Politics
Blueprint for ban on lying politicians published
A THINK TANK has set out proposals to ban lying politicians, with the aim of rebuilding public trust and making Wales one of the world’s most advanced democracies.
The Institute for Constitutional and Democratic Research (ICDR) recommended penalising Senedd politicians who deliberately mislead the public.
In a paper, entitled ‘A Model for Political Honesty’, the ICDR proposed a system similar to existing regulatory structures used for antisocial behaviour and planning enforcement.
Under the ICDR’s model, Senedd members or candidates found guilty of deliberate deception by an independent judicial process would be disqualified from office.
In July, the Welsh Government struck an 11th-hour deal with campaigners by committing to introduce a law on lying politicians before the 2026 Senedd election.
The proposed ban aims to restore public trust in politics, which is at its lowest since records began with only 9% trusting politicians to tell the truth.
More than two thirds of people support a law criminalising political lying, according to a poll, with voters believing systems of ensuring honesty have failed.
Sam Fowles, the ICDR’s director and an expert in constitutional law, similarly argued current systems, such as the Senedd’s standards commissioner model, have proved inadequate.
He said: “The Senedd rules already require politicians to tell the truth as do the internal rules governing the Westminster and Scottish parliaments and the Northern Ireland Assembly.
“The problem is that these rules are not properly enforceable.”
The paper described the current standards model as a “recipe for arbitrariness”, with the system depending on the view of one person who is “effectively unaccountable”.
The ICDR warned the current system, which sees the standards commissioner’s decision confirmed by the Senedd, ultimately hinges on politicians “marking their own homework”.
As part of a three-month project to propose an alternative approach, the non-partisan think tank convened a working group made up of political, legal and academic experts
The group concluded the regime must: break with failed models; be independent; offer swift resolution; and differentiate false and accurate statements, protecting freedom of speech.
Under the model, a court would issue a notice requiring a public correction if a Senedd member or candidate was found to have made a false or misleading statement of fact.
If the politician refused to comply in seven days without reasonable excuse, the court would impose an order disqualifying the politician from holding office until at least the next election.
Any voter would be able to apply for a correction order, with the court able to dismiss trivial claims early and an offence of making vexatious applications acting as a deterrent.
The experts favoured a criminal law model, to send a strong signal to voters that deliberate deception is taken seriously, but found a civil law model could also be effective.
Dr Fowles, who was part of the successful Supreme Court challenge against the unlawful decision to ‘prorogue’ the UK Parliament in 2019, said: “The crisis of trust in politics has occurred because there is currently no genuine incentive for politicians to tell the truth.
“The Institute for Constitutional and Democratic Research model will reverse that by requiring politicians to correct the record when they mislead us.
“It will mean that we, as voters, are better informed and can properly hold power to account and thereby make Wales one of the most advanced democracies in the world.”
Plaid Cymru’s Adam Price proposed making deliberate deception a criminal offence in an amendment to the now-Elections and Elected Bodies (Wales) Act 2024.
The plan received cross-party support in the Senedd, notably including Labour’s Lee Waters, but it was pulled at the last moment due to the deal with the Welsh Government.
Mick Antoniw, then-counsel general, committed to bringing forward a law on disqualification for deliberate deception as he invited the Senedd’s standards committee to develop details.
As part of an inquiry on accountability, the committee is also currently considering a recall system to allow voters to remove misbehaving members between Senedd elections.
Politicians on the committee discussed deliberate deception and four complaints about their colleagues’ conduct on Monday, but the public and press were barred from the meeting.
In its proposal to the standards committee, the ICDR warned that rowing back on the Welsh Government commitment would be seen as a betrayal, further damaging public trust.
Business
New facilities at Haverfordwest Target Shooting Club agreed
A CALL by a Pembrokeshire shooting club for more disability-friendly facilities has been given the go-ahead by county planners.
In an application to Pembrokeshire County Council, Haverfordwest Target Shooting Club, through agent Andrew Sutton Architecture, sought permission for an extension to existing target shooting club building at The Firing Range, Withybush Road, Haverfordwest to improve accessibility and internal facilities, together with associated landscaping works.
A supporting statement said: “The club’s own published history states it was founded in 1968, moved from the Drill Hall to the old wartime airfield butts at Withybush by the early 1970s, and had developed facilities over time, including the clubhouse by 1999. The established leisure/community use has existed on the site for a number of years and the proposal does not seek to intensify the core activity beyond that already authorised/established.”
