Politics
Westminster standards chief urges Senedd to heed public on recall system
A NEW recall system allowing voters to remove misbehaving Senedd politicians between elections must command public confidence, the UK’s standards watchdog has stressed.
Daniel Greenberg, the UK parliamentary standards commissioner, gave evidence as the Senedd scrutinised plans for Wales to follow in Westminster’s footsteps.
Under the recall bill, the Senedd would adopt a similar system – with some tweaks due to differing electoral systems – to one introduced in the House of Commons in 2015.
Mr Greenberg, who investigates MPs, told the Senedd’s newly formed accountability committee that the public view is “absolutely key” to the success of the new system.
However, appearing before the committee today (November 25), he said he had seen no evidence that the Recall of MPs Act has improved the conduct of politicians.
In Westminster, a ten-day suspension leads to a recall petition but the Welsh bill includes no detail of the triggers other than a custodial or suspended sentence of 12 months or less. Sentences of more than 12 months already lead to disqualification.
Mr Greenberg said the proposed approach of leaving the detail to recall guidance, to be issued by the Senedd’s standards committee, leads to flexibility but a lack of certainty and “perhaps a little bit of a lack of openness and transparency”.
But, on the other hand, he said a ten-day automatic trigger is inflexible, adding: “Whichever of the two options you choose has an inevitable upside and an inevitable downside.”
The lawyer argued the bill effectively puts off the challenge of steering between flexibility and certainty rather than addressing it within the proposed legislation itself.
He said: “This is a question of public confidence… The desire to have real trust between the body politic and the public is what underpins the entire standards system.”
Mr Greenberg stressed: “My views about whether a ten-day trigger is more or less effective are much less important than views that you will hear from members of the public.
“And I’m sure… you are inviting many members of the public and third-sector organisations to come and talk to you about their perception of the effectiveness of the standards regime.”
Senedd Members have taken evidence from the Welsh standards committee, commissioner Douglas Bain and the Electoral Commission. They will hear from the Commons standards committee and lawyers this week then conclude with evidence from ministers next week.

Asked about whether conduct such as sexual harassment or fraud should be automatic recall triggers, Mr Greenberg replied: “I do feel that the public are absolutely key here… and I’m not in a position to speak for them.”
He welcomed the introduction of “lay” members on Westminster’s standards committee – which has a 50:50 split, as well as voting parity, between independent and elected members.
Mr Greenberg said: “An independent element of the system is something that, I hope, very much enhances public trust… the only thing we are here to achieve.”
He also pointed to an independent expert panel which hears appeals and the Independent Complaints and Grievance Scheme – features lacking from Wales’ standards system.
“Independence is vital,” he told Senedd Members.
“I often say to MPs that, inevitably, one of the dangers of the standards system is that – from the public’s perspective – the necessary degree of self-regulation can risk a ‘well, you’re marking your own homework’ kind of allegation.”
Under the bill, the Welsh Parliament’s standards committee would introduce lay members for the first time with only a two-year cooling-off period before former Senedd Members can join.
Mr Greenberg raised the danger of the public perceiving former politicians as “reincarnated” rather than truly independent members despite the valuable experience they may bring.
He said: “I think this is something where the public view, which I’m sure you will acquire, really is worth much more than any view I might suggest.”
The bill also would see Wales follow Westminster’s lead by giving the Senedd’s standards commissioner “own-initiative” powers to start an investigation without needing a complaint.
Mr Greenberg, who already has such powers, said investigations must be subject to the same rigorous, evidential standards as opposed to “fishing expeditions”.
He told the committee: “In terms of overarching scrutiny… it is an important tool,” suggesting the additional flexibility enhances credibility and public confidence.
On appeals, he emphasised the importance of fairness and transparency, reminding Senedd Members of the legal principle that “justice must not purely be done but be seen to be done”.
News
Darts star Gerwyn Price backs Reform ahead of Senedd election
WELSH darts star Gerwyn Price has declared his support for Reform UK Wales ahead of the Senedd election next week.
