Health
‘We are not for sale’ – Young people back plan to remove profit from care
FOUR remarkable young people gave evidence to the Senedd’s health committee about their experiences of Wales’ social care system, supporting plans to stamp out profiteering.
Mark Drakeford asked the witnesses if they agreed with the principle of the health and social care bill, which would remove profit from the care of looked-after children.
Elliott James told the former first minister – who introduced the proposal while leading the Welsh Government – that for every £10 given for a child in care, £3 is taken away in profit.
He said one relatively standard residential placement can cost as much as £5,000 a week, with support workers paid a “shockingly” low amount.
Elliott stressed: “At the moment, companies are profiting off us and we are not for sale.”
Joanne Griffith similarly said: “We are not in the care system for people to profit off us – we don’t choose to go in the system, the system chooses us.
“Why should people be able to gain money … and spend it on whatever they want when in actual fact the money should be going to the young people, so that we can thrive?”
She added: “Put yourselves in our shoes, you probably wouldn’t want to be profited off.”
Rhian Thomas and Rowan Gray wholeheartedly agreed with the principle. But Rowan raised concerns for-profit providers “could end up packing up and going elsewhere”.
Elliott raised concerns about children being placed a long way from home, saying: It’s not just about the profit, it’s about the care of young people as a whole.
“A lot of young people are being let down currently.”
He said: “Moving a child hundreds of miles away isn’t always suitable….
“These placements can’t commit to contact, they can’t commit to free time so that leaves us not being able to see our family, not being able to go and see our friends.”
He warned that placements for children and young people with severe mental health problems are more than likely to break down because carers cannot cope.
Elliott said: “Unfortunately, the system thinks as soon as we enter care, all of our problems have been solved. They haven’t. We are still deeply traumatised young people who need care, love and support.”
While recognising the need for emergency placements, Elliot raised concerns about children moving from one to the next until a suitable placement is found.
He asked: “Why can’t we be placed into a suitable placement the first time around?”
Elliott told the Senedd some young people are “placement hoppers”, going to as many as 10 or 20 different placements in one week.
He said he was given only an hour-and-a-half notice before going into care and nobody was trained to really understand his autism.
“I was always left to suffer by myself because nobody knew how to help me,” he said, warning that symptoms of autism were treated as a behavioural issue.
Rhian stressed the importance of keeping siblings together and support for young people transitioning into care or adulthood.
She told Senedd members: “When you first come into care that’s the hardest part of it all.”
Rowan said it is vital to match the children going into care with the right foster carers.
“My last placement was with some people that were in their 60s,” he said. “When I was younger, I had a lot of energy and I was always wanting to do something.”
He told committee members the foster carers did the best they could but he wanted to build memories and they were sometimes not able to take part in activities he found fun.
Rowan was placed “out in the middle of nowhere” more than 10 miles from home.
“I didn’t have anyone around my own age who I could build friendships with,” he said.
Calling for more accountability, he told the Senedd: “If my local authority had actually done what they said they were going to do, I wouldn’t be sat here.
“I would be currently in Bristol living with my mother. Because there was no accountability … they went back on their word … and I ended up in long-term foster care.”
Joanne raised the importance of stability and continuity of care.
She told the committee: “It’s really important that we have a placement that we know we can stay in permanently and we’re not going to be moved within 24 hours … or a week.”
Joanne added: “We need a placement that we can call home.”
She called for compulsory training around mental health and disability, so “we know if we have an issue we can go to the foster carers and we’re not going to get stigmatised for it”.
Joanne also called for more unannounced visits to build up a more accurate picture.
The health committee is scrutinising the bill, aiming to report back to the Senedd in October, ahead a vote on the general principles with amending stages to follow.
Health
Nurses warn of pay and burnout crisis as new report exposes pressures in Wales
A NEW national report has laid bare the growing pressures facing nurses and midwives in Wales, with concerns over pay, burnout and lack of professional development threatening the long-term future of the workforce.
The findings, published by the Nursing and Midwifery Council in its Spotlight on Nursing and Midwifery 2025 report, show that while many nurses remain deeply committed to their roles, large numbers feel undervalued, overstretched and reluctant to recommend the profession to others.
Responding to the report, Royal College of Nursing Wales said the data should act as a wake-up call for government and health boards.
