News
Local authority misleads pupils

THE HERALD has seen a letter from the Council’s education department regarding its eleventh hour cancellation of a meeting between Kate Evans-Hughes, the local authority’s recently appointed Director of Education, and the School Councils of Tasker-Milward and Sir Thomas Picton School.
Ms Evans-Hughes, whose conduct during the consultation has been the subject of complaints to the local authority, cancelled a meeting with members of the schools’ pupil bodies due to take place on March 15 and Prendergast Archives Centre.
While school students were disappointed at the late cancellation of the meeting and the thwarting of their chance to let their views be known to the person with ultimate responsibility for ignoring them, the content of the communication to the schools telling them of the cancellation has raised yet more questions about the Council’s cavalier approach to its legal responsibilities.
The letter, signed by Huw Jones, Professional Officer, Planning Places & Admissions at County Hall, states that. ‘It is considered that there is little purpose in holding further specific events to ascertain the views of pupils on the Council’s proposals for Haverfordwest, particularly as we already have sufficient evidence of their views from previous proposals’.
However, that letter represents either a deliberate or negligent omission of one salient fact that appears at the head of every page of the Council’s current and ongoing consultation; namely, ‘Please note: this consultation supersedes all previous statutory consultation undertaken in relation to secondary school reorganisation in Haverfordwest. Responses previous consultations will not be reconsidered’.
In other words the Council, is telling students it has no need to consult with them because it has their previous responses which it will not consider.
The apparent complete contempt for the views of students is as nothing, however, with the very clear contempt that the Council has for the Code it is supposed to be following in relation to ascertaining pupils’ views. Those rules provide that Pembrokeshire County Council MUST make suitable arrangements to consult with pupils of any affected school… and, where possible, with children and young people who are likely to attend those schools.
As a minimum, this must include consultation with the school councils of the affected schools, but should also include consultation with individual learners where this is appropriate and practicable. Governing bodies must help facilitate this aspect of the consultation’.
At the very least, the letter from the Council to head teachers about the consultation with pupils is a gross misstatement of the position with the potential to mislead pupils that their responses are no longer required. At the very worst, the letter from the Council to head teachers about the consultation with pupils is a deliberate attempt to mislead both pupils and schools as to the terms of the consultation and pupils’ participation in it.
In either the event the breach of Code is clear and, should the Council elect to proceed with the consultation in spite of the breach, it lays itself open to a legal challenge on the basis of that breach.
The Herald invited a comment from the Director of Education and/or the Head of Legal Services asking for clarification of how the Council is able to reconcile Huw Jones’s email with either the content of the Code or the content of its own consultation document.
A spokesperson told us: ‘In accordance with the School Organisation Code, the Council has made suitable arrangements to consult with pupils, and the School Councils of all affected schools have been invited to respond to the current consultation on the proposal to reorganise secondary education provision in Haverfordwest. There is, however, no requirement to hold consultation meetings.
‘All responses from previous consultations have been declared null and void and will not form part of any evidence presented to Council.
‘The Council is committed to securing the views of all stakeholders and their responses will be included when the Consultation Report is considered by Council. This will clearly show whether young people have engaged in the process’.
We responded and pointed out that the response completely ignored the fact the letter said the Council did not need to meet with pupils as it already knew what their views were from previous consultations, even though it now said it would disregard them in ongoing exercise.
We received no reply.
News
Another Senedd member defects to Reform as Lib Dem MP hits out
David Chadwick MP says James Evans MS ‘put career before constituents’ after party switch
A SENEDD member has defected to Reform UK, prompting sharp criticism from a neighbouring MP who accused him of abandoning his principles to protect his political future.
James Evans has left the Conservatives to join Reform UK, a move that immediately drew fire from local David Chadwick, the Welsh Liberal Democrats MP for Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe.
Mr Chadwick said the switch raised serious questions about consistency and loyalty to voters in mid Wales.
‘Career before constituents’
In a strongly-worded statement, Mr Chadwick said: “What’s clear is that James Evans is more interested in protecting his own career than standing up for his constituents in Brecon and Radnorshire.
“You could fill a library with his past criticisms of Reform and of Conservative defectors. He has described Reform as a danger to national security because of its links to Russia, and warned they would push Britain towards an insurance-based NHS.
“Yet the moment his own seat came under threat, he jumped ship to the very people he once said had no principles.
“The Welsh Liberal Democrats are clear: our principles are not for sale. We will continue to do what we were elected to do, stand up for our constituents, not engage in political psychodrama.”
Past remarks resurface
The comments highlight a series of previous attacks made by Mr Evans on Reform UK and those who had joined the party.
He has previously questioned Reform’s leadership and direction, and suggested the party could not be trusted with the NHS, warning of a move towards insurance-based healthcare.
