Crime
How the Post Office Horizon scandal profoundly impacted lives across Wales
IT’S a story etched by systemic shortcomings and individual resilience. And thanks to the recent ITV drama “Mr Bates vs the Post Office” its one which we all now know. The Post Office Horizon scandal has profoundly impacted lives across Wales and beyond, entangling figures like Tim Brentnall from Pembrokeshire and Lorraine Williams from Llanddaniel, Anglesey. Their experiences, are similar despite taking place on opposite ends of Wales. They are unified by a shared ordeal of injustice and a relentless pursuit for redemption – Tom Sinclair reports.
Tim Brentnall, a young entrepreneur from Roch, Pembrokeshire, saw his aspirations crumble when an audit in 2009 revealed a £22,000 shortfall at his post office branch. This led to a chain of events that upended his life. Despite no evidence of wrongdoing, the pressure to resolve the discrepancy saw Tim’s family take out a loan to cover the supposed shortfall, only for him to be prosecuted and advised to plead guilty. This resulted in an 18-month suspended sentence and 200 hours of community service. The guilt plea, made under distressing circumstances, cast a long shadow over Tim’s life, leading to social ostracization and personal turmoil.
In a parallel ordeal, Lorraine Williams from Llanddaniel, Anglesey, faced a similar plight. A cornerstone of her community, Lorraine’s world was turned upside down when she was wrongly accused of stealing over £14,600. Coerced into pleading guilty to false accounting to avoid more severe charges, she too received an 18-month suspended sentence and 200 hours of community service. Her conviction shattered her standing in the community she had served so selflessly.
Central to both Tim’s and Lorraine’s stories is the figure of Stephen Bradshaw, the Post Office investigator whose methods in pursuing these cases have been heavily scrutinized. Bradshaw, known for his pugnacious determination, played a pivotal role in the investigation, often refusing to consider the possibility of innocence or the potential flaws in the Horizon system. His appearance during the Post Office scandal inquiry and his portrayal in the TV drama have highlighted his aggressive approach and unwavering stance in these investigations.
In addition to his inability to comprehend the complexities of the Horizon system, he was evasive about his bonus arrangements. This evasiveness further underlines the corrupt practices that have marred the integrity of the Post Office’s management.
Bradshaw’s actions, particularly his single-minded pursuit of convictions and repayment of alleged debts, have drawn comparisons to those of a ‘mafia gangster’, a term used by some to describe his behavior. Despite these accusations, Bradshaw maintained that his investigations were conducted professionally and that he was simply following orders to defend the Horizon system. His lack of technical expertise, as he admitted to not being “technically minded,” raised questions about his ability to fairly assess the situations he was investigating.
The experiences of Tim and Lorraine, along with those of hundreds of other sub-postmasters, culminated in the quashing of their convictions in April 2021, marking a significant step in rectifying this miscarriage of justice. Their stories, part of a wider narrative involving 736 wrongfully prosecuted individuals, underscore the most extensive legal misstep in UK history.
As the independent inquiry into the scandal continues, the focus on Tim’s and Lorraine’s experiences, and the role of figures like Stephen Bradshaw, brings to light the intricate interplay of personal suffering, technological failures, and institutional accountability. This scandal serves as a stark reminder of the necessity for transparency and responsibility in corporate and government systems, and the dire consequences when these are neglected.
In the aftermath of these events, the resilience of Tim Brentnall, Lorraine Williams, and others like them stands as a testament to the human spirit’s capacity to endure and seek justice in the face of overwhelming odds. Their stories, extending beyond Pembrokeshire and Anglesey, highlight the urgent need for vigilance and reform in institutions that are entrusted with public service. As they reclaim their dignity and continue to advocate for accountability, their experiences serve as a poignant reminder of the enduring impact of systemic failings and the importance of upholding justice for all.
Crime
Sex offender jailed for breaching court order
A SEX offender from Wolfscastle has been jailed after using fake names on WhatsApp and attempting to access a social media app, breaching his sexual harm prevention order (SHPO).
Luke Rogers, 38, was sentenced to 10 months in prison at Swansea Crown Court after pleading guilty to two breaches of the order, which was imposed following his 2020 conviction for sexual activity with a child.
Under the SHPO, Rogers was prohibited from using unregistered internet-enabled devices or creating online profiles under false names. Prosecutor Ryan Bowen told the court that police monitoring software installed on Rogers’ phone detected activity in group chats under three aliases last November.
Further investigation revealed Rogers had also searched for the MeetMe app on four occasions and admitted using it. Rogers, described by Mr. Bowen as “apologetic,” was arrested, and his phone was seized.
The court heard Rogers has a history of 17 convictions for 35 offences, including breaching court orders and failing to comply with sex offender notification requirements.
Defence barrister Olivia Rose said Rogers had cooperated fully with police and expressed a desire to change. She argued that his breaches stemmed from a misunderstanding about permitted names and emphasized his efforts to seek support.
Despite these mitigating factors, Judge Catherine Richards noted Rogers’ pattern of reoffending and stated: “The reality is I can only pass an immediate custodial sentence.”
She expressed hope that Rogers would take advantage of post-sentence supervision to break the cycle of offending.
Crime
Police renew appeal to find Darren Markes from Pembroke Dock
POLICE in Pembrokeshire are renewing their appeal for information to locate Darren Markes, 46, from Pembroke Dock. He is wanted in connection with a domestic assault.
