Politics
Calls for £10,000 cap on donations after Vaughan Gething row
CAMPAIGNERS have called for a £10,000 cap on political donations following controversy over a £200,000 donation that led to the downfall of former First Minister Vaughan Gething.
Mr Gething, who broke no rules, was forced to stand down after accepting the donation from a convicted polluter’s company during the 2024 Welsh Labour leadership race.
Before resigning, the former First Minister – who outspent rival Jeremy Miles by £254,600 to £61,800 – urged the Senedd’s standards committee to look into reforming donation rules.
Now, in evidence to the committee’s resulting inquiry, witnesses have warned a lack of limits on donations, and a high threshold for reporting, risk damaging public confidence.
Transparency International UK, an anti-corruption nonprofit organisation, said the row over the £200,000 donation has correlated with low levels of trust in the Welsh Government.
The group called for a £10,000 cap on contributions to candidates standing in internal elections from any individual or organisation, with limits on how much can be spent.
Transparency International told members of the standards committee: “The Vaughan Gething case also raised questions about the legitimacy of the donations received.
“Some were linked to criminal investigations and convictions. When a politician is seen to receive contributions from those connected with wrongdoing, it undermines public trust.
“Candidates and parties should do more to ensure the legitimacy of donations they receive.”
Only 24% of people believe party funding is transparent, according to a 2023 Electoral Commission survey on public perception of political campaign finances.
Transparency International and the Electoral Reform Society (ERS) Cymru criticised the £2,230 threshold for reporting donations, arguing it is too high by international standards.
ERS Cymru warned: “Whilst there are limits on spending, there are currently no limits on donations. This creates a space for individual, corporate or other interests to have an outsized impact on the financial flows to parties and candidates.
“Both the total amount of political donations and the size of donations has been increasing.”
The UK’s committee on standards in public life recommended a donation limit of £10,000 in an effort to “end the big donor culture” in 2011.
In its evidence, ERS Cymru said: “Whether it’s parties or candidates, reliance on a small number of wealthy donations can distort politics and open up the potential for corruption.
“A donations limit is not only better for preventing undue influence but protects political parties and representatives from risky fundraising behaviours.”
But Douglas Bain, the Senedd’s standards commissioner who investigates complaints against politicians, opposed a cap on donations from any one individual or entity.
He wrote: “Unless such a provision was supported by detailed rules, it would be easy to avoid and so would serve no purpose.
“It appears to me that a variation of the rules depending on the source of the donation would introduce unnecessary complexity and would also be straightforward to avoid.”

Public Affairs Cymru, a membership organisation for lobbyists, supported the status quo, expressing concerns that lower reporting thresholds could become overly burdensome.
Its executive committee warned a politician may have to declare the value of a single Welsh cake at an event if rules were tightened too much, creating a barrier to open engagement.
ERS Cymru called for the introduction of a lobbying register to address a “clear gap” ahead of the May 2026 election, bringing the Senedd in line with Scotland and the UK.
The campaigners warned: “The lack of mandatory record keeping and strong guidance risks inconsistency between members when capturing information around meetings.
“Given the guidance also does not require the publication of such information, there is a lack of transparency for the public who have no way of accessing information.”
Transparency International echoed calls for a register, “the most effective way to create the right incentives for appropriate behaviour and the sanctioning power to prevent abuses”.
The Senedd’s standards committee, which is made up of politicians from the three main parties, has resisted calls to introduce a statutory lobbying register over the past decade.
The committee will consider the next steps during a private meeting on September 16.
Local History
St Dogmaels chapel empty since 1993 to become home
PLANS to convert a former Pembrokeshire chapel, empty for more than three decades, to a home have been approved.
In an application submitted to Pembrokeshire Coast National Park, through agent Preseli Planning Ltd, Chris Jones and Sarah Lloyd sought permission for a change of use of the former Capel Bryn Salem chapel, Cippyn, St Dogmaels, to a dwelling, along with the installation of private foul water system and associated works.