The Liberal Democrats also pointed to remarks made last year when Mr Evans criticised another Conservative who defected, saying she had “no principles”.
Opponents say those statements now sit uneasily with his own decision to change parties.
Growing political pressure
The defection comes amid increasing competition between parties across rural and mid Wales, with Reform seeking to capitalise on dissatisfaction with both Labour and the Conservatives ahead of the next Senedd election.
Mr Evans has yet to respond publicly to Mr Chadwick’s comments.
Community
Milford Haven community mourns loss of dedicated volunteer Robert Duncan
Tributes paid to former RBL chairman and Citizens’ Award recipient
MILFORD HAVEN has been left saddened by the death of Robert Duncan, a well-known and much-respected community figure who devoted decades of his life to voluntary service.
Milford Haven Town Council said it was “so sorry to learn of the passing” of Mr Duncan, describing him as a dear friend to many and a man whose generosity touched countless lives.
Mr Duncan served as Chairman of the Milford Haven branch of the Royal British Legion and was widely recognised for his tireless work supporting veterans and local causes. Alongside his wife Carol, he received a Citizens’ Award in 2016 in recognition of their years of voluntary service to the town.
The couple also fostered children for many years, opening their home to young people in need and providing stability and care to families across the area.
Beyond his work with the Legion, Mr Duncan was involved with the local R.A.O.B. lodge and Milford Haven Museum, contributing time and energy to preserve the town’s history and strengthen community life.
In a statement, the Town Council said: “Robert was a wonderful family man and a most dedicated public servant. So many of us will have stories of his generosity and community activities that we would like to share. Thank you for everything, Robert. We will truly miss you.”
Councillors added that his quiet commitment and willingness to help others made him a familiar and trusted figure across Milford Haven.
Sympathies have been extended to Carol and the wider family, as well as friends and colleagues who worked alongside him over the years.
Those who knew him say his legacy will live on in the many lives he helped shape and the strong sense of community he worked so hard to build.
Photo caption: Robert Duncan and his wife Carol receive a Citizens’ Award in 2016 alongside the Mayor of Milford Haven (Pic: Milford Haven Town Council).
News
Road sign vandalism sparks political row across west Wales
BILINGUAL road signs across parts of west Wales have been deliberately defaced, with English place names sprayed over in what politicians have described as targeted acts of vandalism.
Incidents have been reported in St Clears, Welshpool and Burry Port in recent days, with the English wording obscured while the Welsh language names were left untouched.
The damage has prompted criticism from Andrew RT Davies, the South Wales Central Conservative Member of the Senedd, who said the attacks were “disgraceful” and risk fuelling division within communities.
In St Clears, Carmarthenshire, black paint was sprayed across the English name on entrance signage, while the Welsh version, “Sancler”, remained clearly visible. The town itself dates back to the 12th century as an Anglo-Norman settlement, with the Welsh name derived from the original English.
Similar reports have emerged from Welshpool in Powys and Burry Port on the Carmarthenshire coast, where bilingual signs have also been tampered with.
Mr Davies said: “These attacks, presumably carried out by Welsh separatist activists, are disgraceful.
“The English language is central to Welsh culture.
“Attempts to erase it are completely unacceptable and must be condemned.”
He added that road signs are there for safety and navigation and should not be used to make political statements.
Local residents have also voiced frustration, with some pointing out that obscuring parts of signs could pose a risk to drivers unfamiliar with the area, particularly visitors and tourists.
Bilingual signage has been standard across Wales for decades, reflecting both Welsh and English as everyday languages used by communities. While the vast majority of signs remain untouched, the recent incidents appear to have been deliberate and selective.
Police have not yet confirmed whether any arrests have been made, but anyone with information about damage to public property is urged to contact their local force.
Anyone who spots vandalised signage is also advised to report it to their local council so repairs can be arranged quickly.
-
Crime19 hours agoSex offender jailed after living off grid in Pembrokeshire and refusing to register
-
News2 days agoPrincess of Wales visits historic Pembrokeshire woollen mill
-
Crime6 days agoPembroke man accused of child sex offences sent to Swansea Crown Court
-
Health4 days agoDoctor struck off after sexual misconduct findings at Withybush Hospital
-
Crime6 days agoManhunt intensifies after woman seriously injured in Carmarthen park stabbing
-
Crime2 days agoHakin man’s appeal delayed again as Crown Court seeks guidance on insurance law
-
Community6 days ago50s women threaten legal action over pension compensation refusal
-
Crime6 days agoDisqualified HGV driver charged after dangerous A40 incident












tomos
April 13, 2016 at 11:24 am
I guess at least the young ppl are getting used to the absolute shower of incompetentsthat is PCC early in their lives