Community
Campaigners threaten legal action as Withyhedge landfill complaints return
Residents say they’re “fed up” as council insists odour not linked to site
CAMPAIGNERS have renewed their calls for stronger action against Withyhedge landfill following a fresh wave of odour complaints in Haverfordwest — with some residents now threatening legal proceedings against those they deem responsible for years of inaction.
The latest complaints, made on Wednesday (May 1), prompted local campaigner Colin Barnett to contact Pembrokeshire MP Henry Tufnell, Senedd Member Eluned Morgan, and senior officials at Pembrokeshire County Council (PCC) and Natural Resources Wales (NRW).
In his letter, Mr Barnett — a long-time critic of the landfill’s operators and the authorities tasked with regulating it — described a “toxic” smell in the area around Wickes and Boots in Haverfordwest, saying the stench was so severe it “sent [him] packing.”
“It isn’t good enough that residents have to put up with this awful smell and toxicity,” he wrote. “You would think businesses there would want something done about it. We aren’t going to go through this again.”
A long-running controversy
The Withyhedge landfill site, located near the village of Dreenhill, has been a source of complaints for several years, with residents of Haverfordwest, Merlins Bridge and surrounding areas reporting episodes of foul odours, eye irritation, nausea and concern about long-term health impacts.
In 2023, following a particularly severe spike in complaints, a multi-agency response was launched involving PCC, NRW, Public Health Wales, and other partners. A formal Incident Management Team and an Air Quality Group were formed to co-ordinate investigations and responses. Air quality monitoring was established at Spittal School to track levels of hydrogen sulphide (H₂S) — a gas known for its “rotten egg” smell and sometimes linked to landfill emissions.
Mitigation measures were later introduced at the site by its operators, and in early 2024 both the Air Quality Group and the Incident Management Team were officially stood down, after authorities said the situation had improved and complaint levels had dropped.
However, many campaigners questioned the decision to scale back oversight, arguing that problems were still being experienced in areas not captured by the Spittal monitoring station.
“We are being failed”
Mr Barnett told The Herald that the events of May 1 show the issue is far from resolved.
“After all this time PCC, NRW and public health should have an action plan in place to respond — and they haven’t,” he said. “Waiting for the monthly results of their monitoring station in Spittal isn’t acceptable, especially when the stench isn’t in Spittal.”
He added: “We are now seriously considering legal action to stop this tip from operating and to go after anyone else we can — PCC, NRW, whoever is accountable for failing to protect us.”
He also criticised what he described as a lack of urgency from elected officials and regulators: “Now that the so-called ‘Incident Management Group’ of PCC and NRW professionals feel their job is done, the only route left to us, again, is the press and our elected members.”
Council: No link to landfill
In a statement issued in response to The Herald’s enquiries, Pembrokeshire County Council defended its current monitoring approach and said the May 1 complaints had been investigated.
“Air quality monitoring of hydrogen sulphide (H₂S) levels continues at Spittal School,” a council spokesperson said. “This is based on advice from Public Health Wales and NRW’s environmental air quality specialists. H₂S was identified as the key parameter, and no other substances are currently being monitored.”
PCC confirmed that it has committed to extending the H₂S monitoring programme at Spittal School for a further 12 months. “If exceedances begin to occur that can be attributed to the site, consideration would then be given to standing back up the multi-agency incident arrangements.”
The council added that officers from its Pollution Control Team responded promptly to the May 1 complaints and “carried out odour assessments at relevant locations. During the course of their investigations, no odours attributable to landfill site emissions were detected.”
PCC said the number of complaints has remained low since the incident teams were stepped down. However, it reminded residents that there is a dedicated email address for odour complaints relating to Withyhedge: [email protected].
MP pressed for answers
Mr Barnett also called on Henry Tufnell MP to clarify whether he is part of a cross-party group of MPs who recently met to discuss landfill problems in their constituencies — and if so, what steps are being taken at Westminster level.
No official response had been received at the time of going to press.
As public frustration mounts, campaigners say they feel let down by a system that appears to “wait for things to go wrong” rather than act proactively.
“The smell might come and go, but the failure to deal with this is constant,” Mr Barnett said.
Community
Senedd unanimously backs sign language bill
PLANS to make Wales the best place in the UK for British Sign Language (BSL) users moved a significant step closer to becoming law with the Senedd’s unanimous support.
If ultimately passed, the BSL bill – introduced by the Conservatives’ Mark Isherwood – would end Wales’ status as the only UK nation without specific sign language protections.
Leading a debate on Wednesday December 17, Mr Isherwood said the Senedd supporting the bill’s general principles was a “huge step ahead” for the “vital” legislation.
Mr Isherwood, a disability rights campaigner for decades, explained his backbench bill would introduce legal requirements to promote and facilitate the use of BSL in Wales.
He said the bill, if passed, would be the most progressive piece of BSL legislation anywhere in the UK, recognising BSL is a language in its own right, not a communication support need.

