Connect with us
Advertisement
Advertisement

Business

Farming jobs fears spark fiery Senedd debate

Published

on

A FIERY debate has erupted over claims a financial support scheme for farmers will lead to the loss of an estimated 1,100 jobs, 56,000 livestock and £76m.

Samuel Kurtz, the Tory shadow rural affairs secretary, urged the Welsh Government to scrap the stuttering sustainable farming scheme (SFS) which has been plagued by protests.

He said: “Their own economic impact assessment tells a stark story: job losses, livestock reductions and millions wiped from farm business incomes.”

But Welsh ministers accused the opposition of misleading farmers, arguing the figures were incomplete “scenarios, not predictions” that failed to account for the scheme’s full benefits.

Mr Kurtz told the Senedd the farming sector employs about 50,000 people directly and a further 250,000 in the wider food and drink supply chain – a sector worth £9.3bn a year.

“Behind every one of those numbers lies a family, a community, a business, people who have served Wales for generations,” he said. “Farming is not simply an occupation: it’s a way of life, the beating heart of our rural economy and a cornerstone of Wales’ national identity.”

The Tory said the “flawed” SFS risks hollowing out the core of Welsh farming, prioritises bureaucracy over practicality and puts environmental targets before food production.

Warning of the cumulative burden on farmers, he told the Senedd: “We will not accept a scheme that puts our farms at risk, our jobs in jeopardy and our food security in question.”

Mr Kurtz, who is from a farming family, said: “I don’t believe that this is a farming scheme; I believe it is an environmental scheme that the government expects farmers to deliver.”

He criticised Labour for rejecting calls for a binding vote on the scheme. “They denied farmers the chance to have their voices properly heard here in this place,” he said. “I don’t believe that is democracy in action – rather, [it is] government by decree.”

But Huw Irranca-Davies, Wales’ Deputy First Minister and rural affairs secretary, hit back – warning of inaccuracies in the way in which data has been interpreted.

Deputy First Minister Huw Irranca-Davies

“Even the motion tabled before us today is inaccurate, he said. “Nowhere, nowhere, in the evidence we have published does it say that job losses, livestock number reductions, or reductions in farm business income will definitively happen. Nowhere.

“This is trying to turn really complex information into simple soundbites. This is not helpful to serious debate and, most importantly, it is not helpful to farmers.”

Mr Irranca-Davies said the Welsh Government will invest more than £340m in the first year of the sustainable farming scheme, which goes live in January.

Cautioned that scrapping the SFS and starting again would cause uncertainty and instability, he argued the Tories lost all credibility with their “not a penny less” Brexit funding promise.

Plaid Cymru MS Llyr Gruffydd
Plaid Cymru MS Llŷr Gruffydd

Llŷr Gruffydd took the middle ground during Wednesday’s (October 8) debate, urging Welsh ministers to improve the scheme rather than take the “nuclear option” of scrapping it.

Plaid Cymru’s shadow rural affairs secretary expressed concerns about the impact of falling livestock numbers on abattoirs and the potential for farm incomes to drop.

He told the Senedd: “Yes, perhaps it is the worst-case scenario but it is a cause of concern for me and many people out there whose livelihoods rely on the scheme.”

Mr Gruffydd criticised the Conservatives for complaining about the consequences of Brexit. He also attacked the Labour UK Government for “Barnettising” the farming budget, meaning Wales gets a smaller share based on population rather than the nation’s needs.

Senedd Members voted 30-11 against the Conservative motion before agreeing the Welsh Government’s amended version, 22-20.

 

Business

Call to convert former farmhouse/guesthouse to housing approved

Published

on

A CALL to convert a former Pembrokeshire farmhouse and guesthouse into housing units has been given the go-ahead by county planners.

In an application to Pembrokeshire County Council, Dan Hildebrand, through agent GMW Design, sought approval for the subdivision of Torbant Farmhouse, Croesgoch, near Haverfordwest, to form four residential units.

A supporting statement through Johnston Planning on behalf of the applicant and agent said: “The property has historically been run as a successful guesthouse for a number of years but has recently come under new ownership. The new owner wishes to maximise the potential of the existing residential floor space through the subdivision of this generous property into four units.”

It added: “Whilst the intention is to utilise the subdivided property for residential purposes due regard is given to the 2022 changes to the use class order which in effect created new residential classes for new development in an effort to control unrestricted holiday uses in sensitive locations.

“As such a ‘free use’ is sought within use classes C3 (use as a sole/main residence), C5 (use as otherwise as a sole/main residence) and C6 (use as a commercial short term let).

“These proposed uses, which are considered to be reasonable and to be fully compliant with current planning policy (especially when one has regard to the existing use) will provide the owner with flexibility in terms of proposed occupation. Ensuring full and meaningful use of the property in the future.”

It said the property was once part of Torbant Farm, now been broken up into a number of separate properties, including Torbant Caravan Park immediately to the north.

It added the works to the property “are minimal and will have a negligible impact externally,” adding: “Internally whilst the layout will alter marginally no structural works to the property are proposed.

“In character terms therefore, there will be no discernible physical impact either to the dwelling itself or to the wider locality.”

Six objections to the scheme were received, raising concerns including harm to visual and residential amenity, ecological impact, infrastructure constraints, and claimed inaccuracies in the submitted application, as well as the application overstating available parking space “which would encroach onto shared access areas, causing obstruction and conflict between users”.

An officer report recommending approval said the scheme was amended to move car parking provision within land under the applicant’s control.

It concluded the scheme represented “an efficient use of the existing building stock,” and it “would not result in any external alterations to the host building and would not give rise to unacceptable harm to the character or appearance of the building or its wider rural setting nor the residential amenities of neighbouring occupiers”.

