News
Fight for hospital services: Judicial review lost

CAMPAIGNERS fighting to retain services at Withybush Hospital have been dealt a huge blow. The judicial review has been lost.
Mr. Justice Hickinbottom has today, at The Cardiff High Court, handed down his judgement in respect of the judicial review by Anthony John Flatley and Hywel Dda University Health Board (The SWAT Judicial Review)
The 47 page document set out the reasons why the Judicial review brought by campaigners fighting to retain services had failed.

Justice Hickinbottom
Justice Hinkinbottom wrote: “I do not find any of the Claimants’ applications made good. For the avoidance of doubt, whilst I appreciate that the Claimants’ underlying concern and complaint is about the substance of the relevant decisions (a question with which I am not concerned), given that the question of whether a procedure adopted is fair is ultimately a question for the court I should say that, on the basis of the submissions and evidence before me, I am wholly unconvinced that any aspect of the procedure adopted by the LHB or the Minister was unfair, or unlawful.
The conclusion of the report continued: “For the reasons I have given, these claims fail. Formally, I make the following order: Permission to proceed is refused. The substantive application for judicial review is dismissed. The application to set aside the refusal of permission to proceed with the public sector equality duty ground is refused.”
The Justice added: “I dismiss the application for judicial review, and in respect of all other grounds, I refuse permission to proceed.”
Lead campaigner Dr Chris Overton, chairman of SWAT, said: “We must remember that this is not an endorsement of the Health Board and Health Ministers plans for service change. It was simply a legal argument on whether the Health Board followed the rules and on the powers of the Health Minister.”
Campaigner Lyn Neville told The Herald: “This is a blow but it is certainly not the end. We must all keep fighting, this is not over because of the Judgement today. The Judge said the procedures followed by the Health Board and Minister were not unfair or unlawful, it does not mean they weren’t wrong. Pembrokeshire people will still suffer, lives will be lost, we must now fight on Equality and Human Rights grounds. This is not over!”
Read the whole Judgement here: Judicial review judgement
Crime
Haverfordwest man jailed for seven years for historic rape and sexual assault of girl
A HAVERFORDWEST man has been jailed for seven years after being convicted of raping and indecently assaulting a girl during the 1980s.
Alan Pyart, aged 60, of North Court, Haverfordwest, was found guilty following a trial at Swansea Crown Court earlier this year.
Pyart had denied raping and indecently assaulting the victim, who was under the age of 16 at the time of the offences.
The case returned to court for sentencing after being adjourned for more than two months so that a further psychiatric report could be prepared.
Judge Geraint Walters sentenced Pyart to seven years in prison for rape and four years for indecent assault. The sentences will run concurrently, meaning he will serve an overall custodial term of seven years.
Pyart was also made subject to an indefinite restraining order and will remain on the sex offenders register for life.
He had previously been remanded in custody while awaiting sentence.
Reporting restrictions are in place which legally protect the identity of the victim.
Detective Inspector Sarah Totterdale, of Pembrokeshire CID, praised the victim for coming forward many years after the abuse took place.
She said the case demonstrated the lasting effect sexual abuse can have on victims and their families, adding that it was never too late to seek justice.
DI Totterdale said: “I would like to commend the victim for the immense courage she has shown in coming forward and speaking about what happened to her all those years ago.
“Abuse of this nature can leave deep and long-lasting scars, but it is never too late to seek justice.
“We hope this conviction and sentence sends a clear message that Dyfed-Powys Police will pursue offenders, no matter how much time has passed.”
She encouraged anyone who has experienced sexual abuse, either recently or in the past, to contact police, saying they would be listened to, supported and taken seriously.
Information about reporting rape and sexual assault, as well as details of available support services, can be found through the Dyfed-Powys Police website.
Community
Goodwick Sea Scouts spruce up headquarters ahead of Wales in Bloom judging
GOODWICK Sea Scout Group has praised its young members, leaders and volunteers after they helped brighten up the area outside the group’s headquarters.
The team rolled up their sleeves ahead of the town’s recent Wales in Bloom judging, clearing overgrown vegetation and transforming an old boat into an eye-catching flower bed filled with colourful plants.
The group said the work had made a real difference to the front of the hall and thanked everyone who gave their time to help.