He highlighted that the bill would establish a BSL adviser role, the first statutory post of its kind in the UK, describing its importance as something that “cannot be overstated”.
Mr Isherwood, who chairs cross-party groups on disability and deaf issues, told the Senedd: “This isn’t just my bill. This is the bill of the BSL community. Let’s make this happen together and be proud of it together on behalf of deaf people across Wales.”
Jenny Rathbone, the Labour chair of the Senedd’s equality committee, was convinced of the “overdue” need for legislation to give more standing to British Sign Language.

Ms Rathbone said the committee heard the biggest barrier “by some margin” was the availability of interpreters and the sustainability of the workforce.
She quoted a signer who told the committee: “The bill would make us feel respected and valued. But without proper funding, planning and deaf-led leadership, it won’t go far enough.”
Sioned Williams, Plaid Cymru’s shadow social justice secretary, told Senedd members: “Language is a part of our identity, our culture and our personal dignity.
“When someone cannot use their language, they are excluded from education, health care, employment and public life – and that is not acceptable in today’s Wales.”

Ms Williams warned that if the legislation fails to deliver real change, the deaf community would be left “angry, disappointed and very, very disheartened”.
She expressed concern that the bill does not legally require the BSL adviser to be a deaf person, arguing it is “not appropriate, possible or efficient” for non-signers to lead the way.
Mr Isherwood defended the decision not to require that the adviser must be deaf, warning a successful legal challenge to a single such provision could cause the entire bill to fail.
Welsh Liberal Democrat leader Jane Dodds warned of an immediate workforce crisis, with only 54 registered sign language interpreters in Wales as of July.
With many now approaching the end of their working lives, she said: “We cannot – we must not – allow this bill to fail because we didn’t have the foresight to address this crisis now.”
Support for the bill stretched across the political spectrum, with Reform UK’s Laura Anne Jones similarly welcoming the “long-overdue” and “vital” legislation.
Jane Hutt, Wales’ social justice secretary, confirmed the Welsh Government’s financial backing, committing £214,300 for the bill’s first year of implementation in 2026/27.
If it clears the final hurdles, Mr Isherwood’s proposal will be the first backbench bill to enter the statute book in about a decade following the Nurse Staffing Levels (Wales) Act 2016.
Community
‘Nowhere I can play’: Disabled children excluded from Welsh parks
NEARLY four in ten disabled children in Wales “never or hardly ever” play outside due to a “heartbreaking” lack of accessible parks, politicians have warned.
Rhys ab Owen, an independent, described the situation as “disgraceful” as he cited a Play Wales report showing 37% of disabled children are effectively shut out of playgrounds.
Leading a debate in the Senedd on Wednesday December 17, he read the testimony of a ten-year-old boy from Blaenau Gwent who said: “Nowhere disabled friendly – parks haven’t got disabled friendly equipment, so I can’t play.”
Mr ab Owen warned: “There shouldn’t be any discrimination… disabled children do face much greater problems in terms of park maintenance, and with accessibility and inclusion.”
He shared the experience of a 13-year-old girl from Newport who told researchers: “There’s nowhere I can play or hang out safely by myself as I use a frame to help me walk.”
The former barrister warned budget cuts were leading to a managed decline in standards, quoting a 13-year-old from Caerphilly who said: “Due to anti-social behaviour our equipment gets broken, burnt and vandalised and is then not replaced.”
The Conservatives’ Natasha Asghar was stunned by the scale of the crisis and revealed that only 11% of playgrounds in Wales are rated “green”, meaning they are fully accessible. By contrast, almost half are rated “red” for poor accessibility.

Listing the barriers families face, Ms Asghar highlighted that 30% of sites lack accessible paths and nearly one in five have gates too narrow for wheelchairs. “Those are just two of the barriers preventing disabled children from accessing play,” she said.
Jane Dodds, the leader of the Liberal Democrats in Wales, argued the shocking statistics should be a wake-up call for Senedd politicians.
“To hear that 37% of disabled children in Wales say they never or hardly ever play outside should be a figure to stop us all in our tracks,” she said.

