Local Government
Dramatic U-turn: Full council to decide 2026 rent rises after Stoddart revolt
PEMBROKESHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL has executed a humiliating climbdown over who gets the final say on council house rents. Cabinet this morning formally agreed to hand the decision back to full council on 11 December, explicitly admitting that earlier legal advice – which said Cabinet could impose the rise alone – was wrong.
The reversal comes after weeks of fierce criticism led by Independent warhorse Cllr Mike Stoddart.
Cabinet member for Housing, Cllr Michelle Bateman, opened the crucial item at this morning’s (1 December) meeting with a candid admission that will delight backbench rebels.

“At the time of the Policy & Precepts Scrutiny Committee the advice was that this was a Cabinet decision,” she told members. “This advice has now changed, and today Cabinet are asked to make a recommendation to council for a decision at the December council.”
The climbdown ends a bitter row that erupted when senior officers first proposed that Cabinet alone should set rents for 2026–27, effectively sidelining the other 50-plus councillors who do not sit in the ruling group.
Independent councillor Mike Stoddart, who represents a ward with one of the highest proportions of council tenants in the county, led the fightback. He branded the original plan “a disgrace” at last month’s Scrutiny Committee and fired off a strongly-worded letter to the council’s Monitoring Officer warning that a Cabinet containing few or no members with significant numbers of council tenants could set rents with zero democratic accountability.
Speaking exclusively to The Pembrokeshire Herald minutes after Cabinet rubber-stamped the U-turn, Cllr Stoddart said: “I’m absolutely delighted that Cabinet has finally come round to my point of view. “It could never be right that members like me, with a high proportion of council tenants in their wards, should be deprived of any real say in the amount of rent their constituents were being called upon to pay. At Scrutiny I called it a disgrace that members were being denied the opportunity to determine their constituents’ rents, and I’m glad common sense has prevailed.”
Cabinet unanimously backed Cllr Bateman’s six recommendations, which now go forward to full council on 11 December. They are:
- A base “compliant” option: standard rents up by 3.6% plus up to £2.55 per week for any tenancy currently below the council’s target “standard rent”.
- Cllr Bateman’s preferred “aspirational” option (subject to Welsh Government dispensation): 4.3% across the board plus up to £5 per week on lower rents. Cabinet indicated support for pushing this higher figure.
- Garage rents to rise 4.3% from 1 April 2026.
- Properties upgraded to the highest energy ratings (EPC A or B) to move progressively to a new higher “improved homes” rent band, agreed case-by-case.
- All changes to be collected over 48 weeks, with existing tenancies starting 1 July 2026 and new ones from 1 April 2026.
- Minor drafting amendments allowed before full council.
Cllr Bateman told the meeting that Pembrokeshire’s historic rent anomalies – some identical properties differ by tens of pounds a week – combined with Welsh Government’s strict overall income cap, are preventing the authority from achieving fair “convergence” without falling behind other councils and housing associations.
She revealed she has already spoken directly to Wales’ Cabinet Secretary for Housing and that officers are in active talks seeking special dispensation to breach the income cap for at least 12 months.
Both the HRA Working Group and the Policy & Precepts Scrutiny Committee had backed the recommendations, she added.
The decision means every one of Pembrokeshire’s 60 councillors will now vote on exactly how much extra the county’s roughly 5,800 council tenants will pay from next spring – restoring the democratic link that Cllr Stoddart and others insisted must never be broken.
Reacting to the outcome, Cllr Stoddart said: “This was always about basic democracy. Council tenants deserve to know their local councillor still has a proper voice on their weekly budget – and today we’ve won that back.”
The Pembrokeshire Herald first revealed the controversial attempt to centralise rent-setting powers earlier this autumn, prompting the Scrutiny Committee showdown that ultimately forced today’s reversal.
Full council meets in December to make the final call.
Local Government
Clean-up after yacht wrecked on rocks at Lower Town, Fishguard
A YACHT that ran aground on rocks at Lower Town in Fishguard is being cleared by Pembrokeshire County Council after debris washed onto the shoreline.
Council officers attended the scene to assess the situation and begin removing wreckage after the vessel was found stranded among the rocks.
Heavy machinery was brought in to help clear debris from the beach, with workers seen dismantling parts of the damaged yacht and removing material that had scattered along the shoreline.
Pembrokeshire County Council confirmed it is aware of the incident and has issued a Notice to Mariners, warning of the potential presence of floating debris in the surrounding waters.
The notice advises vessels navigating in the area to exercise caution while clearance work continues.
No further details about how the yacht came to run aground have been released.
Cover pic:
Council workers clear debris from a yacht that ran aground at Lower Town, Fishguard.
Local Government
Petition calling for clean rivers policy wins unanimous support at County Hall
A PETITION calling for Pembrokeshire County Council to adopt a stronger Clean Rivers Policy has received unanimous support from councillors at County Hall.
The petition, backed by environmental campaigners and community groups, was presented during a meeting of the council on Thursday (Mar 6). Supporters in the public gallery applauded after councillors expressed their backing for the proposals.

