Education
Manorbier school closure row deepens as parent challenges PCC figures
Council insists no decision made as consultation opens – but parents, governors and the local MS say the process is “misleading” and shaped by years of delays after devastating 2022 fire
A MAJOR row has erupted over the future of Manorbier VC School as a former governor accuses Pembrokeshire County Council of using “incorrect and misleading” data in its consultation on proposals to close the village primary.
In a detailed letter sent to The Herald, parent and former governor Suzanne Pearton-Scale says the Council’s figures “misrepresent the real situation”, particularly around pupil numbers, surplus capacity, parental preference and the projected cost of rebuilding the fire-damaged school.
The Council says it is following the statutory School Organisation Code, has launched a formal public consultation running until 19 December, and stresses that “no decision has yet been taken”.
Local Senedd Member Samuel Kurtz MS, who has repeatedly called for the school to be rebuilt, told The Herald that the community has been “let down” and that the school “should never have been allowed to drift into this position”.
The future of Manorbier VC School now appears set to become one of the most contentious education issues in Pembrokeshire in recent years.

“The figures don’t reflect reality”: Parent challenges PCC data
Pearton-Scale disputes several central elements of the Council’s published case for closure.
The consultation documents identify a school capacity of 86 places, with a surplus of between 74% and 77.9%.
Pearton-Scale says this is the pre-fire capacity and does not reflect the temporary buildings pupils have occupied since the 2022 blaze.
She says the temporary accommodation provides 30 places, with 23.5 children currently on roll — an actual surplus of around 21.7%, far below the threshold normally considered significant under the School Organisation Code.
“The Council’s headline surplus figure is misleading because it is not the real capacity the school has been operating under for more than two years,” she said.
Pupil-number decline
The consultation cites a 59.8% fall in pupil numbers between 2015 and 2025.
Pearton-Scale argues that this is skewed by the fire and subsequent delays to reinstatement.
She notes that the decline between 2015 and 2022 (pre-fire) was around 30.7%, which she says is “not enough to justify closure”.
The Council states that only 18.5% of children in the catchment attend Manorbier.
Pearton-Scale says this reflects the limited temporary accommodation, not a drop in parental preference.
“Families haven’t turned away from Manorbier. They’ve been forced away by lack of space. If the school were reinstated properly, local enrolment would rise immediately,” she added.
Cost of rebuild
PCC’s consultation lists a projected rebuild cost of £2.6 million.
Pearton-Scale says the figure “lacks transparency”, claiming the documents do not clearly set out how much insurance will cover, how much additional funding would be needed, or whether competitive quotes have been obtained.
She also argues that temporary accommodation costs have been treated as long-term per-pupil costs, inflating the school’s apparent financial inefficiency.
As a Church in Wales VC school, Manorbier’s status requires consultation with the St David’s Diocesan Board of Finance.
Pearton-Scale says the Diocese has expressed opposition to closure, but claims this is not clearly reflected in PCC’s public documents.
PCC: “No decision has been made – we are following the Code”
Pembrokeshire County Council says it is following all statutory procedures.
According to the consultation timeline:
- Cabinet considered the review of Tenby-area schools on 8 May 2025
- The Diocese was formally consulted on 14 May
- Cabinet approved general consultation on 17 July
- Public consultation is running from 5 November to 19 December
Cabinet Member for Education, Cllr Guy Woodham, recently told councillors:
“We’re not at a situation yet where any decision has been taken; I can’t agree we’re ‘steam-rolling it through’.”
PCC says the consultation was launched due to:
- declining numbers
- high surplus places
- long-term budget considerations
- concerns about viability
- the impact of the 2022 fire and extended use of temporary accommodation
The Herald has asked PCC to clarify:
- whether surplus-place calculations should be based on the temporary units
- the method behind the stated 59.8% decline
- the basis of the £2.6m rebuild estimate and the role of insurance
- whether temporary-accommodation costs were included as long-term costs
- how the Diocese’s position has been incorporated
A full response is expected next week.