Markes is believed to have links to the Portsmouth and Sussex areas.
If you have seen Darren Markes or have any information about his whereabouts, please contact the police through one of the following methods:
- Online: https://bit.ly/DPPContactOnline
- Email: [email protected]
- Phone: 101
You can also provide information anonymously via Crimestoppers:
- Phone: 0800 555 111
- Website: crimestoppers-uk.org
Please quote reference number 24*944729 when providing information.
Crime
Triple killer sentenced to life for brutal murder of Wendy Buckney
TRIPLE KILLER Brian Whitelock, 57, has been sentenced to life imprisonment without parole for the savage murder of 71-year-old Wendy Buckney. The sentencing took place at Swansea Crown Court, with His Honourable Justice Griffiths describing the crime as of “exceptionally high seriousness.”
Whitelock, who was previously convicted of killing two men, including his brother, in 2001, carried out the brutal attack in August 2022 at Ms. Buckney’s home on Tanycoed Road, Clydach, Swansea. The court heard how Whitelock used a knife, a table leg, and shelving to inflict a “sustained and vicious” assault, leaving his victim with multiple blunt and sharp force injuries. Justice Griffiths revealed there were “too many stab wounds for the pathologist to accurately count.”
‘Monster’ trusted by his victim
Ms. Buckney, a retired horse riding instructor, had been living in the flat since 2018 and was described as a kind and generous neighbour. She had employed Whitelock, her neighbour since 2019, for odd jobs despite her family’s concerns about his violent past. Her response to their warnings was: “Everybody deserves a second chance.”
On the night of the murder, Whitelock stripped both himself and his victim, leaving Ms. Buckney’s body naked and face down on the floor. Her home was ransacked, and objects and clothing were placed on her body in what prosecutors described as a degrading act.
In a 999 call following the attack, Whitelock admitted to the killing, saying: “I just snapped, there’s no reason I killed her.” However, Justice Griffiths dismissed any claim of diminished responsibility, stating: “You knew what you were doing. She was old, vulnerable, and alone at home at night. She trusted you as a friend.”
Family devastated by loss
Ms. Buckney’s family paid tribute to her, describing her as having “a heart of gold.” In a statement, they said: “We all adored her. Wendy had a close bond with her family and loved her animals. She was taken from us in such a horrible way, at the hands of the man she helped.”
Her sister added: “We had a wonderful life together as sisters, and the bond between us can never be broken.”
A history of violence
Whitelock’s violent past began in October 2000 when he killed Nicky Morgan, 34, during a drink and drug-fuelled argument. He beat Mr. Morgan to death with a hammer and set the house on fire to cover up the crime. Whitelock’s brother, Glenn, who was asleep upstairs, died from smoke inhalation. Whitelock served 18 years in prison for these crimes and was released on licence, only to breach his conditions and be briefly recalled to prison. He was released again in 2021.
Melanie Huxley, the sister of Nicky Morgan, expressed her anger at Whitelock’s release: “He should never have been released from prison. We always knew he would kill again.”
Life without parole
At the sentencing, Justice Griffiths told Whitelock: “For the murder of Wendy Buckney, I sentence you to imprisonment for life. The seriousness of this murder is so exceptionally high that the punishment is for you to stay in prison for the rest of your life. You will never be considered for parole.”
Addressing Ms. Buckney’s grieving family, Justice Griffiths added: “I hope in the passage of time, you can think of her, in her 71 years of life. I hope that eventually you will be left with all those memories that you and she would want to have.”
Whitelock’s crimes have left a lasting impact on the families of his victims, with the sentence reflecting the gravity of his actions. Justice Griffiths’ ruling ensures Whitelock will spend the rest of his life behind bars, bringing a measure of justice for those affected by his heinous crimes.
Detective Chief Inspector Matt Davies said: “We are pleased that Brian Whitelock has been given a full-life tariff, which is a fitting sentence due to the countless lives that have been destroyed because of his actions.
“Despite his past, Brian Whitelock received nothing but kindness from his neighbour Wendy Buckney. He repaid this kindness by carrying out her senseless murder.
“The level of violence Brian Whitelock enacted upon his defenceless victim was sickening.
“Defending himself in court, Brian Whitelock’s aim was to distance himself from his actions, but the reality is that he was well-aware what he was doing.
“Wendy Buckney’s family has been through an unimaginable amount of pain and heartbreak because of the actions of Brian Whitelock. I hope, because of today’s sentencing, that they can finally feel closure, and can begin grieving the loss of Wendy.”
-
News6 hours ago
Ferry accident causes delay on new Dublin-Fishguard route
-
Top News5 days ago
Pembrokeshire man jailed after repeatedly punching pregnant wife
-
Top News4 days ago
Police investigate dogs seen persistently chasing sheep on Pembrokeshire airfield
-
News5 days ago
Dyfed-Powys Police launches attempted murder investigation
-
News5 days ago
Heroes of the storm: How Council workers rallied during rare red wind warning
-
Business6 days ago
Ferry traffic surges at Pembroke Dock due to Holyhead closure
-
Farming7 days ago
Call for Pembrokeshire to oppose farming inheritance tax withdrawn
-
Top News4 days ago
Milford man dealt ‘persistent’ blows on girlfriend after urinating in flat