The presentation was delivered by James Harrison-Allen, representing The Cleddau Project, a volunteer-led initiative focused on protecting and restoring the River Cleddau and its surrounding environment.
Campaigners said the atmosphere inside the council chamber was “extraordinary”, with councillors from across the political spectrum voicing support for improving river protection measures in Pembrokeshire.

The petition calls for the council to adopt a clearer policy aimed at improving water quality and tackling pollution affecting local rivers.
Supporters say pollution from multiple sources, including agricultural run-off and sewage discharges, has placed increasing pressure on rivers across Wales, including the Eastern and Western Cleddau.
Following the presentation, councillors backed the petition unanimously, prompting applause from members of the public and campaign supporters in attendance.
The campaign has drawn support from a number of environmental organisations including West Wales Rivers Trust, River Action UK, and the Campaign for National Parks.
Representatives from several organisations and public bodies were also acknowledged by campaigners, including Natural Resources Wales, Pembrokeshire Coast National Park Authority, and Dŵr Cymru Welsh Water, as well as local political representatives Henry Tufnell MP, Samuel Kurtz MS, and Paul Davies MS.
Campaigners say the decision marks an important step in raising awareness of river pollution issues affecting the Cleddau catchment and wider waterways across Pembrokeshire.
The Cleddau Project said the outcome was “a great day for the Cleddau” and praised the work of volunteers and supporters who have helped drive the campaign forward.
Education
Future of Pembrokeshire school destroyed by fire hangs in the balance
THE CLOCK is ticking on the future of Manorbier Church in Wales VC School as Pembrokeshire County Council debates a decision that could lead to the school’s permanent closure.
Dozens of parents, residents and campaigners gathered outside County Hall in Haverfordwest ahead of today’s meeting (Thursday, March 5), in a last-ditch effort to halt the proposed closure. Their placards read “Save our school” and “Rural schools matter”.
Inside, councillors sat debating the school’s future, which has served the community of Manorbier since January, 1877.
The council report outlines the results of a statutory consultation on a proposal to discontinue the school altogether. Councillors must now decide whether to proceed with the closure process, abandon the proposal, or significantly change the plan and consult again.
Fire and temporary classrooms
Manorbier School has been operating from Jameston Community Hall since the fire destroyed large parts of the original building in October, 2022.
The historic school building was already considered to be in poor condition before the blaze, according to the council report. Ownership of the building lies with the St Davids Diocesan Board of Finance.
Council officers argue that closing the school could represent better value for money, noting that nearby schools have spare capacity and that maintaining or rebuilding the facility may not be financially viable.
If councillors authorise the next stage, the Director of Education will publish a statutory notice proposing the discontinuation of the school, triggering a further 28-day objection period before a final decision is made.
Strong opposition from community
The consultation process revealed overwhelming opposition to the closure proposal.
A total of 252 responses were submitted, with more than ninety per cent opposing the plan to discontinue the school. A petition has also been submitted, signed by more than 1,500 people.
Many respondents described Manorbier as a small, nurturing school particularly suited to pupils who need additional support. Others warned that closure would damage the community and reduce the attractiveness of the area for young families.
Campaigners have also questioned the council’s financial arguments and believe insurance money from the fire should be used to rebuild the school.
Concerns were also raised about transport, with parents warning that narrow roads and longer journeys to alternative schools could create safety issues and undermine efforts to encourage sustainable travel.
However, a smaller number of respondents supported the proposal, arguing that pupils could benefit from larger schools with broader extracurricular opportunities and wider friendship groups.
Jobs also at risk
If the closure eventually goes ahead, staff positions at the school could be at risk of redundancy, although the council says efforts would be made to redeploy employees wherever possible.
Council officers maintain that discontinuing the school would provide a more sustainable model for education provision in the area, taking into account the condition of the buildings, available school places and overall value for money.
For parents protesting outside County Hall, however, the issue is about far more than finances.
They say losing the school would mean the loss of a vital community asset and could change the character of the village for generations to come.
The council is expected to decide whether to proceed with the statutory notice in the coming weeks. If it does, the final decision on the future of Manorbier School will return to councillors later this year after the objection period has concluded.
-
Community2 days agoWhitland Post Office re-opens under new management
-
Crime5 days agoNine deny Class A drugs conspiracy as case set for Crown Court trial
-
Health5 days agoWelsh Labour launches Senedd campaign with £4bn hospital pledge
-
Health4 days agoDavies and Kurtz attack ‘fantasy hospital’ pledge for west Wales
-
Sport5 days agoNew arrival celebrated at Bridge Meadow
-
Education5 days agoSchool in lockdown after reported phone threat
-
Crime5 days agoSchool lockdown lifted after telephone threat as police continue enquiries
-
Crime2 days agoMan who threatened to kill police during Milford Haven standoff avoids jail







