Connect with us
Advertisement
Advertisement

News

Police officer ‘should be sacked’ over rape interview mess-up

Published

on

A TEENAGE victim of an alleged rape will have to re-live her ordeal for a second time after police in Pembrokeshire messed up her video interview.

It was the second time a judge at Swansea Crown Court has criticised the way Dyfed-Powys Police has dealt with alleged victims off serious sex crimes.

In the latest case, Judge Keith Thomas, the most senior resident judge, said the officer who monitored the interview should be sacked.

Those making allegations of a sexual nature are allowed to make a statement to police in a comfortable and secure environment, which is video taped and placed onto a DVD.

Later, if the alleged attacker is traced and put on trial – possibly years later – that DVD is played to the jury and becomes the victim’s evidence, without her having to repeat her story in person.

But Swansea Crown Court heard that the interview of a teenager who complained of being raped when she was a child had been handled so badly the DVD was useless.

Judge Thomas said it was so poor he would not allow it to be played to a jury.

Instead, she will have to re-interviewed.

Carina Hughes, prosecuting, said at one stage the camera was not even focused on the victim.

“It is completely unfair because it’s not her fault, but the DVD is not acceptable,” she added.

The poor audio was also an issue, said Miss Hughes.

Sex assault victims are supposed to be interviewed by a trained officer with a second officer monitoring the process from a different room.

Judge Thomas said he was not sure that anyone had bothered to monitor this particular interview but if he or she had then they should be sacked.

“There’s absolutely no control over the recording. They (the police) must get a grip.”

He also slammed the police for questioning the victim for one and half hours about a single allegation.

Judge Thomas said the next interview must be completed within 30 minutes or he would want an explanation ‘as to why he or she is incapable of carrying out a simple instruction’.

He said: “I cannot understand how any trained officer could think it is appropriate to question a [girl of this age] for ninety minutes.

“The new tape must take only thirty minutes maximum,” he added.

It is not known where the interview was conducted.

In 2014 another judge at Swansea Crown Court criticised Pembroke Dock police who left a window open during an interview with a rape victim. The sound of passing traffic drowned out her testimony and she had to give live evidence in court.

 

Crime

Carmarthenshire man jailed for having lock knife

Published

on

Court told offence was committed during suspended sentence period

A CARMARTHENSHIRE man has been jailed after admitting possessing a lock knife in a public place.

David Jones, aged 61, of Cwmcatty, Porthyrhyd, appeared before Llanelli Magistrates’ Court on Friday (Jun 5).

He admitted that on June 4, at Llanelli, he had a lock knife with him in a public place without good reason or lawful authority.

Jones was jailed for four months.

The court record stated the offence was so serious that only custody could be justified, and that it was committed during the operational period of a suspended sentence.

The court also ordered that the lock knife be forfeited and deprived from him.

A second charge, alleging threatening or abusive behaviour towards PCSO Nicholl of Dyfed-Powys Police, was withdrawn.

 

Continue Reading

Crime

Milford Haven man admits harassment and assault

Published

on

Case adjourned for pre-sentence report at Haverfordwest court

A MILFORD HAVEN man has admitted harassment and assault charges.

Wayne Whatling, aged 40, of Howarth Close, Milford Haven, appeared before Llanelli Magistrates’ Court on Friday (Jun 5).

The court heard that between September 1 and September 13, 2025, at Milford Haven, Whatling pursued a course of conduct which amounted to harassment of Carol Whatling.

The charge stated that he regularly asked her for money and that she was in fear of repercussions if she did not provide it.

Whatling also admitted assaulting Ben Whatling by beating him at Milford Haven on September 13, 2025.

Magistrates adjourned the case for a pre-sentence report.

He was remanded on conditional bail and must return to Haverfordwest Magistrates’ Court on Thursday, June 11.

 

Continue Reading

Crime

Milford Haven man fined after restraining order breach

Published

on

Defendant admitted contacting woman and attending Fishguard address

A MILFORD HAVEN man has been fined after admitting breaching a restraining order in Fishguard.

Steven O’Sullivan, aged 40, of Milton Crescent, Milford Haven, appeared before Llanelli Magistrates’ Court on Friday (Jun 5).

He admitted breaching a restraining order imposed by Ceredigion and Pembrokeshire Magistrates’ Court on November 8, 2012.

The court heard that between June 2 and June 5, at Fishguard, O’Sullivan contacted Delyth O’Sullivan and attended her address without reasonable excuse.

The order prohibited him from doing so.

Magistrates fined O’Sullivan £200 and ordered him to pay £85 prosecution costs.

 

Continue Reading

News23 hours ago

Council tax shake-up in doubt as Welsh Government reviews reform plans

Questions over 2028 revaluation as ministers reconsider next steps THE FUTURE of council tax reform in Wales has been thrown...

Crime24 hours ago

Paddleboard company owner loses bid to cut sentence over Haverfordwest tragedy

A FORMER paddleboard company owner jailed over the deaths of four people on the Western Cleddau has failed in a...

Community2 days ago

Crisis response dogs launched to support people through trauma and distress

A NEW project using specially trained dogs to support people during moments of trauma, grief and crisis has been launched...

News2 days ago

Major fire breaks out at Tata Steel site in Port Talbot

TATA STEEL has confirmed that a major fire broke out at its Port Talbot steelworks on Wednesday night, with emergency...

Community3 days ago

HMS Erebus tragedy links Pembroke Dock ship to Templeton family

DNA breakthrough identifies cabin boy David Young as exhibition marks 200 years since ship’s launch ON MAY 19, 1845, a...

Community3 days ago

Narberth cash machine closures spark urgent access review

CALLS have been made for an urgent review of access to cash in Narberth after two town centre ATMs were...

Health4 days ago

First Minister quizzed on Welsh NHS pressures in his first-ever FMQs

SENEDD Members pressed the First Minister over the state of the health service in Wales, as the Plaid Cymru leader...

Community4 days ago

Historic paddle steamer Waverley to return to Fishguard this month

THE WORLD’S last seagoing paddle steamer will return to Fishguard this month as part of her annual visit to South...

Local Government4 days ago

National Express use of new Haverfordwest interchange still subject to risk checks

A RUMOUR that National Express coaches may struggle to use Haverfordwest’s new transport interchange has been denied by Pembrokeshire County...

Crime4 days ago

Milford Haven man jailed for illegal Premier League streaming service

A MILFORD HAVEN man who supplied illegal Premier League streams and loaded Firesticks to almost 2,000 customers has been jailed...

Popular This Week