The 1850-built independent chapel, some 1.5km from Poppit Sands, had fallen into disuse by 1993, but remains in a “generally intact and in a sound condition,” a supporting statement says.
It added: “Based on the fact that the building has been disused for at least 32 years it can be concluded that there is no longer a community need for the facility.”
The statement went on to say: “The building is largely intact, and the proposal mirrors its existing form. The scheme is sympathetic to the character and appearance of the existing building and would include comparatively minor works of re-roofing (maintaining the existing pitch and appearance).”
It finished: “It has been demonstrated that the retention of the building for community or commercial uses would not be viable. The proposed dwelling would contribute to the housing stock and accord with the strategy of the LDP2, to prioritise open market housing over holiday accommodation.
“The proposal would also contribute towards the provision of affordable housing through a commuted sum in line [with adopted policy].
“Furthermore, the proposed scheme is sympathetic to the character and appearance of the building and its setting and results in an appropriate and attractive form of development.”
The application was supported by St Dogmaels Community Council but concerns by members of the public were raised including the suitability of the existing access track and bridleway to serve a residential building and other access and highways issues, as well as impacts on neighbours and the effect of the proposal on the historic character of the former chapel and the surrounding landscape and potential land ownership issues.
An officer report recommending approval said: “During the determination of the application, amended plans and additional supporting information were submitted, including a revised Transport Management Plan, amended access arrangements, additional passing opportunities, ecological information and revised drainage details. These amendments were subject to further consultation.”
It added: “Whilst officers acknowledge the concerns expressed by neighbouring residents, matters relating to private legal rights, ownership of land, easements and other civil matters fall outside the remit of the planning system.”
The application was conditionally approved.
Business
St Davids family-friendly coffee bar approved
PLANS to change a former hairdressing salon in Pembrokeshire’s only city to a family-friendly coffee bar have been approved by the national park.
In an application to Pembrokeshire Coast National Park, Gerallt Nash sought permission for a change of use of 26 High Street, St Davids from a hairdressing salon to a family friendly coffee bar and children’s playroom.
The first floor, formerly used as accommodation of a tenant, would be used as an office and storage of business.
A supporting statement said: “It is proposed to open a family-friendly coffee bar with a children’s playroom on ground floor. It is not intended to cook food on the premises, therefore there will be no requirement for an extractor system.
“Other than small scale repairs to part of one floor, and the installation of a sink and serving counter in the inner room (plumbing and electrics are already in place since its last use as a salon) the main work will be the redecoration of surfaces and ceilings, the provision of new light fittings and laying of new floor coverings.
“This part of High Street has been identified as a ‘commercial’ zone by PCNPA. Existing businesses close to No 26 include outdoor and surfing outlets; restaurants; clothes shops; holiday accommodation; ice cream parlour; fish and chips outlet; delicatessen and craft shops.
“The current proposal would fill a gap in the market, as most food outlets do not open until after 11am or 12pm, or only during the evenings in some cases. It would also provide somewhere for [young] families to go to unwind whilst their children can relax in the playroom.”
The scheme was supported by St Davids City Council but one representation from a member of the public raised concerns about potential noise, smells and risk of vermin from waste storage on site.
An officer report said the county council’s public protection team has been consulted and has no objections to raise, adding the application states there is no intention to cook on the premises; the opening hours listed as 8am-6pm, Monday to Friday, and 8am-7pm on Saturdays.
In recommending approval, it said: “There are no concerns in relation to significant impacts upon amenity, subject to a condition relating to opening hours, and it is not considered that the proposal would have an impact upon the character or appearance of the St David’s Conservation Area.”
The application was conditionally approved.
News
Burnham sweeps aside Starmer allies in major Cabinet reshuffle
Rayner, Healey and Miliband handed senior roles as Reeves, Lammy and Stevens leave government
PRIME MINISTER Andy Burnham has announced a further wave of Cabinet appointments, bringing Angela Rayner back into government and handing senior roles to Lucy Powell, Jonathan Reynolds and close political ally Anneliese Midgley.
The latest announcements confirm that Burnham is carrying out a significant restructuring of Sir Keir Starmer’s former administration rather than simply moving a handful of ministers between departments.
