News
Parents sued for share in £7 million estate
A FARMER’S DAUGHTER from Whitland who claims she had to stay at home and tend the cows while her teenage siblings went dancing is now suing her elderly parents for a share of their £7 million estate.
Eirian Davies, aged 45, insists she was repeatedly assured by her parents, Tegwyn and Mary Davies, now in their 70s, that she would ultimately step into their shoes and take over the family’s ‘golden egg’ – thriving Caeremlyn Farm, Whitland, and its herd of pedigree Holstein cows.
She says a substantial stake in the 200-acre farm is no more than her due for the years of toil she put in, but her parents are fighting her every inch of the way and the case is now under the legal spotlight in the Court of Appeal.
Miss Davies testified at an earlier court hearing that she missed out on going to Young Farmers’ Club dances with her two sisters as a teenager because she had to stay at home to deal with her farming chores.
She said her parents told her that her sisters were not interested in the farm and that her patience would one day be rewarded.
“They always told me that the farm would be left to me. Even on my birthday, when the other girls were having things, they would say – ‘you will have the damn lot one day, it will all be yours’,” she told Judge Milwyn Jarman QC.
The judge found that Miss Davies had “established an entitlement to a beneficial interest in the farm or farming business” – but her parents are now challenging that ruling before three of the country’s most senior judges.
Timothy Fancourt QC, representing Mr Davies, aged 75, and his 76-year-old wife, argued their daughter had earned a fair income during her stints working on the farm and was provided with ‘bed and board’.
Her parents also put their daughter through agricultural college, said the QC, adding: “She said in terms that agriculture was her love and she wanted to be on the farm”.
Even when Miss Davies had worked elsewhere she failed to boost her earnings, said Mr Fancourt, pointing out that she only earned £5,000 while working as a consultant for Slimming World in 2006.
“So when the opportunity is there to do something else, she does worse”, the QC argued.
Insisting that she had suffered no ‘substantial detriment’ in reliance on anything her parents had said or done, he told the court there was no evidence that ‘she would have been better off’ had she not worked on the farm.
However, Leslie Blohm QC, for Miss Davies, said promises were made by her parents from 1985, when she was 17, and she had worked “extremely long hours” with the cows – at times underpaid, and sometimes for nothing.
If she complained to her parents about meagre wages, she was told that the farm would ultimately belong to her – and ‘not to kill the goose that laid the golden egg’, added the barrister.
Although Judge Jarman found that Miss Davies had ‘walked away from the farm’ for periods between 1989 and 2008, living and working elsewhere, she had eventually moved back home following a reconciliation with her parents.
Mr Blohm said the rapprochement also followed a ‘representation’ by her father that she could live on the estate, in Henllan Farmhouse, rent-free for life, and that she was to be a partner in the farming business.
In 2009, a pledge that she would inherit the farm was also made in a draft will, the barrister added.
However, following a final family ‘rupture’ in late 2012, her parents gave her notice to quit the farmhouse. Possession proceedings followed, but Miss Davies insisted she was entitled to a beneficial interest in the farm.
In his ruling last year, Judge Jarman said that, after periods away, Miss Davies had always returned home – “relying on the representations by continuing to work and live on the farm”.
And Mr Blohm told the court: “It is plain from the evidence that a talented, hard-working and capable lady has spent a substantial part of her adult life – over a period of 25 years – carrying out difficult physical work for the benefit of her parents.
“That was on the strength of their repeated representations that she would eventually take over the farm and business.
“If not for those representations she would have employed her skills elsewhere.”
Mr and Mrs Davies sat together in court throughout most of the hearing, although he later moved to a seat nearer to the judges as he is hard of hearing.
After several hours of legal debate, Lords Justice Richards, Underhill and Floyd reserved their decision on the couple’s appeal and will give their ruling at a later date.
News
Lib Dems criticise Reform over coal and fracking comments
THE WELSH LIBERAL DEMOCRATS have criticised comments by Reform UK figures suggesting coal mining could be revived in Wales, describing the idea as unrealistic and warning it could damage both the environment and future investment.
