Business
Sub-postmaster caught in Horizon scandal offered fraction of claim
A FORMER sub-postmaster from Roch, Pembrokeshire, who was wrongly prosecuted in the Horizon IT scandal, has said he was left “in disbelief” after being offered less than 17% of his compensation claim.
Tim Brentnall was prosecuted in 2010 for false accounting after a £22,500 shortfall was identified at his branch. In 2021, his conviction was overturned, and he submitted a claim for full financial redress to the Post Office last August. Four months later, in December, he received a response that he described as “litigation all over again.”
Speaking to the BBC, Mr Brentnall said: “[I was] just in disbelief. What I prepared myself for and what came were two totally different things. It very much reminded me of receiving a summons to court from the Post Office the first time around.”
Legal battle continues
Mr Brentnall, who had his claim prepared by lawyers and forensic accountants, said his offer was significantly lower than expected. “We haven’t picked these figures out of the air,” he added.
He is one of 736 former sub-postmasters who were prosecuted due to faults in the Horizon computer system. His response from the Post Office came in a 50-page letter dismissing much of his claim, along with nearly 15,000 supporting documents that he has spent the past three months reviewing for re-submission.
“You sit down and get to a number or percentage where you think, ‘well, that’s enough for me to walk away and draw a line under it.’ But what I was offered was nowhere near that.”
Victims still waiting
Mr Brentnall highlighted the case of Terry Walters, a fellow former sub-postmaster who died in February without receiving full financial redress, despite submitting his claim more than a year ago.
“I’m 43, I can afford to wait,” he said. “But there are so many people much older than me who should be able to sit back, relax, and enjoy the years they’ve got left. Instead, they’re still fighting.”
He criticised the slow pace of compensation payments, pointing out that the UK government was able to act swiftly when public opinion demanded it. “Surely they can do something, because people are dying, and it’s not fair.”
A devastating impact
Mr Brentnall and his parents had bought the shop in Roch when he was 22, hoping to secure a future in the community where he grew up. That future was shattered in 2009 when auditors found a discrepancy and he was suspended before being taken to Haverfordwest police station for questioning.
“It was horrific. I felt totally alone and helpless. Even though I knew I hadn’t taken any money, my parents were desperate to make up the missing funds, so they took out a loan to cover the supposed debt. Then I was prosecuted anyway.”
His conviction meant he was given an 18-month suspended sentence and 200 hours of community service. “It wiped out any savings my parents had, the business we had, and cost me any future employment for the last 15 years.”
In 2021, his conviction was finally overturned, and he gave evidence to the Post Office inquiry the following year.
Government steps in
On Monday, the UK government confirmed it would take over responsibility for the Overturned Convictions Scheme, which compensates those who have had their convictions quashed.
A spokesperson for the Post Office said more than £768m had been paid to 5,100 people affected by the scandal, adding: “We continue to listen to feedback to make improvements to the redress process for those affected.”
However, for Mr Brentnall and many others, the fight for fair compensation continues.
Business
Salon plans for Haverfordwest car valet site approved
RETROSPECTIVE plans to change a Pembrokeshire car sales/valet area to include a barber shop and tanning salon have been given the go-ahead.
In an application to Pembrokeshire County Council, Zizo Barbers & Affordable Cars, of Cambrian Place, Haverfordwest sought permission for the change of use of previously granted valet and car sales area, the works completed in 2024.
A supporting statement through agent Hayston Developments & Planning Ltd said the former commercial garage business has been operating in several guises from the premises for many years and has included petrol sales, motor servicing and repairs, MoTs, vehicle valeting, car sales and customer parking.
This followed on from a 2011 permission for the partial demolition of the original commercial garage, with a later approval for the site refurbishment to provide a workshop, valeting and offices for the existing car sales.
A supporting statement said: “The proposed update to a change of use involves the replacement of a car valeting service, which took place under a covered area at the rear of the site by a wash and valet operation – and restricting this service to those cars being sold at the Cambrian Place site. The use of a former office / store as a barber shop.
“The use of the former customer waiting area as a tanning salon including a new moveable timber shed for use as a meet and greet facility and as a car sales office. Provision of a communal parking area. Whilst retaining the principal use of the site for the sale of used cars.
“It is therefore suggested that the proposal will reduce both the elements of noise and the generation of dust whilst improving air quality as substantially fewer cars being power washed and valeted as well as the visual impact of these activities in this very public location – and with adjacent residential properties.”
Haverfordwest Town Council had objected to the scheme on highway safety grounds, but an officer report recommending approval said: “Highways colleagues have advised that the mixed use at the site is not likely to generate a significant number of trips that would lead to congestion and/or road safety issues due to the hours of operation are suggestive of visitors in the non-peak hours over the course of the day.
“In addition, highways colleagues have confirmed recorded accident history is negligible at the site, with one accident in 2023 at the nearby junction as a result of a rear shunt.”
It also said that, as the site lies adjacent to the A40(T) Welsh Government as a highway authority were consulted on the application, but has not not issued a direction in respect of this application.
One letter of objection had also raised issues of traffic and highway safety, chemical and detergent waste from the site and occasional activity after 5pm.
The report said the cessation of the valeting/washing use will reduce water usage at the site and any activity outside normal hours was an enforcement matter.
The application was conditionally approved by officers.
Business
Community council objections to Tenby Lidl store scheme
PLANS for a new store on the edge of Tenby by retail giant Lidl, which has seen objections from the local community council, are likely to be heard next year.
In an application recently lodged with Pembrokeshire County Council back in October, Lidl GB Ltd, through agent CarneySweeney, seeks permission for a new 1,969sqm store on land at Park House Court, Narberth Road, New Hedges/Tenby, to the north of the Park Court Nursing Home.
The proposals for the latest specification Lidl store, which includes 103 parking spaces, would create 40 jobs, the applicants say.
The application follows draft proposals submitted in 2024 and public consultations on the scheme, with a leaflet drop delivered to 8,605 local properties; an information website, with online feedback form; and a public exhibition, held last December at the De Valence Pavillion in Tenby, with a follow-up community event held at New Hedges Village Hall, close to the site, publicised through an additional postcard issued to 2,060 properties.