Rayner has returned as Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government, the position she left last year. The department will also oversee Burnham’s plans to transfer greater powers away from Westminster and into the nations, regions and local government.
Lucy Powell, Labour’s deputy leader, has been appointed Education Secretary, replacing Bridget Phillipson.
Phillipson will remain in government as Minister for Women and Equalities, although the move represents a substantial reduction in her responsibilities.
Jonathan Reynolds has returned to his former position as Business and Trade Secretary after serving as Chief Whip under Starmer.
His department is being expanded to take responsibility for science and innovation and will be renamed the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade.
Anneliese Midgley, who played a central role in Burnham’s return to Parliament and leadership campaign, has been appointed Chief Whip.
The appointments follow the earlier confirmation that former Defence Secretary John Healey will become Chancellor.
Healey’s selection was considered a surprise after Ed Miliband and Shabana Mahmood had both been strongly linked to the Treasury. He replaces Rachel Reeves, who left the government after reportedly turning down another senior Cabinet role.
Miliband has instead been appointed Foreign Secretary, replacing Yvette Cooper, while Mahmood remains Home Secretary.
Cooper has moved to the Department of Health and Social Care, where she replaces James Murray. Burnham has made reform of adult social care one of the central missions of his government.
Pat McFadden will continue as Work and Pensions Secretary, providing one of the clearest elements of continuity with the previous administration.
Louise Haigh has been handed one of the most powerful positions in the new government. She becomes First Secretary of State, Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster and the senior Cabinet Office minister.
Although she has not formally been given the title of Deputy Prime Minister, the appointment makes Haigh Burnham’s principal coordinator across government and effectively his deputy at the Cabinet table.
Who has left?
The reshuffle has seen several figures closely associated with Starmer removed from government.
Rachel Reeves has departed as Chancellor, while David Lammy has left his positions as Deputy Prime Minister and Justice Secretary.
Darren Jones, who served as Chief Secretary to the Prime Minister, has also been removed, alongside former Housing Secretary Steve Reed and Business Secretary Peter Kyle.
Attorney General Lord Richard Hermer, Science and Technology Secretary Liz Kendall, Welsh Secretary Jo Stevens and Northern Ireland Secretary Hilary Benn have also confirmed their departures.
James Murray has been replaced as Health Secretary, although it remains unclear whether he will be offered another government position.
Wales still waiting
No replacement has yet been announced for Jo Stevens as Secretary of State for Wales.
The vacancy is particularly significant because Burnham has promised a major programme of constitutional change and greater devolution of powers from Westminster.
The identity of the new Welsh Secretary will provide an early indication of how prominently Wales will feature within the new Prime Minister’s plans.
Several further senior appointments remain outstanding, including the posts of Defence Secretary, Justice Secretary, Northern Ireland Secretary and Welsh Secretary.
Wes Streeting, Lisa Nandy, Heidi Alexander, Miatta Fahnbulleh, Angela Eagle and a number of other Labour figures have entered Downing Street, but their positions had not been formally confirmed at the time of publication.
Burnham took office on Monday after being formally appointed by the King, promising what he described as a “circuit breaker” moment for Britain.
His government is expected to announce its first package of cost-of-living measures on Tuesday, with proposals involving energy bills and bus fares among the policies being considered.
-
Health1 day agoWelsh Ambulance Service invites public to AGM and Board meeting
-
News2 days agoAndy Burnham set for No 10 as Wales awaits change
-
Crime23 hours agoWhat the Milford Haven School stabbing verdict really means
-
Crime23 hours agoTeen cleared of attempted murder but guilty of GBH after Milford teacher stabbed
-
Business1 day agoPort appoints two new directors as energy and regeneration projects advance
-
Community2 days agoTributes paid to long-serving Mansel Davies driver Gareth Griffiths
-
News1 day agoAndy Burnham promises new politics as he enters Downing Street
-
Community12 minutes agoHousehold Cavalry drum horse returns home to Pembrokeshire for final farewell








