Crime
Judge criticises reluctance to jail offenders after Haverfordwest hammer attack
A CROWN COURT judge has hit out at the judicial service’s reluctance to send criminals to custody despite their regular offending when sentencing a Haverfordwest man accused of attacking his victim with a lump hammer.
Addressing Joshua Lee, 21, when he appeared for sentencing at Swansea Crown Court on Monday for a revenge attack against a man he accused of raping his best friend’s sister, Judge Geraint Walters condemned the system for handing out persistent Community Orders instead of custodial sentences.
“Pussyfooting around with sentencing is a mistake in many cases,” he said.
“What’s the point of a fine or a Community Order, when on and on it goes?
“This is a man who needs help, but sometimes that means a more serious sentence.”
Lee, 21, had pleaded guilty to attacking his victim with a lump hammer in Salutation Square, Haverfordwest on the afternoon of Sunday, August 25.
Counsel for the Crown, John Hartson, KC, said the attack took place soon after 4pm.
“The victim was walking through the town centre when he was assaulted by the defendant and punched to the back of his head,” he said.
“[The victim] turned around and recognised the defendant but he was then punched to the head numerous times. There were 20 hits to his head and he was also hit twice to his face. The defendant then produced a lump hammer and used it to hit the victim to his right temple. He felt immediate pain.”
The defendant ran off but was later traced by police officers to an address in Fleming Crescent, Haverfordwest.
“He came out with his arms in front of him, saying, ‘So [the victim] raped my best friend’s sister. Now I’ve dealt with it.”
Meanwhile defence counsel David Johns, KC, said Lee’s life in the run-up to the revenge attack had been exceptionally difficult.
“He had a very difficult upbringing and was put into the care system when he was two years old where he was physically abused,” he said.
“This is a young man with mental health problems, who’s extremely immature, and it’s exacerbated by the fact that he’s had little or no moral guidance.
“Maybe if he’d had some sort of proper support before now, things would have been different.”
Mr John’s comments were endorsed by Judge Geraint Walters.
“The defendant was brought up in the most depressing way, and that is not his fault,” said Judge Walters.
“No two-year-old can be blamed for being taken into care and no two-year-old can be blamed for being abused so yes, you are the product of your upbringing.
“The courts, over the years, have given you one Community Order after another and they’ve achieved absolutely nothing. Someone should have taken the bull by the horns before now.
“You’re now getting some structured intervention in the prison which you were not getting in the community. I’d like to think that this is the last time that you’ll end up in court.”
Joshua Lee pleaded guilty to assault causing actual bodily harm and to possessing an offensive weapon, namely a lump hammer, in a public place.
He was sentenced to 15 months in prison. Half of this sentence will be served in custody with the remaining time being served on post-sentence supervision.
A five-year restraining order was imposed, preventing him from having any form of direct and indirect contact with the victim and a forfeiture and destruction order was made for the lump hammer.
Crime
Police hunt driver after dog walker killed in Carmarthenshire hit-and-run
A PEDESTRIAN walking his dog has died after being struck in a hit-and-run collision on a Carmarthenshire road on Monday (December 23).
The incident occurred in Llanpumsaint, near Caer Salem Baptist Chapel, between 6:45pm and 7:45pm.
The road remains closed, and police are urgently appealing for information to locate the driver of a blue vehicle believed to have fled the scene.
A spokesperson for Dyfed-Powys Police said: “We are actively searching for the driver of a blue vehicle with noticeable damage, which was involved in a fatal hit-and-run collision in Llanpumsaint, Carmarthenshire. The driver left the scene, and locating them is now our top priority.
“We are appealing directly to the driver to do the right thing and come forward. Additionally, we urge anyone who may have seen the vehicle or has dashcam footage from the area during the relevant times to contact us immediately.
“This collision, which tragically resulted in the death of a pedestrian, happened near Caer Salem Baptist Chapel between 6:45pm and 7:45pm on Monday, December 23, as the man was walking his dog.
“Our investigation indicates the vehicle was travelling northbound through Llanpumsaint at the time of the incident.”