The row follows comments by Reform candidate Ben Hodge-McKenna, who said reopening coal extraction using newer and “safer” technology could help meet Wales’ future energy needs. Reform leader Nigel Farage has also previously faced criticism over remarks about sending young Welsh people back down the mines.
Responding to the comments, the Welsh Liberal Democrats said Wales should focus instead on developing newer industries, including floating offshore wind in the Celtic Sea, tidal energy and green manufacturing.
The party also linked the issue to Reform’s previous support for fracking, arguing that both positions point to what it sees as an over-reliance on older fossil fuel industries rather than long-term economic planning.
Welsh Liberal Democrat leader Jane Dodds said: “Reform’s plan to reopen coal mines is pure fantasy politics. It won’t cut bills, it won’t deliver lasting jobs, and it won’t stand up to even the most basic economic scrutiny.
“The fact they also want to open Wales up to fracking tells you everything you need to know. Fracking would destroy our countryside, can cause earthquakes and risks contaminating local water supplies, yet Reform seems willing to ignore those dangers.
“This is a party doubling down on the failed energy policies of the past, with no serious plan for the future.
“Wales cannot build its future by trying to relive its past. Communities that once powered the industrial revolution deserve better than being sold false promises about industries in irreversible decline.
“Instead of chasing yesterday’s solutions, we should be investing in the industries of the future and giving Welsh workers the secure, well-paid jobs they deserve.”
The Welsh Lib Dems said former coalfield communities deserve serious economic plans for regeneration rather than what they described as headline-grabbing promises.
Reform has argued that Wales should be more willing to use domestic energy resources, including fossil fuels, as part of a wider push for energy security and lower costs.
I’d add a line at the end saying Reform was approached for comment, if you have asked them.
News
Local Conservatives launch campaign with pledge to protect local health services
THE WELSH CONSERVATIVE team has officially launched its campaign for the new Ceredigion Penfro constituency, pledging to protect vital local health services including Withybush Hospital and Bronglais Hospital.
Leading the campaign are current Senedd Members Paul Davies and Samuel Kurtz, who were joined by members of the Welsh Conservative team and fellow Ceredigion Penfro candidates Claire George, Brian Murphy, Jill Evans and Claire Jones.
At the launch, held outside Withybush Hospital, the team set out its vision for improving healthcare provision across west Wales. The campaign will focus on protecting and strengthening services at Withybush Hospital in Haverfordwest and Bronglais Hospital in Aberystwyth, both seen as essential lifelines for rural communities in Pembrokeshire and Ceredigion.
Paul Davies said: “Residents across Pembrokeshire and Ceredigion deserve access to high-quality healthcare close to home. We have consistently stood up for Withybush Hospital and will always fight to defend it. Any attempt to downgrade services is simply unacceptable.”
Samuel Kurtz added: “Labour has overseen the downgrading of local health services, while Plaid has enabled it by propping up Labour budgets in the Senedd. Reform has been silent on cuts to Withybush and Bronglais hospitals. Only Paul, myself and the Welsh Conservatives are standing up for our local health services, from Withybush and Bronglais to GP and dental access.”
The Welsh Conservatives said their campaign would focus on protecting and improving services at both hospitals, cutting waiting times, improving access to GPs and dentists, securing fairer healthcare funding for rural areas, and ensuring local voices are heard in decisions about health provision.
They said rural healthcare needs tailored solutions and long-term investment, rather than further centralisation of services away from local communities.
Paul Davies added: “This campaign is rooted in the priorities of local people who have trusted us to deliver. We have a strong track record of action, and we will continue to stand up for our hospitals, support local businesses and farmers, and fight for a healthcare system that works for everyone, no matter where they live.
“This election is about making sure west Wales has a strong, experienced voice focused on what really matters – our NHS, our economy and our future.
“After more than two decades of Labour running Wales, too many public services are still falling short, especially in rural areas like ours.”