The application was conditionally approved by county planners.

 

Continue Reading

Business

Council-owned housing at former Milford Haven social club approved

Published

on

PLANS to convert a former Pembrokeshire town centre social club into council owned social housing have been given the go-ahead.

In an application to Pembrokeshire County Council, the authority itself, through agent KEW Planning, sought a change of use of the former Manchester Club social club, Fulke Street, Milford Haven to seven social rented residential units.

The Manchester Club public house/social club closed in March 2024 due to the cost of operations rising to be more than the monetary value that the club delivered, remaining vacant since this time, and was marketed for sale before an offer from the council was accepted.

The council scheme will provide five one-bed flats, one two-bed, and one studio flat; an amended scheme from discarded initial options which included one for 12 apartments and two studio flats. The scheme revised to restrict proposed alterations to the existing building to a minimum.

The proposal includes the demolition of the single storey garage to the front, and a single-storey extension at the rear, which will allow a communal amenity area.

A supporting statement said: “The vision for this project is to provide social housing to address housing stock shortages and to give a new life to a vacant building in a central location of the town. The property will be rented to mixed aged tenants, with PCC as the corporate landlord.”

An officer report recommending approval said the site had been marketed since 2024 at £170,000, with a £150,000 offer made but was unable to be proceeded with, the price later reduced to £150,000, three offers later received including £140,000 from the council, which was accepted in April 2025.

“For the two years that this property has been marketed the market response to the property has been limited with no viable interest in retaining the building for its existing community facility use,” the report said.

It concluded: “The loss of the former community facility has been robustly justified in accordance [with planning policy], and the scheme would deliver social and economic benefits through the provision of additional housing and the re-use of a vacant building.

“The proposal would enhance the visual appearance of the site, provide an acceptable standard of residential amenity for future occupiers without undue harm to neighbouring properties, and would not give rise to unacceptable impacts in respect of highway safety, drainage, biodiversity or the historic environment.”

The application was conditionally approved.

 

Continue Reading

Business

Wales unemployment close to UK rate as ministers promise productivity push

Published

on

WALES’ unemployment rate is broadly in line with the UK average, according to the latest labour market figures.

The Welsh Government said figures from the Annual Population Survey showed unemployment among people aged 16 and over in Wales at 4.5%, compared with 4.4% across the UK.

Ministers said Wales’ employment rate was also “relatively close” to its all-time high, but acknowledged that official labour market data should be treated with caution because of continuing concerns over reliability.

The figures come as the newly elected Welsh Government seeks to put productivity at the centre of its economic agenda.

A Welsh Government spokesperson said: “As a newly elected Government we are committed to driving investment, innovation and higher productivity across Wales.

“We have announced a National Productivity Goal to close the gap with the rest of the UK and help unlock the full potential of the Welsh economy.

“By focusing on productivity, we will deliver more jobs, higher pay, stronger businesses and thriving communities.”

The Government says the new goal will help shape the work of its planned Welsh innovation and development agency, including how it supports businesses, develops skills and invests in the wider economy.

However, ministers also said Wales’ labour market appears to be following similar trends to the UK as a whole.

They pointed to ongoing work by the Office for National Statistics to improve the quality of Labour Force Survey data, saying the figures should be read alongside other labour market indicators to get a clearer picture.

The Cabinet Minister for Enterprise, Connectivity and Energy, Adam Price, is seeking a meeting with the ONS to discuss the reliability of labour market data for Wales.

 

Continue Reading

News22 minutes ago

Motorcyclist, 22, dies in A4075 crash

A 22-year-old woman remains in hospital after two-vehicle collision A MOTORCYCLIST has died following a serious two-vehicle crash on the...

Community1 hour ago

Why police will be visiting every home in Pembrokeshire

New operation aims to knock on more than 257,000 doors across Dyfed-Powys over the next three years DYFED-POWYS POLICE has...

Crime4 hours ago

Prisons at breaking point: MPs warn Wales is paying the price of a failing system

Frozen healthcare budgets, overcrowded jails, homelessness on release and mounting pressure on staff are undermining rehabilitation across Wales, according to...

News18 hours ago

Brexit at 10: How Britain was sold a dream that cost us dearly

A decade after the referendum, the promised benefits remain hard to find while the economic costs are increasingly difficult to...

Crime19 hours ago

Worcestershire man jailed after violent attack on woman in Tenby

Defendant was already serving a suspended sentence when serious assault took place A WORCESTERSHIRE man has been jailed for more...

Climate21 hours ago

Offshore wind ‘could bring new generation of jobs to Milford Haven’

Pembrokeshire ports and Celtic Sea projects placed at centre of Wales’ green energy ambitions MILFORD HAVEN and Pembroke Dock could...

Community2 days ago

Police officer hailed hero after midnight sea rescue in Milford Haven

PC swam 100 metres offshore to save distressed woman heard calling for help in darkness A DYFED-POWYS POLICE officer has...

Local Government2 days ago

Security privately arranged by Mayor at Beating of the Bounds

HAVERFORDWEST TOWN COUNCIL has confirmed that security personnel seen at this year’s Beating of the Bounds were privately arranged and...

Business3 days ago

Celtic Freeport five-year plan puts Milford Haven at centre of green energy future

Strategy promises investment, skilled jobs and new supply chains, but major barriers remain over grid connections, planning and delivery THE...

Education3 days ago

Closure of Ysgol Clydau approved after emotional council debate

COUNCILLORS WARNED RURAL COMMUNITIES WILL REMEMBER DECISION PEMBROKESHIRE councillors have voted to close Ysgol Clydau following an emotional debate over...

Popular This Week