It added: “The primary objective of the scheme is to improve inclusive access to the club’s facilities for disabled users and those with reduced mobility. The internal arrangement will provide adequate entrance and lobby space, clear accessible routes and appropriately designed sanitary accommodation, including an accessible wetroom/shower and separate WC.”
It also said accessible parking and surfacing designed to provide a firm, even, slip-resistant route from parking to the principal entrance.
It added: “The Equality Act 2010 places duties on service providers to make reasonable adjustments so that people with additional access needs are not placed at a substantial disadvantage.
“The proposal is therefore a positive enhancement to a community/leisure facility and supports wider policy objectives for inclusive environments.”
It went on to say: “The club operates within a highly controlled environment, and the proposed works will maintain and enhance safety and security measures.”
The application was conditionally approved by planners.
News
Watchdog criticises health board over £10m GP contract checks
A HEALTH board has been criticised by Audit Wales after GP contracts worth more than £10m were awarded without sufficient due diligence checks.
Aneurin Bevan University Health Board allowed a GP partnership associated with eHarley Street Primary Care Solutions to take on eight GP contracts in south-east Wales, with a combined annual value of around £10.1m.
Audit Wales said the board should have carried out greater scrutiny before approving the arrangements, including checks on financial resilience, workforce plans, business risks and the partnership’s ability to manage several practices at once.
However, the watchdog found no evidence of fraud and noted the board was dealing with significant pressure in general practice, including vacant contracts and limited interest from other bidders.
The report said weaknesses in governance and scrutiny contributed to later disruption and uncertainty for patients and staff when problems emerged.
Concerns included financial and workforce pressures, unpaid invoices, and issues relating to tax and pension payments. Some contracts were later handed back, requiring the health board to step in to protect services.
Natasha Asghar MS, Welsh Conservative Shadow Cabinet Minister for Health and Social Care, said the findings were “deeply concerning”.
She said: “Patients and staff were left facing disruption and uncertainty because proper scrutiny was not carried out before these contracts were awarded.
“The Welsh Conservatives believe lessons must be learned to ensure robust checks are in place, protect frontline services and restore confidence in primary care across Wales.”
Aneurin Bevan University Health Board accepted the recommendations and said it had already strengthened its processes.
Audit Wales said the case highlighted the need for stronger checks before GP contracts are transferred, particularly when a single partnership is taking on multiple practices in a short period.
News
Welsh Conservatives demand clarity over EHRC guidance in schools
THE WELSH CONSERVATIVES have called on the Welsh Government to clarify whether new Equality and Human Rights Commission guidance will be implemented in schools across Wales.
Shadow education minister Sam Rowlands MS has written to Cabinet Minister for Education and the Welsh Language Anna Brychan MS following the UK Supreme Court ruling on the Equality Act.
Mr Rowlands said schools, teachers, governors and parents needed clear answers on how the guidance would apply in practice, including on single-sex spaces, safeguarding, changing facilities and sports participation.
He said: “Parents, teachers and pupils deserve clarity from the Welsh Government.
“Schools cannot be left in limbo while ministers avoid making a decision on such an important safeguarding and legal issue.
“The Equality Act applies in Wales, and schools now need clear guidance on what this means in practice.”
In his letter, Mr Rowlands asks whether updated guidance will be issued to schools in Wales, whether schools will be expected to amend existing policies, and what advice will be given to headteachers on safeguarding and compliance with the Equality Act.
He also asks whether the Welsh Government intends to diverge from the approach set out by the EHRC.
The letter says schools and parents require “clear and consistent guidance” to ensure the rights, dignity and safety of all pupils are respected.
-
News2 days agoWatchdog criticises health board over £10m GP contract checks
-
Crime4 days agoFarm owner in court after 26 dogs removed over welfare concerns
-
News3 days agoPaul Davies meets Openreach Cymru at the Senedd to discuss Full Fibre rollout
-
Crime5 days agoTree surgeon sentenced for failing to provide breath test
-
Crime5 days agoPembrokeshire teenager admits driving almost four times over drug-drive limit
-
News5 days agoMilford man admits handling stolen goods from three local properties
-
Crime6 days agoBuilder jailed for £82,000 fraud affecting 18 victims
-
Crime3 days agoMilford Haven man admits affray after alleged pub incident






