Crime

A watershed moment for the criminal justice system?

Published

1 year ago

February 18, 2025

THE FINDINGS of the Ministry of Justice’s Independent Sentencing Review Report could mark a turning point in the future of Britain’s criminal justice system, according to Nacro CEO Campbell Robb.

The report, published on Tuesday (Feb 18), argues that successive governments’ “tough on crime” stance has contributed to the ongoing prison overcrowding crisis, which has brought the system “to the brink of collapse.”

Prison overcrowding at crisis point

The UK’s prison population now exceeds 85,000, a figure the report describes as symptomatic of a justice system prioritising punishment over evidence-based intervention. According to Nacro, research shows that community-based sentencing and investment in support services are more effective at reducing reoffending, yet government policies have continued to rely on longer custodial sentences as a default response.

Robb said: “This is a pivotal moment for justice reform. If we’re truly committed to a fair and effective system, we must shift away from the illusion of quick fixes and tough sentences and focus on building a system that rehabilitates and reintegrates people.”

Decades of flawed policies

Chair of the Independent Sentencing Review, David Gauke, criticised the “haphazard policy making and underinvestment” that has plagued the justice system for decades.

“For too long politicians have operated in a vacuum, increasing sentencing for individual crimes without considering the knock-on impact on the wider system. It is time to accept this does not deliver justice for victims; it fails them,” he said.

Academics contributing to the report have identified the 1991 Criminal Justice Act as a key turning point in the shift towards “penal populism,” in which political pressure has led to increasingly severe sentencing policies. Measures such as mandatory minimum sentences, extended terms for specific offences, and recall policies have inflated the prison population, with little evidence that they contribute to crime reduction.

Is prison the right answer?

According to the review, those given custodial sentences have some of the highest reoffending rates, with overall reoffending for ex-prisoners standing at 37.2%. For offenders serving short sentences of under 12 months, this rises to 56.9%. By contrast, community sentences and rehabilitation orders have been shown to be more effective at reducing reoffending.

Gauke stressed the need for an “honest conversation” about sentencing, stating: “Punishment will always be a central aim of the criminal justice system, but it is not the only aim; and prison is not the only form of punishment.”

Alongside the trend of longer sentences, the growing use of recall has significantly increased the prison population. In 1993, fewer than 100 people were in prison due to recall; by the end of 2024, this number had risen to nearly 13,000.

The review notes that changes such as mandatory post-release supervision for short sentences, combined with a more risk-averse probation service, have fuelled this surge.

The Independent Sentencing Review will release its full proposals for reform in the spring, calling for a “system reset” that aligns with all five statutory aims of sentencing: punishment, crime reduction, reform and rehabilitation, public protection, and reparation.

Crime

Former Swansea Prison inmate died 48 hours after release

Published

20 hours ago

June 26, 2026

Tom Sinclair

A FORMER Swansea Prison inmate died from combined drug toxicity just 48 hours after being released, an official investigation has found.

Jason Maynard, 43, left HMP Swansea on May 23, 2024. Two days later, he was pronounced dead by paramedics after being found unresponsive in the back of a friend’s car.

The Prisons and Probation Ombudsman report says Mr Maynard had been given overdose-reversal medication before leaving custody and warned about the heightened risk of overdose after a period of reduced drug tolerance.

After his release, he attended his first probation appointment and was placed in temporary hotel accommodation by Swansea Council.

The following day, police were called after concerns were raised that Mr Maynard had a cut above his eye and appeared incoherent. He refused hospital treatment and was taken to his mother’s home.

The report says he later used drugs and drank alcohol with friends. He then fell asleep in a car outside an address, where he was later found unresponsive.

Mr Maynard had missed a substance misuse appointment on May 24 but attended the service the next day. Staff noted he had “blue around his mouth”, which caused concern about possible drug use.

The Ombudsman found that prison, probation and support services had taken appropriate steps before and after his release.

Its findings said Mr Maynard had received suitable substance misuse support, had been referred for accommodation, and had licence conditions in place covering drug and alcohol use, engagement with services and drug testing.

The report concluded that the necessary referrals and support arrangements had been made, but Mr Maynard died later the same day he attended the community substance misuse service.

Crime

Police appeal after reported rape at Young Farmers rally

Published

2 days ago

June 25, 2026

Tom Sinclair

POLICE are appealing for witnesses after an allegation of rape at a Young Farmers Club rally in Builth Wells.

Dyfed-Powys Police said the incident was reported to have taken place at Wernhalog Farm on Saturday, June 13.

Officers said it happened in the portaloo area sometime between 11:00pm and 11:45pm.

Anyone who witnessed anything, or who has information which could help the investigation, is asked to contact police.

Reports can be made online through the Dyfed-Powys Police website, by emailing [email protected], or by calling 101.

Information can also be given anonymously to Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or through the Crimestoppers website.

Quote reference: 26*472649.

Crime

Dock woman given mental health treatment order after supermarket thefts

Published

3 days ago

June 24, 2026

Sarah Jane Absalom

A PEMBROKE DOCK woman has been placed on a mental health treatment requirement after repeatedly stealing meat, cheese and other grocery items from local supermarkets.

Lisa Stewart, 45, admitted three theft offences when she appeared before Haverfordwest Magistrates’ Court this week.

The first offence took place on March 11, when Stewart stole Vanish, Lenor and three packs of Persil capsules from Home Bargains in Pembroke Dock, with a total value of £58.41.

The following month, she stole four small beef joints, four steaks and three blocks of cheese from Asda in Pembroke Dock, worth £55.68.

Seven days later, she stole four legs of lamb from Farmfoods in Pembroke Dock, valued at £99.96.

Stewart, of Truscott House, London Road, Pembroke Dock, also pleaded guilty to failing to surrender to police bail on or around May 26.

She was represented in court by solicitor Alaw Harries, who told magistrates the thefts involved items of relatively low value and were not the result of “sophisticated offending”.

“The defendant has had an exceptionally difficult time, as last year she lost her partner to cancer and has struggled profoundly to process that grief,” said Ms Harries.

“Instead, she has attempted to cope by taking more of her prescribed medication than she should. And this is what has led her to be here today.”

Ms Harries said Stewart is now motivated to address her issues.

Magistrates sentenced Stewart to an 18-month community order. She must complete 15 rehabilitation activity requirement days, a 12-month mental health treatment requirement and a 12-month drug rehabilitation requirement.

The order will include monthly reviews in court.