Professor Sandy Harding, Associate Director of Nursing, Policy and Professional Development at RCN Wales, said:
“We welcome the determination and commitment shown by our existing nurses in Wales, with more than half surveyed saying they are satisfied with their day-to-day work and motivated by making a difference to people’s lives. However, the findings also present a stark reflection of the poor health of nursing in Wales.
“Too many nurses are not recommending the profession to others, are struggling and are facing abuse and discrimination in the workplace.”
Pay falling behind responsibility
One of the most pressing concerns raised in the report is pay.
Nursing leaders say salaries have failed to keep pace with the growing complexity of the job, heavier caseloads and the rising cost of living, leaving many staff feeling undervalued and financially squeezed.
For some, the pressure is forcing difficult decisions about staying in the profession or reducing hours.
RCN Wales argues that without meaningful improvements to pay, recruitment and retention will continue to suffer, placing further strain on already stretched hospital wards, community services and care settings.
Training and career progression gaps
The report also highlights inconsistent access to continuing professional development, with many nurses struggling to secure protected time or funding for further training.
According to the union, this not only limits career progression but risks undermining patient care in the long term.
Harding said: “Access to protected time and funding for continuing professional development remains inconsistent, undermining both career progression and the sustainability of the workforce.
“RCN Wales believes this is unacceptable and we will continue to support nurses and fight for fair pay, meaningful investment in professional development and better working conditions across Wales.”
Commitment remains strong
Despite the challenges, the report does note strong dedication among nursing staff.
More than half of those surveyed said they were satisfied with their day-to-day work and remained motivated by the difference they make to patients’ lives.
Health leaders say that commitment is a strength the NHS in Wales cannot afford to lose.
With around 35,000 members in Wales, the Royal College of Nursing says it will continue pressing ministers to address what it describes as a “workforce crisis” before it deepens further.
The union is calling for fairer pay settlements, safer staffing levels and guaranteed investment in training to ensure nursing remains an attractive and sustainable career.
Health
Doctor struck off after sexual misconduct findings at Withybush Hospital
Tribunal history reveals medic was removed in 2012 for dishonesty before being allowed back to practise
A DOCTOR accused of sexually harassing junior colleagues while working at Withybush Hospital had previously been struck off the medical register for lying about his qualifications, the Herald can reveal.
Dr Velmurugan Kuppuswamy is currently at the centre of fitness-to-practise proceedings after allegations he made sexually inappropriate comments and subjected two female doctors to unwanted physical contact during his time as a locum consultant in Haverfordwest.
But records show this is not the first time his conduct has come before regulators.
In 2012, an independent tribunal found he had been dishonest during an application and interview for a postgraduate cardiology training post at an NHS deanery in England.
The panel heard he falsely claimed to have submitted a Doctor of Medicine thesis, said he was a member of the Royal College of Physicians and stated he had passed a practical clinical skills assessment.
He initially admitted misleading information before later retracting parts of his account. The tribunal concluded he had “maintained his dishonest accounts” and had wrongly accused a witness of giving misleading evidence.
He was erased from the register and returned to India, where he later worked in a cardiac hospital.
In 2020, he applied to be restored to the UK medical register.
The General Medical Council investigated and opposed the application, arguing his expressions of remorse had come years late and raising concerns about a lack of independent evidence regarding his work overseas, as well as the absence of relevant ethics training.
However, an independent Medical Practitioners Tribunal at the Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service accepted his assurances that he had changed. His evidence was described as “compelling, heartfelt and genuine”, and the panel decided a well-informed member of the public would not be concerned about his return to practise.
His name was restored to the register.
Shortly afterwards, he began working shifts as a locum consultant at Withybush Hospital, which is run by Hywel Dda University Health Board.
Within months, fresh allegations emerged.
A tribunal has heard claims that between August and September 2021 he hugged junior colleagues without consent, touched their backs and waists, squeezed their wrists and arms and made sexually suggestive remarks at a staff social event.
On two occasions, he is alleged to have gripped one doctor so tightly it caused pain and ignored her requests to stop. He is also accused of staring at female colleagues, following groups of women around the venue, making comments about their bodies and placing a hand high on one doctor’s thigh.
Further allegations relate to behaviour at work, including sitting extremely close to a colleague, draping an arm behind her on a sofa and grabbing her arm while whispering comments.
According to the charges, his conduct created “an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment” and amounted to a sexually motivated abuse of his senior position.
Dr Kuppuswamy denies wrongdoing.
Following the investigation, the case was referred to a tribunal by the General Medical Council. The decision on his fitness to practise was made independently by a Medical Practitioners Tribunal at the Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service.