Some 1,365 responses have been received, with 89 per cent of respondents expressing support for the proposals, the applicants say.
A supporting statement says: “Lidl is now exceptionally well established in the UK with the Company operating c.980 stores from sites and premises both within and outside town centres. Its market share continues to increase substantially, and the company is expanding its store network considerably. The UK operational model is based firmly on the success of Lidl’s operations abroad with more than 10,800 stores trading across Europe.
It adds: “The granting of planning permission for the erection of a new Lidl food store would increase the retail offer and boost the local economy. The new Lidl food store would create up to 40 employment opportunities for people of all ages and backgrounds, providing opportunities for training and career development. This in turn will create an upward spiral of economic benefits.”
Local community council St Mary Out Liberty Community Council has formally objected to the scheme, saying that, while it supports the scheme for a Lidl store in principle, recognising “the economic benefits a new retail store could bring,” it says the proposed location “is unsuitable, conflicts with planning policy, and cannot be supported in its current form”.
Its objections add: “The A478 is heavily congested in peak tourist months. A supermarket would worsen congestion, increase turning movements, and heighten risks to pedestrians, cyclists, and emergency access.”
It also raises concerns on the potential impact through “noise, lighting, traffic disturbance, and loss of quiet amenity” on a neighbouring residential care home.
An initial assessment by Pembrokeshire County Council, highlighted concerns about the visual impact, with the authority’s landscape officer commenting that the store would introduce “an intense urban function into an otherwise rural context”.
The report added: “It is not considered to be compatible with the character of the site and the area within which it is located; and furthermore, will lead to a harmful visual impact on the setting of the National Park.”
The application will be considered by county planners at a later date.
Business
Senedd approves £116m transitional relief for business rates
BUSINESSES facing sharp hikes in tax bills after the 2026 revaluation will see increases phased in over two years after the Senedd backed a new transitional relief scheme.
Senedd Members unanimously approved regulations to help businesses which face significant rises in non-domestic rates bills after a revaluation taking effect in April 2026.
The Welsh Government estimates the transitional relief will support 25,000 ratepayers at a cost of £77m in 2026/27 and £39m in 2027/28. The partial relief covers 67% of the increase in the first year and 34% in the second.
Mark Drakeford, Wales’ finance secretary, stressed the £116m scheme comes on top of permanent rate reliefs which are currently worth £250m a year. He said ratepayers for two-thirds of properties will pay no bill at all or receive some level of relief.
The former First Minister told the Senedd: “In providing this transitional relief scheme, we are closely replicating the scheme of relief we provided following the 2023 revaluation – supporting all areas of the tax base in a consistent and straightforward manner.”
The Conservatives’ Sam Rowlands expressed his party’s support for the transitional relief scheme which will help ratepayers facing sharp increases after the 2026 revaluation.

He said: “We are grateful that the Welsh Government has at least brought forward a scheme that will soften the immediate impact for thousands of Welsh businesses.
“We also understand that if these regulations are not approved or supported… this relief scheme will not be in existence. Many businesses across Wales would face steep increases with no protection at all and that is certainly not an outcome we would want.”
But the shadow finance secretary warned businesses up and down Wales are worried about the increase in rates that they are liable to pay.
Advocating scrapping rates for all small businesses in Wales, Mr Rowlands said: “We’ve heard first-hand from many of those in the hospitality and leisure sector, some of whom are facing increases of over 100% in the tax rates they are expected to pay.”
Responding as the Senedd signed off on the scheme on December 16, Prof Drakeford said the Welsh Government had to wait for the UK budget to know if funding was available. As a result of the time constraints, the regulations were not subject to formal consultation.
Prof Drakeford agreed with Mr Rowlands that voting against the regulations would not improve support, only eliminate the transitional relief package before the Senedd.

Earlier in Tuesday’s Senedd proceedings, former Tory group leader Paul Davies warned Welsh businesses have already been hit with some of the highest business rates in the UK.
He said: “The latest business rates revaluation has meant that some businesses are now facing rises of several hundred per cent compared with previous assessments…
“Whilst I appreciate that a transitional relief scheme will help some businesses manage these changes, the reality is that for many businesses it’s not enough and some businesses will be forced into a position where they will have to close.”
-
Crime3 days agoMilford Haven man jailed after drunken attack on partner and police officers
-
News6 days agoDyfed-Powys Police launch major investigation after triple fatal crash
-
Crime3 days agoTeenager charged following rape allegation at Saundersfoot nightclub
-
Crime4 days agoMan charged with months of coercive control and assaults
-
Crime5 days agoMan sent to Crown Court over historic indecent assault allegations
-
Crime7 days agoMan spared jail after baseball bat incident in Milford Haven
-
Crime5 days agoMilford Haven man admits multiple offences after A477 incident
-
Crime4 days agoWoman ‘terrified in own home’ after ex breaches court order











