News
Committee rejects Ocky White sale price
COUNCILLORS have overwhelmingly stated they feel the sale price of £460,000 for the Ocky White building in Haverfordwest does not represent good value for money.
When it was agreed at a meeting of the Cabinet in September that the Council should go ahead with acquiring the building many people were left angry at the decision.
Three days later after that meeting, Cllrs Jacob Williams, Mike Stoddart, Viv Stoddart, Mike Evans, Pearl Llewellyn and Phil Kidney called in Cabinet’s decision saying it was poor value for taxpayers money and that it does not present the full financial picture.
The matter was then brought to an extraordinary meeting of the Services Overview and Scrutiny Committee held on Friday, September 28.
Before discussion took place members were presented with an option of discussing the matter in open session or in private as two documents had been classed as restricted.
Cllr Phil Kidney said he was ‘very keen’ for the matter to be held in open session as it was a ‘very large amount of money’.
The Councils’ Head of Legal Services Claire Incledon told members that the parties involved had asked for the documents to be restricted.
Cllr Jamie Adams said they had to respect those wishes and proposed that the meeting be held in open session and go into private session to discuss the restricted document if necessary. That was approved unanimously.
Cllr Jacob Williams said there hadn’t been much scrutiny at Cabinet and said it represented poor value to taxpayers. He also said that the price agreed of £460,000 was ‘vastly over the top’ and described it as ‘scandalous’.
He added: “The significance of the building is overhyped. It has a listed building as an annex and we would be rewarding a property owner of a not particularly attractive building with taxpayers’ money.
“I have not yet seen a positive public comment on this proposal. People say this will be a waste of millions of pounds, the purchase price is too high and there is a lot of resentment to the council spending £460,000 on the back of the 12.5% hike in council tax.
“People have said to me the price agreed is way too high, that it has been up for sale and attracted no interest and that it is worth a maximum of £100,000.”
Cllr Mike Stoddart added: “We are offering £460,000 spending £3m on it and ending up with asset of £750,000, even with the Welsh Government loan it is still a bad deal.”
Cllr Viv Stoddart explained that at a meeting of the strategic asset management group in July there were serious concerns that the figures didn’t stack up and called for the Cabinet to look at this again.
Cllr Mike Evans said that other than this committee they had no involvement in this decision and said once the building was purchased the rates on an empty building would be the councils to pick up. He also said there had been no interest in other buildings in the town and that rents in Haverfordwest had ‘fallen through the floor’.
Cllr Pearl Llewellyn said she had listened to people in her ward who were complaining about vacant buildings in Pembroke such as South Quay and added they had said it was nice to see that some councillors have had the balls to call this in.
Cabinet member Cllr Paul Miller said they had given much greater priority to supporting economy in Pembrokeshire and that the aspiration for Haverfordwest was much wider than this one building.
He added: “The acquisition of Ocky White shouldn’t be viewed in isolation, it is the proposed first step in future for Haverfordwest. The grant award is based on refurbishment and this is the option we have pursued so far.
“We need to buy this building to demonstrate our commitment to the wholesale plan for the redevelopment of the town centre.”
Cllr Jamie Adams said although the scheme had been in the offing for a long time he could not support the decision to invest in the building saying ‘it is incompatible with financial demands’.
Cllr Stephen Joseph said it did not make sense and said he couldn’t back it as it is ‘fundamentally flawed’ adding it was ‘bonkers’ at a time when everyone is feeling the pinch.
Cllr Di Clements added: “Just because Welsh Government money is available it doesn’t me we should go chasing it. This is taxpayers money, I am not sold on this and demolition is probably the way to go.”
She later added that they were being asked to make a ‘huge leap of faith’ as they did not know the final costs or if the building would be occupied.
Cllr Brian Hall said it was a ‘total waste of money’ while Cllr Tony Wilcox suggested the council should get another independent valuation on the building before having another long hard look at it.
Cllr David Pugh said: “Retailing has changed dramatically, just basing it on retail is not going to work. Business rents have dropped dramatically and there just isn’t the demand for it, I do sympathise, it is a huge problem and there isn’t an easy fix. Something needs to be done or we will just end up with another shambles.
“The revenue implications are huge and I really struggle to make sense of this acquisition, the price is far too high, it is not worth a penny and I can’t support spending £460,000 for a building where we don’t know what we’re going to find.”
Haverfordwest Cllr Tim Evans said a lot of these things should have been done 30 years ago but did not support the sale going ahead at the price mentioned.