The tribunal determined his behaviour amounted to serious professional misconduct and ordered that he be erased from the medical register.
Asked whether the doctor remains employed, the health board said it does not comment on individual staffing matters.
Medical director Mark Henwood said: “We have robust policies and procedures in place to ensure the safety of both staff and patients in our care and we take seriously our responsibility for their wellbeing. We are committed to providing a safe, supportive environment where patients and staff can be confident that best practice is being followed at all times.”
Health
‘Parking fine or miss my appointment’ say patients pressure mounts at hospitals
From sleeping on chairs to parking fines, patients say everyday barriers are pushing the NHS to breaking point
PATIENTS across West Wales are describing a health service under such strain that some say they now expect to be penalised simply for trying to access care.
At Glangwili Hospital, stories of patients sleeping on chairs for days due to a lack of beds have been accompanied by growing frustration over issues that begin long before anyone reaches a ward — including parking, access, and the sheer difficulty of getting through the hospital doors.
One disabled patient said they had resigned themselves to receiving a £25 parking fine in order to attend hospital appointments.
“I now accept I will be fined,” they said. “Parking is impossible, but it’s that or miss my appointment. I am too disabled to park miles away and the disabled spaces are always full.”
Others have described spending days in A&E or side rooms, unable to lie down, while waiting for a bed to become available. One patient admitted on New Year’s Day with pneumonia said they slept in a chair for four nights without a pillow or blanket before being moved, only to later discover they also had flu and should have been isolated sooner.
Across social media and in correspondence with the Herald, patients and families repeatedly stress that frontline NHS staff are not to blame — instead pointing to a system that they say is buckling under years of structural strain.
Glangwili, the largest hospital managed by Hywel Dda University Health Board, serves Carmarthenshire and is home to the county’s only accident and emergency department following the closure of A&E at Prince Philip Hospital. That closure, along with reductions in services elsewhere, is frequently cited by patients as a turning point.
Several people said the loss of local A&E and cottage hospitals has forced more patients into already stretched units, increasing ambulance reliance and long-distance travel — particularly difficult in a largely rural region.
Further west, uncertainty over services at Withybush Hospital continues to fuel anxiety, especially given the scale of reinforced autoclaved aerated concrete (RAAC) identified across the site.
Hywel Dda has acknowledged that almost 90% of Withybush is affected by RAAC, while Glangwili itself is the oldest acute hospital in Wales. The health board says more than £50 million has been spent on the two hospitals in recent years, largely to address critical safety and infrastructure risks rather than expand capacity.
Patients, however, question where that money is felt on the ground.
Some have criticised NHS procurement and management structures, while others point to social care as the missing piece. Repeated comments highlight the lack of care packages and closed care homes, which many believe are leaving medically fit patients unable to be discharged — effectively blocking beds and creating bottlenecks throughout the system.
“There’s nowhere for people to go,” one reader said. “Until social care is sorted, nothing will change.”
Concerns have also been raised about staff morale, with some alleging bullying cultures and burnout contributing to recruitment and retention problems. Again, blame is consistently directed upward rather than at nurses, doctors or porters.
Behind it all looms the long-promised new ‘super hospital’ for Carmarthenshire — first discussed in 2006 and formally launched in 2018. Eight years on, construction has yet to begin, and public confidence in the project is fading.
While Hywel Dda and the Welsh Government insist improvements are under way — including additional funding to expand capacity at Glangwili and improvements to patient experience — many patients say their reality feels far removed from official assurances.
For those attending appointments, sleeping in chairs, or weighing up a parking fine against missing care, the crisis is no longer abstract.
“It’s not politics,” one patient said. “It’s whether you get treated — and how.”
-
Health6 days agoConsultation reveals lack of public trust in health board
-
Community7 days agoPembrokeshire students speak at national Holocaust Memorial Day event
-
News1 day agoPrincess of Wales visits historic Pembrokeshire woollen mill
-
Crime5 days agoPembroke man accused of child sex offences sent to Swansea Crown Court
-
Community6 days agoCampaign to ‘save’ River Cleddau hits over 2,200 signatures
-
Health3 days agoDoctor struck off after sexual misconduct findings at Withybush Hospital
-
News7 days agoWelsh Conservatives push for reversal of 20mph limit and major road spending
-
Health7 days agoAmbulance called after ‘drop of mouthwash’ swallowed as 999 abuse highlighted