Price, known to fans as “The Iceman”, has backed the party as voters prepare to go to the polls on Thursday, May 7.
The former world number one, who is from Markham, Caerphilly, made his views known on social media, writing: “Plaid is Labour so don’t be fooled… they will work together.”
He added: “We need change, we need Reform UK Wales.”
His comments come during a volatile election campaign in which Labour is facing pressure after more than two decades in power in Cardiff Bay, while Reform and Plaid Cymru are both hoping to make major gains.
Reform UK Wales leader Dan Thomas welcomed Price’s support, describing him as a “fellow Valleys boy”.
Mr Thomas said: “I’m chuffed to have fellow Valleys boy Gerwyn Price on board for our campaign.
“Communities like ours have been left behind by the political establishment, and now they are crying out for real change.
“Reform is the only party that can deliver that change.”
Price is one of Wales’ best-known sporting figures. He won the PDC World Championship in 2021 and has previously held the world number one ranking.
His public backing for Reform is likely to attract attention during the final days of the campaign, with all parties battling for votes under the new Senedd voting system.
Reform UK has been attempting to position itself as the party of political change in Wales, while Plaid Cymru and Labour have both strongly rejected suggestions that they represent the same politics.
Voters will elect members to the expanded 96-seat Senedd on Thursday, May 7.
News
Almost half of Welsh voters blame government policy for pub closures, polling finds
ALMOST half of Welsh voters blame national or local government when a pub closes, new research has found.
Polling carried out for the Long Live the Local campaign by More in Common found that 48% of people in Wales hold government policy partly responsible when a local pub shuts its doors.
Campaigners say the findings should act as a warning to politicians ahead of the Senedd election, with voters calling for greater support for pubs and brewers.
The survey found that almost one-third of Welsh voters, 32%, believe the single most important action government could take to help the sector would be to make business rates fairer for pubs.
The figures also suggest voters feel their elected representatives are not doing enough. Only one-in-ten said their MP had spoken up for the pub sector, while just 6% said their MP had done enough to protect pubs in their constituency.
The results come despite recent support for pubs from the UK Government, with campaigners warning that many voters still believe not enough is being done to protect Britain’s locals.
According to figures from the British Beer and Pub Association, one pub a day is currently closing in England and Wales, while the UK has lost 2,000 pubs since 2020.
Industry leaders say pubs are under pressure from a combination of business rates, employment costs, energy bills, beer duty, VAT and wider inflation. However, ministers have previously pointed to support measures for hospitality businesses, including rates relief and changes announced in the Budget, while arguing that difficult decisions must be balanced against wider public spending pressures.
Changing consumer habits, the cost-of-living crisis, and the long-term impact of the pandemic have also affected many pubs, particularly in rural and town-centre communities where footfall has not fully recovered.
‘Soul of the community’
Emma McClarkin, chief executive of the Welsh Beer and Pub Association, said: “Despite recent important support from the Government and the many MPs across all political parties that champion pubs and brewers, voters clearly believe that there is still more to be done.
“Pubs are the soul of the community, create jobs, and, with a quarter of a million people joining our Long Live the Local campaign that supports the people behind the pint, including thousands in Wales, it’s no wonder people care about them so much.
“What the public want is a fair tax system for pubs, one that keeps businesses competitive and recognises their unique role as valuable spaces for communities across the country.
“With the Senedd election right around the corner, it’s key for candidates to recognise just how important pubs are for so many and to back their local.
“We’re calling on both the UK and Welsh governments to continue to work with us and deliver permanent business rates reform, lower employment costs, cut beer duty and VAT to save countless locals who are burdened with huge regulatory costs.”
‘Public really care’
Luke Tryl, executive director at More in Common, said the polling showed the strength of public concern over pub closures.
He said: “One thing comes through really strongly in this polling, the British public really care about pubs, they think they are a central part of their community and they don’t think the Government is doing enough to protect them.