The road is expected to remain closed for some time while enquiries continue. Police stress that any piece of information, no matter how small, could be crucial in identifying and locating the driver. Anyone with information is urged to contact Dyfed-Powys Police immediately using the details provided in the comments.
Crime
Haverfordwest man given restraining order for stalking ex
A HAVERFORDWEST man who had difficulty coming to terms with the end of his marriage has appeared before magistrates where he pleaded guilty to stalking his former wife.
Terry Mochan and his wife, Carol, separated in January 2024, but three months later, Ms Mochan found herself being harassed and intimidated by her former husband.
The first incident took place on April 13 when Mochan, 25, of St Issells Avenue, Merlins Bridge, Haverfordwest, raised his middle finger at his wife in a public place, and shouted at her.
Three days later Mrs Mochan noticed that her ex-husband was following her through Haverfordwest town centre.
“He was driving very closely behind her in his van,” Crown Prosecutor Sian Vaughan told Haverfordwest Magistrates this week.
In a victim impact statement that was read to the court, Mrs Mochan said both incidents have had a profound effect on her self-confidence.
“She’s now concerned, whenever she’s driving through town, that the defendant will be following her,” said Ms Vaughan. “It’s having an impact on her life and she’s concerned that he’ll attend her property.”
Mr Mochan was represented by solicitor Mr Gavin Rofer who said the defendant has no previous convictions.
“Both incidents were the result of the breakdown of their marriage,” he said. “But since April 16 there have been no further incidents.”
After considering the mitigation, magistrates fined Mochan £180 and ordered him to pay £325 court costs and a £72 surcharge. A 12 month restraining order was imposed, preventing him from having any contact with Carol Mochan.
Crime
Hostel resident brandished knife after seizure fears ignored
WHEN hostel resident Andrew Finan feared he was suffering a seizure, he attempted to contact the hostel’s support worker for help.
But when she failed to answer his calls, Finan walked up to the hostel’s CCTV camera, shouting angrily and brandishing a large kitchen knife.
“He’s been at the hostel since August, but he’s hard work,” Crown Prosecutor Sian Vaughan told Haverfordwest magistrates this week.
“He has various mental health issues and the staff have difficulty controlling him.”
Incident captured on CCTV
The incident took place in the early hours of December 22 at the Furnace Bank Hostel, Carmarthen.
“The CCTV covers the hostel, and the defendant was shouting angrily directly at the camera and holding a large kitchen knife in his hand,” said Ms Vaughan.
The support worker on duty at the time heard Finan shouting, “I’m sick of you, you b*******,” before turning away and going upstairs to his room.
Support worker left shaken
“I found the incident scary,” the support worker said in a victim impact statement. “His behaviour is erratic and unpredictable, and he scares me. I don’t know what to expect from him from day to day. Waving the knife around and directing it at me was extremely worrying.”
Defence cites frustration
But Finan’s solicitor, Fenn Richards, said his actions were the result of frustration at being ignored by staff.
“He believed he was going to have a seizure, as he’s had five brain bleeds in the past as a result of an assault,” she said.
“He tried to get the staff’s attention, but they didn’t answer the door, and the only way he could get their attention was to stand in front of the camera.”
Sentencing next month
Finan pleaded guilty to a charge of possessing an offensive weapon in a public place. Sentencing was adjourned to January 14 to allow a probation report to be prepared. Finan was released on conditional bail, with conditions including reporting twice a week to Carmarthen police station, not visiting the Furnace Bank Hostel, and having no contact with the support worker.
-
News4 days ago
Ferry accident causes delay on new Dublin-Fishguard route
-
Education5 days ago
Home Education: Delays and missed opportunities risk further tragedy
-
Business5 days ago
Pembrokeshire care home group hit by £150,000 budget blow
-
News6 days ago
Rift between Neyland councillors now ‘as wide as Grand Canyon’
-
News6 days ago
Labour’s refusal to compensate WASPI women sparks outrage
-
News7 days ago
Plaid Cymru calls for HS2 funding as disruption sparks debate
-
Community5 days ago
Tips for coping with Mental Health challenges this Christmas
-
Politics6 days ago
Pembrokeshire Long Course Weekend changes could be made