Mr Kurtz said: “Paul and I have experience, and we have put that experience into practice by working hard for our communities. That experience will matter in a larger Senedd. We are ready to hit the ground running and fight for west Wales, no matter who ends up running the Government.”
The campaign will now continue across the constituency, with candidates meeting residents and listening to their priorities.
Aled Thomas, Chair of the Pembrokeshire and Ceredigion Conservative Federation, said: “With six Senedd Members representing the new constituency under the new voting system, every vote matters, and every vote for the Welsh Conservatives can help return Paul and Sam.
“Both Paul and Sam are well known locally, with years of experience standing up for west Wales. They understand the issues that matter, they are proud to serve, and they have consistently worked hard to get results.”
Photo caption: Welsh Conservative candidates Paul Davies, Samuel Kurtz, Claire George, Brian Murphy, Jill Evans and Claire Jones launched their Ceredigion Penfro Senedd campaign on Wednesday (Apr 2) with a pledge to protect local health services.
News
Police search for distressed man in Pennar ends safely
Concerns for welfare raised in early-hours incident near Bentlass Terrace
POLICE were called to Pennar in the early hours of Sunday (Mar 29) after concerns were raised for the welfare of a man near Bentlass Terrace.
Dyfed-Powys Police said officers received a call at around 2:45am reporting concerns for the individual’s safety.
A search was carried out in the area and the man was later located before being taken to hospital.
The incident is understood to have happened near the garages at Bentlass Terrace, with witnesses reporting a police presence in the area between around 3:00am and 5:00am.
The force has not released further details about the circumstances, but confirmed the matter was treated as a welfare concern rather than a criminal incident.
A spokesperson for Dyfed-Powys Police told The Herald: “Dyfed-Powys Police received a call reporting concerns for the welfare of an individual at around 2.45am on Sunday, March 29.
“A search was conducted for the man, who was located and taken to hospital.”
The Herald understands officers acted quickly after the report was made, and the man was found alive and given medical assistance.
-
Education6 days agoYsgol Henry Tudor reassures parents over Sikh ceremonial kirpan
-
Crime6 days agoTaylor wins appeal as Crown Court quashes ‘no insurance’ conviction
-
Local Government6 days agoPembrokeshire Coast National Park members salaries to rise
-
Crime6 days agoAppeal dismissed in blood sample case after court rejects PTSD defence
-
Sport7 days agoWorld Cup dream shattered for Wales in penalty agony
-
Business6 days agoPopular extreme sport off Pembrokeshire coast to become licenced activity
-
Crime6 days agoFour men fined over illegal cockle gathering on the Burry Inlet
-
Charity3 days agoRSPCA calls for stronger animal welfare measures as Welsh Labour launches manifesto












Teifion
March 15, 2014 at 6:19 pm
It’s sad when parents seem to favour the feckless, the kids who left and don’t want to know or care about their parents anymore and not appreciate the kids who stayed at home, who sacrificed their lives to look after their parents.
Laura
March 18, 2014 at 11:44 pm
Is no one reading this story properly, eirian obviously couldn\’t hold down a job so was given everything from her parents including a job when she wanted one. £300 a week a house, car and clothing allowance sounds like a good wage to me. Besides all that, what makes her think she is entitled to anything just because her parents worked hard to build up a successful business? It\’s up to them what the do with their estate. I think she is a lazy money grabber!
Teifion
March 19, 2014 at 10:23 pm
oh Laura, I think we should know your agenda – do your family relations suffer?
Farmer
June 6, 2014 at 11:15 am
Who is Laura? I don’t think that anyone without all the evidence has any right to make judgement! The four Judges had all the evidence and not the word of the mother! The lazy money grabbers are those who come out of the woodwork when the work is done! I know so many middle aged people that have given up they’re entire lives to farm for they’re parents as slaves, only to find out when it’s too late, that what they have worked for, goes between the siblings! Good luck I say