“In fact, over half of British voters blame national or local government for pub closures and want to see politicians at all levels doing more to stand up for them.
“At a time when the Government already finds itself struggling with a restless electorate, a wave of further pub closures will only reinforce the frustration that those in charge are unable or unwilling to deliver for local communities across Britain.
“On the flipside, taking action on issues like rates is one way the Government can show that it gets it, recognises the value of pubs and gets the public back onside.”
The Welsh Beer and Pub Association’s Long Live the Local campaign launched in 2018 to raise awareness of the UK’s rate of pub closures. It now has more than 250,000 supporters across the country.
The campaign says almost 40,000 letters were sent to MPs last year alone as part of efforts to raise concerns about the pressure facing pubs.
More in Common’s polling, commissioned by the British Beer and Pub Association, was conducted between March 28 and March 30, 2026, and sampled 2,003 adults across Great Britain. Respondents were weighted according to age, sex, region, ethnicity, 2024 General Election vote and education level.
Charity
Row erupts at Spitfire museum after Reform poster displayed at charity premises
A HAVERFORDWEST museum has become caught up in a political row after Reform UK campaign material was photographed inside the premises.
The Welsh Spitfire Museum, based in Bridge Street, is now facing the threat of a peaceful protest after campaigners objected to what they described as political propaganda being displayed at the heritage attraction.
A photograph sent to ‘The Pembrokeshire Herald’ shows a Reform Wales poster on a wall inside the museum, alongside other aviation-related material. The poster includes the words “Wales needs Reform” and urges people to vote Reform UK.
On Wednesday morning (April 29), museum manager Ray Burgess (pictured), received a message from a woman identifying herself as Emma Flavell, who informed him that campaigners were in the process of organising a peaceful protest outside the museum. In the message, she claimed the protest was aimed at stopping charitable organisations from being able to “openly advertise political agendas”.
She also alleged that Reform was an “extreme right wing party” and accused it of promoting division and racist policies.
Commenting on the escalating row Scott Thorley, the recently elected Reform county councillor and Haverfordwest town councillor, claimed the incident had ‘intimidated and bullied’ Mr Burgess.
“Emma Flavell called him a racist, she began filming him, and the irony is striking,” he said. “The museum window was previously defaced with ‘Vote Plaid’ graffiti, and then 80-year-old Ray Burgess was intimidated and bullied into supporting their views. This kind of behavior has more in common with fascism than with democracy.”
Cllr Thorley went on to say that Mr Burgess and his team at the Spitfire Museum ‘proudly support Reform’.
“They believe it’s the party best placed to save our country,” he said. “We at Reform, Ceredigion and Pembrokeshire stand firmly with him. There is no place in politics for bullying, intimidation and harassment.”
The Pembrokeshire Herald is unable to confirm whether Plaid Cymru was responsible for the alleged window defacement.
Meanwhile the incident has raised questions about whether political campaign material should be displayed in a charity-linked museum, particularly during an election period. According to a government website, the Charity Commission states that a charity must not support, oppose, promote or appear to promote any political party or candidate. This applies even if the charity strongly agrees or disagrees with that party’s policies.
The Commission also says that ‘charities must be, and must be seen to be, independent from party politics’.
-
Local Government6 days agoUnresolved building control record leaves buyer’s cottage unregistered
-
Crime6 days agoMan on trial over historic sex offence allegations
-
News6 days agoWaiting lists fall for ninth month — but cancer, A&E and ambulance pressures grow
-
News6 days agoKemi Badenoch warns over loss of industry during Valero visit
-
News4 days agoBarley Saturday brings bumper crowds to Cardigan
-
Local Government1 day agoFishguard children’s home application is a ‘legal test’, not planning merits decision
-
Climate7 days agoBid to turn Maidenwells field into garden is approved
-
Crime5 days agoHakin resident fined £1,330 over repeated noise and intimidation breaches