Sam Kurtz MS: “The Council let the community down”
Carmarthen West and South Pembrokeshire MS Samuel Kurtz has consistently supported a full rebuild.
After the fire in 2022, he says the community was assured that rebuilding was the intended route.
In September he told local media: “Manorbier School has been at the heart of its community for generations. Its loss has been deeply felt. I’m calling on the Welsh Government to work constructively with Pembrokeshire County Council to honour the original commitment to rebuild the school.”
He has since criticised “broken promises” and said pupils and staff “deserved better than to be left in temporary accommodation for years”.
Kurtz has now asked the Education Minister to intervene to ensure that “closure is not the default option”.
Background: the fire that changed everything
Manorbier VC School was severely damaged by fire in June 2022, forcing the evacuation of pupils and the long-term closure of the main building.
Since then:
- pupils have been taught in temporary units
- no firm rebuild timeline has ever been published
- tight temporary accommodation has influenced catchment choices
- parents have repeatedly sought clarity on the Council’s intentions
The school, which has served the community for more than 150 years, remains highly valued locally.
Community concerns growing
Parents contacting The Herald this week say they feel the consultation treats the school as “already closed” and that temporary conditions have been wrongly used as evidence of falling demand.
Others believe the Council favours consolidation of smaller schools rather than undertaking costly rebuilds.
Pearton-Scale said: “The consultation is built on flawed data and cannot fairly inform the public. We want transparency and the chance to save our school.”
What happens next
The statutory consultation closes on 19 December.
After that:
- PCC officers will analyse all submissions
- a report will be presented to Cabinet in early 2026
- if Cabinet agrees, a Statutory Notice would be issued
- a 28-day objection period would follow
- Cabinet would make a final decision later in 2026
For Church in Wales schools, the Diocese plays a formal role throughout the process.
The Herald will continue to seek answers
Given the seriousness of the issues raised, The Herald has submitted detailed questions to PCC and will publish the response in full.
We have also invited the Diocese, Sam Kurtz MS, and local county councillors to provide further comment.
Anyone wishing to share factual information may contact: [email protected]
Education
Police dogs visit Greenhill School for community afternoon
PUPILS at Ysgol Greenhill were given a close-up look at the work of police dogs during a visit from local officers.
Officers from the Tenby Neighbourhood Policing and Prevention Team attended the school on Thursday (Apr 23), joined by police dog handler PC 301 Bain and police dogs Stan and Archie.
The visit gave pupils and staff the chance to learn more about the role of police dogs, their training, and the work they carry out alongside officers.
Police said the afternoon was also an opportunity for positive engagement and relationship building between young people and the local policing team.
The visit appeared to be a hit with pupils — and with Stan and Archie, who were said to have enjoyed plenty of fuss and attention during the afternoon.
Tenby, Saundersfoot and Narberth Police thanked Greenhill School for hosting the visit.

Books
No ‘touch-and-go’ effort for Theatr Clwyd’s ‘Under Milk Wood’. This is an absolute corker!
We studied it in school, some of us may have re-opened its pages as adults and a few of us might even have been fortunate to see what’s hailed as Dylan Thomas’s greatest masterpiece – ‘Under Milk Wood’ – performed on stage.
I fall into all three categories, but never have I been made so aware of Thomas’s sheer literary magnitude as I was during Theatr Clwyd’s production of ‘Under Milk Wood’, currently showing at The Torch Theatre, Milford Haven.
The cast’s command over this mighty work becomes manifest within minutes of curtain-up thanks to some exquisite stage definition and a magnificent yet unadorned script delivery. This, after all, is a poem where rhythm and precise diction are essential.
With each character dressed in white, characterised solely by a specific clothing item or prop, it was initially difficult to work out who was who. But then ‘Under Milk Wood’ was first aired in 1954 for radio, where the spoken word was the audience’s sole pilot.
Throughout Theatr Clwyd’s production, I was constantly reminded of just how strongly the Llarregyb community – I’m deliberately spelling it this way to match Theatr Clwyd’s laudable captioning – unites. So much happens during those intertwining 24 hours when everyone is interconnected in so many different ways. And Theatr Clwyd makes one realise just how canny Thomas was in his social observations of the busy lives that bustled around him. The play takes its inspiration from so many segments of the poet’s life, be it his childhood letters, his adolescent poems and the time he spent at his waterside homes in New Quay, Ceredigion, and Laugharne. The friendships and the social understanding that existed between the people of Llarregyb was intense but Thomas’ writing also depicts an honesty so indicative of post-war society. How many houseproud women would echo the words of the controlling Mrs Ogmore-Pritchard – she who’s already nagged two husbands to death – as she caws ‘Before you let the sun in, mind he wipes his shoes’?
In many ways the play typifies ‘Under Milk Wood’s’ ‘clock without hands’ as it presents a solid and changeless society, with many traits remaining just as strong in 2026. How many of us know a Nogood Boyo (Jacob Coleman) who flirts shamelessly with that deliciously naughty sparkle in his eyes, an uptight Mrs Ogmore-Pritchard (Georgia Griffiths) who hates people breathing over her immaculate home and maybe even an Evans the Death (Macsen McKay) who loves his job just that little bit too much.
Theatr Clwyd has to be commended for some creative staging set against Llarregyb’s piled up, box-like houses, their windows illuminated by nightlights, capturing the dreamlike, often dark nature, of Llarregyb’s bible blackness. Lighting, in many ways, is used to exemplify Thomas’ narrative as well as the relationship between darkness and light – good and evil – that’s found within the town.
The choreography is also exquisite, each character moving as one, with the result that the movement becomes an integral part of the production’s strength. Not once did I feel this movement overpower the words, but rather support it and magnify the poem even more.
Initially I felt that being able to see the script printed on the backdrop would be a detraction from what was going on on stage. But how wrong can one be? Seeing the text helped me appreciate the way in which Dylan Thomas was able to metamorphose his words into such an overwhelming power force but is also reinforces them as we watch the actors on stage.
Under Milk Wood also uses integrated BSL with signing, audio description (which doesn’t require headsets), and captioning, all built into the design of the show. This, incidentally, doesn’t detract one iota from the performance’s strength.
The play has over 60 characters, played by a cast of 11. And despite their considerable task, the actors capture the intimacy of this tightly-knit community so well. This particularly comes to the fore with Jacob Coleman’s Organ Morgan and Sean Carlsen’s portrayal of the Reverend Eli Jenkins who captures the Welsh passion and musicality so beautifully. “Praise the Lord! We are a musical nation.”