A spokesperson said: “Our Scout group worked hard to tidy up the front of our hall in time for the town’s Wales in Bloom judging.
“Well done to all the young people, leaders and volunteers who helped.”
The group is now hoping to build on the improvements and would like to hear from anyone with gardening experience who could volunteer to help care for the land surrounding the hall.
Anyone interested in lending a hand is encouraged to contact Goodwick Sea Scout Group directly.
News
Burnham more willing to listen on Welsh devolution, says First Minister
Rhun ap Iorwerth says he will press the new Prime Minister for powers over policing, railways and Wales’ natural resources when the two leaders meet.
FIRST MINISTER Rhun ap Iorwerth has said he believes Andy Burnham is more willing to listen to Wales’ demands for further devolution than his predecessor, Sir Keir Starmer.
The Plaid Cymru leader is expected to hold an introductory meeting with the new Prime Minister on Thursday, following a telephone conversation between the pair earlier this week.
Mr ap Iorwerth said he hoped the change in leadership at Westminster would provide an opportunity to take Welsh devolution to the “next level”.

Speaking to BBC Radio 4’s Today programme on Wednesday, he said: “I had a conversation with Andy Burnham yesterday, congratulated him on becoming Prime Minister, and we both made it clear to each other that we wanted to have a positive relationship, a constructive relationship.
“I know that he understands devolution for Manchester. I want to help him understand what devolution means in Wales and what tools we need to make it work better.”
The First Minister said his government had been elected with a mandate to seek greater control over policing and justice, rail services and funding, as well as Wales’ natural resources.
He said: “There is a list, if you like, of things that we need to devolve now in order to move the story of Wales, the story of devolution, on to the next level.
“It’s clear that we now have a Prime Minister who is open to listening, perhaps in a way that Keir Starmer wasn’t, and I’m eager to do everything that I can to make the case for Wales.”
A planned meeting between Mr ap Iorwerth and Sir Keir failed to take place before the former Prime Minister left office, with the First Minister previously blaming “chaos in Westminster”.
Plaid Cymru formed the Welsh Government in May after ending more than two decades of Welsh Labour rule at the Senedd election.
Mr Burnham has extensive experience of devolved government after serving as Mayor of Greater Manchester, where he repeatedly called for greater powers and funding to be transferred away from Westminster.
However, the new Prime Minister has sought to play down the prospect of major constitutional reform.
During conversations with the leaders of Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland on Tuesday, Mr Burnham said his immediate focus would be on “practical measures” rather than constitutional changes or further independence referendums.
Mr ap Iorwerth supports Welsh independence but has said his government will not seek to hold an independence referendum during its first term.
Thursday’s meeting is expected to focus on the working relationship between the Welsh and UK governments, as well as funding, transport and the future balance of devolved powers.
-
Crime19 hours agoDrunken rail passenger tried to headbutt police after being refused travel
-
featured2 days agoFrom a father-and-son project to an award-winning campervan business
-
Crime18 hours agoWomen jailed after man chased through Milford home and attacked with knives
-
Community2 days agoHousehold Cavalry drum horse returns home to Pembrokeshire for final farewell
-
News13 hours agoBurnham more willing to listen on Welsh devolution, says First Minister
-
Entertainment2 days agoRobin Hood: A magical show by young talent at The Torch Theatre
-
Crime9 hours agoHaverfordwest man jailed for seven years for historic rape and sexual assault of girl
-
Crime19 hours agoMother headbutted and clawed police officers after threatening social worker








Peter Warrender
July 10, 2014 at 11:01 am
Justice Hinkinbottom wrote: “I do not find any of the Claimants’ applications made good. For the avoidance of doubt, whilst I appreciate that the Claimants’ underlying concern and complaint is about the substance of the relevant decisions (a question with which I am not concerned), given that the question of whether a procedure adopted is fair is ultimately a question for the court I should say that, on the basis of the submissions and evidence before me, I am wholly unconvinced that any aspect of the procedure adopted by the LHB or the Minister was unfair, or unlawful.
The conclusion of the report continued: “For the reasons I have given, these claims fail. Formally, I make the following order: Permission to proceed is refused. The substantive application for judicial review is dismissed. The application to set aside the refusal of permission to proceed with the public sector equality duty ground is refused.”
The Justice added: “I dismiss the application for judicial review, and in respect of all other grounds, I refuse permission to proceed.”
Is he on drugs?
Naomi Wadw-Jones.
July 10, 2014 at 11:29 am
STUNNED, at this minute I cannot say anymore.
vicky moller
July 11, 2014 at 12:01 am
we must fight on, as the editorial says.
Ideas?