account containing significant volumes of illegal content.
Officers discovered 120 Category A images, 36 Category B images and 29 Category C images.
Category A represents the most serious level of abuse.
The material included extreme and disturbing bestiality content. Further Category C images were also located within the Dropbox account.
Two identified victims depicted in the images were girls aged nine and eleven.
Beale initially denied the allegations but later admitted the offences.
Passing sentence, at Swansea Crown Court on Tuesday (Feb 3) the His Honour Geraint Walters said: “This was not an innocent pastime. Every time an adult views that image, a child is still being abused.”
He added that an early guilty plea had spared Beale immediate custody but warned the offences would have lifelong consequences.
“The public have no time for anybody doing this,” the judge said. “If you’re doing this, the police will find out. They didn’t knock on your door randomly — they knew what they were looking for.”
Beale was sentenced to eight months’ imprisonment, suspended for two years. He must complete 20 days of rehabilitation activity and pay £300 in prosecution costs.
The court also imposed a Sexual Harm Prevention Order, ordered the forfeiture and destruction of his electronic devices, and placed him on the Sex Offenders Register for ten years.
“If you keep yourself out of trouble, you won’t have to serve that custodial sentence,” the judge told him.
Crime
Hakin man’s appeal delayed again as Crown Court seeks guidance on insurance law
Judge gives CPS more time to review latest road traffic law guidance before case returns in March
A HAKIN man’s appeal against a conviction for driving without insurance has been delayed after a judge granted prosecutors additional time to review updated legal guidance.
Seventy-six-year-old Niall Taylor, of Haven Drive, appeared at Swansea Crown Court on Tuesday (Jan 13) for a mention hearing in his case.
Taylor has accepted the finding that he drove otherwise than in accordance with a licence, but is challenging the separate conviction for using a vehicle without insurance.
The case relates to an incident on January 18, 2023, when he drove a Vauxhall Zafira along Hammond Avenue, Haverfordwest.
The matter has already followed an unusual procedural history. Taylor initially pleaded not guilty in the magistrates’ court but later changed his plea during the original trial. Questions were subsequently raised over whether that plea had been “equivocal”, leading the case to be reopened under Section 142 of the Magistrates’ Courts Act 1980 and reheard in full.
Following a trial of the facts, magistrates found him guilty and imposed sentence in December. Taylor has since lodged an appeal focused solely on the insurance offence.
During Tuesday’s hearing, His Honour Judge Walters granted the Crown Prosecution Service 28 days to review Wilkinson’s Road Traffic Offences (32nd Edition), the leading legal reference text used by courts in motoring cases.
Addressing the court, the judge said the matter may still require further consideration, adding: “The court still might want to reconsider the sentence even if the insurance company is right. It does look as if different insurance companies do things in different ways.”
He added: “It is not in fact void, but it is voidable.”
Taylor maintains that a valid insurance policy was in force at the time of driving and argues that, in law, third-party cover cannot simply be cancelled because of an administrative licensing issue.
The appeal is due to return to Swansea Crown Court on March 27, when further legal argument is expected.
Crime
Pembroke Dock woman admits breaching community order
Magistrates revoke sentence after missed appointments
A PEMBROKE DOCK woman has admitted breaching the terms of a community order.
Shannon Charge, aged 30, of Pater Court, appeared before Haverfordwest Magistrates’ Court on Monday (Feb 2).
She admitted failing to attend a scheduled probation appointment and a drug dependency appointment.
Magistrates revoked the existing community order and ordered her to pay £60 in court costs.
The court heard the order related to earlier offences, for which she had been made subject to rehabilitation and drug treatment requirements. A further review hearing is listed for March 2.
-
Health5 days agoConsultation reveals lack of public trust in health board
-
News6 days agoCaldey still unsafe, survivors warn — despite Abbey’s reform claims
-
Community6 days agoPembrokeshire students speak at national Holocaust Memorial Day event
-
News9 hours agoPrincess of Wales visits historic Pembrokeshire woollen mill
-
Crime4 days agoPembroke man accused of child sex offences sent to Swansea Crown Court
-
Education6 days agoAttendance concerns at Milford School reflect wider issue raised at the Senedd
-
News6 days agoKurtz raises Gumfreston flooding in the Senedd as petition deadline nears
-
Community6 days agoCampaign to ‘save’ River Cleddau hits over 2,200 signatures