Mirain Fflur oozes sexiness with her stunning looks and her slightly revealing costume, speaking in a seductive manner as she delivers Rosie Probert’s immortal words ‘Come on up, boys. I’m dead’.
Talking of voices, I was immediately struck by Georgia Griffiths’ dulcet tones as she plays Polly Garter and Mrs Ogmore-Pritchard. But when Griffiths breaks into song, her vocal quality takes on a completely new level. Truly beautiful.
Also wonderful to watch is Macsen McKay as he flits through no fewer than five characters – the local undertaker Evans the Death; the town’s draper Mog Edwards who’s hopelessly in love with Miss Price in the sweet shop; Mr Pritchard who is one of Mrs O-P’s two long dead husbands; the would-be wife murderer Mr Pugh and finally the sadly troubled Lord Cut-Glass, for whom darkness always lurks on the horizon. McKay gives us five outstandingly quirky individuals, each displaying some fabulous facial expressions and a sizeable helping of humour.

In a nutshell, this is a truly magnificent performance that captures every essence of Dylan Thomas’ legacy.
‘Under Milk Wood’ will be showing at The Torch Theatre, Milford Haven, from Tuesday April 21 to Friday, April 25.

Education
Penrhyn Dewi celebrates pupil success at cathedral awards evening
Former pupil Simon Davies returned to present prizes as students, staff and the wider community gathered in St Davids for a night of achievement and music
YSGOL PENRHYN DEWI’S secondary phase pupils were honoured at a packed achievement evening held at St Davids Cathedral on Wednesday (Apr 15).
The annual event drew a large crowd of pupils, parents, former staff, former pupils and supporters from across the wider community to celebrate another successful year for the school.

Former pupil Simon Davies, this year’s Chwaraeon Sir Benfro / Sport Pembrokeshire lifetime achievement recipient, was invited back to present the prizes.
Guests also heard from Tom Sawyer, of the Port of Milford Haven, who spoke about learning from mistakes, serving others and improving the way challenges are approached each day.
The evening’s celebrations were led by senior head prefects Celyn, Zosia, Todd and Chloe, who highlighted the achievements of pupils throughout the year.
Music and performance formed a major part of the event. Liza, a chorister, performed a solo in Ukrainian accompanied by St Davids Cathedral Director of Music Simon Pearce. Year 8 Evita performers were joined by members of Milford Haven Amateur Operatic Society for an Evita medley, accompanied by Mrs Cilla Bramley, while Alex, in Year 10, gave a guitar solo performance.
The school also recognised what it described as a record-breaking class of 2024-25 during the evening.

A number of local businesses and community groups were thanked for supporting the event. Prize sponsors included The Bench ice cream parlour, St Davids Fish and Chips, Siop Felys Dewi, Losh’s Pasties and White Sands Beach House.
The Cyfeillion Ysgol Penrhyn Dewi fundraising group served refreshments, MamGu Welshcakes provided resources, and The Bishops in St Davids were thanked for supplying a free buffet.
Former pupil and cathedral verger Morgan Davies was also praised for going above and beyond in helping the evening run smoothly.
The school said it was wonderful to see so many members of the community come together to recognise the exceptional achievements of Team YPDVA.
-
Crime7 days agoMilford man admits TV piracy offences linked to estimated £6m losses
-
Local Government5 days agoUnresolved building control record leaves buyer’s cottage unregistered
-
Crime5 days agoMan on trial over historic sex offence allegations
-
News5 days agoWaiting lists fall for ninth month — but cancer, A&E and ambulance pressures grow
-
Crime6 days agoKeeston driver to face trial over A40 driving allegation
-
News5 days agoKemi Badenoch warns over loss of industry during Valero visit
-
News3 days agoBarley Saturday brings bumper crowds to Cardigan
-
News6 days agoMcDonald’s customers abused by drunk in Milford