Head of property Barry Cooke said he would not buy the building at that price saying it was too high but added that the owners won’t sell for anything less than that. “If we can’t acquire the property we will not able to proceed with first step. It is a difficult building to value but we did get them down to £450,000 but they have quoted more than that,” he added.
Cllr Williams went on to ask questions of where the £460,000 figure came from and described it as ‘really bad negotiation’ adding it was ‘very dodgy’ if they were to pay that price for the building.
Cllr Paul Miller explained that although Cabinet resolved to buy the building they would need to some further work on the masterplan.
He said: “If once we have done the work we decide we don’t need Ocky White, it needs to be demolished and we wouldn’t accept the grant and refurbish building.”
Cllr Stoddart said that wasn’t the impression the public got and said he did not want to see the authority with another Cherry Grove on its hands.
Summing up he said it was the view of the committee that there was no problem with the council buying the building but that there was a problem with the price.
Cllr Jamie Adams moved that the Committee does not support the decision of Cabinet due to inevitable ongoing revenue risk and that the purchase price offers poor value for this Council. It was seconded by Cllr Pugh and was passed by a majority with Cllr Alison Tudor voting against.
Charity
Lidl colleagues back Sandy Bear charity with community donation
Support for bereaved children among local causes chosen in Pembroke Dock
LIDL colleagues in Pembroke Dock have chosen a Pembrokeshire children’s bereavement charity to receive a community donation as part of the retailer’s expanded investment programme across Wales.
Staff at the store selected Sandy Bear Children’s Bereavement Charity as one of two local organisations to receive a £500 donation. The charity provides specialist support to children and young people up to the age of 25, helping them cope with loss and rebuild confidence.
Sandy Bear was chosen in recognition of its work supporting bereaved families across Pembrokeshire, including more than 20 families in the Pembroke area.
Ben Rees, shift manager at the Pembroke Dock store, said the scheme allows staff to support organisations making a real difference locally.
Martin Jones, business development manager at Sandy Bear, said: “Behind every child we support is a story of loss that no family should have to face alone. Support from local businesses like Lidl means we can continue to be there when families need us most, helping children understand their grief and find a way forward.”
Colleagues also selected Pembrokeshire and Carmarthen Mind, which provides mental health support through community programmes and wellbeing initiatives across the region.
The donations form part of Lidl GB’s wider community investment programme, which has supported more than 145 causes in Wales since 2022, contributing over £188,000 to local charities.
Alongside financial donations, charities linked to Lidl stores also receive support through the retailer’s ‘Feed it Back’ scheme, run in partnership with Neighbourly. The initiative redistributes surplus food, providing the equivalent of more than 2.3 million meals in Wales since 2016.
Lidl GB chief executive Ryan McDonnell said the programme empowers staff to support causes that matter most to their communities.
The retailer says its wider community work in Wales includes investment in initiatives such as its Foodies programme, which promotes healthy eating in schools and has reached more than 25,000 children across the country.
Health
Average of 18 deaths a week in Wales linked to A&E delays, figures reveal
NEARLY 1,000 deaths in Wales have been linked to long waits in accident and emergency departments, according to new data.
Figures published by the Royal College of Emergency Medicine (RCEM) estimate that 965 deaths in 2025 were associated with patients waiting 12 hours or more for care. That equates to around 18 deaths a week and marks an increase of 29 compared to 2024.
The RCEM has described the situation as a “tragedy” that should send shockwaves through the political system.
Dr Rob Perry, Vice President of RCEM in Wales, said his thoughts were with the families affected.
He said: “My heart goes out to the loved ones of anyone who died following long waits in emergency departments.
“These are often some of the most vulnerable patients — those who are seriously ill or injured and in need of urgent admission. They should be receiving timely care, but too often they are left waiting the longest.”
Dr Perry said the figures point to a wider failure across the healthcare system, highlighting a lack of hospital beds and what is known as “exit block” — where patients cannot be discharged due to delays elsewhere in the system.
He said improving patient flow through hospitals, rather than diverting people away from emergency departments, is key to tackling long waits.
With Senedd elections approaching, the RCEM is urging political parties to prioritise increasing hospital capacity and addressing overcrowding in emergency departments.
A Welsh Government spokesperson said too many people are still waiting too long for emergency care.
They said: “Long stays in emergency departments are distressing for patients and their families and can lead to poorer outcomes, particularly for older people and those with complex needs.