Meanwhile, Mike Hedges pointed out that Wales became the first country in the world to put a duty on councils to secure “sufficient play opportunities” for children in 2010.
And Julie Morgan, a fellow Labour backbencher, celebrated Cardiff becoming the UK’s first Unicef-accredited child-friendly city in 2023.
Dawn Bowden, the minister for children, pointed to £5m to improve playgrounds this year but she too was “disappointed” by play satisfaction figures falling from 84% to 71% since 2019.

She said the Welsh Government has provided a “toolkit” to Wales’ 22 councils, “ensuring a holistic outcome-focused approach” to inclusive and accessible play.
The cross-party motion, which called for play to be protected from cuts – as well as improved access for disabled children – was agreed unanimously but does not bind ministers.
Climate
Pembroke tidal flood defence work to continue to January
SIGNIFICANT issues with a part of Pembroke’s tidal barrage are not expected to be fully fixed before late January, councillors heard.
Pembroke councillors Aaron Carey and Jonathan Grimes submitted an urgent question heard at the December meeting of Pembrokeshire County Council, which said: “In light of the repeated flooding events across the county – including the recent overflow at Castle Pond and the acknowledgement by your own Coastal, Rivers & Drainage Team that the barrage tipping gate remains inoperable until mid-January can you explain what assessment has been made of the adequacy of our tidal outfall infrastructure in the face of current and projected future storm surges and sea-level rise?
“If no such assessment has yet been undertaken, will you commit now to commissioning an immediate structural and risk-capacity audit, with a report to full council within three months, and with proposals for funding any remedial works required — to avoid recurring damage and disruption to residents, highways, and public amenities?”
Responding to the urgent question, Cabinet Member for Residents Services Cllr Rhys Sinnett said a significant assessment of the Pembroke Tidal Barrage had already been undertaken over the past two years, with regular inspections.
He said “a comprehensive package of works” began in September which were due to be completed before Christmas but said there had been “significant issues” with the tipping gate hydraulic ram, with a significant overhaul now taking place, with reinstatement expected by late January.
He told members additional mitigation measures were now in place and, once works are completed, enhanced works will provide improved resilience and “long-term reliability,” with further reports due to come to Cabinet.
Cllr Carey and Cllr Grimes had also submitted a notice of motion saying: “That this council notes with concern the repeated and increasingly severe flooding experienced in our coastal, estuarial and river-fringe communities over recent weeks — in particular the flooding events affecting the Commons/Castle Pond area.
“That the council further notes that, according to correspondence from the Coastal, Rivers & Drainage Team Manager, the tipping gate at the barrage remains out of operation until mid-January due to mechanical issues; meanwhile high tide, heavy rain, wind-driven tidal surges and overspill at the sluice have combined to overwhelm the drainage/outfall infrastructure.
“That we recognise the current maintenance schedule (delayed ‘til after the summer season) and the justification given — but further that such planning failed to foresee the likelihood of severe winter storm and surge events, which climate change makes more frequent and more intense.
“That this council therefore calls on the Cabinet to commission an urgent review of:
- The adequacy of the current drainage/outfall and tidal-sluice infrastructure (barrage tipping gate, sluice/sluice-valve, flap valve, outfall capacity) for current and projected climate/tide conditions.
- The maintenance scheduling policy for coastal and estuarial flood-risk assets, with a view to ensuring critical maintenance is completed before winter high-tide / storm-surge season, rather than — as at present — being delayed until after summer for ‘recreational / biodiversity’ reasons.
“That, pending the outcome of the review, the council should allocate appropriate emergency capital funding to remediate the barrages / sluices / outfalls at risk of failure or blockage — to safeguard residents, properties, highways and public amenities from further flooding.
“That, further, this council resolves to publish a public flood-resilience plan for the county, identifying all coastal and river-fringe ‘hotspots,’ maintenance schedules, responsible teams, and a transparent timeline for upgrades or remedial works — so residents have clarity and confidence in flood prevention measures.”
The notice of motion itself will be considered by the council’s Cabinet at a later date.
-
Crime1 day agoMilford Haven man jailed after drunken attack on partner and police officers
-
News4 days agoDyfed-Powys Police launch major investigation after triple fatal crash
-
Crime1 day agoTeenager charged following rape allegation at Saundersfoot nightclub
-
Crime2 days agoMan charged with months of coercive control and assaults
-
Crime3 days agoMan sent to Crown Court over historic indecent assault allegations
-
Crime5 days agoMan spared jail after baseball bat incident in Milford Haven
-
Crime3 days agoMilford Haven man admits multiple offences after A477 incident
-
Crime2 days agoWoman ‘terrified in own home’ after ex breaches court order