“We have made clear that health boards must improve patient flow, eliminate 12-hour waits and end care being delivered in temporary spaces.
“We are working with the NHS, local authorities and partners to reduce pressures by expanding community-based care and increasing social care capacity.
“We remain committed to improving outcomes for people who need emergency treatment.”
Community
Calls to block Withyhedge landfill expansion amid ‘worst in Wales’ claims
Campaigner and Senedd Member urge residents to respond as consultation deadline approaches
FRESH calls have been made to block the proposed expansion of Withyhedge Landfill, with residents warning that allowing further waste operations would be “outrageous” given the site’s recent track record.
Natural Resources Wales (NRW) is currently consulting on a permit variation application submitted by Resources Management UK Ltd (RML), which operates the Pembrokeshire site.
The consultation, which could allow the site to accept additional waste including up to 50,000 tonnes of “waste soils” per year, will remain open until Thursday (Mar 26).
The Herald has previously reported on ongoing issues at Withyhedge, including complaints of strong odours, gas emissions and concerns about potential health impacts in nearby communities.
In a formal objection submitted to NRW, long-time campaigner Colin Barnett said the regulator should not consider expanding the site while problems persist.
He said: “The public have had enough of ineffective regulation of Withyhedge Landfill by NRW’s hands-off minimal inspection process.
“We don’t want to breathe toxic gases from this landfill. We don’t want to be woken up in the night by poisonous gases trapped in our house and we don’t want to step out into our gardens to be chased inside from the insidious stink still being emitted from the pit of corruption.”
The objection raises concerns about the operator’s compliance record, claiming the site has been among the worst-performing permitted installations in Wales in recent years, with further issues identified following its reopening in 2025.
It also points to reported hydrogen sulphide emissions, which residents say have at times exceeded recognised odour guidelines and caused distress to those living nearby.
Barnett added: “RML, the waste company, will say they spent £10 million on resolving this problem. We would advise them to ask for their money back as we still get horrendous spikes of gas drifting into our communities.”
The proposed variation would also include revised restoration levels and changes to monitoring of groundwater, surface water and leachate.
However, objectors argue that the term “waste soils” is too vague and could include contaminated materials. Particular concern has also been raised about the site’s existing licence to accept asbestos and the potential risks of handling multiple hazardous waste streams.
Barnett said: “Of specific public concern is their request to tip asbestos on this site. Beggars belief.”
The objection also questions whether the permit process is being advanced ahead of any decision by Pembrokeshire County Council on increasing the site’s capacity.
Concerns have further been raised about what has been described as a “daisy chain” of companies linked to the site’s ownership, which objectors claim allows waste to be transported with limited oversight.
Barnett said: “The documents identify our concern with the ‘daisy chain’ of companies owned by David Neal that allow him to transport waste into our county with minimal inspection.”
Preseli Pembrokeshire MS Paul Davies has also urged residents to take part in the consultation, warning that local voices must be heard before any decision is made.
Mr Davies said: “This consultation is an important opportunity for residents to make their views known about the future of the Withyhedge landfill site.
“There have been ongoing concerns about the site’s environmental performance and its impact on local communities, and it’s vital that Natural Resources Wales hears directly from the people who live in the area.
“I have made clear to the Welsh Government that I believe the site should be looking towards closure rather than expansion, and that Pembrokeshire must not become a dumping ground for waste.
“I would strongly encourage residents to take part in the consultation and submit their views before the deadline.”
NRW’s consultation process is ongoing, and no final decision has yet been made.
The proposed changes are likely to intensify an already heated debate around Withyhedge, which has become one of the most contentious environmental issues in Pembrokeshire in recent years.
-
Crime6 days agoMother given community order after admitting child cruelty offence
-
Health5 days agoNHS waiting list falls — but cancer delays and diagnostic backlog worsen
-
News7 days agoSenedd votes to ban Greyhound racing in Wales to protect animal welfare
-
News7 days agoSenedd vote to ban greyhound racing hailed as ‘landmark moment’ by charities
-
News6 days agoReform secures first Pembrokeshire councillor in Hakin by-election win
-
Crime6 days agoWoman stole from pharmacy despite ban, court hears
-
News7 days agoCould Pembrokeshire hold the key to St Patrick’s lost birthplace?
-
Crime5 days agoIllegal workers found at Cardigan takeaway after immigration raid











